I am absolutely blown away by how incredible the food quality is in this little known place. Not touristy or Chain quality, it's the place to go for absolutely homemade everything. I took my Grandkids there, and after tasting their Huge Buffalo Wings, Stinger Sub, and Cheese Pepperoni/Bacon Pizza they immediately started talking about "Next Time!" I brought my son the next visit, and the Beef on Weck Pizza was REAL smoked Beef on a salty Weck Crust. The "sauce" was Au Ju. Delicious. If anyone is wondering where the BEST little known place is by Letchworth State Park, its' Wolf Creek Deli! I can't wait to go again! read more

Now, this place is known as Wolf Creek Deli. I tried a normal Pizza with pepperoni and mushrooms and was delicious, but recommend you try their breakfast pizza!! I was absolutely blown away at the quality of the ingredients that were used, to the point where the bacon was still crispy on top when I got it home read more

Al's Sub & Pizza Shop - Breakfast pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Castile, New York

Having grown up near here this was one of the best places near Letchworth State Park. It's under new ownership and is known as Wolf Creek Deli. Their variety and quality are excellent. And they have ice cream too! You won't be disappointed! read more

New owner as of March 2023! Love the changes to the menu so far ! New stuff plus old favorites! A great little pizza & sub place but not limited to just that ! Appetizers & salads too !! Excellent homemade chips !! Highly recommend for takeout or there is a small area to sit down as well! My recent visit I had a loaded baked potato with fresh broccoli and cheddar cheese sauce, and I also had the special which was a garlic Parmesan chicken sandwich with a homemade chips on an everything bagel seasoned roll ! read more

Al's Sub & Pizza Shop - Loaded baked potato with fresh broccoli and homemade cheese sauce and a garlic parm chicken sandwich with a everything bagel roll - Pizza Near Me - Castile, New York

My absolute favorite pizza. Nice yeasty crust, delicious sauce, and generous cheese. There's a huge selection of other things I've been meaning to try but always wind up with pizza. Just can't rsist. But my family loves the wings. Small and homey but with pearls inside read more

The pizza is decent but every time I have gone to pick up food from there they are NEVER on time and always have the worst attitude. I would recommend adding atleast 10 minutes to the time they tell you it will be ready and also be prepared to be spoken to in a nasty and degrading tone read more

I'm camping at Letchworth State Park, and there's a sign for Al's as soon as you exit the park. I had to finally stop in yesterday and try a pizza. Super cheesy, not too saucy (if you like it saucy, you can ask for extra), pepperoni was crisped perfectly, and the party slices were great. There are also a few outside triangle slices that are almost like a bread stick, it's hard to describe, but it tasted great and was great to dip in bleu cheese. There's an ATM machine inside, as they are cash only. So if you order via phone, make sure you have cash on you if you don't want to take money out there. Wasn't an issue for me, I always pay with debit, and I didn't mind paying the ATM fee to help them out. They're a small local business with overhead, it's also very hard to get food delivered to restaurants and what not down here, I was very impressed with how large of a menu they had. Definitely stop in if you're in the area! read more

Always order here before heading into the park. Fresh bread and good subs or pizza. My order took 15 min and a large sub can feed 2 people easily. They have a lot on their menu and cookies too! If your gonna hike and enjoy Letchworth without grilling, then order your sub here and head in to the Grand Canyon of the East!! read more

Me and my family of 5 tried to stop and get dinner on our way home from Letchworth. We live an hour from Letchworth. I asked the lady if we could eat in the building as I saw 3 spaced out tables. She said there's a family at one and we haven't cleaned the other ones. One would think she would say she was going to clean it but no...just silence and she went back to doing something else. Thanks! read more

Sold our food to someone else- husband went down to pick it up and they turned everything off. It was 8:30 when he was there and they don't close until 9. Tried calling down after he called to let me know what happened and they didn't even answer the phone. read more

You know, this isn't a drive by. We were vacationing for a few days with extended family. 12 people, ranging from 7 to 69, and we were hungry. Pizza was VERY good! Lots of cheese, lots of flavor. The crust had butter drizzle too, which was a nice touch. And they cut it in smaller pieces, in a grid. so we made it last a little longer. We also had wings, a burger, and a salad. My parents aren't the most critical consumers of restaurant food, and they liked the burger and salad. The wings were good, though. The only reason I don't give it a five is that the seating area wasn't very appealing. Kind of dark, kind of hot. One couple sitting there. However, if I transition to seeing Al's as a take out place, then it hits the mark. Took about 30 minutes for the order, but it was worth it. Would definitely come back if I'm in the area. read more

We ordered a large cheese pie with meatballs and pepperoni. The sauce was delicious! The pie was nice and fresh with the perfect amount of crunch. My daughter ordered a stuffed chicken breast dinner and hers was tasty also. The woman that served us and took our order was friendly. Great place to stop for lunch. read more

I don't know where the other reviewers were eating, but I just got a sub from this dive and it was terrible. Stale bread roll of the mass produced frozen variety. Not even a nice made in house roll. Really? I ordered a CAPICOLA sub. I am so sick and tired of pizza places slapping chopped and formed "spicy ham" on a sub and calling it CAPICOLA. The garbage meat on my sub was NOT capicola. Change the name on the menu. Then to make matters worse the sub had less meat than you get at subway. It was pathetic. This was my first and last time eating at this place. The young man at the counter was rude to the customers ahead of me and then mocked them when they left. Referring to customers as "old and stupid" is not appropriate behavior. Not impressed at all. Lousy sub. Fake meat. Bad service. Keep driving. read more

Food is always pretty good, sometimes over fried and it is on the more expensive end compared to the other pizzerias around. Chicken finger pizza is the best thing I've had there. read more

The chicken finger pizza is legendary here! Everyone I know loves this place because of that. Any of their pizza is good, I love the sweet sauce. I never get anything besides pizza here. I'm not the biggest fan of the subs, the appetizers are pricey and nothing to write home about, but the chicken finger pizza is a 5/5!!! read more

Tried calling at 925 for a sub on a night closing was at 10 ..... no one answered, not good for a place with such good reviews :(

Local. I've never had a problem with this place. I would rather go here than Subway. The best chicken finger subs around.

Unfortunately this place only receives 1/5 stars for the following reasons: the staff were working their tails off trying to fulfill orders and the food that we never received after an hour wait did smell amazing. This place would get zero stars if it wasn't for their great employees since the manager April was incredible rude. Upon asking for a refund for a $75 bill after waiting an hour for no amount of food to arrive at our table the manager argued with us in regards to a refund. We feel bad for the staff as the manager is not providing proper management to her staff by not overseeing her business on a busy Saturday night. She left her poor staff with no help and this is why we cannot recommend this place. If you are looking for a good pizza place that is managed properly try down the road in Perry NY at Daryl's Pizzeria. read more

Considering this place is in a very small town in western ny. The pizza. And the sandwiches are excellent. Price extremely reasonable. Highly recommended if u r visiting letchworth All food made to order so u need to wait. read more