My wife and I both tried a slice, she had a plain and I had a pepperoni slice... We both thought it was very good... I definitely will come back again and order a whole pizza... The pizza place itself was very clean and well kept... Also the staff is very helpful and friendly... The shared parking lot is clean and is free of potholes... I didn't see any garbage of any kind as well... read more

Called in a food order on Friday 5/16/25 at 5:30 pm and was told it would take approximately 40 mins. It was 7:00 pm (90 mins. later) and I called back. I was told it was on its way. 7:30 pm came (2 hours later) and still no food. We do not live that far away. Had to call back and cancel. read more

Fast friendly! Pizza is delicious and cheesy the cheese fries are the best I ever had I highly recommend them

I ordered from All-Star as my usual pizzeria was on vacation. Pizza was ready when promised, my wife said it was great. Lactose Intolerant, so pizza is out for me. The owners are the same as Valley Pizza, not sure which bought the other. Place was clean, fast, efficient. Will go back. Nicely lit, I didn't have to go blind trying to read the menu. read more

This place has really gone downhill I'm sad to say. I've always gone out of my way to go here when I could because the pizza used to taste so close to boardwalk pizza ...not anymore. The service I received the other day on my last visit was downright ridiculous. I called ahead and placed my order and when I get there a half hour later the food was not ready. I only ordered a cheesesteak a large pizza and an order of french fries The pizza was cold...it took the girl a while to understand that I wanted my steak cut in thirds instead of half because I am handicapped and only half my body works from having a stroke... It's just sad because I found this place decades ago and my children and I would always stop here after a day out clothes shopping for that seasons wardrobe... I guess nothing lasts anymore What restaurant doesn't have condiments available ?? I had to use packets for ketchup and even salt for goodness sakes...this is difficult for people who have health issues. i will mot ever be eating in there anymore that is for sure...I MIGHT stop by if I'm ever in the neighborhood but probably not read more

We stumbled upon this place while going to another store, within the shopping center. I observed so many people coming in and out with food, that I figured I'd give it a try. Tonight was our 5th time ordering from here and we have yet to be disappointed. Their pizza is phenomenal, both white and plain, the buffalo cheese steak and chicken parm sandwich is really good. The counter staff are so friendly and attentive. There is hardly a wait time, especially on busy Friday or Saturday nights. We live 15 mins from here and have plenty of pizza shops to choose from in between, but we love it here! Keep up the great work! read more

Grandmas pizza is amazing!! Pizza is so good. Love the crunchy crust of the pizza. Never had the grandma pizza before, highly recommend!

Ordered the cheese steak Stromboli Large....very bland. If you want fried onions in they charge $2.00. Really for onions!....the dough they use is not hand made. It's made in a factory. $26.00 all together with tax and tip. Definitely not worth it all. read more

the food is mad bussin and customer service amazing they took like 5 minutes to get my food affordable/reasonable pricing too im telling you hit this place up immediately and get there honey bbq chicken wings this is coming from a picky eater btw read more

Worse pizza I've probably had ordered a cheese steak slice and they put Kraft white American cheese lol what is the jail house pizza recipe read more

Never as in never will I get pizza from this place again. Put a order in on line they delivered the pizza the day before. Then the day it was supposed to be delivered they brought it 1 hour late. It was cold and dried up. It tasted so bad it was you could not eat it. It looked like dried up puke on the pizza and the fries were cold and horrible. Probably the same food they delivered 24 hours early. And their response was oh well it is busy tonight. Stay away from this place. read more

Do not eat here!!! I have a food allergy I order a salad without green peppers I am allergic I told the guy that answered I No Green Peppers I am allergic He struggled with English I got a salad with green peppers Thank God I saw them before so ended up in the hospital No sorry no refund just offers another salad HORRIBLE CUSTOMER SERVICE read more

DISGUSTING pizza. I asked for it well done and it was delivered soggy and barely edible. Additionally the steak and toppings are disgusting. Was offered a refund if I brought the pizza back which is absurd. I will not patronize this type of place ever again! Their pizza is gross. read more

All Star Pizza - a pizza with cheese and meat - Pizza Near Me - Bensalem, Pennsylvania

See all

Both my cheesesteak and my wife's cheesesteak had the least amount of meat on a sandwich I have seen in my adult life and I am 35 years old crazy they want to be ashamed or sells cheap bastards read more

All Star Pizza - a hand holding a half eaten sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Bensalem, Pennsylvania

Street road and Bensalem in general is pretty notorious for having awful food for some reason, pizza especially. When I moved to Bensalem 2 years ago it was a STRUGGLE to find good places to get food. After trying and bring seriously disappointed by pretty much every other pizza I could get delivered to my apartment, a coworker recommended this place and it was a game changer. Their pizza is consistently good and the wait isn't ever unreasonable and their prices are good too. All their delivery guys are friendly and cool. Their food is never cold when it gets here and second day cold pizza is still awesome. Highly recommend this pizza place. read more

It was not the best service in my life but it was decent. I came there for the first time ordering a Sandwich for my lunch and food was ok. One thing I didn't like about there was a group of black kids were pretty violent and uncivilized... Kinda distracted me while I was sitting and waiting for my pick up order. But it wasn't their fault so it was not the best and not bad at all. read more

I am a frequent customer. I love your pizza and boast about it to everyone. However, tonight you have lost me as a customer. I ordered a plain pizza wings and fries at 8:08 pm. I paid over the phone with a card and was told that my food would be delivered between 40 and 45 minutes. After an hour, I called your store and was told my food would be delivered any minute. After 30 more minutes my food was finally delivered. The driver apologized and told me that he was the only driver working. The food was cold and non-eatable at that point. I called the store back and spoke to Markos about the issue. He offered to give another pizza and have me wait another 45 minutes. I declined and asked for a refund to my card. I was then told that he couldn't authorize that and that I had to understand. First of all a customer never has to understand anything. You are always supposed take care of the customer. It is not my fault that you are short staffed. I asked to speak to the manager and was told they were not there that they were going to call them. I waited on the phone and was then told that my refund would be back on my c and rd within 2 days and that the driver was coming back to get the food which he got here faster to pick the food back up then it did to get the food delivered on time. On a Saturday night having one driver and minimal customer service, that is unacceptable. I never once got an apology nor offered compensation for my family not getting to eat the food we ordered. If I was told from the beginning that it was really busy that it would take longer than nornal to be delivered I would have picked up the food myself no problem. I'm not writing this to get a gift card or anything like that because I will no longer be a loyal customer to your establishment. I do want to make sure that a situation like this never happens again to someone else. I hope you take this experience and share it with your staff as a teachable moment because at the end of the day your profit and margins are affected. Thank you. read more

I had the BEST cheesesteak ever!!! Their pizza slices are really good too. Must try both, it was delicious! I live 30 mins away from Allstar and will drive back here again read more

1st time my wife and I went here. She ordered a calzone I ordered a small Stromboli. When the order was finished they only made the calzone and I believe it was the owner to who made the order. But he didn't read the slip and forgot my Stromboli. Tonight I order a couple things ask for stuff on the side pick it up get home my sides are not in the bag. It's not that hard of a job read the slips and double check the bags. I'm done with ordering out completely I work to hard for my money. Pound sand. read more

Very good pizza! My husband has been working in PA since December while I come back and forth to visit from FL. We love pizza!!! We have had 2-4 other places ( between us) and can't seem to find a GOOD pizza place. We have a place back at home that we LOVE and nothing seemed to compare. We usually look on Yelp and find the highest rating place and try them. The high ratings for the other places around here are not worth it!! They did not compare what we are use too for (New York style). This time I saw All Star Pizza while going to the pet store and asked my husband if he had them. He ordered while I was in the pet store and said it only had a 3 star rating. For us this was like a well it can't hurt. Well that was the day we tried them and now we have found our place to order pizza. Very happy we didn't stick to the ratings like we normally do. We ordered two med pizzas one cheese and the other white. So good!! Next time we will add the ricotta to the white and try it out. Very happy to have found these guys! Thank you!! read more

Unfortunately, I have to give 1 star. Our entire order was a mess. We didn't get things we paid for, and the things we did get were just not good. read more

Best buffalo chicken pizza I've ever had. Love the blue cheese and hot mix. I've been eating it since I was about 7, favorite pizza by far.

Family members and i have ordered many times mainly because they sell gluten free pizzas. My wife ordered me a gluten free pizza and 12 all flat wings well done. What i got after an hour of waiting was a non gluten free pizza & wings that were not only not all flats but also not well done. The counter girl even went back and fourth with me that she didn't ask for all flats when i know for a fact she did seeing as though i texted her my exact order and she read it from the text. I have celiac disease and if it wasn't for the fact that i have ordered before and know their gluten free is not Sicilian i would of ate it and ended up in the hospital. Not only this but I'm disabled and after telling the counter girl over and over i was not picking up the replacement food she kept saying "you're going to pick this up right?" I've never had a problem with all star! Honestly use to brag about them and the service i received. But this was by far the worst experience I've had with them. They did correct the order (other than the wings still not being well done) which is why i still gave 3 stars and the delivery driver was very nice about having to come back read more

very friendly family business. Allstar has been my go to place when I feel lazy to cook or feeling for pizza. plain cheese pizza is good. i also like their Pennie vodka. my kids' favorite is Taco Pizza. read more

Horrible experience. My BF and I went in last night as we were at the Petco just a few store down. We walk in and there was no customers an clearly they were not busy as everyone was on their phones. We pick up the menus that are located on the counter and start to review them. We decided to order the Monday special (sicilian for I believe it was for $10) also the bf wanted some wings and a sandwich. He then starts to order and says we will take the Monday special. The girl at the counter said we could not have that as we had to bring our own menu in(not even sure i know what that means). Both myself and my Bf looked confused and we said I am sorry what. She then repeated herself saying we can not have that special as its not valid with the menus from the counter. BTW the coupon that is listed on their menu on their counter does not say that anywhere. So we both said never mind and left only to go to another pizza shop and spend about $30. read more

OK. The pizza crusts and the hogie bread are very good. Not the best I have ever had but good enough to go back again and again.

This was my go-to pizza when I lived in Northeast Philly. Loved everything about it - the crust, the cheese, the sauce, the toppings (except the sausage -- they slice the sausage link instead of crumble it). Not too expensive, and there are always coupons that you can use. Cheesesteaks are great, too. read more

Wings were dry and over cooked. Cheese steak "tasted" like steak umms... that is it had no flavor. To top things off they either can't count or were to busy fighting with one another over another order bc they did not give me the correct change. Needless to say I wouldn't recommend this place and wouldn't go back read more

I have been a customer for almost 20 years. Friday my daughter placed a order for a pizza 1/2 spinach 1/2 pepperoni and a ham and cheese hoagie. She ordered about 6:30. At 7:45 we were still waiting. Called the store and was told order was just leaving and be here in about 10 minutes. The pizza was cold and the ham and cheese hoagie was soggy. Tasted like it had been sitting on a shelf for a while. She called back,now it was about 8:00 and complained. She asked for a credit and you offered another pizza. It was blamed on the driver. We waited 1 hour and 15 minutes for the original we were not waiting anymore. My concern is you must be new owners, because I never ever had a problem when Maria and Luigi were there. Sad to say that I will not order from All Star again. You have lost a great customer and I will not recommend AllStar to anyone. It is sad when a business will not accommodate their long time customers. read more

there cheesesteaks and cheesesteak pizza are amazing. and they have a great lunch special also for the cheesesteaks with fries for like 6 bucks read more

All Star Pizza - cheese steak pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Bensalem, Pennsylvania

Ok when the original owners opened up this place food was incredible. Friendly staff great prices felt they cared about the customers. The appearance was nice as well. Now that was many years ago, the new owners ok but seems to let place go downhill. Food not as good, cheese steak sandwich like chopped dog food dry, they cut rolls totally in half messy sandwiches. They charge more to deliver, place looks messy hot in dining area, busy place for take out offers eat in but tight area plus help sits at tables not good. I do go there in a pinch keep hoping they renovate place but doubt it. Not the worse place to go. read more

We went in about a half an hour before closing and ordered our food. The buffalo chicken cheesesteak we ordered was more vegetables and soggy bread than anything else. Halfway through each half, all the meat was gone. I ordered a cheeseburger or a "Bruno". The tomatoes were under the burger on the bread which made it soggy. The bacon was not thoroughly cooked, the burger was not well done but pink throughout and I ordered extra cheese for my fries which I was charged for, and didn't get. We were very disappointed. read more

Everything is so good! Salads are super fresh, pizza is hand tossed, delivery is fast.

Consistently good pizza. Always ready on time, this is definitely my new pizza place.

Pretty bunk food was pretty bland took 1.5 hours for delivery... wouldn't order from again

Sorry for the Kraft Mac & Chees reference. I like that the cheese was abundant while not completely overshadowing the sauce. The slice was served nice and hot. The crust was also not overcooked allowing it strike that happy medium between being too soft and too crunchy. It's all-star caliber. read more

Great food with fantastic service. Best pizza and sandwiches around. Also if you are in the mood for a great Italian meal, this is the place. Large portions at an affordable price. Second to none! read more

Great food.. My family and I eat here every week. The staff is friendly and inviting makes you feel right at home. I always recommend Allstar pizza to my friends and family when they ask for a good place to eat. read more

Food is fine. But if you get a delivery from them as I have, go over your receipt. They don't give you an actual breakdown. Having done the math, I knew that I was overcharged (again). Today I wrote the real numbers on the receipt and drove there to get the overcharged amount back. I showed them, in broken down numbers, what the total should have been as opposed to what I had to pay the driver. My overcharge was paid out instantly. I have saved the receipt from this order. Forewarned is forearmed! read more

The best!!!!! If you are hungry and you want enough food to satisfy you, go to ALLSTAR PIZZA in Bensalem.Great service,.Food is Yummy and plentiful, and very inexpensive!! Best in the County!!! read more