Great food, great service, best in bensalem for pizza i've tried every other their plain cheese pie…read moreis amazing

Delivery to my hotel just before the Super Bowl was timely and efficient. Pizza was extremely thin…read moreand crispy with great toppings. Cheesesteaks were hot and scrumptious. I highly recommend this pizza parlor. I would certainly visit again if I were in the area.

Careful as you approach Sophia Bella on Street Road Southbound, as you will drive past their small…read moreparking lot curbcut before you know it, and be forced to drive around the block to get back to the entrance of this Italian kitchen in Bensalem, PA. Worse, you might decide to just drive on, and miss a straight up very good meal. There are a few small dining areas in the building in addition to a large back kitchen and prepping/cashier zone up front. Attractively utilitarian, all. Room to stand and wait for your order without feeling cramped, as I was doing as my two hot sandwiches were working. These were taken to go, so when I opened the brown bag at home, I found neatly packaged long torpedo sammies (Boardwalk Sweet Sausage, Pepper and Onion/Eggplant Parm) in separate recyclable styro containers. Naturally, the enclosed bread absorbed some condensation so they were no longer dry and a crunchy bite, but were still delicious. Quality Italian sausage complemented well with the sweet and savory sauteed veggies. Eggplant breaded lightly and pan fried in extra virgin before placed in the roll with mozza and tomato sauce on top, and baked in the pizza oven until all melted into a savory layered tasty ensemble. I bought two to share, and everyone was happy, even the next day when reheated. Service was friendly and casual, and prices reminiscent of pre-pandemic days. Pizza looked good, too, but will have to save comments until I return to sample a few.

New owners and it's the worse!…read more Do not recommend. Food was blah and not how it used to taste with past owners. Food came out very slowly even though we were the only ones in there. When it came to the check- it was so expensive and the prices on the menu was different then on the check. They were making up their own prices. I would not be back here again.

Been here numerous times, first was when we received a gift card (great idea) and the food is…read moreoutstanding! Our server, Rylie, was just so sweet and accommodating! Everything made to order!!!! Try the hot pork sandwich on seeded roll, with sharp provolone and extra gravy.. chefs kiss! Chocolate Lava cake with vanilla ice cream , the perfect combination, when you need a sweet! New fave restaurant! Love the BYOB!

One of the BEST local BYOB restaurants in the area! Portions…read moreare spectacular! Food quality is exceptional! The staff is what really makes this place shine!!! Probably have eaten here 20 times and have NEVER been disappointed!!! One night they lost power in a storm. We had 15 people in our party and they came through with a great selection of pizza. All they could cook was pizza. It turned out to be one of our favorite nights there.

I was on a road trip and really did not feel like eating in a restaurant. Pizza seemed the perfect…read morething. There actually was a different pizza place in the plaza next to the hotel, but I wasn't impressed with the reviews -- or the prices. But I came across reviews for Momma Mia's and decided it was the one I wanted. I got the cheesesteak pizza and a piece of Oreo pie. The crust on the pizza was thin but not think like a cracker (I don't understand those) and the toppings were delicious. The small pizza was probably the size of mediums at chains. This turned out to be a very good thing because I ended up eating the leftovers for breakfast the next 2 days! Who know that pizza makes good road food?

Great place for pizza and cheese steaks. Close to home so…read moreit's only a few minutes walking to grab som tasty food. Staff are always friendly and the food is usually done pretty quickly. My favorites are the garlic knots and cheese steaks. My daughter loves the chicken fingers and fries. They also have some tasty desserts like tiramisu, chocolate cake and cannolis. If you're ever in the mood for some good food and good prices- this is the place to go!

I've been ordering from Stefano's for years and they are consistently good. The food is typical…read moreneighborhood pizza store faire but everything is great. My family and I really enjoy their Stefano fries. It's french fries topped with cheese, ranch sauce, and bacon bits. Their hoagies are good too with fresh bread and fresh produce. They're very fast, you can eat in, take out, or get delivery.

Ordered tuna hoagies with specific items to add in and take out. Both were perfect and were in…read morewonderful long rolls. We appreciate the staff for perfecting our order!

Everything I've tried has been very good…read more The chicken cheesesteak was a little skimpy but the pizza, stromboli and other sandwiches were excellent.

Stick with the pizza... everything else is just average. I've had burgers, wraps, cheesesteaks,…read moreand salads from here. Their variety of pizzas is where its at. Some of my faves include the incredible grandma pie, buffalo chicken, soooo many good brooklyn pizza variations, and finally the taco pizza!

Great pizza. Great cheese and tasty sauce. Old Haven pizza stands out out far ahead of the other…read morepizza places in lower Bucks and even Philly and NYC. I've tried a lot of them and the others don't compare. Even guests from Chicago have raved about it. It's the gold standard I compare other pizzas to. The gyros, cheese steaks and buffalo chicken cheese steaks are also great. Also, Phil the founder and his son Paul are great. Too bad it's take-out only. The only problem with this place is the pizza is so addicting. Even cold, the next day, it's delicious. Though I usually pick up, delivery is fast and friendly.

My husband brought me Stromboli from Phil and Leon's in PA. We lived in Arkansas and I promise you…read morethat was the best Stromboli I've ever had and want to find a recipe to make this for myself. Sincerely Sherry New Mexico

Staff are very nice, prices are good, food is great. The Buffalo bites are my favorite thing on the…read moremenu.

Ok, so i'm originally from Buck County and have since moved to San Francisco. I was recently back…read moreto visit my sister, and my brother-in-law suggested that Croydon pizza was the best pizza in the area. I called immediately and ordered a large pizza and a chicken Parm sandwich for our group. Once I got a taste of the chicken Parm sandwich, there was no way anyone else was touching it. It was delectable! The chicken was quality, and it was very tender. The roll was soft in the middle and crunchy on the outside just as it should be. The next day, I was kind of hankering for it again so I called and ordered another chicken Parm sandwich. It was every bit as delectable as the day before. Flash forward two days and I decided I can't go back to the Bay Area without having pizza considering SF pizza is not that good. I ordered the Sicilian. Oh my God! It was the best pizza I have ever eaten. It had to have weighed 20 pounds. I am not kidding you. It has 20 large pieces and it was only $26!! in San Francisco that pizza would cost near $100 bucks. I told my brother-in-law that it was the best pizza I've ever eaten in my life and that is 100% true. The people who work here are smart and amazing and very helpful. Next time I come to town, I'm heading straight for Croydon Pizza. A++++++

Great hidden gem of Bensalem. I like other pizza places more so than others for various items. Old…read moreRomans "gravy" (for my Italian readers) / marinara sauce is over the top delicious! I hate doughy pizza, Stromboli's, etc. that are too cheesy and undercooked. I always ask for these type of items to well done, and Old Roman nails it every time! The pizza is made in a pan, the crust is delicious, toppings perfectly added, and yes, well done when you ask! I highly recommend their steak Stromboli- well done of course!

The old guard of pizza joints in Bensalem, Old Roman's been around since 1971. In the early 80's I…read morethink it was only Old Roman and the Pizza Hut on Street Road that I can remember before Tony's Pizza came on the scene. I've never really eaten much from these guys because their pizza is more of the New England/Greek style, pan little greasy. Just not my fav. My wife is a huge fan of the chicken in their Caesar Salad so I had to at least try it. The inside is a bit dated, but clean. The staff seemed nice. Menu prices are on the higher end. Their wings in a mild "house sauce" were small and bland. The sauce needed some major work. The Buffalo chicken wrap was drippy and not appetizing. Fries were bland, chicken fingers were small and flavorless. The only thing worth my two visits was the grilled chicken Caesar wrap. The chicken was seasoned well, fresh and delicious. The wrap was well put together with fresh lettuce and the lettuce wasn't drenched in dressing. I'd give them 3.5, but I'd have to try more menu items that are worthwhile for the price. Having said that, the Chicken Caesar wrap/salad are worth a visit.

Conveniently located and the cheese steak was good. I will go back the next time I'm in…read morePhiladelphia.

The cheese steak hit the spot! Droning on about a 4 ingredient menu item seems like a waste of time…read morewhen you could be eating one yourself instead of reading a long post about a simple dish so get out there and get chu one .