1. Algonkin Motel

    1. Algonkin Motel

    0

    Bainbridge, NY

    Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Algonkin Motel

    3.3 (4 reviews)
    Open Open 24 hours

    Algonkin Motel Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Algonkin Motel

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Kah M.
    0
    107
    47

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Algonkin Motel

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Hotels 148 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Farmhouse Catskills - The Cafe

    Farmhouse Catskills

    (6 reviews)

    My bf booked a night for us here after receiving a targeted Instagram ad. He's an absolute sucker…read morefor targeted ads, and I must congratulate Farmhouse Catskills on their marketing prowess; however, the marketing strategy gives you a pretty good idea of what you can expect. This place is definitely instagrammable... but unfortunately not much more than that (at least for now). Pros: They've done a seriously beautiful job on the decor- lots of grays and moody dark blues, mid-century furnishings, and prolific use of some of the best artificial tropical plants I've ever seen. All of it is as pretty in person as it is in those Instagram ads. When you walk in, there's ambient music that matches the vibe perfectly. We didn't take a dip in the pool because it was kind of chilly, but I thought it was neat that there was a poolside DJ. It's also worth mentioning that this place is clearly very dog friendly, and as a dog-lover-but-not-owner I was happy to be able to pet so many pups on the property. And there's a decent pool table, yay! Cons: It's pretty clear that this place was sort of hastily opened in an attempt to pull in some cash before the end of the summer, without being adequately prepared and staffed. (It kind of reminded me of one of those house-flipping shows on HGTV.) In our room, one of the ceiling lights still had blue painter's tape around it. The door (which opened to the outdoors) stuck badly, and the knob was not really appropriate for the purpose- more of a closet or bathroom doorknob than something secure for a hotel room- no deadbolt, etc. We had the same troubles with the hot water that another reviewer mentioned. We had to wait almost an hour to get a cocktail at the bar because it was understaffed. I imagine there were just one or two bartenders serving the bar, restaurant, and pool areas. (For the record, the cocktails were nice, though, as was the bartender.) At one point a man who seemed to be more or less in charge of things (but somewhat overwhelmed) was quite rude to us and another couple we were socializing with in the bar area. The morning we were to check out, a housekeeping person opened the door to the room at around 8:30 AM when we were still asleep. She apologized and said, "Oh, my manager said you already checked out!" We said "No, isn't check out at noon?" She confirmed and went on her way. No big deal. But about an hour later, ANOTHER person barges into the room and says her manager told her we had already checked out. (I'm guessing that her manager was the aforementioned overwhelmed guy.) In short: This place has definite potential- again, so pretty!- but it seems the focus right now is aesthetics over experience. At a lower price point I'd probably call it four stars, but at $300/night in the middle of nowhere, I'd expect better management and service. I'd be interested to see if they work out some of the kinks next summer.

    A little soho, a little Sag Harbor, a little boozy prohibition vibe and all here in Calicoon…read moreCenter!! I have no words to describe the vibe and amazing staff when you walk through the doors. The owner Chris has put all his heart and soul into this amazing property, incredible bar and fantastic restaurant and it all just works. Run to this place and don't hesitate for a second, you will be amazingly surprised by what he has built here! Cheers to Chris and the fantastic staff at Farmhouse! My new go-to!

    Deposit Motel - Inside room 7.  *Cat stickers added to obscure my friends sleeping in the king bed.

    Deposit Motel

    (18 reviews)

    TLDR: -The motel was great!!…read more-VERY affordable compared to the other places in the area!! (Most other hotels/motels were twice the price of this one for a single night.) -Would definitely stay here again if i stop in the area!! -Sure, the decor is a bit "dated". But Motels exist for functional & affordable overnight stays. (if you're looking for something grand and pretty go book a hotel room for 2-3x the price lol) More detail: Me and two friends stayed here 7/19/2026, during a week with wildfires, thunderstorms, & tornado warnings that had most of the other motels+hotels fully booked up. This place was definitely the cheapest option in the area, so we weren't expecting much since you usually wind up getting what you pay for. Plus, we were a bit hesitant to book a room in the first place because some of the recent reviews on here were a bit negative... ****BUT-!! I'm happy to say that this place was cheap, AND perfect for the night !! It was tidy, the beds were comfy + clean, & there was no "bad smells" in the room we wound up booking. So about the motel/service: -Their 24 hour service is no joke, We called ahead around midnight and our call was answered right away! (Unlike most of the other places in the area...) -After arriving around 1AM-ish, we called again and were greeted shortly after. The price was confirmed to be the same as they had said on our earlier call, ~140$ for the night for a party of three adults. -We were looking for one room with two beds, and he gave us two choices (He even led us to open & check out an available room we were interested in before booking). -Very friendly owner/worker (not sure which he was lol). He was flexible/generous with the checkout time as well. After booking around 1AM, we asked when we'd need to check out and he said, "Ehhh... Before 3pm should be alright? That way you guys can sleep in, you'll need it haha." About the room we booked: -I believe we wound up staying in room 7 on the front side of the motel. -The room was a decent size, with: Free wifi, 1 king & 1 twin bed, a TV, an in-wall AC unit, a small minifridge & microwave, coffee maker, two lamps (1 bedside table lamp + 1 full lamp), a desk space area with 2 chairs opposite to the beds, & a sink + mirror in the back of the room just outside the bathroom door. ^[All of these are somewhat visible in the attached picture] About the bathroom inside our room: -The bathroom was a bit tight inside, but i didnt mind it. The sink was outside, a sacrifice made to make space inside for the toilet + a full bathtub with a shower head. -The shower had great water pressure, an adjustable+detachable shower head, and hot water that STAYED hot for an admittedly drawn out ~1.5hr shower. (That shower & clean water was HEAVENLY after staying for a week in a distant mountain cabin with no AC and foul sulfur-smelling water lol.)

    Place is a dump smell real bad , well water needs TLC , cops are there at least once a week , go to…read moreHancock you will pay more but nicer rooms

    The Roxbury - Amazing Banister - Faerie Forest

    The Roxbury

    (190 reviews)

    We absolutely loved our stay at Terrazza of the Titans. The space was bright, spacious, and…read morebeautifully designed, with thoughtful details and gorgeous décor throughout. Every inch felt welcoming and comfortable for our family of four. The waterfall at the Stratton Falls campus was absolutely stunning and incredibly relaxing. Falling asleep to the sound of the water from our deck made the experience feel truly special. Even with the cold weather, there were still plenty of activities to keep our family entertained. Between the waterfalls, game room, Netflix, life-sized chess, foosball, air hockey, the Crooked Cabana bar, hot tub, and dry sauna -- this place truly has it all. A special thank you to Chuck for making our Mother's Day weekend even more memorable than we could have imagined. From the cookies and coffee to the kids' welcome packets, every detail reflected warmth and care. We could not imagine a more family-friendly and welcoming experience. This was our third stay here, and it somehow keeps getting better every time. We already cannot wait to come back again and bring even more of our family with us next time.

    Totally decent as far as hotels go but way, way overpriced. Really consider how much you want to…read moredrop money here. I would rather have stayed at the $70 motel nearby. They actually have 2 locations, The Falls (this place has a pool and some very cool design elements) and the less impressive Village location which has some large suites but is mostly just a refurbished typical motel. I couldn't find any way to tell which room is in which location online. The design elements in our room felt cheap and were not impressive for the price. Disappointing.

    Algonkin Motel - hotels - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...