Outstanding! Garlic knots, large pie, tried the Sicilian too, great food and reasonable. Highly recommend read more

This is HANDS DOWN THE BEST pizzeria! I'd drive across state lines to get this deliciously wonderful pizza if I had to! The everything is fresh, delicious and boy does it smell INCREDIBLE! The staff has ALWAYS been incredible and amazing! They are great with their customers and their entire community! If you feel like sitting down you can kick your feet and slide into a table at Alfies! There is even a TV that almost makes you feel like you're eating a pizza at home. Rossella & Lou are the beautiful kids of Alfie and definitely have made their father so proud! Don't miss out on the BEST PIZZA EVER in Richmond Hill! read more

See all

Keepin it real out here in Richmond Hill I actually really like this spot, grew on me over the years. Nothing special in today's standards but you can tell it's a family own neighborhood spot. Been around for a long time and still deliver solid pizza all these years. read more

Alfie's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Richmond Hill, New York

Alfie's Pizza is tucked away in Richmond Hill & does have some great stuff & is popular for a good reason. I didn't have the pizza or the garlic knots that looked absolutely amazing but instead had the chicken caesar wrap. It was quite tasty & filling plus the price was great as well. All in all, I'd go back whenever I'm in the area. read more

Alfie's Pizza - Garlic Knots! - Pizza Near Me - Richmond Hill, New York

Best pizza for delivery in the area hands down. It's so reasonably priced and the pizza is just so amazing for the price. Such a classic new york pizza. I've tried a bunch from here and my review is simply based on my personal taste: My favorites are the plain pizza and the stuffed shells. I'd skip the chicken francese, the caesar salad, or pastas that don't have tomato sauce (their tomato sauce is just the best). Every pasta i've tried with tomato sauce has been a winner and the pizza is just great. Perfect delivery place. read more

THE best pizza in allllllll of NYC. Went to Joe's near Times Square... naaahhh that ain't it! They have good service, but the pizza wasn't hitting' like Alfie's Pizza. Do yourself a favor if you're in the city... take the hour or so train/subway ride out to Alfie's Pizza. The sauce is amazing and the service is even better. It's a tiny shop, but there's enough room for about 4-5 groups of people. read more

Alfie's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Richmond Hill, New York

See all

I am a sucker for a good square and had to come to Alfies. This is an old school spot and I am glad I came. The upside down slice is awesome. Crunchy and fluffy. The flavor is perfectly balanced. The owner was even eating a slice for lunch which is always a good sign. I could eat a whole pie from here. I didn't try anything else but I would come here for the sicilian. No brainer. 5 stars all the way. read more

Great pizza!!! The women who take your order on the phone is pleasant and helpful. Delivery is always quick.

Best Sicilian. Seriously. Tasty sauce and cheese. Crust is light and yet crusty on the bottom and sides. We travel 20 minutes just to get slices. The garlic knots are delicious too. They always add a side of sauce for dipping. Regular slices are fine but not as good as the Sicilian, in my opinion. Will try salads, sandwiches and more another time. Nice staff too. Yum! read more

Alfie's Pizza - BEST Sicilian!!!!!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Richmond Hill, New York

One of the best places in all of Queens! Solid food and staff friendly and sweet! Fresh ingredients and truly eat here three or more times a week!!! read more

So I ordered a chicken roll. More roll than chicken. I would not get again. No chicken at all just dough.

Great little neighborhood pizza place.Very affordable prices with great food.One of the best Sicilian slices in Queens.

Best Pizza around. Staff very polite. Only Pizza I buy, Great Prices. I've been buying from Alfie's for over 20 years very consistence with all their product's read more

I'm in the area for jury duty and looked up some of the best slices near Kew Gardens. Enter Alfie's - well worth the 15 minute walk - tucked in the lovely neighborhood of Richmond Hill! Friendly fellas behind the counter. I ordered a Caesar and a grandma slice plus a DP ($8 total, a steal compared to some other places). Apologies there's no pic, but the Caesar was so good I gobbled it up too quick! The grandma is also delish - well seasoned, crispy crust, perfect sauzz to cheese ratio. Glad I stumbled upon this spot and will try to visit again! PS - love the booths they have inside. A slice shop staple! read more

Alfie's Pizza - Grandma Slice - Pizza Near Me - Richmond Hill, New York

See all

Always fresh and they never miss , best eggplant parm slice in town hands down n not over priced

Best pizza ever! Great sauce, delicious main dishes and sides. Friendly and fast service. Our family's go-to place for lunch and dinner to many years. read more

Awesome old school pizza. I go out of my way to get to this place when I get the hankering for really good Sicillian. Keep up the good work! read more

Friendly staff. Cash only spot. Their Sicilian slices are heavenly. I really liked the veggie & grandma slices. Very fairly priced. A large pie is just $15. read more

See all

Best upside down Sicilian pizza EVER!! Plain pies are amazing too. Fresh ingredients, the sauce isn't overly sweet or spiced. The regular Sicilian kicks ass too. Topping are always delicious. Salads are packed full of protein and veggies. The garlic knots...... KILLER.... Light and airy, melts in you mouth. Rose and Louie are awesome. Been going here for 20+ years. Old school pizzeria charm. read more

When it comes to a traditional Sicilian pie, Alfie's is it! Sliced into 12 slices, the perfect dough is lightly topped with a marinara with great flavor and seasonings and then shredded parm. I ordered it through Yelp to be delivered and it arrived even faster than the time quoted. Nowadays, if you want to order a few different slices from some place it's over $20 easily and this pie with delivery (tip) was $27 and has given me 6 meals/snacks (albeit not the healthiest) but I've been in the mood for a good Sicilian and now I don't have to look further. read more

I moved away from Queens and up to Westchester a few years ago. Had Alfies today for the first time in years and it still checks out! Best pizza I've had in my life. It was the best a few years ago, and it's still the best today. I usually order a Sicilian pie with pepperoni and it never disappoints! Love this spot! read more

Don't pass this place by. The pizza and entrees are consistently great. Also really affordable.

Went back to RH to visit where I grew up. I went to go to Alfie's but could not park anywhere close. In fact, the parking in RH is a nightmare! Then went up to Dani's but no parking as well. Stopped off at New Park on way back to LI, got a spot in lot, but pizza sucked. Just not the same there! Drove back to LI telling everyone about the parking. Oh well, maybe next time. Alfie's was #1 on my list for pizza but just couldn't find any parking. read more

I love how super old school this place was, it has been around for over 45 years and the nostalgia was great. I heard of this from The Pizza Show: NYC's Other Boroughs and they featured this place with Action Bronson, so I decided to take a trip. I was talking to the owner Luigi and he was really nice, I talked to him about the episode and he said Action was bouncing around everywhere lol But yeah just talking to Luigi for a few mins was pretty awesome and the pizza was great so definitely a place to check out. The food: Upside Down- I thought this was good and I liked how the sauce had a nice pop from the tomato sauce. The dough on this has a little more crisp than the Sicilian, which was nice. Between the two, I think I would give a slight edge to the upside down. Sicilian- Nice classic and fluffy Sicilian, this was made well and I enjoyed it but it kinda felt like I was eating bread. But the fluffiness on this was great, so soft and pillowy but the upside down had a little more flavor. read more

#ThankYouThursday A friend on Facebook asked what one meal you'd want to have right now, and my mind did not hesitate to go directly to Alfie's Pizza. For those who are close by, Alfie's is open every day 12-9 PM for takeout and delivery during these crazy times. I am locked down and too far away to do either, so I am jealous of those who can and angry at those who don't. Alfie's Pizza has been located in the same spot for at least 45 years. This was the very first pizza I ever ate and it's still the best pizza I've ever eaten. I've had the good fortune to have eaten in some of the best restaurants in the world, and I include Alfie's among them. Thanks for the delicious food and the memories! read more

4 words for you: CHICKEN CAESAR SALAD PIZZA!! If you know, you know!! I'm here to convince you to try the chicken caesar salad pizza! Okay, I know it sounds weird to put a salad on a pizza slice, but so does putting pineapples and yet we all still eat them! lol. Every time I have one of those, oh I'm going to watch what I eat today kind of day, I end up at Alfie's for my salad slice. haha. It's the perfect combination. You really can't go wrong. It's so delicious! But honestly, everything on their menu is very enjoyable, super fresh, and affordable. The customer service is phenomenal and they take care of you like family. I've been coming here for years and I don't see that changing any time soon. Now that I have convinced you to stop by Alfie's for your next meal can I just also share with you how gooooooood their zeppoles are!!! Make sure to get that for desert. The other day I brought them home with me and I put some cherry jam on them and let's just say "it hit the spot". (hmmm... now that I think about it, Alfie's should actually start serving the zeppoles with a side of jam) lol. Great, another way to make them better, like they aren't the best already. Now I will never leave!! read more

Alfie's Pizza - Order's to-go, during quarantine!! - Pizza Near Me - Richmond Hill, New York

I'm a New York that has been living in Georgia for the past 8 years. And God, do I miss good pizza. I got off of a flight today at JFK and searched the highest rated pizza shop close by. An hour later I walked into Alfies. My wife and I ordered slices: sausage and pep, pepperoni, cheese, and sicilian. Every bite and every slice had me in pizza heaven. Also, sicilian isn't typically my style, but this was the best I have EVER had, and I'd definitely repeat. 5 out of 5 stars and everything you could ever want from a pizza shop. We ordered three more slices on the way out for later tonight. Pizza: 5 out of 5 Price: 5 out of 5 Owners: 5 out of 5 and SUPER friendly I'd go out of my way next time I fly into JFK to stop by. What a gem! read more

Went with a group of friends this past weekend on the recommendation of one of them that had grown up eating at Alfie's. Honestly I'm a bit ashamed I've never been here or even heard of it before because it was SO SO GOOD and deserves all the praise. We got the Sicilian and an upside down pie and both were fantastic. Also, I don't know how because the ingredients are the same, but they taste different! It must be the way the tomato sauce soaks into the crust versus the other one not doing that...not quite sure but it's magic. Lastly, we got some garlic knots and they were fluffy delicious pillows of joy. Seriously some of the best garlic knots I might have ever had. That may have been my first time eating there but it certainly won't be my last! read more

Alfie's Pizza - Sicilian Pie - Pizza Near Me - Richmond Hill, New York

See all

Fast service, good pizza. Sauce was good and the pizza wasn't super thin. Was expecting more with the garlic knot. They were a little burnt. But still good! read more

Alfie's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Richmond Hill, New York

These broccoli pinwheels have me obsessed! Worth the trip even if you aren't around the area. The broccoli is always so fresh tasting. read more

Alfie's Pizza - Broccoli pinwheel - Pizza Near Me - Richmond Hill, New York

Best pizza place I've ever been to - the friendliest staff and quick, efficient service. Can't recommend this place enough!

Best pizza by far. I miss the days when I worked that area in my 3-11 pm and would go by and get my daily dose of my favorite pizza.Chris NYPD Retired coming back Saturday 11/23/24 for a slice read more

Delicious and freshly made pizza in the neighborhood Delivery service available Affordable prices Great phone etiquette Daily specials are awesome Delivery never takes longer than 40 minutes Open daily Wings & garlic knots are delightful Close to home Reliable service Want to try the other dishes they have but always go back to the pizza. :) Definitely recommend this pizzeria. read more

Rating: 4.1 Grandma slice was recommended by staff, so that's where I've started my taste test with Alfie's.. A square Grandma slice, offers an appealing visual. Chunks of tomato and sauce with spots showing cheese. My initial experience went like this; A bite into the cheese diffuses oily, fatty flavor which hits you with happiness. A bite into the tomato portion offers a hearty, satisfying sweet tomato flavor, which you really don't get at other pizza shops. Cheese is thick and sturdy and doesn't ooze oil at all. It's more of a pure mozzarella. Crust is light on the bottom. You easily bite through. Edge crust is also light, with a uniform and simple flavor profile. Although this slice is heavy enough to fill you up, it's not an ugly, heavy piece of pizza. Overall, this is worth taking a drive down to Jamaica, Queens. During virus days - Good news is that staff will bring your order out to your car. Remember - No credit card. Bring cash with exact change if possible, just to make it easy! read more

Alfie's Pizza - This is just a bit of the grandma square. See how rich the sauce and cheese are? The squares are huge. One piece works for big eaters! - Pizza Near Me - Richmond Hill, New York

I always LOVED ALFIES , although quality is lacking a little since "Alfie" passed ! Still love the pizza, but some other stuff- not as much , ie eggplant parmigiana read more

When in NY, usually try to get to Brooklyn for my pizza addiction, but short on time and stayed in Queens. Tried out Alfies based on Yelp reviews and it lived up to the rating it holds. I went with 5 Stars because not only was the pizza hitting on all cylinders, the customer service made me feel like a regular and at home. She greeted us warmly, was patient while we decided what to order- Went with a special - Large Pie, Garli. Knots and 2 Liter Soda for $16 - WOW, and while waiting I could not resist a slice of Sicilian Style. Just what the doctor ordered for my pizza taste buds fix. The sauce and cheese was incredible, warmed me up for our pie, so good, despite knowing my upper mouth was going to get burned just had to eat as soon as it hit the table. Paid the price, but so worth it- Definitely fulfilled the New York Pizza craving, till my next visit to the Big Apple. read more

See all

After reading the review in the Daily News I decided to go try Alfies Pizza. The news reviewer compared Alfies to L&B and DeFara in Brooklyn. I took my daughter who is a fan of L&B's upside down slice she ordered one of Alfies, I ordered a regular Sicilian. We shared them. The dough was too thick and pastry like and could have used more sauce. Salt, pepper and grated cheese were added and that made the pizza a little better. We then ordered their regular slice but we still had to add the above condiments to make it tolerable. I think the Daily News reviewer needs to rethink her pizza palette. We will not be going back. When I want a regular slice Lillian's is still my go to neighborhood place. For Sicilian I'll go to Pizza Classica and their grandma slice. Feel free to try Alfies your mileage may differ. read more

Alfie's Pizza - Sicilian slice was OK. - Pizza Near Me - Richmond Hill, New York

See all

This place is near and dear to my heart. Alfie's has been an institution in Richmond Hill from when I first moved to the area back in 1987. My last meal on Earth would absolutely have to include a Sicilian slice from Alfie's. The interior has changed many times over the years, as have the people working behind the counter (going from father to son to daughter), but Alfie's has consistently turned out a good slice of pizza from as far back as I can remember. I have many fond memories of getting a slice of pizza and playing Sunset Riders at Alfie's, and while he was alive Alfie himself was an integral member of the community who would spot you a slice, or throw in a free one every now and then....a truly good person who resonated kindness to his customers. Every neighborhood in New York has THE pizza joint you HAVE to try, and in my opinion, Alfie's is definitely THE pizza place in all of the 11418, 11415, and all throughout. It's not the oven, the dough, cheese, or sauce that sets Alfie's apart....it's the heart and soul that goes into making you happy with your food. read more

It's o my the best pizza in the entire neighborhood it has that taste of originality everything they make it's great. My family it's alway happy on Alfies night. read more

Revisited my childhood favorite yesterday. Place brought back many memories. Sicilian slice is the best. Customer service was epic. And the ambiance very family oriented. Place is amazing!!! Definitely going to be seeing more of me! read more