Good end result, but be ready to run the project yourself…read more
Topaz did a ~$50K basement finish for me (ceiling, shower, cabinets, door, vanity). Several areas genuinely look good and a couple of their people are talented. But getting there took constant oversight, and the missing management, communication, and QC made it a part-time job and weeks of stress.
Safety and avoidable damage:
- During the work, Topaz drilled through an existing, fully exposed water pipe about 6" in front of the crew, after the adjacent line had already been nicked.
- I saw an existing junction box in the ceiling when Topaz removed the drywall. Later, the box had been removed and was lying on the floor, while the wiring was left above the ceiling with multiple splices and disconnected wires. I found it before the ceiling was closed.
- The electrical work knocked out my greenhouse circuit, leaving the vent fan off long enough that I lost about half my plants. I spent about an hour restoring it myself. Power to another room was also knocked out later.
- In both cases, drywall was being installed before these problems were caught. Had I not been home and checking the work, the issues could have been sealed inside the walls.
Communication and management:
- Promised a manager on site every other day; saw one once. Promised nightly summaries; rarely got one.
- Communication went quiet right after each payment cleared, then reappeared the moment I held the next one.
- Crew arrived unannounced early on multiple mornings (including a holiday weekend), then vanished on weekdays. I put plans and payment milestones in writing myself because info wasn't reaching them.
The milestone dispute (why this is a 3): we spent nearly two hours agreeing to a payment plan tied to specific milestones. A week later, wanting the next payment without having hit the milestone, they disagreed with the terms we'd shaken hands on, as if that meeting never happened. Their management then framed me as the problem for holding to it.
Quality control, found by me and not them:
- Shower door: asked ~5x to have it picked up; grabbed at the last minute. The base had a non-standard 2.5" threshold, so the door I'd bought didn't fit. I researched, bought, and coordinated the replacement, which also failed after a week. Early pickup would have caught this weeks sooner.
- Vanity: told to buy one size, then last-minute it "had to be" smaller. Top drawers came with no handles and almost no storage. We'd sent a photo of the exact vanity up front; nobody flagged it until install.
- One cabinet installed wrong three times: too wide, then a color matching no other cabinet.
- Ceiling lights out of alignment, and pushback when I wanted a few recessed lights moved even though the whole ceiling was being replaced. I also fixed thin and missing insulation myself.
Trim and dust:
- After a month of ceiling demo and hauling debris, the basement trim had well over 100 dings. I bought the house six months ago, the basement was unused, and my upstairs trim is perfect. First response: "how do you know it was us?" They fixed it, but only after I argued.
- Asked three times to seal a closet off from drywall dust. Never done; Dust all over in master closet.
- A cabinet/vent piece was removed without a word, left outside, and water-damaged beyond reinstall.
Painting: one of their painters is a true pro, taped correctly, matched colors, cleaned up. The rest was hit or miss: wrong paint more than once, and tape over uncured paint pulled finish off walls and floors.
Credit where due: some finished areas look great, their better people do quality work when pointed in the right direction, and they came back and fixed things when pushed, without nickel-and-diming every change.
Before signing, I was offered a 1% discount to sign that day and give them a review. Not explicitly required to be positive, but the incentive is obvious, and relevant when weighing their many positive reviews.
Bottom line: the craftsmanship is there in spots, but this company runs on the homeowner catching mistakes. Several of these could have been far worse and were only caught because I was standing there. If you hire Topaz, budget the time to manage them closely and inspect everything before releasing a dime.