Contacted 5 Star week of Nov10, 2025 for low water pressure in kitchen faucet and sprayer. They sent Chris Bain plumber, and he shut down water and told me I had to have whole new faucet. Moen equipment under lifetime warranty so I ordered replacements 5Star was to return when Moen shipped, I asked Chris cost he said $250-$350, I SAID OK. In replacement Moen rep asked why my plumber advised whole faucet not just the cartridges and diverter valve, I had no answer, she said she would ship as requested. On 11/12 I had surgery for total knee replacement very difficult to be without water in my kitchen. On 11/18 Chris Bain returned spent 3 hours removing a faucet, 2 handles + sprayer. He replaced with new Moen atop sink but used existing old parts from under sink. When he was leaving, he had packed up the large box from Moen with old & many new parts including water lines, I asked him to leave them as I keep all related products to any home repair especially new and extra, he just said, "no, I am taking these". The final bill went to $550 without him advising me before and he removed several hundred dollars in Moen old and new. I let it go just thinking I post surgery and need no stress. As I began to use the sink the faucet is wobbling and not screwed down as well as the sprayer is continually leaking under the sink. Called 5 star and asked someone be sent to repair and asked also, "have Cris Bain return the parts he took with him. The office manager (owners wife) immediately said "hold on, none of my techs would steal anything from your home and it crazy for you to say". I calmy asked she send repair and the parts. Chris Bain arrived today 12/11 pounding on my front door aggressively pushed in with his camera on and loudly announced "you and I are going to have a conversation, you accused me of stealing" and raged on walking aggressively toward me (75 years old, new knee replacement) and continued to accuse me of lying about telling him to take parts. He said I heard the faucet break and new it was unsalvageable, I did not. I told him to drop it and he continued to tell me "oh no, you are going to resolve this with me. Chris is about 6'2'' and 200 lbs. I asked that he just repair the poorly installed leaking faucet and sprayer and leave ASAP, again persists that I will listen to him because I am wrong. I have no reason to lie about this man or accuse him falsely, stress is dangerous to all and I am trying to minimize that to heal. He continued to escalate until I turned on my phone but had to proceed move to my bathroom because he was getting scary. He refused to repair sink, went to his vehicle at which time I locked the front door and called the Ann Arbor police. I will pursue this thru all channels as I am now out $550.00, a terrible installation leaking under my sink and 5 Star fully support Chris Bain's abuse of me and declines to return to my home even after police requested they bring back equipment taken. He took all that time to remove a simple faucet in order to resell, 5 Star has a parts department, and this is how they roll. read more