Top tier steak house! The meat is prime. Seems people who don't want to pay for fine dining like to run things down but this is a great experience. The atmosphere is a cool blue lighted mix of rustic and modern. You forget you are in Starkville. We have tried most of the menu and everything is great. read more

We Had an amazing experience last night. I was the only vegan and Anna had Chef Jeff personally come out to offer a handful of ideas to make my vegan night as excellent as my oyster, filet and flounder eating comrades. I said "surprise me" and he and the team did so and also were highly impressive. I was presented with a Most delicious and flavorful cauliflower mushroom étouffée with a touch of heat that reminded me of my college days in naw'lins. I get back to the area a few times a year and will not hesitate to put mused in Chef Jeff's hands again to make it memorable again. read more

Love this place. Every time I'm in Starkville I try to go. The food is always on point, the service is amazing and atmosphere is perfect.

The best food in Starkville right now, though there is other very good food in town. Chef Jeff keeps it interesting and imaginative, and, as they say, "The boy can cook!!" Jeff also has an incredible kitchen staff that always produces consistent top quality. With apologies to Billy Joel, "Abigail is a friend of mine. She gets me my drinks for free [if only] . . . ." Abigail is especially knowledgeable and a deft hand with a cocktail. Ask her for a "Jimlet"! Take my word for it. Great environment. My wife and I just love this place. Absolute recommend it!! read more

Went to 44 Prime to celebrate mine and my father's birthdays. The ambiance and service were top notch. We ordered the calamari and octopus appetizers. The calamari was fantastic and the octopus was very good. It could have benefited from some acid to brighten it up a bit. We all ordered steaks which were good but a little salty. My husband ordered fries with his meal. They were so salty that they were almost inedible. I would have sent them back. Overall the meal was very good, but could have been great. They just need to tone down the salt. read more

We visited recently with a group of coworkers. We congregated in the bar while our table was prepared. I enjoyed discussing drink options with the bartender but I failed to get his name. Ultimately, I chose a Blitz. It was prepared with Tito's vodka and a blueberry flavoring. It was light and refreshing. We were seated in a very nicely decorated dining room and Grace told us about the appetizers and we decided on the calamari, meatballs, and steak fat fries. All were nicely plated and delicious. The calamari was my favorite. I chose the crab and lemon sauce pasta, my husband chose the lamb shank, and another friend chose the pork belly. They all came out beautifully plated. I think of the 3 dishes the pork belly was the most popular. My pasta and my husband's lamb shank looked beautiful and were cooked appropriately but were lacking in the seasoning department. I would visit again but perhaps have the server steer me towards a more flavorful dish. read more

44 Prime - Lemon Crab pasta - Steakhouses Near Me - Starkville, Mississippi

See all

One of the more upscale restaurants in Starkville. The food was decent but left me wanting considering the price. Ambiance was pleasant. Dimly lit. Music being played was a bit out of place. Service was courteous. read more

The bartender, Alex, took my preferences and crafted two amazing cocktails. Our waiter, Noah, was very attentive and gave excellent service and advice. Our table of eight, ordering steaks , pasta, and salmon was uniformly pleased. read more

Pulled up on the Harley with a 12 yr old passenger went inside to eat with only 5 or 6 cars in parking lot got greeted at the door by the manager stating she could sit us at the bar but we wasn't allowed in dining because of dress code little guy had blue jeans and a nice hoodie I had blue jeans button up shirt and black leather vest with patches on so as we sit at bar she comes to get our drink order and I politely ask so what's the dress code here oh just blue jeans and like a polo or something I said oh as I looked down at my button up shirt vest also buttoned up she says well sir I like your vest and all but whoa hold up that was all I needed to hear no wonder there were only a couple people in there eating cant wait to see it shutdown!!! Bikers lives matter read more

Very nice place with lighting that was easy on the eyes but not too dark. Very intimate setting. Bartender hooked me up with the first drink the $16 "Walk Off" which was pretty good. Got the $18 shrimp cocktail that came with 5 big shrimp which were delicious. Would definitely get those again. Then got the side size of their caser salad which was tasty and would get again. Best part had to be the showcasing of wine. Got to see their selection up close and pick an exclusive $85 bottle of Bella gros, great experience and truly enhanced the dinner. $49 14oz ribeye was cooked perfect medium, seasoned perfectly along with the mushrooms well worth it. My date had the same steak with potatoes au gratin that were approaching being too rich tasting but overall really good. We also got the $27 ala carte lobster Mac and cheese that was very good. Finished the dinner with a $12 "la buena vista" which was a great coffee cocktail well worth it. A truly great experience. Love this place read more

44 Prime - $49 14oz ribeye and sautéed mushrooms - Steakhouses Near Me - Starkville, Mississippi

See all

Our food was pretty good! Extremely pricey and the vibe is super swanky! Waiter was very nice and timely.

Food was impeccable!!! Service was wonderful as well as the atmosphere!! We will be back! The filet was delicious with the loaded backed potatoes. read more

This a great special occasion or pamper-your self restaurant. The food was excellent and the chef made us a treat too. There is not a restaurant in town quite decorated as 44 Prime so there is that. Our server took very good care of us throughout the evening. read more

Hostess told a member of our party with cancer to take of his hat and when he told her he was going through chemo and had just lost his hair she said it was store policy and she was just doing her job. Then said if he wouldn't take the hat off he would have to leave!! Terrible service and extremely overpriced average steaks. Don't know how to cook a steak medium rare. Cold sides and a terrible inconsiderate hostess. I will never be returning and would recommend you never go especially if you have any sort of thing you need them to accommodate for because they definitely will not go out of their way for you! read more

Service was good. They do have a policy that unless over half of your party is there you cannot be seated. Bar area to wait in is a little snug. But once we were seated, the staff was very attentive and we enjoyed our dinner immensely. read more

Sat at the bar and hung out with Awesome Abigail on a Tuesday night and had some amazing food and drinks! The carpaccio was stellar! The tuna tartare was so delicious and the chopped salad was scrumptious! Abigail did a great job and kept the drinks coming! We had something with butter pecan old fashioned is to die for! read more

44 Prime - Carpaccio - Steakhouses Near Me - Starkville, Mississippi

See all

We came during the NYE special, and our food was delicious! What really made the night was our server, James. We were waited on with such great service and hospitality! We will definitely be back! read more

Good food not great, service good , ambiance great and steak what you would expect from a quality steakhouse

Holy smokes what a great experience! Great setting for a one on one dinner for a special occasion. Food was all around excellent from the appetizers to the sides, but the true stars were the steaks. Both the Fillet and the Ribeye were excellent, cooked to perfection with the best crust I may have ever had on a steak. Our waitress Ana also made sure to take great care of us for our entire visit. Highly recommended if you find yourself in the vicinity. Just as a note, coming in from out of town, I didn't realize that reservations appear to be highly encouraged. They still were able to take care of me immediately despite my lack of one, but your mileage may vary here. read more

This is new spot for the town of Starkville and it's first tru upper scale steak restaurant. I have eaten at Berns in Tampa, Ruthcrist in Vegas, Charley's steakhouse, and some of the most recognized steak restaurants in the continental US. THIS RESTAURANT IS ON PAR IF NOT BETTER THAN ALL OF THOSE PLACES!!!! The setting is perfect and quaint, the staff is extremely friendly and well versed with their menu options. The food is absolutely amazing!! I ordered the ribeye covered with their signature black truffle butter, the potatoes au grautin, with a side lobster tail and delicious does not do it justice for how good it was!!!! If you're in town for a visit please make this a stop on your visit! You will not regret it!! read more

44 Prime - a plate of food on a table - Steakhouses Near Me - Starkville, Mississippi

Super disappointed. We've had this planned for months. Went to the game and plannned for dinner here after. Not to knock the service as it was excellent. The food however was subpar. I eat meat nearly exclusively so this should be up my alley as it's mostly A la carte. Great!! I ordered the cocktail shrimp to start. Gross. Tasted like it had been in the fridge for days and I mean days. It literally broke down in your mouth to nothing. Meh. Not for me. Cocktail sauce seemed out of a jar. For that kind of money made in house is expected. Oh well not a big deal right? It happens maybe just a fluke deal with the shrimp. Pretty good day I'm having so on to the real meat. Well I ordered the 12 oz filet. Most expensive steak on the menu. Back to I eat meat exclusively so turns out.... I know my steaks. Well im all but certain these folks are pulling some kind of scam. What I had tasted nothing like any filet I've had before. Seemed more like a chunk of ny strip Which I don't care for!! Consistency was almost like roast or chuck. Had to saw on it which is inconsistent with any filet. To top it off it was burnt to hell on the outside but in their defense was cooked correctly to medium rare. Not sure how you got a bbq like bark on the outside but still kept it close to rare. Bravo! Little bits of burnt steak all in your teeth. LOL! NOT for me. Mine was salty (which doesn't bother me) but I'll just say my wife's steak was so salty she couldn't eat it along with both of her sides. I won't go into great detail on hers as it was possibly worse than mine. Dont worry we PAID and left without issues. I wasn't about to let an overpriced ripoff establishment ruin my day. Do better. 270.00!! I mean I've got the money and it's no skin off my back but I expect superior quality for that kind of coin. Better steaks at Texas Roadhouse or better yet MY house. You guys want some lessons? come on up my way! 2 stars just cause the service was good And folks were nice. Otherwise this place is a NO GO!!!!!!!!! And yeah the server still got a healthy tip. Not her fault. She was excellent! read more

In town to celebrate graduation. Excellent service. Drink were great. Filet and was super salty and not cooked according to request. Sides and apps were good. read more

Nice steakhouse in Starkville, MS...service was very good. Steaks were good, though overcooked. I requested med rare plus on a 14 oz ribeye, was served med well, still had good flavor. Dinner guests had filets, both overcooked. Sides were good, and calamari appetizer was very good. Appears to have a good wine selection, but two of the three we chose were not in stock. Overall the experience was good, but for the most upscale place in town, boasting a skilled chef, it should have been better. read more

A great place to go and have a good quality meal with great service. The ambiance is great too! The bartenders are some of the best I have ever seen. read more

Always pretty good when we come here! Service is also very amazing. Visited this place multiple times and would recommend to anyone! read more

44 Prime - Steak - Steakhouses Near Me - Starkville, Mississippi

While the highlight of the night was clearly the amazing butter you get with your bread, the steak was 11/10 . Service was also amazing. I recommend getting the Hunters Sauce on your steak as well. Not cheap by any means but 100% worth the price. 100%. read more

44 Prime - 18oz Ribeye - Steakhouses Near Me - Starkville, Mississippi

Awesome Eats. Knowledgeable Staff, Food Quality exceptional. Ideal for great wines!!. This place is a diamond in the ruff. Take your love ones there for the experience of your life. read more

My steak was cooked perfectly. The ambiance and vibe of the place was cool with dark blue lights. We basically made it into a girls night out. The dessert portions were huge and the cheese cake was perfect. Only gripe was the size of the sides for the $10 price. You get something about the side of a dipping sauce cup. Definitely can't share. Rest of the food and experience was good. read more

Top tier steak house! You won't find a finer steak in Mississippi. The meat is prime. Seems people who don't want to pay for fine dining like to run things down but this is a great experience. The atmosphere is a cool blue lighted mix of rustic and modern. We have tried most of the menu and everything is great. read more

My mom and I split one of the filets and it was below average. Didn't have a whole lot of juice and could benefit from more seasoning. Got a side Caesar salad and it tasted fine although they chop the salad up way too much so it takes awhile to actually eat. We also got potatoes au gratin but it wasn't any better than a standard potato casserole. I will say their bread/butter is divine and the couple bites of ribeye from my dad I had were much better. As far an environment, it's not your typical steakhouse. Gives off a Miami nightclub vibe with pretty loud music and blue lighting which was not ideal for a usually intimate setting. I wouldn't go back for what I got but it could be worth trying something else on the menu. In my opinion, you're better off driving to Memphis or Jackson for a nice steak dinner for better quality and a lower overall price since it was not cheap in the slightest to eat here read more

Another reviewer mentioned Bern's and said 44 Prime was equivalent. Not quite- the steaks are good but not at the same level as Bern's. We ordered two filets which were solid but the ribeye left a little to be desired (heavily salted) and nothing above average as far as the quality of the meat. For $49 I expected more. The calamari was delicious, the ahi tuna was good, and so was the black bass. Steaks were cooked as requested and the service was great. The ambience is different but unique. Our table (which was two silver tables put together) was very wobbly. I couldn't give it five stars - for the money I spent I expected outstanding and it was above average. read more

This is our 3 trip visiting Starkville for our sick dog needing to be treated by MSU Veterinary Specialty Center. Today is also happen to be my wife birthday so I wanted to treat her to a nice fancy Steak & Seafood dinner and I found 44 Prime and though that the menu was very fancy and interesting. Normally in previous trip we would often go to Harvey's for steaks. Due to having a sick dog that needs constant observation and supervision we couldn't dine-in so I decided to order take out. From the menu I selected the Seafood Tower because it includes a varieties of seafood like Snow Crab, Blue Crab, Oyster, Shrimp Cocktail, and most important a Lobster Tail which is really the main reason for selecting this for my Wife to enjoy. and ofcourse a nice 18oz Ribeye Steak. When I place the order, I was informed that unfortunately the restaurant cannot offer the Seafood Tower for take-out, which to me was understandable, so we were given option to get the Snow Crab & Shrimp Cocktails instead, which I thought was reasonable given the situation. When we got back to the hotel, we then found out that we didn't get the Snow Crabs, instead we got a bunch of Blue Crab Claws which was very disappointing. The Steaks turn out great but we felt like we were ripped off for the price we paid and did not get the Snow Crabs as ordered. If it was a simple mistake so be it, but I hope this review provide feedback for the owner to runs the business a little better being that your restaurant was suppose to be top notch fine dining. read more

I wish I could leave ten stars. Tonight was our 7th wedding anniversary, and we wanted to try something new. We decided on 44 Prime, and boy are we glad that we did. Even though it is MSU graduation week, and the restaurant was completely booked, we were able to grab a seat at the bar. The bartender, Ryan, could not have been more phenomenal. We started with the calamari appetizer, and it was delicious. The chili sauce on top of the tempura batter and large pieces of calamari were to die for. I ordered the Strawberry tease cocktail along with the 8oz filet with truffle butter and half lobster tail. Hubby got the 8oz filet and we shared lobster Mac and cheese and creamed spinach. I would highly recommend this place to anyone looking for a nice atmosphere and delicious food! read more

44 Prime - 8oz filet Half lobster tail Truffle butter Creamed spinach Lobster Mac and cheese - Steakhouses Near Me - Starkville, Mississippi

See all

Had the 8oz filet, with baked potato, they were both very good. The crab claws are also very good. My favorite of all was the cheesecake. I also suggest the Houston 44, great bourbon drink. read more

Great food, dedicated service and staff! Loved the atmosphere! Will return for special occasions and family events.

Had my first trip here Thursday July 28,party of 4.Food and service were both excellent.We all had different entrees,filet,fish,shrimp and ribeye.creme brûlée for dessert.Atmosphere was also excellent.Great addition to Starkville restaurant options. read more

44 Prime is definitely worth the price!! All appetizers, entrees, sides, and desert were top tier. The service and environment were amazing. I will definitely be back!! read more