Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    1800 Atlantic

    3.5 (14 reviews)
    Closed 9:00 am - 5:00 pm

    1800 Atlantic Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - 1800 Atlantic

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    View from 110a
    Sheri F.

    Nice older condos- Unit 110a Papaya Place has a master bedroom with an unusual shower layout and two twin beds in the other bedroom. The headboards were not attached securely to the frames. Beach chairs and ice chest were in the closet, much appreciated! Dryer does not work efficiently. Walk to Smathers Beach, but that's about it. Poland hot tub were nice, but only open sunrise to sunset. Was told by a resident we could stay later, but security guard let us know otherwise.

    Private beach at 1800 Atlantic
    Melissa C.

    Another resort winner Here!! Beautiful Indoor and Out. The Condominium units were well maintained. Spacious and Clean. Our unit was on the 5th (top) floor. They had Vaulted ceilings and breathtaking views of the resort and of the ocean. Each unit has its own private balcony. Spacious 1 & 2 bedroom units. Full kitchen with breakfast bar & Full dining rooms. Most units have 2 bathrooms. The condos have their own private section of beach. It is also conveniently located 2 minutes from one of key wests most beautiful beaches. Smathers beach. your stay includes an indoor parking space and keys to all gates. There is a large pool. A huge hot tub maybe 20 people at once. The grounds have its own exotic tropical paradise with walking paths to enjoy the tropical foliage. About 10 minutes from downtown and Duval street.

    Jimmie H.

    This is a decent place with good rooms and really close access to Smathers Beach. It's not a full service resort by any means though. The only staff person we saw was the security guard although the grounds and pool are well-maintained. Each unit is independently owned so quality can vary. We were very pleased with our rental. It was very clean, spacious, and well stocked.

    View of the pool with my back to the ocean

    See all

    3 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Sheri F.
    24
    14
    12

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    This place is great. A little overboard with the restrictive gates. But with Uber on the island now it is an ideal location.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    14 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    great. stay every winter.. clesn. very well maintained. security. great......great vacation

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - 1800 Atlantic

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Vacation Rentals 119 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Vacation Homes of Key West - Sunset Key private 2BR/3BA vacation rental.

    Vacation Homes of Key West

    4.2(72 reviews)
    1.7 mi

    My family and I rented a home in Key West over the holidays. First of all, the house was nothing…read moreshort of outstanding! Everything was perfect...the house itself was gorgeous, the location was ideal, and the personal service we received from the staff at Vacation Homes of Key West was nothing short of amazing! We were so well cared for, and we could not possibly have asked for a better experience. Among other wonderful things I could say about the house, the kitchen stands out in particular. Some rental houses have the bare minimum when it comes to pots, pans and cooking utensils. Not this house! We had everything we needed to make excellent meals. And, of course, the pool was a wonderful extra...even though the beach is only a block away, we enjoyed the pool every day! Oh, and one more thing...the outdoor shower! That's the only place we showered for our entire stay. So fun! When we come back to Key West, we will rent again from Vacation Homes of Key West. In fact, we wouldn't want to go anywhere else! Thanks again to the staff. We love you!

    We got 4 bedrooms house rented for 5 night. We use it for our work visit to Key West. We search the…read moreentire area during the winter time in Key West is expansive if we have each room for person. The house renting make sense for cost and close proximity in downtown and a street away the Duval. Pro One spot parking assign to a house. 4 individuals bedrooms, two kitchen, one swimming pool, courtyard, secure entry way. It is affordable during high season. Con The shower room cannot be open in one of bedrooms. The problem reported but they cannot fix till we move out 5 days later. The security alarm across the street court house sound every night. They cannot do about it. Carpet is a bit dirty in some room. We have to take the garbage out when we vacated with we paid extra for the cleaning fees. The best thing of this location is located right at the mile marker zero of US1. Very close to downtown for food. Central location for attractions.

    Photos
    Vacation Homes of Key West - The Key West Dreamin 2BR vacation rental.

    The Key West Dreamin 2BR vacation rental.

    Vacation Homes of Key West - The porch at our Sunset Key Monthly Vacation Rental.

    The porch at our Sunset Key Monthly Vacation Rental.

    Vacation Homes of Key West - A classic Key West Style Vacation Rental.

    See all

    A classic Key West Style Vacation Rental.

    Suite Dreams Inn By the beach

    Suite Dreams Inn By the beach

    4.7(23 reviews)
    0.3 mi

    **the owner has called and threatened to sue me for $25,000 for leaving my honest review**…read more We booked this hotel months in advance, and exactly one week before arrival the owner called asking us to change our dates. We couldn't due to flights, work, and pet care already arranged. He then informed us he needed to cancel our final night due to "maintenance," but refused to explain what the maintenance was or consider rescheduling it. They did book us another hotel for the final night, which was nice, but it was about $100 less per night than what we originally paid, the room was much smaller and didn't have any of the amenities we had originally paid for-and we were not refunded the difference. We were required to check out at 11 AM (only extended to 1 PM after I asked twice), even though the new hotel's check-in wasn't until 3 PM. I had to arrange early check-in myself to avoid being stranded in Key West with luggage. We also had to pay for our own transportation and lost a large part of our afternoon packing and relocating. No apology or gesture of goodwill was offered. Further, despite being given a 1pm check out, the owner started calling me at 12:30pm asking if we were out yet, making us feel rushed and adding another layer of unhospitality to our experience. He THEN told me to be sure to leave a tip! Are you kidding? Additionally, the hand soap in the bathroom was watered down, and most concerning, the private pool deck -- one of the main reasons we booked -- was severely caving in and felt unsafe to walk on. I'm attaching photos of that. We were not informed of its condition before we booked. I've since requested a partial refund (50% of the final night) due to the inconvenience and price difference, but the owner has not responded to my emails or text.

    This is a great location! You are able to walk to the beach and also go downtown by bike for…read moredinner. This is an old mansion in a nice area that's been turned into suites yrs ago. It's funky and very charming! Very Key West! Very nice owners also.

    Photos
    Suite Dreams Inn By the beach
    Suite Dreams Inn By the beach
    Suite Dreams Inn By the beach

    See all

    Key West Vacation Rentals - Sticky remote

    Key West Vacation Rentals

    3.0(62 reviews)
    1.4 mi

    The rental from this place was a BIG OOF. My party had arrived 30 minutes after the agreed upon…read moretime for check in of 4pm. When we parked the car we heard people inside the house, which we thought was weird. Well the door was wide open because the cleaners had just arrived and were setting up. We contacted the office and they said yes the cleaners have to clean. Ummm...as a business charging over $800/night are you not supposed to have the rental property ready by the agreed upon time at a minimum? They were not willing to give us anything for not having their rental property ready. Well here's a list of everything else wrong (other than the condescending office who tries to gaslight you when you ask them about the property being ready at the contracted time?? Why is it not ready at 430 when you told me Check in was at 4??) There is a hot tub in the back but half the jets aren't working and it's infested with mosquitos. There is no bug spray provided so I suggest you bring some. The carpet looks raggedy. They might vacuum it but I don't know how often they really clean it. The place looks like it needs renovations like 8 years ago. The laundry machine outside is nice to have. Just make sure your shots are all up to date. It's ruiuuuusssty. And if you have any issues with the place...too bad. The front office will do anything but own up to their mistake. We stayed at "Hemingway's View".

    The house is nothing like the pictures. Can't open the doors from the kitchen from the pool. The…read morestairs inside and out side have no hand rails . The driveway is so small you can't open the doors and get out. The beds are hard . This is a total rip off !

    Photos
    Key West Vacation Rentals - Tv with "cable". It says central AC. I'm not familiar with AC terms but if window units are central ac. They have that

    Tv with "cable". It says central AC. I'm not familiar with AC terms but if window units are central ac. They have that

    Key West Vacation Rentals - Rusty door hinges

    Rusty door hinges

    Key West Vacation Rentals - Floor is beat up and that carpet needs to be cleaned

    See all

    Floor is beat up and that carpet needs to be cleaned

    Pelican Landing of Key West

    Pelican Landing of Key West

    2.0(16 reviews)
    0.8 mi

    It sucks. Get rid of the codes, they don't work. ( get key cards) elevator, once we got on didn't…read morework. It took a while to get codes to work, unit is 30 years out of date and there is no one on site to help with problems. Absolutely horrible.

    What a horrible experience. Stayed less than 24 hours…read more We booked this on Dec of 2022, was told less than 2 weeks before our arrival date that the HOA was going to be doing MINOR CONSTRUCTION and there may be excessive noise. Bull shit! It was more than MINOR they were working on the roof, jackhammering concrete under the building & both stairways were being worked with jackhammers which we had to use we're not cleaned up and full of concrete dust etc. It was so loud we had to go out to the balcony to make phone calls & even then it was loud. We were advised the day before we got there that the elevator had stopped working & would not be available when we arrived the following day. Was advised to knock on the office door to see if someone was available to assist us, we arrived after 6pm no one around. Had to carry luggage up 4 flights of stairs to our room. Was told they were waiting on a part & it would be fixed the following day. That was a lie we ran into another guest who had been there already for about a week & was told it had been out since they arrived. We drove back by on Monday this was after we had checked out & the elevator still was out of order. We found other reviews from a week prior to our arrival & the elevator was out then as well. Was informed that the pool may experience temporary closures starting Wednesday (10/11) through Saturday (10/14). The pool closures are expected to be temporary while they are performing roof work with the pool reopening in the afternoons. Was not opened when promised it was not uncovered at all Thursday night or on Friday & the so called tiki bar HAHA!! was never opened either, That's a big joke! We had to drive past there on Sat & Sun to get down to Duval St & neither the pool or the tiki bar was opened. Door entrance to our condo needed attention no deadbolt & a big gap between the door & wall easy for someone to break in. Upon Our one and only less than a day stay, we found our sliding doors to the porch were left unlocked and one of them was actually cracked open WTH! Over half the parking lot was taken over by construction equipment & a dumpster, parking was horrible & not enough spaces for everyone that was staying there to park! We were told construction would be between 8am-8pm, umm no it started at 7am backing up work trucks & cleaning out the dumpster. We booked in Dec 2022 & there is no way the host had just found out right before our arrival. This would have been scheduled months before the work began! We checked in on 10/12 after 6pm left by 3:30 Pm Friday with a massive migraine there is no way anyone could relax & have fun with all the banging & jackhammers going none stop! The host should have gave us a full refund but refused! Not even there for 24 hrs! And had to find other accommodation! Jennifer which is the host LIED THRU HER TEETH she NEVER TOLD US EVERYTHING THAT WAS GOING TO GOING ON.

    Photos
    Pelican Landing of Key West - Elevator

    Elevator

    Pelican Landing of Key West - Under the building

    Under the building

    Pelican Landing of Key West - The gap between the wall and front door did not close properly

    See all

    The gap between the wall and front door did not close properly

    At Home In Key West - Rooms with a view

    At Home In Key West

    3.0(28 reviews)
    1.1 mi

    I didn't break the lease I was told If you gonna be able to find a new tenant I'm gonna be able to…read morewalk away from the lease. And I paid the difference after I moved out and the new tenant moved in. I'm outraged by the fees they charged me...people be aware there is a lot of hidden fees before you sign the lease read carefully! They gonna charge you for this and that....This company also overcharged me for maintenance fees! its making money by ripping off people. I replaced the a/c filter and there was no damaged smoking detector or missing bulbs. And they charged me $198 for nothing! For hidden damages! And the yard yes I agree I didn't cut the grass so they charged me $179.30 for 10×10 townhouse yard cleaning for cutting the grass basically there us nothing to clean there. And the garbage what garbage I put everything in the trash can and what i supposed to do take the trash with me??? If garbage day is Monday and i moved out on Sunday. So basically they charged me for taking the trash cans out! I will never recommend to rent from this company for all my friends and anybody!

    I lived in one of their properties for 3 years. Paid rent on time (actually early). Everything…read moreseemed fine until it came to maintenance. They take the cheap option. Ex: the dishwasher flooded underneath the flooring so some of the wood panels had to be replaced. They went with a cheaper wood that didn't match the rest of the flooring and didn't even run flush with the cabinets. Another ex: the AC kept kicking off. Mechanics would come to "fix" the issue. We later found out, they were putting a bandaid on the problem. Our AC went out again for over 5 days in the summer. We asked if they would pay to relocate us temporarily until the AC was fixed. They said no- it was my spouse, cat and myself living in a space that was 90°! As they were fixing the AC, construction took over the living room making it uninhabitable- no compensation, just an experience of cleaning up after the repair. As we moved out, they came up with ridiculous fees (processing, admin, cleaning). When we moved out, the unit was cleaner than moving in. This company does not care for their tenants. I've heard horror stories of how they have treated others but I was being hopeful. This company is full of inconsiderate managers, often with attitude problems, as well as hidden and made up fees. Would not recommend. Rent if you dare.

    Photos
    At Home In Key West - Spacious homes with private pool

    Spacious homes with private pool

    At Home In Key West - Charming city scenes

    Charming city scenes

    At Home In Key West - Historic homes

    See all

    Historic homes

    1800 Atlantic - vacation_rentals - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...