It's been my "go to" pizza for several years now... Delicious, authentic, reliable... there are…read morelots of pizza places in the Cape, but IMO this is the best in terms of a genuine pizzeria... Maybe Downtown Pizza in Fort Myers is comparable. Prices however, have gotten out of hand. An 18-inch pizza with two toppings will set you back close to $30. The antipasto salad is now up to $18.

Sorry to say, this wasn't a four star visit. Three was a gift. Ordered two sandwiches, took a…read moregood bit longer than expected, 30-35 minutes became 50, hey it happens. But if I am waiting 50 minutes for a chicken parm vodka sandwich, it better be good. Soggy bread, chewy chicken and very little sauce with even less flavor. Wife got an eggplant sandwich, she was ok but said her bread also suffered from the sogginess. I gave three stars because 2 seemed unfair, this is a 2.5 place at best. Pizza in the display looked dry and less than enticing. Overall, there are more places to try in the area.

Our first time at BRK pizza. When I noticed that brick style pizza oven, I knew the pizza will be…read morecrusty! We ordered a large pie half sausage and half cheese. Not surprisingly, it was thin crust. Normally, we share a salad like Caesar or Greek salad. For some strange reason, we skipped the salad today! The sausage was very tasty and cheesy half was wonderful. Instead of wine and beer, a simple classic Coke was the drink of the night! My wife loves the idea of small cheese pie with a side order of salad under $10 for lunch! You can eat in with a small TV at the table or eat outside. Love that drink dispensing machine near the counter. Very modern and clear options for all drink! Clearly, this is a family owned business. The young staff is extremely friendly. Will definitely be back for more pizza!

We have ordered to go from here a couple times and really liked it. We get the cauliflower crust…read moreand it's a good one. Our order was wrong one of the times and we called, they said come in that day or the next to fix it. We didn't end up making it back in till a couple weeks later, but they remembered - made it right - and it was even better fresh, at the restaurant. Inside is tables and booths, small store but they do have a couple beers and lots of sodas. Super friendly! Good pizza.

We got the deep dish pizzas and they were delicious. Best pizza I ever had and I've had a lot of…read morepizzas. Staff was very nice. Highly recommend this place. Will definitely stop there again when we return to Sanibel.

We loved the fried chicken spot that used to occupy this space on Sanibel, and knew that whatever…read moretook its place needed to command the same great flavors and friendly service we've come to expect from Sanibel restaurants. Scooters delivered and then some. After seeing other reviews we decided to order the Miles of Pepperoni pizza, Detroit style. Scooters' 8x10" Detroit style is the same price as Scooters' 16" Regular and Thin crusts, so the Detroit style might be a little less food than the NY style if you are trying to get the most bang for your buck, but I wouldn't think about ordering another crust style here. The crust is reminiscent of focaccia, with very crispy (but not burned!) buttery, cheesy edges that soak up sauce and ensure that every bite is as good as the last. Probably the best Detroit style pizza I've ever had. The toppings also tasted very fresh, and they even include fresh shredded basil in a cup with the Miles of Pepperoni pizza to ensure maximum freshness at home. The drizzled hot honey tied everything together and solidified Miles of Pepperoni as a pizza to remember. After seeing the option of different crust flavors we couldn't resist and chose "Scooters" crust style (Romano, garlic, butter) although next time we would not reorder a crust flavor with the Detroit style pizza, since there really isn't a lot of crust real estate for toppings (this may be a "duh" moment but we did not realize it until after receiving the pizza). We also ordered a side of Scooters' homemade ranch, which was creamy and paired well with the pizza. Although the pizza seemed small, the crust was thick and we, two adults, only ate four out of the six slices for dinner. The remaining slices were even better the next day for lunch. I foresee many future trips over the causeway to Sanibel just for another taste of Scooters.

Unparalleled experience! This is the real deal. It's consistently out of this world. We came back…read moreto try the house special, Grandma's pizza this time and it's EXCELLENT. Thin crust, amazing flavors of garlic tomato and the perfect amount of cheese. You feel like family the moment you walk in the door. I can't believe how friendly they are- it's seriously remarkable. We will certainly be back- again and again!

Disappointed…read more Called ahead because I was 45 minutes away and asked them to time the pizza to be ready at that time. They guy who was on phine said it would be ready in about 45 minutes. When I arrived the man suspiciously announced "perfect timing right out of the oven!" I drove 15 minutes to my destination with the pizza that was "right out of the oven" to find totally overcooked pizza nearly burnt and the cheese had already solidified. Top of pizza totally dry. Crust was dry and overcooked. Two of the worse pizzas I have had in a long time. My family agreed and a sibling actually made fun of the leftover slices the next day. I suspect the pizza boxes were sitting on top of the stove for about 30 minutes and they immediately cooked the pizza as soon as I called. It was not busy this was 4pm and no other orders being cooked and underway. No phones ringing. Just me and my $40 waste of money.

First time here, definitely not the last!!!! I love pizza…read morethis is now my new pizza spot! The only other place in town I can compare quality to is Oda's around the same price BUT this spot has it! The dough on this is by far some of the best I have ever had crispy with a softness, the bruschetta I was hesitant on getting large, I wish I got a full size!! Their customer service was some of the best I've ever seen too, instantly greeted us, were helpful knowledgeable and kind. They also sell by the slice The place was very clean and organized! Can't wait to be back! Thank you!!!!

$7 for a coffee latte and they are just regular size. $27 16" chicken parm pizza. Was def lacking…read morechicken. 1-2 bites in a whole slice, come on!!! Overpriced! Pizza tasted decent but skimping on the toppings. They had a bunch of slices available but $6-8 for one slice. I won't be running here anytime soon.

The pizza here is fantastic!! I have been gluten intolerant for 12 years and Mcgregor has to have…read morethe best gluten free crust I've ever had from a pizza spot!! All the different topping options are fantastic. The customer service and different coupon/reward options are amazing. Cameron and Eric are who I see most often and they're both so friendly and welcoming

I found a pizza place finally after decades of trying places "once" so I ordered a pizza a few…read moreweeks ago, then again a couple days ago. I got the Mcgregor pizza both times and it comes with 5 topping your choice. Like I said before I have found my pizza place finally! And McGregor Pizza wowed me again! Perfect PIZZA EVERYTHING AGAIN!!! I won't order from anywhere else now !! Thank you for finally trying and finding! I also like they are a small business family owned and operated!!! 10/10 all the way!!

We stopped in for a quick lunch between tournament baseball games at JetBlue. Service was great,…read morefood was delicious, and the space was welcoming. There is limited seating inside but there are additional seats outside.

A preferred pizza place to order from! The pizza is not oily and thick. The service is fast and…read moreaccommodating. Their toppings are amazing. The ambiance is cozy and offers books and games to play with while waiting for your food. I will note however, that their arugula salad which was an extra up charge had more spinach than arugula. This may of been due to being low on arugula and had to substitute. Or the ratio was off. Despite this one time they have a great track record of salad portions! Their cannolis are tasty. 10/10 recommend! I recommend ordering ahead either by calling or online. Uber eats and DoorDash have not been very good in this area.

What a wonderful establishment to visit for our 35th anniversary…read more The food was excellent, service like family and special attention like we were VIP's. Having only been open for 4 months, they have nailed it. We were so happy we chose this place. We went with the gnocchi with oil, garlic and cheese, fettuccine ragu bolognese and meatballs appetizer. As declared in previous reviews the meatballs were tender , tasty and the sauce spectacular. I've always loved a good gnocchi, but this was the best ever. My beautiful bride loved the fettuccini ragu bolognese, I tried it and found the noodles to be firm, but she told me it is dead on authentic as experienced in Italy. I highly recommend Trattoria Alvito. I guarantee you'll like it or I'll eat it for you .

New Italian in our general neighborhood. WELCOME- arriving…read moreon a Wednesday at 3:45p- to taste the hot (3-5p) specials: coconut shrimp (6) and meatballs (3) and a chicken parm (shared) 20. The meatballs were excellent tasting, better than a national chain brand's. The meat$ tomato-sauce has a pleasant lingering mild-to hot taste and slightly sweet. It was the best tasting item we ordered. The chicken parm was good, lovely cheesy and served hot. However, It needed more tomato sauce (similar to the meat ball sauce) and the side spaghetti was served already dressed but lacking in flavor after sampling the precedents. Perhaps naked with a lite garlic butter dressing would be better . Every dish needn't be washed with tomato accompaniment. Additionally, served along with the parm was some Romaine greens which needed a splash of balsamic vinegar for a taste bid reset. Still exploring other menu options next time. We were served by Vito (the owner) and he was delightfully available when needed. To their herald they are open 7days a week with frequent specials. Upcoming is a paella weekend (3-day) in July 10-12 at $25 pp. That's phenomenal. I would recommend a make your own SALAD BAR. Clientele would come for just that. Surrounded by competition, a jump OUT attraction would stimulate more business. With Ruby Tuesdays long departure, this option screams for attention. We enjoy the menu options, special pricing, $3.50 drafts (3-5p) and ample ambient space for couples or a group. Finding an open restaurant on Mondays or a tasty late lunch is rare, but here it is. We will be back. Main thing missing is crusty bread. With some ambient music this is a winning beginning. Every Italian restaurant should be evaluated on two main items: meat balls. (A 5 star here) and chick parm (3-star). There is room for improvement here.