It was yummy! I ordered their Wednesday special and definitely recommend it. I've tried quite a few things on the menu, which is one of the reasons I keep coming back. They have a really diverse menu, including plenty of healthy options, and the prices are reasonable. Definitely a hidden gem! read more

I love this place. I drive across town for the chicken salad croissant. And my husband swears the French dip Is the best he has ever had. Try the hummus - made in house. And the brownie - well, it is a brownie so delicious is the only word. The staff are friendly - which boosts the experience. Try it!! read more

Great food, friendly service and fair prices! I would recommend this place if you're looking for a great sub at a good price!

I stopped in here for a quick lunch before an appointment nearby after reading other Yelpers' good reviews! It was absolutely worth the hype. The cashier guy was super friendly. My lamb and beef gyro was huge and delicious. Sweet potato fries were hot and fresh. I love that they have Pepsi zero. It's a cute little place inside with a good amount of seating. Excellent lunch spot. read more

See all

This Friday I needed a fast lunch in Broken Arrow and I'd been meaning to try out Yummy Subs & More, so things kinda just fell into place. TLDR: Good food, decent prices. Arriving a little after 1pm I briefly eyeballed the menu until I saw they served spiedies. Full stop at that point. I'd been wanting to try this for quite some time and Yummy was the first place I'd seen them, so my mind was made up. My sandwich arrived at my table in decent time, hot and ready to go. I opted for the 8" version since I wasn't starving, and I'm glad I did. Even the smaller version was more than enough for lunch. The chicken was well seasoned and cooked to perfection. Piled onto the bun with all the lettuce and tomato, it was graced with a generous amount of hot, melted cheese. This was probably one of the better sandwiches I've had in a long time. My only comment, and it's not a complaint, is it would have been a little bit better had they used dark meat. More flavor and a moister finished product, but that's just a personal preference on my part. Service was as good as you could expect from a walk up, order and go sit down environment. The place is clean, spacious and maybe a little on the noisy side because of acoustics, but not enough to be a distraction. Overall, a great sandwich. read more

YUMMY Subs & More - Chicken Spiedie - Sandwiches Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

See all

Highly recommend!!! Fresh and delicious food! Friendly and helpful service! Something for everyone! After ordering, they realized the hummus wasn't ready and asked what I would like instead. I suggested an ingredient swap, they did it, and it was awesome. Can't wait to go back! Maybe tomorrow! read more

The back to school deal was yummy & very filling, I enjoy yummys especially to go & when we eat their I really like the pickle bar while we wait! I always appreciate their specials & deals. Great food @ a good price ! read more

We loved our patty melt and especially the French dip Sammie so GOOD! You better try it and give these awesome locals their due diligence. Thumbs up!!! read more

It was delicious, everything was fresh and the service was great. Bright and cheerful

You got to love a place that names a restaurant Yummy. And they are definitely yummy! The appearance of the place made it obvious that the owner cares more about the quality of food than whether or not you are aesthetically pleased by the environment. However the environment was exceptionally clean The bathroom was immaculate. Back to the food holy cow it was so good. I chose a large New York chicken speedy and just half of that sandwich settled my fat belly. But the taste of that sandwich told my fat belly to shut up and finish the freaking food. Absolutely fantastic delicious and the people there that were serving the food were extremely friendly and if it took a little while they let you know hey it's on its way. And those sometimes it might take a little while it's not fast food mind you that little 5 minute 10 minute wait that you may have to do will be so worth it. Five stars all the way around five stars read more

YUMMY Subs & More - New York Chicken Speidie - Sandwiches Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

This is exactly the kind of local sandwich and salad spot I want to have here I live!! As a person who has travelled a bit I like to see local favorites elsewhere on a menu here in Broken Arrow. A couple of good examples are the chicken speedy and Philly cheesesteak!! None of the menu items claim to be "traditional " but rather they put their own spin on these classics and ya know, I like that a lot!!! I've always had excellent customer service here and the food is quality. I've even been impressed with the size and freshness of salads I've consumed here!! Overall great spot and I highly recommend!! read more

See all

I was in the area during lunchtime and had been wanting to try this place so I made my way through the drive-thru and ordered at the window. There was a kind gentleman working the window and we briefly chatted as he took my order. I chose the hot Italian sub, and am so glad I did! The sub was the perfect amount of meats, cheese, lettuce, and tomato with a tasty italian dressing on top. So good! And now I can't wait to come back to try some of their other menu items. Highly recommend! read more

Philly Cheesesteak with actual Wiz! The meat was so tender and delicious. The bun was very tasty as well. read more

YUMMY Subs & More - Philly Cheesesteak with Wiz and Provolone - Sandwiches Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

Best gyros in town! Staff is always friendly and helpful and I know the food will be fresh. My favorite gyros and burgers in Tulsa county. The owner always goes out of his way to make it just like we like! They also made the Tzatziki in house. Better than anywhere! Plenty of room and comfy booths to eat in. The drive-thru is very convenient as well. A side note: during the recent snow/ice storm Yummy was the first restaurant to be completely clear and ice free. Both in the parking lot and walking into the restaurant. We so appreciated that! read more

Hubby and I stopped in for lunch today and I'm glad we did! He had the lamb gyro w/onion rings and I had the hamburger w/tots. Yummy is right it was all great! Very reasonably priced, lots of good healthy options on the menu and the staff is super awesome. The place is spacious and clean, I hope it is around for awhile!! read more

See all

Not enough sauce on my gyro, the meat was dry and the bread hard. I've loved this place before so It was a big disappointment for me this time read more

Food was delicious and good portions! The people working there were very friendly! Definitely will return!

This is a fabulous spot for lunch or dinner. The Greek salad with lamb was phenomenal and is topped with pita triangles that are so tasty. You can never tire of the menu because of all of the choices. This is a hidden gem in Broken Arrow that is a must try! read more

My new favorite spot in BA. The food is always delicious, made from scratch, and the people are just as good. The whole family is hooked now. If you haven't tried it, stop in and treat yourself! read more

YUMMY Subs & More - Sourdough Melt with Tater Tots - Sandwiches Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

I am a big fan of Yummy. I love their food. Today was my first disappointment. There are two new items on the menu; Cabbage Rolls and a Winter Salad. The winter salad was a big bowl of spinach, slices of grilled zucchini, feta and too many croutons, in an attempt to make up for the mediocre salad's short comings. Fortunately, my wife ordered it with grilled chicken. The chicken and the good Balsamic Vinaigrette dressing made the salad decent. The cabbage rolls were large, filled with a good portion of unseasoned or lightly seasoned rice and ground beef. The topping is sad. It is a thick combination of what tastes like spaghetti sauce and chili sauce combined. The first bite was a surprise. I was expecting the combination of middle eastern/Mediterranean flavors of cinnamon, nutmeg, garlic etc. All absent. The hummus was disappointing also. It was a dry very lightly seasoned ball. Not smooth creamy flavorful. There was no pita served with the meal. This visit and only this visit ...3 stars. Two meals not recommended. Stick with the main menu and avoid these two new meals. I had planned to order Wednesday's special the chicken fried steak sandwich. I got distracted by the cabbage roll pictures. All of this makes me wonder. Is the restaurant under new management? read more

See all

Yummy Subs is legit. The food was great and the fresh Pita bread was on point. I loved it!!!

A hidden gem in plain sight!! You've probably passed this restaurant multiple times on Elm Street. Delicious food; attentive owner; reasonable prices for the quality!! read more

Great subs. Flavorful and plentiful. We took out and received everything we needed for a hotel stay.

Surprisingly fresh food that won't leave you feeling like you ate a gut bomb. Go inside and take your time perusing the menu, as well as the cooler of side offerings they have just to the left of the countertop. The vast range of options is surprising and yet everything is very tasty and well prepared. Not a corporate experience whatsoever. Don't let the location and outward appearance of this place fool you. It is ABSOLUTELY worth visiting! The owner is almost always there and very friendly. Once familiar with the menu, order online and go through the drive thru. A true economic and valuable gem right under our eyes. read more

Amazing food, fantastic restaurant. Great food variety. Lamb gyro bowl full of fresh meat, rice, veggies, hummus, pita bread.... Great cheesesteak sandwich too. Highly recommend. Fantastic customer service. You won't be disappointed. read more

This place has amazing food! It's homemade and the owner is so nice as are all of the people who work there. The food is delicious. I have yet to have anything I didn't like here. read more

The food is amazing. Chicken parm sub and chicken salad croissant. Delicious. Will be coming back - a lot!

My husband and I attended a conference down the road and saw this restaurant pop up with good ratings. Service was great but food was amazing. Cute place to grab lunch or dinner. We wish we were staying longer so we could have come back and enjoy their menu. read more

My husband ,daughter and I just had Lunch here today. The owner makes everything from scratch. Tabouli, hummus, chow chow jalapeño and garlic aioli and all the soups. My daughter and I had the chicken focaccia sandwich and tomato soup. YUMMY! My husband had a burger said it was delicious. They make homemade cookies also. Go and try it out. It's has great service and food We will definitely go back! read more

Absolutely amazing food! And the owner is so nice. Super friendly and great! Support local and eat here!!!

I love this place and can't stop sneaking over there a couple times a week to grab lunch. I have reviewed this place before, I'm sure I talked about the food, service and ambiance. Honestly, it's a good portion and seems somewhat healthy depending on what you order. I'll be back! read more

See all

Everything I have eaten from here has been great! Super friendly service and clean relaxing lunch atmosphere. read more

YUMMY Subs & More - Lamb and beef gyro. Only about my 4th gyro I've ever eaten and it was excellent! - Sandwiches Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

Food was delicious and fresh. Just wished I lived closer so I could eat here more often. The turkey wrap and lamb gyro were especially good served with hot, crispy fries. read more

Some of the best sandwiches in the Tulsa area. Service is always great and fast. We will keep coming!

I got the chicken fried steak sandwich it was made while I waited which takes more time but is way better than one that has been kept under a light for an hour. And the price was good. I will definitely go back good job. read more

They make amazing subs! Full of meat and so fresh. One of our favorites. I do wish they had a phone, so I could order and pick up.

I have eaten here 3 times now, I highly recommend!! I had the grilled chicken bowl, everything was fresh and flavorful! My husband had the Reuben., Reuben has lots of meat, and it could be shared by two if you're not a big eater, The tabouli was fabulous ! The lady at the counter was so sweet, witnessed a lot of food going out the door, check it out. read more

Ate here today and was very impressed. I had the cabbage roll platter with 2 cabbage rolls, tabouli, hummus and pita bread. Cabbage rolls were the best I've ever had and even the pita bread was fantastic! Highly recommend!! read more

This is my absolute favorite spot in broken arrow. They have the freshest selection. Best authentic gyros and Mediterranean dishes. The owner and staff are always so friendly and make you feel like family there. read more

Didn't know what to expect- just thought I'd try something new. My husband and I both loved the food and the service was great. I had a bowl loaded with everything- it was so amazing. My husband had a type of cheese Philly- he liked it. read more