Cancel

Open app

Search

Your Pie Pizza

4.0 (122 reviews)
Closed • 11:00 am - 9:30 pm

Order Your Pie Pizza Takeout or Delivery

Your Pie Pizza Photos

Business Info

YOUR PIE PIZZA ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Trendy
Casual
Moderate noise
Outdoor seating

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Your Pie Pizza

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Ham and pineapple pizza on whole wheat crust
Kasey G.

I heard that Hawaiian pizza was better with BBQ sauce instead of marinara, and thanks to Your Pie's many options, I was able to try it. Though I did not become a pineapple pizza convert, I'll gladly return to try something more in line with my usual tastes. Recommended!

Undercooked
Nicole M.

Horrible manager!!! Pizza was undercooked and soggy. Hardly any cheese on the cheese bread-no taste at all. Owner refused to give a refund-insisted on remaking it. Out $30 for nothing. Would never go back to this location. Manager seemed like a con. He gave another lady the same story about not being able to give a refund. So much for customer satisfaction!

Elf on the shelf!
Kaia F.

Me and my best friend went because it was the only place open on Christmas eve, but wow!!! I love the decorations and the whole mood of the place, employees were so nice! We got a pepperoni pizza and I was amazed at how good it was! Only bad thing was how thin and crunchy the crust was, other than that everything was perfect! I seriously recommend this place!

Cheese pizza and happy kid!
Aimee N.

I have not been here in many years and from my memories it was delicious.i dont know if they were having a bad day or what. But it was awful. The breadsticks with cheese had no flavor and they were hard. Thrown away. The pizza was a crisp that it was a cracker. It was so average. .

They tried to make my gluten allergy pizza here.

not safe for gluten free people any more!! absolutely horrible and unsafe. They grabbed a GF pizza crust with dirty gloves and put it on the counter with all the gluten ingredients. Things went downhill from there.

CHEESY ALFREDO PASTA
Sara L.

Since this is a franchise, so owner operated not a company chain, I want to give Your Pie in Wilmington props for being my go to delivery treat! Either the kids pasta or pizza meal delivers tastiness at such a reasonable cost every time. At $8.74 each, both the pasta and pizza are made with quality ingredients in a good sized portion. I customized each to contain broccoli and plant based sausage this week. The Alfredo sauce on the perfectly cooked lemme pasta is just the right level of creamy-ness. The perfectly baked pizza is thin crust style and can be customized to have only vegan cheese on it. Each meal comes with a generous scoop of either vanilla Tahiti or Chocolate gelato too and a small drink. Both gelato options are great. For rainy day deliveries, I don't think you can go wrong with this choice.

CHEESE STICKS
Kim C.

We are here for vacation and placed our order online. We picked our order and got back to our place and it was so undercooked. We tried to heat it up and eat it but it didn't have any flavor whatsoever and the dough was still very undercooked. We both ate only one piece and decided it was not edible so we called the restaurant. The first person we spoke to was nice and was apologetic for our experience but I guess she was unable to make any decisions as to how this would be handled and gave the phone to the 'manager'. When he got on the phone he was very passive aggressive and said the we checked the order when we picked it up and said it was fine , "what changed between then and now'". Yes, we did look at the pizza to make sure they were the correct as to what we ordered, but we didn't taste it or pick it up to make sure it was done all the way. We tired to explain that checking the order and tasting the food is not the same thing. He stated that he would make us a new pizza but the problem with that was we were about 20-25 min away and it was already 8:30pm. We really didn't want to drive an hour for a pizza we really didn't want anymore. We said we would bring him the pizza tomorrow so we could just get a refund but he stated we had to get the refund on the same day as the purchase. Then he said he would refund us but he would have to give us money out of his own pocket tomorrow and he would do whatever it took to make it right. Then he said we need to take multiple pictures of the pizza we didn't eat to prove to him we didn't eat it. We expressed our confusion to the whole situation and how it was being handled. He ultimately stuck to this resolution and we didn't get a refund. We plan on contacting corporate to inform them of our very negative experience. We will never visit here again.

BBQ Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Tori H.

TOTAL: $26.82 - 10" Pepperoni Pizza - 10" BBQ Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza (lasted me two meals) ‍SERVICE: Very kind and friendly folks! I placed my order online and when I came in to pick up, they had the pizzas in a warmer to make sure they were fresh! FOOD: Both pizzas were good! The ranch that came with the BBQ chicken pizza was really nice! Not the best pizza I've ever had, but a solid option and all the customization you could want, especially if you want just an individual portion rather than a big pizza. TRAVEL: ~16 mins. Pizza was still nice and hot when I made it home! No big grease spots seeping through the box either. Your Pie would make a great lunch option! Get (more than) a slice!

The 10" Lineage Pizza
Tim S.

Got four pizzas to try. All delivery thanks to this coronavirus crap. The Ischia - Margarita The Nat - basil, feta, chicken, spinach, etc The Lineage - Supreme Build my own - meat I'm not sure what is up with the names but I do appreciate the variety of pizzas and the fact you can pick your own toppings. The pizzas are only 10 inches. Now 10 inches may be a respectable size for other things, but it is small for a pizza. Basically individual serving size. Taste was good. It's a decent pizza. They have other items on the menu as well.

Surprisingly crispy crust despite the many toppings

See all

8 years ago

This was my first time here and it was FANTASTIC!! We will definitely be back! So delicious and such a friendly staff!!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Great pizza and friendly staff! The ingredients were so fresh! Was worth the little line we had to wait in!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 4 of 4

Ask the Community - Your Pie Pizza

Do they deliver?

Not directly but you can order them through Door Dash.

Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

You might also consider

Wendy's House Wine Shop & Cafe - Wendy, the founder of Wendy's House Wine Shop & Cafe.

Wendy's House Wine Shop & Cafe

3.9(10 reviews)
2.6 mi
Boutique
Romantic vibe

We'd had a large lunch and we're not really hungry but thought something light would be fine, as…read morelong as it wasn't at a fast food place. Searching for specialty places in the area, we found this gem of a wine and cheese shop! Sounded like just enough and it was fairly close to our hotel. The staff, both Christine and Andrew were helpful and very friendly. We got a card to use the wine dispensers and asked about some of the whites. Andrew suggested a Luca chardonnay that was so yummy we had a couple of glasses. We bought a cheese assortment and rustic crackers that went terrifically well with each other and the wine. By the time we left, Christine and Andrew had made us feel like we were having light refreshments in a friend's home. In fact, it's a small home decorated artistically in various rooms. There is ample parking in the back, as well as patio seating behind the home, and on a small front porch. I don't know of any place we've been to that is anything like it, but I sure wish there were, especially back at home in the Tampa Bay Area. What a fun concept!

What a fun evening! We stopped on our way to dinner for snacks and wine! It was a fun atmosphere…read moreand the owner was so welcoming .

Photos
Wendy's House Wine Shop & Cafe - Wendy's hand-selected collection of bottles and 16 wines featured daily that you can taste by the ounce.

Wendy's hand-selected collection of bottles and 16 wines featured daily that you can taste by the ounce.

Wendy's House Wine Shop & Cafe - Come try the new Caymus California. It's less expensive than the regular Caymus and just as delicious.

Come try the new Caymus California. It's less expensive than the regular Caymus and just as delicious.

Wendy's House Wine Shop & Cafe - The outside seating is as a cozy as the inside.

See all

The outside seating is as a cozy as the inside.

Your Pie Pizza - tradamerican - Updated November 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...