Such an adorable and historic candy shop near Salem's downtown area (across from the House of Seven Gables). Great selection of assorted chocolates and many hard to find candies. They have a great selection of taffy and hard candies. COVID update: be prepared to wait in long lines the month of October. It is a very small space and only 6 customers are allowed at a time. It is SO worth the wait! read more

Ye Olde Pepper Companie - Yaaaaas!! - Candy Stores Near Me - Salem, Massachusetts

See all

I just couldn't help myself, it's Milk Chocolate Day (07/28) and I just had to write a review of Ye Olde Pepper Companie. Anyone who knows me, knows my love of chocolate. I have been called an addict, I have been called obsessed, some think I would willingly live off chocolate as my sole food source. These opinions, mind you, come from friends and family. They know me to well! Thus I believe I am a connoisseur of chocolate. The chocolate here is absolutely amazing! I decided to come here because the tour guide who dropped us off in Salem, said this was America's oldest candy company. He also said they sell candy made exactly like back during the Revolution. I was curious and wanted to see it. They did in fact sell those types of candies: Gibraltar's and Blackjacks. This is where I got some candy to give to a friend's roommate whose birthday I went to when I got from vacation. While here I noticed they sold fine chocolate... my hunger arose. I bought one piece of chocolate (a sea salt caramel milk chocolate piece) on my way to the House of the Seven Gables that is just a few blocks from the store. One bite... sent me straight to Heaven! This was the best chocolate I had ever eaten. It didn't just melt in my mouth, I melted into the street. The mix of savory salt, smooth chocolate and sweet caramel... oh lord my mouth salivates thinking about it! Before this bite, I thought Fannie Mae Chocolate in Chicago was the best... not anymore. I resolved that I would return before I left Salem to buy chocolate to take home with me back to Miami! I did return, and I bought fudge to take back with me to the hotel... and then a huge box to take with me back to Miami. If I could, I would have taken the store with me! If your in Salem visiting, you need to come here! Buy here! Eat from here! If you can't get to Salem... order from here online! https://www.oldepeppercandy.com read more

See all

Loved it Got the blackjack molasses sticks, lemon and pepermint gibralters, and a licorish pipe. It was all great! Although I was surprised by the size of the gibralters. Brought them back to share with folks at home and everyone liked them. Can't speak for everything in the shop, but these historic candies had little to no food coloring, which was nice as it allowed my siblings to eat them (allergies). Shop was a bit small, and a few blocks away from the main tourist street- but totally worth a stop! read more

Coll candy shop with lots of neat options. It is the oldest in the US so of course we stopped in after our tour of the House of Seven Gables. We went in hungry so that was our first mistake (oh and we took our kids in - second mistake). They have a chocolate case and a fudge case. We each picked out a few items we wanted to have and snack on during our stay. They also offer some packed candy made like they did when the store would have first opened. We purchased a bag for us to try. It really was not bad and had a little sweetness to it. The staff was nice and offered a bit of help on the items. The store was not busy when we were in there so we had time to look and ask questions. Very cute shop with some interesting items and a bit of history while you are there. read more

The shop is tiny and super cute. You really feel the tininess when you step inside, especially when there are other people in there browsing (and it felt like there were always other people inside browsing!). There is so much candy here. You will find a lot of old fashioned candy, like black jacks, taffy, sugar sticks, ginger candy and the like. You'll also find lots of chocolate (and chocolate-dipped things, like chocolate-dipped Oreos, chocolate-dipped pretzels, chocolate-dipped marshmallows, etc.) We opted for a handful of gummy fruit slices, in lemon-lime, grape, watermelon and cherry. They were really good! Four gummy slices put us back a dollar and some change, so it's not the most economical place to buy candy, but the variety and quality (and novelty) make it worth it. read more

See all

Great chocolate candies and truffles. Old fashioned sweets many are house made. Place was swamped with customers. read more

Ye Olde Pepper Companie - Lots of stuff - Candy Stores Near Me - Salem, Massachusetts

Oprah recommends this place, but what does she know? They have a sign by their chocolate turtles that says it's one of her favorite things. I'm not an Oprah fan. I don't care much for her Starbucks Chai, and these turtles didn't taste fresh. They tasted like they've been sitting around for weeks. I could have gone to Walmart and gotten the same thing for less than $23/lb. read more

Ye Olde Pepper Companie - Candy Stores Near Me - Salem, Massachusetts

This place is one of the hidden little gems in Salem. I say hidden, because literally no one told us about this spot while we were on vacation. We got information about some of the typical tourist spots, like the House of the Seven Gables and the Witch Museum. But while we were down by the wharf, we happened to find this place on accident. It's tucked away, just a cute, old little storefront. But inside, it's full of an amazing amount of different candies. Their chocolates are so good! I came back twice before we left, because I kept eating the chocolates that I was saving to bring home as souvenirs. I regret nothing! It's a neat place to poke around, and the chocolates are really good too. Though, I admittedly can't comment on Oprah's favorite turtles, since I 1) don't care what Oprah has to say about chocolate and 2) don't like nuts. But this place is definitely worth checking out. Bonus: they have a really good variety of sugar free items, too. read more

We walked a ways to get there and I laughed as we approached because there was a line. It's a Saturday in October. We waited and finally got it. Lots of chocolates and fudge. I got a selection. It's expensive but in a touristy area so not surprising. I thought it all would be okay. I was wrong. It was amazing. The raspberry jellies were the best I have ever had and I love raspberry jellies. I've had them all over. The orange pumpkin gummies were really flavorful. It is worth the walk and the wait! read more

Ye Olde Pepper Companie - The line outside on a Saturday in October. - Candy Stores Near Me - Salem, Massachusetts

See all

For a smallish place, this shop packs a big punch. There is a wide variety of yummy candy treats, especially of the chocolate variety. I was recommended the cherry cordials and definitely would get them again. The turtles were also delicious. Ask for recommendations and try them out! read more

Ye Olde Pepper Companie the oldest candy shop in the USA. While in Salem, Ma I had to give this place a try. It was neat to look at from the out side the building was a small grey Salt box style cape cod looking house. But sadly not wheelchair accessible, which I can understand given it's age. Good thing I had my son with me. I sent him in told him what I wanted. He came out about 40 minutes later this place is popular and busy. I got their signature candies (Molasses Blackjacks) not bad if you like the flavor of Molasses, I also tried their Peppermint Gabarlters, Not a fan of peppermint, Not for me but I had to try. and the No Brainers. Old fashioned Lemon Drops & N.E. Saltwater Taffy. Oh Yeah Ye Olde Pepper Companie is a must take while visiting Salem, Ma read more

Lots of candy to choose from in what is supposedly the oldest candy store in America. Not cheap either but cute.

Small candy shop across from the Seven Gabels. In Salem, Massachusetts this place is down town in walking distance from the mairetime national park. The building is old and has a step to get in with no wheel chair entrance. It is a tight squeeze that gets busy easy. The chocolate is done well and lots of cute and creative options. There are plenty of choices for the whole family. Home made fudge and truffles, maple candies and more. My favorite was the chocolate covered gummy bears. The oldest candy shop in the United States and a great attraction. read more

Ye Olde Pepper Companie - The oldest candy shop in America. Full selection of fan favorites and the things that got them started! - Candy Stores Near Me - Salem, Massachusetts

AN ABSOLUTELY MUST DO! Ye Olde Pepper Companie is THE OLDEST CANDY STORE IN AMERICA & has Candy that Can't be Found Anywhere else. The Shop has been in existence since 1806. This is a Great Place to buy unusual Gifts for the person who has a sweet tooth. See Below Gifts. Ye Olde Pepper Companie is located right across the street from The House of Seven Gables in Salem MA. Imagine the shop was created a mere 30 years after the country was first born in 1776 & it's still around today. AMAZING! Co-owner Bob Burkinshaw 3rd Generation & his daughter, Jackie , Fourth Generation are candy makers who still make the same sweet tasty treats just like they did Back in the Day. Not only are the old fashioned recipes from the 1800s still being used & are the same but also some of the equipment dates back to that time period as well. Just look at the Spelling of the shop's name; that tells you Everything. This is how The Olde English & The New colonists spelled things back in the 1800s. It is a completely different spelling than would be used today. The Ye Olde Pepper Companie traces its origin back to an Englishwoman named Mary Spencer who arrived in America in 1806 after being shipwrecked. She was really destitute but luckily she had some great neighbors who helped her out. They gave her some sugar so she could make her candy & support herself. George Pepper a confectioner bought the business in 1830. At the turn of the 20th Century, Burkinshaw's grandfather bought the company from Pepper & now has a multi generational family of Burkinshaws running the operations. It is a small shop but LOADED with all Kinds of Treats, Confections, Chocolates & Candies Both Modern & from Back in the Day too. YOU MUST TRY THE FOLLOWING AT LEAST ONCE IN YOUR LIFE. UNUSUAL GIFTS THAT MOST PEOPLE HAVE NEVER EVEN HEARD OF: 1) Gibralters which are the first commercially sold candies in America. They come in 2 Flavors Lemon & Peppermint. They are an unusual white chalky like consistency Candy that can be broken apart in pieces with your hand & has a Lemony Flavor & the other has a Minty Flavor. 2) Black Jacks are America's First Stick Candy. They are Hand Made Molasses that tastes like Creme Brûlée. These Gibralters & Black Jacks are completely different than any of our modern day candy & have to be tried at least once. THEY ARE GOOD! 3) Home Made Chocolates & Turtles & a Chocolate with a Pistachio Cream Filling that's Delicious. 4) They also carry Seasonal & Holiday Only Candies as well as Salt Water Taffy, Barks, Patties, Squares, Non-Pareils, Brittles, Caramel Corn & Fudge. Ye Olde Pepper Companie is such a Cool Candy Shop loaded with Rich History of Delicious & Unusual TastyTreats. YUM!!!!!! It used to be, you had to have Mega Bucks & be really rich to have The Good Life, not anymore. The Game has changed. You've Been Upgraded. Now You Can Live Like A King On A Limited Budget! read more

Great little candy shop! We loved visiting. The candy was delicious. We loved the handmade taffy! The lady behind the counter said it was handmade by the owner. Can't beat that! read more

Some of the reviews of Ye Olde Pepper Companie make this shop sound like an overcrowded tourist trap, but that wasn't my experience at all. I stopped into Pepper Companie after an early morning tour of the House of the Seven Gables. There were maybe one or two other customers in the shop at the time and 4 employees: a few behind the counter and at the cash registers, and one dressed in Colonial garb, handing out samples. I sampled (and ended up buying) the black strap molasses Black Jacks, which are exclusively made by Pepper Companie, using the original recipe. If you love molasses, these are the treat for you! There were lots of other prepackaged candies and fudge options like you'd find in other candy stores. But the "historical" treats like the Black Jacks are really what makes this place stand out, and totally worth visiting for! read more

Ye Olde Pepper Companie - Candy Stores Near Me - Salem, Massachusetts

See all

Bought a package of their coconut squares at Henry`s market on Tuesday, and the inside of the fondant was a slightly yellow color. I tried two of them and they were definitely rancid. It seems that the milk or cream was old, not fresh, but the expiration date said good til July 13, 2024. The company, it seems, when making this batch, wanted to use up the milk or cream as it was starting to turn. I will not be buying from this company again, and I always had good luck before, but not when they are not using fresh milk and cream. My husband and I were at the Beverly Henry`s market, and he always buys the ones from Winfrey`s. We are loyal customers to Henry`s market and will continue to patronage this wonderful market. read more

One of the oldest candy companies in the U.S. and it was really good. Lots of old fashioned candies, chocolates and taffy. Try the Black Jacks (old fashioned hard candy sticks made of black strap molasses) and the Lemon Gibraltar's (basically pillow mints that melt in your mouth!) read more

Ye Olde Pepper Companie - Candy Stores Near Me - Salem, Massachusetts

Came here for for some homemade chocolate and I must say that I was extremely pleased. If you're looking for a small authentic chocolate and fudge shop this is be place to be. I would highly recommend it! I ordered the milk chocolate salted caramel pretzel and cookies and cream fudge and I must say it was very fresh and soft. Definitely would come back again! read more

See all

Cute little shop in this charming little town! The lady working at the Witch House told us to check out the waterfront and this cute little candy shop! We were glad we took their suggestion, because the candy was so good! The ladies working were super nice and told us more about the town and it's atmosphere. If you stop in make sure to try some of their caramels, they were my favorite! read more

Fail. I really wanted to take home something made there. If it ain't chocolate, it seems like it ain't made there. I picked up numerous items and they were all made elsewhere. Prices were also really high. I did love the inside decor. And it is adorable outside as well. read more

This store is neat, there's a lot of seasonal candy that changes frequently. It's in a good place to walk in and do some more shopping. The 200 year old candy in the jar freaks me out for some reason. I don't know what it is about it. Maybe it's the fact that if you'd open it, it could turn to dust, or if you ate it you would probably die instantly. I still find it a really really unique and interesting piece of history though.Other than that it's really cool! They have fudge, sweet popcorn, chocolate, gum, and even retro candy....a lot of it too! (Not counting the old jar candy.) Next time I visit, I will definitely look for this place, it has quite the history and is wicked cute inside. read more

While On our trolley tour today it was suggested we check out the oldest candy store in the US. Which we did but I wasn't to impressed with the chocolate. I did like how many options of chocolates and other candies they had. read more

Super crowded and stuffy. There's no structure so it's just mayhem trying to get a place in line and keep it. I got cut three times trying to buy chocolates but it all worked out in the end and the chocolates were delicious. The salted caramel is the best!! We tried about 14 flavors and the salted caramel blew the rest away. We also tried the infamous black jacks and they are good as well! read more

Ye Olde Pepper Companie - Candy Stores Near Me - Salem, Massachusetts

Cute! Great spot, but was definitely disappointed. Not too much out of the ordinary. Candies you can find at home. Also wish they'd play more on the Halloween theme... walked out empty handed. read more

If it weren't for the fact I'm allergic to nuts I would have gone crazy in this store. They have the distinction of being the oldest American candy store, and even though they're a little off the beaten path in Salem you should make a little trek down there! Crammed into the small shack is a really large variety of candy. True, they do resell some candy from other manufacturers, however almost everything in those glass cases (including the 19th century Gibraltars) is made by them! This place is great for getting a little sugar fix or picking up a few souvenirs for the trip home. There are also little gummy candies for the kids too. Allergy alert: they warned me that pretty much everything in the store is processed on the same equipment and as a result nuts are in pretty much everything, including the resold goods. Times visited: 1 read more

Ye Olde Pepper Companie - Candy Stores Near Me - Salem, Massachusetts

See all

We come in to Salem, MA once every year and always stop at Ye Olde Pepper Companie. This candy store has it all. If it's the busy Halloween Season, plan to wait in line but definitely bring your money and try a little bit of everything. Great gift ideas too. read more

Ye Olde Pepper Companie - Candy Stores Near Me - Salem, Massachusetts

Charming little candy store in Salem, MA. Large variety of sweets and treats to snack on after a long day of shopping for cauldron and brooms. Try the Gibraltars! Minty goodness. read more

Mmmmmm......America's oldest candy shop. *Homer Simpson drool* On a girl-date with a friend who lives in Salem, I stopped by here not realizing it was across the street from the House of Seven Gables (also on our list of places to visit). Score on location! The store is that cute, slightly squashed, ye-olde-timey everything that's characteristic of fudge and candy shops in small towns across the country. They pack a lot in such a small space. I got the jelly beans, the coconut squares, a peanut butter and chocolate egg and an ice-cream truffle. What's an ice-cream truffle? It's milk chocolate on the outside, creamy, creamy vanilla on the inside. It's also chocogasmic. As was everything else. Except the jelly beans. I should have gotten the gummy bears instead. read more

This place is making boatloads of money, and yet they treat their customers like nothing more than an inconvenience. Some of the least welcoming, least polite, least friendly service I've had in a long time. If you expect to go in here and look around and what they have and ask questions- don't bother. This place is a revolving door and they move you through like cattle. No stopping. No questions. No talking. It's like if the soup nazi from Seinfeld opened a candy shop, except not in a funny way. 0 stars read more

This is a great place to stop. Practically right across from the House of The Seven Gables it is slightly off the beaten path. Oldest candy company in America. There is a lot of selection, many choices. Truefuls are a signature chocolate! Apparently it's a cross between a truffle and a cream center. They are yummy! One thing I will say is the staff here is the friendliest. I mean, they are the best. This goes a long way in my book. This place is always teeming with children and tourists. I personally happen to be a lover of both children, and tourists. However the onslaught must be incessant if I've been here, say, 15 times and it is always the case (I'm a local so that's not 15 times in tourist season or weekends only)! Despite this, the staff is reliably patient, helpful, friendly. It's unusual to feel so at home in a chocolate shop, but the staff ensures this, and does it well. Also I love the history of the place. It is kind of cool to a be part of something like this place. Go experience and enjoy it. Perhaps I should have started my review with the important credentials that the chocolate is really good, and the price is right! Also, of note : I have gone during this Covid era, and they are doing an amazing job with balancing safety protocols with maintaining a welcoming, congenial atmosphere and delicious candy. Thank you! read more

Was planning on purchasing a couple pounds of various fudges. I asked if I could have a small taste of one and was told no . We don't give free samples ...you have to buy it 1st before you can taste it. She could have easily said something positive like like if I give you a free sample the owners will take it out of my salary and laughed. I would have accepted this . But she wasn't apologetic or concerned and I walked out disappointed But glad I didn't give them my 30 or $40 that would have more than made up for the small taste I asked for. read more

I love this candy shop! They make their candy right on the premises and it's all so delicious. They have all types of candy: fudge, chocolates, hard candy, salt water taffy and even some hard to find varieties of candy. They make turtles here that are pretty awesome as well. read more

My friend Gary aka Gigi Gill took us to the Ye Olde Pepper Companie, where we spend about an hour shopping for a variety of chocolate treats. We purchased Taffy, and the famous turtles that made Ophra's 10 best things list. We purchase chocolate and candies for everyone we know, including ourselves. We have enough chocolate to get us through any apocalyptic event. This is a MUST place to go when visiting Salem. read more

I love this little store. Its quaint and old-fashioned and I wouldn't have it any other way. If you're walking to the House of the Seven Gables, it's easy to stop in for something sweet. The sugary goods are re-packaged, but the chocolate candies are made in-house. I love their bog turtles (caramel, nuts, and cranberries) and various truffles. The staff is always friendly, helpful, and patient -- even when they're completely swarmed in October. If you're interested in local flavor, this is it. They even have a display for Gibralters: the first commercially made candies in America (still made by them today). Worth checking out for the history and the selection. It's almost like stepping back in time! read more

You have to try their fudge! It was out of this world! The ladies st this shop were so lovely, too! If you get a chance to visit, have a look and see if you can find their old candy stored in an old glass jar. It's awesome. I highly recommend this place. read more

Ye Olde Pepper Companie - I brought some treats for my boys. They loved it. Great candy and fresh too. - Candy Stores Near Me - Salem, Massachusetts

A lot of history here and definitely a place all tourist should stop by to support a local business. It is a bit pricey but still one should make it a point to stop by. I tried some of their chocolates, Halloween mix, and sweet popcorn. All in all not the best candy but still good enough to enjoy! read more

LOVE LOVE LOVE this place. If you like candy, this place is nirvana. They make everything the old fashioned way with recipes that are about as old as the shop itself. I always get the milk chocolate covered butter creams and the chocolate covered caramels. Both are simply to die for. read more

In a world where most companies go under in a year or less, you can assume that a local candy company that's been around since guys were wearing wigs as a sign of social status is doing something right. Well, you would assume correctly. Ye Olde Pepper Company is in a house and it's full of CANDY! But not like twizzlers or crap like that, no it's full of old school candy made on the premises they way they used to back when Moby Dick was a tadpole. I seriously can't even begin to tell you what all they havem I can only say that everything i've had caused me to immediately fall in love with the first person I saw and Oprah like them. Yeah, seriously. Oprah. She LOVES this place. I mean, really, what do I matter? OPRAH-FRIGGIN-WINFREY LOVES YE OLDE PEPPER COMPANY! What else is there to say? GAH! Why are you still reading get down there before she does! It'll all be gone if you get there too late! read more

Super cute old fashioned candy shop with delicious treats. The molasses hard candies were so good and the peppermint and lemon old fashioned candies were perfect! I also purchased a few pieces of fudge that I was not super impressed with (pistachio, maple something, and a lemon). The store is quite small and got very crowded quickly. There is no flow in the traffic so it was annoying to try and look around and get in line to purchase my items. read more