Well, this is an update to the review I made 4 years ago. Today was a better experience all around…read more We arrived around 2pm and it was not crowded at all. They added an enclosed outdoor seating area, Thats lets you enjoy the breeze or sun, but protects you from the rain. It used to be a tent, so this is definitely nicer. My wife and I were seated immediately. The server quickly brought us water and garlic bread. I really like that they give you 5 fairly big pieces of garlic bread for only two people. Nice touch. We were not in a hurry and couldn't decide what we wanted so we started with the calamari salad. $29, but it's huge and chock full of those calamari guys. Lettuce is always crisp and has everything I like in it (olives, eggs, carrots, artichoke, peppers, cucumbers, tomatoes, onions, and romaine lettuce). We were almost full just from the salad alone. I ordered a grouper sandwich (not fried), and my lovely wife ordered the Scottish salmon plate, which comes with potatoes and grilled vegetables. My sandwich came with coleslaw and fresh cut fries. They switched to fresh cut since my last visit, and this was an upgrade. My sandwich was great, and huge too. Could not finish it. Wife's meal was a humongous slab of salmon. The veggies now come on a smaller plate, but that's okay, given the size of the fish. Service was a tad slow, but like I said, we weren't in any hurry. Total tab was $100, with tax and that pesky 3% service fee. I really enjoyed the food and the ambiance. It's not a place I can go every week, but when I can splurge, and have a taste for fresh seafood, this is the best around.

I drove a long way to obtain fresh quality seafood from an independent vendor. I was so put off by…read morethe extremely unfriendly, nearly mean, service. The cashier was a jerk. I don't think I'll be back bc of that. I'll drive to a further fish market just to be treated w friendliness. Get a grip on the FOH staff. She might need a day off.

I needed something very specific for a recipe, it's so hard to find guanciale to make carbonara!…read more Carnivore was about the 10th place I called and they right away let me know they had plenty! As soon as I walked in, I saw so many goodies I knew I was taking home. They had a very well curated selection of fancy condiments from small makers, rare ingredients, and the highest quality version of many every day foods! Everyone behind the counter was so friendly and knowledgeable. I had to try one of their sandwiches and got the salmon po boy at their recommendation. It was really well seasoned and super fresh with a very generous slice of fish on it. Definitely coming back for another one next time I'm in the area! Thank you so much for great service and products!

A gem of a shop! Great selection of quality meat and seafood. Very knowledgeable and kind staff…read more They make you feel very welcome! The lunch was unbelievable! Was nice to finally have a burger not dripping in grease. The sausage was an andouille. Had a nice kick to it and might have been even better than the burger. I'll come back to try some other items for sure.

Been buying salmon, cod, tilapia and other non-frozen fish from here for years and while a little…read morepricey, it's always the best fish available in my book. Never had any bad fish from here. I often buy 2-3 lbs of Atlantic salmon from here for smoking and it always turns out great. It's my go to store for fresh fish

I have been buying fish here for many years. Their prices are pretty high, but usually good…read morequality, especially fresh fish. Today I bought some fresh manila clams...which I've done many times before. They were not fresh... smelled off, and after I cooked them in a white wine,butter and lemon sauce for my spaghetti dish, they really smelled " unfresh" and funky. Threw everything out.

The options are a good variety. There is steamed, raw, or fried. The service was exceptional. The…read moreyoung lady was very kind and helpful. Oder options, order ahead or to go. No done in. The shrimp were good, the lobster tail a bit overcooked, the crab smaller and cooked properly. The flavor was different. I got the Cajun seasoning and they gave me garlic and a Cajun butter. Y weren't bad but again different. The broccoli was good and the potatoes were soft. Many drink options and desserts. In all fairness this is a place you will or you wont like it. Good thing you can get the seafood to go raw and cook it yourself.

The new boy that works the register is rude as hell I did not get my full order. he only gave me…read moreone butter for three things of crab legs, and dinner to feed three people and then missing my whole extra side of broccoli called up there four times and he hung up on me every single time he is not good for business and needs to be fired. Immediately the other boy that's usually there I never have a problem with spent $60 and didn't even get what I wanted. Refused to give me butter gave me one butter for a meal for three people. When I ordered over the phone asked for extra lemon pepper and lemon pepper on the side and he refused to give me a lemon pepper. I had no lemon pepper on my food at all!!!!

Owner was very friendly. He perfectly boned, skinned, and portioned an absolutely delicious lake…read moretrout for me. I had it for dinner tonight at it was excellent. Fresh, buttery, superior quality. Hearing the locals chatter in Yiddish is a nice touch of ambience.

Very happy with the fish we've gotten from Robert's. Better than anything from the grocery store.read more

I'm not sure why it's taking me years to do this review however I've been going to seafood city…read moresupermarket since they opened this Chicago location years ago. When it first opened, it was great to see how bright and clean it was and to see all of the incredible stacked foods and items. However, over the years it's definitely been worn down a little bit and could use a new refresh. What has been good is that they really expanded some of the seating area as well as the seafood city Grill area and the food offerings. However even this is slightly inconsistent as far as what's available when it's open, etc. It's also great that this particular location also is able to build out some of the other additional vendors like the bakery by Valerio. Again, though, I wish there was a little bit more consistency and organization throughout. Parking lot is has been quite ample except during peak times. I really wish they would open one in the suburbs as well. The only major disappointing thing was I used to carry the best Chicharron by Saint Michaels and then they absolutely abused and price gouged the bags. And eventually they stopped carrying it. I however, have gone directly to the stores to purchase.

First time here. Very large variety of shops and the grocery store part was very busy. They have a…read morelarge variety of items to purchase and I will be back, if in the area.

Great fresh smoked fish. Plenty of salmon types with garlic, lemon, and a honey maple syrup that's…read moreamazing. Love this place.

No bueno fish was not smelling fresh (halibut) and was dry…read more Eal is tough very salty Salmon was just ok Not coming back sorry Btw service is terrible but that's owners fault one person does everything from serving to cashiers

We've been to Flagship for the seafood we've needed to cook. It never disappoints…read more For the holidays we've gotten outstanding shellfish here. The mussels were the biggest I've seen since Arnold's Mr. Olympia days. The clams we recently had were also very good. Throw in a nice, crusty baguette, a wedge of humboldt fog, crackers and the must have sticky toffee cakes. Yes, cakes-plural. This was our favorite dessert when we lived across the pond. The ones they sell here are spectacular. Keep in the freezer, nuke for saucy goodness and thank me later.

Super cute roadside specialty food market and seafood shop. I wanted to try some local fish and…read morechips on my road trip. I ordered the fish and chips and a Diet Coke. At almost $25 it's not a cheap lunch. But it was delicious. A generous portion of flaky, thick cut fish was battered and fried dark golden brown. The fries were absolutely outstanding, but with a little too much salt.