Boy have I been missing out! I'd never tried Whits until this day. At first, I was overwhelmed by how many choices they had on their menu. The worker was kind and didn't rush me into making a fast decision. I ended up trying the "Hilliards finest" and it was delicious. It had brownie pieces, nuts, and hot fudge - perfect for a warm sunny day! read more

See all

I have been going to Whit's since it came to Cbus a few years ago!! I love it here & it is healthier than top competitors! That makes me feel a bit better at least lol. The parking gets a bit congested/difficult here in the summers with only street parking, so get ready to walk a bit! This location is adorable with the cutest, hardest workers! Whitsers are my favorite thing to order, which is vanilla custard mixed with different toppings. I got one with butterscotch, pecans & chocolate shavings last night and it was to die for, I will be back for another & definitely add it to my top flavor list! The prices are ok! Everything is always fresh! I always have to add in a doggie sundae as well with vanilla custard, peanut butter and a chocolate dog biscuit!! It is only a few minutes away from my home, so this is a very bad thing for my health, but good for local business! read more

Whit's Frozen Custard - My dog - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

See all

used to really enjoy Whits. we were getting whisters at least once a week. for the past month or so, every whitser has been disappointing. we pay for 2 additional mix ins, and there's hardly anything in them. I'm not interested in paying that much for a cup of only custard. it's really disappointing. :( read more

Drop what you're doing and head to Whit's. I mean it. Why are you still reading this review? You see it's 5 stars! But in all seriousness, Whit's is a step above the rest. I went to school in Missouri, so I got VERY accustomed to frozen custard over regular ice cream. So when I originally discovered Whit's, I knew I was in trouble. Whit's in Hilliard is a stand-alone storefront that looks like a former home. It's cute and quaint with very little seating inside and few benches outside. But it's in a perfect spot after dinner in downtown Hilliard where you can stroll up and down the sidewalks and enjoy delicious custard. And now on to the important stuff - the custard itself. If you've never had the pleasure of eating frozen custard, you are truly missing out. Frozen custard is like ice cream, except it's thicker and creamier. Whit's does scoops, sundaes, and "Whitsers" which are similar to concretes or blizzards. You can customize your own or pick any of the ones off the menu. Whit's also does special flavors throughout the month. My personal favorite is Mint Cookies and Cream. If they have extra, they put it in pints and quarts for you to take home. Whit's has several locations in the area, but the Hilliard one is always friendly, welcoming, and very clean. So if you're craving frozen yogurt, be sure to stop here! read more

Whit's Frozen Custard - Mint Cookies and Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

Had such a fun time at Whits! It was my first time having custard and my favorite part about it was that they had dairy free custard!! The staff was so kind and made the root beer float with the dairy free custard option. Their old fashioned root beer was tasty. It was a pretty big portion and took me a while to finish. It's a small shop but has some outdoor seating and you could even walk around and enjoy as well. Great time at Whit's! read more

See all

Very good ice cream I usually come here after the school year is over and every time I come, I am never disappointed. read more

Fantastic custard and very friendly staff. Lots of different ways to enjoy this treat with MANY different toppings. Well worth it! read more

See all

Waited 10 minutes to receive two melted cups of ice cream. I was the only person waiting on an order. Don't expect what you pay for. First time visitor also. read more

Whit's Frozen Custard - a cup of ice cream and a muffin - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

I am basing this off of my service. Keep in mind I was the only one there. A young girl working the counter refused to give me pints of several different flavors I asked for she pretended to walk back didn't look and said that they were out of those... which seems odd for an ice cream place for multiple flavors... then said the only flavors I could get in a pint were in the cooler/already made up.. apparently your employee didn't feel like scooping ice cream. She was very rude. Hope business owner or manager reads this. I won't be back. read more

I've been hesitant to try because i didn't know what custard was.... needless to say it's delicious! The difference is that it's denser than ice cream (no air in the swirly machine) and has to have egg yolk to emulsify. Anyway I got the mudpie ( vanilla Oreo and caramel---- i don't know if it said mocha but I didn't get any and honestly it's ok..... i didn't need it) I got the mini size and it's definitely enough. The young girls working were friendly and patient..... I can never make up my mind at these places. Give Dairy Queen a break and drive down to Whits read more

This is a nice addition to Hilliard's little downtown. We've twice walked down for ice cream after having dinner at Local Cantina. It's very small and doesn't appear to have restrooms, but there is seating inside and the front patio. They have great selections of ice creams and toppings. Last night I had a caramel apple sundae: vanilla ice cream (custard) with apple and caramel topping. It was fantastic. The small serving cup is just the right size; it's an ample portion. The teenagers who work there are all pretty friendly and efficient. read more

Best custard ever miss them they use to have a store on karric place on frants rd. But for sure I will visit them at their store on Hilliard now that I know read more

Very creamy and you get a lot! Also a good amount of mix-ins, worth paying for 100%! I could tell the custard was fresh and the service was great too. Very nice and very fast! Absolutely would come back and recommend to anyone in the area! read more

I was so skeptical before my wife talked me into trying Whits for the first time,but We love this place. Tons of variety to choose from and it's always delicious! The staff at this location has always been friendly and attentive to our needs. read more

I've only been here once, and overall, my experience was pretty good. My friends LOVE this place and I was pretty excited to try it out. The workers were very friendly, they had a lot of different options to choose from, and the place itself was really nice and 'aesthetically pleasing'. However, the custard was just ok (I got the dairy free vanilla). I'd definitely recommend trying it out for yourself, though. They have sooo many options to choose from I'm sure there's something there for everyone!! read more

I am sure of the custard is good, however the establishment does not keep to its hours. They close quite early according to the time they were supposed to close, and then even though they saw me at the door they pointedly ignored me trying to patronize their establishment read more

As a recovering lactose-intolerant, Whit's renewed my love for ice cream. High quality ingredients lead to the creamy custard that you'll want again and again. I love their daily and weekly flavor variety. If you're in the mood for something chocolatey, get chocolate custard with brownies and pecans, lightly blended. If you want something lighter, get the Hawaiian luau: vanilla ice cream with pineapple, bananas, coconut and macadamia nuts. I also recommend getting a mini or small as this stuff is RICH. It's a great addition to downtown Hilliard. Go to the splash pad with the kids and walk down to get frozen custard. A perfect evening! read more

They had their music on full volume when I went in, then 3 girls at the counter started laughing and joking about how loud the music was and turned it down to just loud...then I said I need to make a call and ask someone at home which flavor they wanted...only person in store mind you...3 people "working" and when I got on the call they turned the music back to full volume. I could not hear my call and asked them to turn it down again. They laughed and turned it down, making jokes about it. Then I tried to order, and they got 2 out of 3 ice creams wrong...mine was beyond tiny, and another one had wrong toppings we found out later, and also not mixed, lumped in bottom of cup. While I waited for ONE out of the 3 to slowly make my order while the other two dance...they turned the music to full volume again. This time I said to turn the music down! And they acted like I was insane, and gave me my wrong order and I was shaking by this time(due to my cptsd, and the fact that I am affected by very loud sounds) and they were laughing and turning the music up again as I left, but still in store. NEEEEVVVVEEERRRR going back!!!! Terrible experience, zero consideration for anyone, and the delicious ice cream was ruined by getting the order seriously wrong. I paid 17 dollars, and my icecream was less than half a scoop, but was supposed to be 2 scoops! I ended up getting more ice cream at Graeters, which is where I will continue to frequent! read more

I've lived in Hilliard for almost a year now and somehow I didn't realize there was a Whit's in the downtown area! I'm so sad that I've missed out on their custard for so long. I've been lucky enough to go to undergrad and grad school in towns that have Whit's, so I was excited to be able to frequent Whit's again, especially because it will be walking distance from my home. I'm partial to the Buckeye Madness Whitser (all of their Whitser's blow Dairy Queen out of the water, in my opinion), but recently I've been a fan of trying their flavor of the week. Recently I ordered one scoop of the Raspberry Chip and one scoop of the Peanut Butter Cookie Dough. Both were delicious, although I will admit there wasn't a ton of cookie dough in my Peanut Butter Cookie Dough ice cream. I'll definitely be back! read more

All I gotta say is.... get very stoned. Go get a Whitser. Throw whatever toppings you want in it. Enjoy every single spoonful. Come back again next time. That's my pattern. read more

I stood there for 20 minutes for them to get my order wrong. I was burning up and when I told them my order was wrong they were rude about it. My order wasnt that good and they overcharged me. Will not go back soon. read more

Whit's is the absolute best custard around!! The contactless pick up is great, all the staff is so nice! I ordered 3 pints today and they all taste amazing! It is my favorite place to go! Delicious all the way around!! Any flavors you can think of!! Go get yourself some! read more

I noticed Whit's after driving past a few days before. Decided to go one night after dinner and knew it must be good with the line out the door. I do not remember ever trying frozen custard before and was delighted with my purchase. The custard was very creamy and the toppings were plentiful. Will definitely be going back. read more

Frozen custard is the best frozen treat and Whit's is the best frozen custard. Great value, especially the pints and quarts in the fridge. Homemade on site deliciousness. read more

Creamy and flavorful frozen custard! One of these days I will have to order a sundae but I just can't get over their chocolate custard as is. My recommendation is to think about what you want ahead or time because there are a lot of options to choose from. Perfect for a hot day but I feel like it does melt quicker than the hard ice cream. read more

The frozen custard is delicious, but the waffle cones are stale and gross; it actually ruined the custard. The service wasn't great either. read more

Whit's Frozen Custard - Menu - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

See all

My fiancé and I tried their frozen custard for the first time last week. It was the best we have had so far! Definitely will be making the trip back! read more

Weird hours, driveway to parking once blocked with their food service truck, so couldn't park. That said, it's great custard. A little short on pineapple in a shake I ordered once but otherwise delicious. read more

I was really excited when Whit's of Hilliard changed locations to a more central and downtown location. The location is great but there is essentially no parking - they say there is a back lot but by the time employees park and you worry about getting blocked in, you opt to parallel park off Main St. Or just park at the gas station and pizza place next door which I really try not to do... This Whit's never has the number of quarts or breadth of flavors available compared to the other stores. They did start some daily flavors on the weekend when they reopened (yay!), but there are some fun concoctions that other local stores try that I never see advertised. Also, I have never seen pistachio at this location, ever. The outdoor patio and walkability is great, but the inside is a disaster. The cash register is right next to the door so the line is very confusing. to enter/exit using the front door you run into patrons waiting to order that think you are trying to cut them in line. Once you finally make it in the door you ask all 20 people where the end of the line is and if they have already ordered. Don't get me wrong, the custard is incredible and is my favorite local 'ice cream' as a Granville native, but this location is not my favorite. It is the closest so I try to go before it gets busy and buy a quart and get out. read more

The portion sizes are huge! The prices are good and the taste is great. Minimal parking, but still better than most places in old Hilliard. You can eat either outside or inside, and the staff is very friendly. read more

I went here and this young chap named Adam B. served me. Give him a raise his work goes unnoticed.

Love the product. Love the flavor. Hate the wait. When you have so many soccer players across the street that the soccer parking has to rollover into the field next to it, you have a pretty captive audience. How about planning ahead with a few more gallons of custard to be scooped? It may help speed up product delivery. May need to add another scooper, or work on efficiency. 10 people deep, waiting on a machine to churn out product may end up costing you business. read more

Great custard, and nice staff. Parking is confusing for me, but that's Old Hillard in general.

Our family of 8 went in tonight around 8pm and the staff was very pleasant, courteous and fast! Custard was delicious!

My favorite frozen custard place! Buckeye madness is bomb. And FYI - I guess they are moving to old Hilliard in February.

Wouldn't return. Place was packed, which is great for business. Took a bit to get our order but it was good. However the girl with the Skelton clips in her hair (curly dark hair) was not nice. I heard her say "ugh only one more hour" loud enough for customers to hear while scooping ice cream. She had a terrible attitude that needs addressed, others noticed it too. Next time we'll just go to Dairy Queen or anywhere else. Felt like I was a nuisance being there. read more

Whit's is my favorite place for frozen custard. I have been to Whit's a number of times but this is the first time I have been to this location. The location was very clean and tidy and the employees were very friendly and patient with our group. We all had the buckeye frozen custard, the flavor of the week. Buckeye is peanut butter custard with chopped up Reese's and peanut swirls. Slap it in one of their awesome waffle cones and I'm happy as can be! read more

Loyal whits customer! So good, nothing compares to frozen custard. The food is great too!

This is the place to go if you want frozen custard. They have a new flavor every week so check out the calendar online and go try a unique flavor. The staff is always quick and friendly and the shop is clean. read more

We love eating ice cream at Whit's. They don't have a ton flavor selections but they make up for it with topping selections. It's always fun to try their flavor of the week. We've been there several times and have not been disappointed. read more