Never Again! Server ignored us for the first 15 minutes we were there. And there was only one other customer. Server said yes, you can substitute a salad for fries, but, charged me for a salad. It was lunch, so we only had soda. They charged us for every refill and didn't say anything. For two of us our soda bill was almost $20. We should have had beer at those prices. I still left a decent tip, but I was pissed when I left $75 for a two person hamburger lunch. read more

Just when you think you've walked into a dive bar, you get surprised by a 5 star experience. I'm so sad I don't have a picture because it would be very different than the other pics on here. But, we were starving. They have scaled back on their menu bc of covid, so if you had something in mind, call first. BUT, the abbreviated menu was all we needed! We had the capris pizza. Please don't kill me, but I don't care for the Buffalo style thick, sweet sauce pizza (but don't get me wrong--I eat it). This was wood fired and maybe a combo of Neapolitan/New York? It was crispy but just thicker than Neapolitan. This was a white pizza with pesto. This tasted like everything but the cheese was made in house. The slight drizzle of balsamic was delicate but meaningful. All in all, this was not at all the pizza we expected when we walked into a bar called Whiskey Hill in Lilydale. It was some of the best pizza we've had. We will be back, but also when we just need a drink. The place was adorable, the crowd was friendly, the bar tender was helpful and made an excellent old fashioned. read more

The food was amazing! The drinks and ambiance were also amazing. This was an unexpected gem in Cassadaga. So cute and rustic. The outdoor area was perfect and shaded. I loved it. read more

Whiskey Hill Saloon - Fried pickles (hand not included) - Bars Near Me - Cassadaga, New York

See all

I'm a Halloween person! Like year round lifestyle choice haha! This is some of the coolest Halloween decorations I've seen in a place! Amazing nice crispy wings with many great flavs and nice thick ranch! The only down sides to this place are the long wait time on food, bad cell reception (I can't even check in), and it's pretty pricy for what and where it is. read more

See all

This may have been a good place once upon a time. Now it sucks. $19 for taco salad that was 90% Romain lettuce. Totally sucked. Romain lettuce was used as a base to prop up a small amount of crappy meat. Can't say enough how sucky it was. I'll never go back. read more

Great food and great service and always a great time! They always have great entertainment and good drinks.

5 Stars for the wonderful Halloween decor. Sadly no one under 21 is allowed to see it (or eat there.) No parties over 6 people allowed and no credit cards allowed. The food was also 5 Stars. Pot roast dinner and order of spicy chile wings. Delicious. However, very slow service and we could only be seated in the bar, although the dining room (with comfortable chairs) was only a few feet away. $17 for 10 chicken wings + $1 for extra bleu cheese? Is that the new normal? So, the negatives balanced out the positives and that is the reason for the 3 Stars. It used to be much better and hoping they can get back to that someday. (Photos are the Halloween decor, staff was nice looking.) read more

See all

This place meant a lot to me. I have been going here for over 15 years whenever we visit our family here in the area. We are from California so we come here only during the summer. I have been bringing my kids since there were little. Now that this place is 21 and over and cash only it is safe to say that it is a massive disappointment. I am truly sad about this. read more

We stopped going to whiskey hill after they changed there rules to 21 years or older. We would go there about 2 to 3 times a month to order there wings because they were the best but the fact that I had a baby and can't bring her in is insulting. Not going to give business to a place that won't accept my family!!!! We always looked forward to the Halloween decorations and ambiance of this place and my daughter would have loved it. read more

Great atmosphere. This saloon is a clean and 'dark' little watering hole. Wings are wonderful. B dubs X four is how I'd judge them. Whiskey selection is nice. Beers are abundant. Staff was inviting. Would definitely recommend. read more

Stopped in around 8 on Friday and had an amazing dinner! Ordered the Cowboy Jack burger off the specials menu, which was piled high with 4 onion rings, a fried egg, lettuce, tomato, sweet pepper relish and mayo, served with Buffalo tots, YUM!! Paired with a mule, it was perfect and filling, took half of the burger home. Their menu is diverse and it was evident from the flavors and variety that the chef knew what he/she is doing. Will definitely come back! read more

Stop in on a busy Sunday and sat at the bar. First thing I noticed the employees were not that overly friendly. To start I ordered chicken wings extra crispy, when they came out they were actually not crispy at all. It was nice to see that the fish and seafood dinners are offered here on Friday's, Saturday's and Sunday's so I ordered the fish fry. The fish was good but I didn't care for either side Mac and Cheese and the Cauliflower. Maybe the employees are over worked as I don't believe there is another good place in the area but I would have given 3 stars but since I had to ask for napkins, Tartar sauce, since the kitchen forgot mine and it seemed like every person working there had a bad attitude or was grumpy. read more

Whiskey Hill Saloon - Wings ordered extra crispy that came out not even crispy. - Bars Near Me - Cassadaga, New York

See all

I ordered the Tri-Pirogies, Garbage Charred Wings, Potato Salad and a Coke. $27.00 Authentic Polish ingredients, techniques and flavors, great quality. Garbage wings: I guessed plum, honey, bourbon, nutmeg.....I was told that I couldn't be more wrong.... read more

See all

Food was great and the menu has a good variety. I had the jack daniels burger and peanut butter pie. Both were great and a good size for the price. The pie is a frozen pie. Decent beer selection including a few craft beers. The wine list includes a local winery, Merritt. I'm always glad to see places carry local wine. read more

I use to love this place very sad its Not the place its use to be. Completely fell off. Food is horrible. Menu is 5 items. And they cant even get that right. No wings, or fish fry, some of there top items no longer. And my fav jacked up nachos. They need to lose that shit cook. Sorry its true. I loved that place. read more

What a pleasant surprise. We were driving from Syracuse to Jamestown and the kids were getting hangry. The ambiance alone is worth the pit stop. The menu is extensive pub fare - not too many healthy options - but if you are looking for deep fried pickles, pot roast wraps, wings and burgers, this is a pretty great option. Lots of beer options to wash it all down. Also check out the pierogies, which my son loved. My only complaint was how slow the kitchen was. We kept ourselves occupied with "Eye Spy" and trips to the bathroom to check out the decor. read more

Whiskey Hill Saloon - a view of the bar - Bars Near Me - Cassadaga, New York

See all

We used to frequent this restaurant but will most likely not go back. Our grandchildren loved the food and enjoyed all of the decorations. Now that children and for that matter,anyone under 21, is no longer welcome, it leaves one to wonder what goes on there that people are no longer allowed to dine there as a family? Do you not need or want family business? Whiskey Hill- I hope you will respond. read more

Would not recommend we wre visiting out of state and had 2hours before having to be somewhere about 4people in there we ordered best thing on menu lady came back and said 30 min later she forgot to put the order in so we left nobody in there how do you forget just horrible service I rate you 000should be ashamed of yourself treating out of town guests like this big deal we got our pop for free .they had no problem waiting on the people at the bar our mom had just passed that week and thought we could have a good meal somewhere close to where we were .4people again 4people and 3were at the bar .this is ashame read more

My fiance and I were looking for a place on the way home from Niagara Falls to the Cleveland area. We couldn't find anything worthwhile on the IExit app so I turned to Yelp! I talked my fiance into driving 15 minutes off the freeway to try Whiskey Hill Saloon for something different and I'm so glad we did! When we walked in, we had a choice to sit in the dining room, a covered patio area or the bar. We decided on the bar, as it had some cool decor and most patrons were in there. Had to follow the reviews and try the garbage wings - fried & chargrilled wings with spicy BBQ sauce - YUM! One of the best wings I've had. I ordered a sandwich that had brisket, pulled pork and ham with a BBQ sauce. That was also delicious! My fiance tried the brisket pierogies; he said they weren't to his liking but everything else was really good! Can't wait to come back on a trip out to the Finger Lakes region! read more

See all

Don't bother if anyone in your party is under 21. They will refuse you service. Now if this was just a bar I'd totally understand. I mean of course you wouldn't serve anyone under 21. But this is a restaurant as well. I've never gone to a restaurant with a bar and seen families being turned away because someone in the party is under 21!! Which is exactly what happened to us when my family tried to go out for dinner with my 20-year-old daughter. We had dined there before Covid, when my daughter was a teenager and no one said a word, so not sure when this rule went into effect. Needless to say, we won't ever be going back there even when she turns 21. read more

I've been going here for a few years now just a few times each year but every time its always nice and yummy. Sometimes the music near the bar can be too loud and if you sit in this one corner the speaker is literally right behind you and incredibly annoying.. The food hits the spot every time though and beer prices are good. Be aware that it can be really busy and you might be waiting for a table read more

Whiskey Hill Saloon - Whiskey Hill Sandwich - Bars Near Me - Cassadaga, New York

i have loved this place from the start, awesome atmosphere with people to match and the menu is even better right along with the massive drinks!!! read more

The freakin friday fish fry is one of th best I ever had. Perfectly, lightly crisped batter around fresh caught haddock. I came back for the Saturday fish fry also (only 2 a week). The fried appetizers were all eh, including veggies, jalapeno cheese curds, jack daniels shrimp, onion ring twistys things, etc. The chard garbage wings were pretty good, giving it a 3/5. The honey mustard wings were 2/5. The service fukin ruled all the girls are friendly. Plus we were here during Halloween Haunted Dining all month, basically a makeshift haunted house is there all October. Which rules. Place gets it. Ill be back for the haddock. read more

Whiskey Hill Saloon - Kiddin me? #beast - Bars Near Me - Cassadaga, New York

Went for my sons early birthday dinner while visiting him at college. Loved the Halloween decor! The service was amazing on a very busy night. And for a table of 7, everything came out very fast. Food was very good! We had a great time and I'll absolutely take my family again! read more

See all

This is a fun place with a great ambiance. Other than a long wait for our food everything has been great. We got their garbage wings, sweet whiskey and charred bbq wings. The wings were amazing and we will definitely come back here in a heartbeat! read more

Whiskey Hill Saloon - Bars Near Me - Cassadaga, New York

See all

Used to be a wonderful restaurant and bar but now seems more concerned on being a party bar. They have ok bar food now, but do not let any family in. I came in with my daughter and 15 year old granddaughter to eat, it is the only sit down restaurant in Cassadaga. Was told we could not eat there as grandchild was under 21. What was disturbing is they have a pretty decent sized dining area --separate from the bar area. But nope, wouldn't let us eat there if we don't buy booze. What a shame. I can understand no young kids up at a bar, but a 15 year old girl in a dining room? I know this is not a state law, it is their preference. I have nothing against bars, but if you are serving meals and have tables...anyway, I ate there prior to this incident. Food wasn't extraordinary enough to give them any business and support their obvious dislike of families at their businesses. read more

I find myself here at the whiskey Hill saloon in a very festive atmosphere toasty warm near an old fashioned register. The ceiling in the bar is alight with tiny string lights. Christmas decorations abound throughout the restaurant. Annette was our server and she is very sweet. She was helpful, patient and very happy to serve us. We felt very welcome. The food was good with good portion size. I had a fish fry and my friend had chicken wings. There is off street parking. Rest room is very nice and clean. I will definitely be back. read more

See all

I gave it one star to be able to write this review. The take out was great, but they have been closed for weeks now. Too bad! read more

This place was a treat! My friends from the area rave about Whiskey Hill and are never disappointed. We sat at the bar and were greeted by the awesome bar tenders - they took excellent care of us while we were there and we enjoyed chatting with them. Their cocktail menu is certainly different - I had their blue lemonade, which apparently can knock you out if you aren't careful (yes, it tastes sweet). If you want shots, they have them too - ask the bartenders! Since we were starving, we started with the fried calamari, which they only offer on some occasions. We were very impressed with the delicious calamari and the home-made cocktail sauce, which had a little kick to it. For the wings, we shared a double order of the "garbage" flavored wings - HOLY MOLY this was delicious. The wings themselves came out nice and hot. The "garbage" flavor is essentially a mix of multiple wing sauces (wet rubs) and it comes out tasting like a tangy barbecue sauce. Those wings were addictive. My point? If you're in the area, you have to give Whiskey Hill Saloon a try, I promise it won't be disappointing! read more

Came in at meal change breakfast to lunch. The staff was friendly and the place was clean. Apologized it be a few minutes as the kitchen made the change. Ordered drinks came out fast. Food had good flavor and portions were just right. Great decor. Servers worked as a team. Plenty of parking. read more

Whiskey Hill Saloon - Bars Near Me - Cassadaga, New York

Visited a few days before Christmas, arriving in earlier evening when it wasn't too busy. By the time we were done, the place was almost packed! Our family said it's always a wait on the weekends! Four of us shared the wing bucket. We had medium, BBQ, and garlic flavored. The wings were tasty, and definitely more than enough for all of us. We also had the fried banana peppers and onion rings. They were pretty good, probably wouldn't get banana peppers again. I can tell whiskey hill is a favorite in this neck of the woods. Both times that I've been, I enjoyed the food and environment. I know we will be back on our next visit! read more

Place was decent had the taco pizza was exactly what you'd expect from a taco pizza. The chicken Tenders left a lot to be desired. Pizza logs were excellent and loaded fries were delicious. Would definitely come back again not a total write off but would definitely try different menu items. read more

Got right into the restaurant, was directed to a board to write down my name to wait for my seat, wrote my name down, great environment. Ordered a blue raspberry lemonade, TASTED DELIGHTFUL. Got the fried pickles and the soft pretzels with cheese and honey mustard as an app. Both were delightful. Ordered the cheeseburger with bacon, mayo, cheese, onion, and lettuce. IT WAS DEAD HEAT!!! This burger was one of the BEST ive had in this country the U S OF A! Only downside was the wait and where we were seated. read more

See all

Nicer inside than it looks from the outside, with cute country decor. The food was excellent and there was a ton to choose from. read more

I asked for a burger Rare and got a burger with no pink. I know better than to send food back to a kitchen. plus, they could warn you that you don't get free refills. We were waiting for our check and ready to leave and she asked if I wanted more tea. I said sure and got charged the additional $2.50 FOR UNSWEETEDED ICED TEA... Food is overpriced for average bar food. read more

Get the taco salad with a margarita or the wings too ! While I was eating, kept looking around and around. read more

See all

I have been to Whiskey Hill twice. The first time was a few years ago and the food was decent, no real complaints but nothing to really brag about. I went again yesterday and... my two stars could possibly be three but they lean two for this reason: the prices are nuts. A single order of wings for $11 or a double for $21 is ridiculous. Our whole order (single order of wings, single order of cheese sticks, 3 Busch Lights and 3 Bud Lights) came to $45... unreal. Don't get me wrong, the food was still decent. I just can't figure out why the prices are that high except that there could be some greed involved. Either way, it wasn't the worst meal (if you can call it that) I've had but it wasn't he best. Consider saving yourself some cash and just going to the grocery store down the street and buying all the above for $25. read more

Had planned an evening with friends from Pennsylvania at an approximate 1/2 way meeting location from Buffalo. Our original intent was to have dinner at EBC at the Dunkirk/Fredonia location but it was unexpectedly "closed for employee training and cleaning". Asked a "local" (Taylor)walking by on the sidewalk for a recommendation (after Yelp reviews of nearby options did not seem terribly appealing). She nailed it when recommending The Whiskey Hill Saloon (ten minutes away in Cassadaga)! Large menu offering of good quality and personalized service. Excellent burgers, the wings with their "garbage" sauce rival the best wings in Buffalo, and the fried pirogies were good although the pirogies portions were on the smaller side. Very nice house salad. Very good house-made pies and cakes. Good selection of beer. Clearly a family operation and worth the 1 hour drive from the Buffalo area for future visits. Don't be put off by the exterior appearance, interior is western themed and nicely decorated. Parking is in a lot behind the building (accessed from side street at the signal). read more

I've driven by this place many many times over the years. I can recall it being other bars / restaurants over the years too. I never once stopped before as Cassadaga is normally somewhere I am driving through in the morning or on the way home after a long day at work. Never a place I drive by right around lunchtime until now. While doing some work at a local establishment my customer kept talking about lunch and suggested we all go to Whiskey Hill. When we arrived I was actually thrown off a little. It is a very nice place in "the middle of no where". It was a little confusing where you go to get a table or if we were supposed to pick out own?? We went to the bar and were promptly sat. The very friendly woman may have told us the specials?? I have no idea as I was too busy admiring the unique decor and really cool lights they have hanging from the ceiling throughout the restaurant. I ordered Jalapeño cheese curds as an appetizer then the Jack Daniels burger for my meal. We all split the Jalapeno's cheese curds which were great, but had no hint of Jalapeño to them at all. The burger was wonderful and cooked perfectly, the fries were bland and boring steak fries. By changing the fries or maybe adding a little bit of creole spice to those bland fries would have made my meal over the top. This will to deter me however, the food was great, the service was great, the atmosphere was great!!! I will be back!! read more

Whiskey Hill Saloon inhabits the space that many other bars have been in, however I think it's going to stand the test of time. The previous bar was Howie's (I think), and served a very small menu that was below average bar fare. Whiskey Hill Saloon looks like a small town bar, but looks are deceiving. The owners have really made Whiskey Hill Saloon gorgeous inside - don't get me wrong, it's not a fancy place. But the food? Really good. The wings are decent, but you can get those anywhere. Go for the beef on wheck - my mom's favorite that I think she could eat every night when we're in New York. She says it is one of the best she has ever had. One night I had the burrito which was just average, and that's the worst item I've had to eat or drink. The pizza is better than any chain. Any sandwich I've had has been wonderful. Food and drink are very reasonably priced, especially for good food. The best part is by far the service. Once you've been in a few times, they treat you like a regular and remember you. They remember my friend, my mom, and I from last summer! (I also enjoy being in a bar that has cowboy hats all over it, but having a conversation about both Lil Wayne and Social Distortion with two employees). The servers and bartenders are all so friendly and very fun - they all seem to really enjoy being there. There are different drink specials every night - I was pretty happy to have Southern Tier on draft as I grew up in that area but now live in Cleveland. My mom definitely enjoyed the Ruby Relaxer (or three) - they were a very generous pour without tasting like pure alcohol or just sugar mixer. read more