A good, simple NY-style pizza. Hot and saucy and cheesy. Thin foldable crust. Big slices! There's a full takeout menu, too. It's in a corner gas-station. It' small. Don't blink or you'll miss the pizza shop! Nice welcoming staff. I was out with a hot melty slice in a couple of minutes! read more

See all

They must've had a price increase. It is now $4.50 a slice or the equivalent of $36 a pizza. It's very thin and floppy but has a decent taste, and a lot of grease see picture. read more

Waterloo Pizza - Slice of pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, Maryland

Was in the area and saw slices at this spot that's attached to a gas station so decided to give them a try. Take-out spot with pizza and a good amount of sandwich options. Pizza slices looked fresh so ordered a cheese and a pepperoni. Billed as NY style and I would say the slices lived up to it. Thinner crust with balanced ratio of cheese and toppings. We enjoyed these slices. Service was ok. Looks like they have a second location in Elkridge. An out of the ordinary location for a pizza spot but it works for some tasty slices. read more

See all

This place is a hidden Gem. Don't sleep on it, they probably have the best fast Pizza. I'd rather go here than order from any of the fast food pizza chain. It's not going to Beat your Wise guys pizza or Andy's pizza but man I'd say they have the best NY style pizza in Howard county. The service is quick and casual. They even have a bar table outside to eat at. I'd definitely comeback again. read more

Waterloo Pizza - Pepperoni by the slice - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, Maryland

Pizza is decent and the wings are great. Fast service and convenient. I like that they open late. For people like me who often get off work late. It's a great place to get late dinner. read more

I went on Next Door ap asking the best Pizza in Columbia, MD....everybody said this spot... Place was busy. The fried mushrooms are nasty. Jalapeno poppers were very greasy and not memorable. Pizza was ok but Ive had better in the area. Its a real whole in the wall next to a gas station. Save your money and go with Diogiornos. read more

Friendly staff, I have been eating their delicious pizza by the saline for years. Today I had the cheesesteak, hot and delicious. Also their fried zucchini, wonderful. Also recommend their cold cut sandwich. Also very tasty. read more

Waterloo Pizza - Hmmmm pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, Maryland

Not like old days! Low quality and much smaller portion. Subway is much better at this point read more

Waterloo Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, Maryland

See all

I'm a regular at this place, when I first moved into the area I thought to myself: "Gas station pizza? Really?". Well, I was wrong. Fantastic pizza! Not as good as NY slice but pretty good. The guy running the shop seems nice enough. One complaint is that they put mayo by default on the cheesesteaks. Good food. Decent prices. Would recommend. read more

I finally found the NY style pizza I had been searching for in the greater Baltimore area. The crust was thin and crispy and the sauce was delicious, not sweet at all. I thought the cheese was enough and the slice was bigger than a regular pizza slice. The owner, Chris came to talk to us and he was super nice and asked us what we thought of the pizza. I told him that was the best slice I ever had in Maryland. I like crispy slices and it wasn't greasy at all! I would definitely go back and try a whole pie this time and try the cheesesteak sub! read more

You're going to instantly look at this place and judge. Let me have your attention for a second. Listen to me ... DON'T. My GF recommended Waterloo Pizza to me after a wine festival & I trust her opinion to I went into this experience hopeful. To say that they've exceeded my expectations each time I've gone is the understatement of the month. This is the closest thing to New York style pizza that I've tasted in MD. The staff is friendly, the food is fresh, and authentic. They have lasagna. They have wings. They have cheeseburger subs and everything is delicious but the star of the show is definitely the pizza and you'd be cheating yourself if you don't try it atleast once. Trust me. read more

Let's call today's dining experience a weak 4...more like a 3.5, TBH. Visiting from PA for a soccer match, and found pizza nearby at Wqterloo. Was surprised to find it in a gas station, and unfortunately, was disappointed to find no seqting...besides the outdoor "deck??" On what probably was the old dumpster pad. Nice overlook of a green space, surrounded by bags of trash outside the fence. Pizza quality was fair. A bit greasy, but for $12, not bad. 1 topping was free. Suited our road-warrior purposes today, and let the dog join us for outdoor seating. The other good reviews certainly indicate a good following with the local crowd, and TBH again, maybe the ambiance affected my palate. Really friendly counter staff. Decent grab and go, but I wouldn't come here for atmosphere. read more

I decided to see what the hype was with the pizza. The pizza was ok on the bland side. The service was good, but there prices are outrageous $ 5.00 for a slice of pizza, and the small pizza with 3 toppings $16+. read more

We were gifted a nice large pizza from Waterloo over the weekend. Surprisingly, we've never tried this place despite the positive reviews and it being so close. IT WAS LEGIT!! the pizza was cooked perfectly, crispy but also still had a nice Chew and not like a cracker crust. They definitely do not skimp on toppings!!! The delivery person also wore a mask and gloves which is appreciated. Will order here again!! read more

I've been ordering delivery from here much too often lately. Delivery is incredibly fast and the food is still insanely hot upon delivery. As the mother of a nearly one and a half year old, speedy hot food is a rarity these days for me. I love that I've found a place that routinely delivers both! My go to here is a pepperoni pizza and an order of their stuffed shells or manicotti. I know, you're thinking stuffed shells from a place connected to a gas station? Yes! They're surprisingly good! Entrees also come with garlic bread and a side salad. I get their house dressing which seems to be of the Greek variety. SUPER tasty. The pizza is one of my favorites but not necessarily one of the best I've ever had. They're pretty conservative when it comes to toppings. As a result I've started ordering double pepperoni. That's my only complaint! read more

Don't let the location fool you. I got 2 slices to go and damn they were on point! The slices are huge for a couple of dollars. I also burned my face off but it was totally worth it. The sauce had some tang to it, not too much cheese but just the right amount. The dough is cooked to perfection. This place is an absolute gem. The staff was friendly and place smelled amazing when you walk in. If this place was on my way home, I would be here everyday and be proud of the weight I put on. read more

One of the Best pizzas and subs in town. Prices are reasonable, Quick and friendly service. read more

A spectacular mistake! Long-story-short: Ordered 4 pizzas and on one of them instead of ordering a regular 16-inch pizza with pepperoni and mushrooms, I mistakenly ordered a White Pizza with pepperoni and mushrooms. Caught the error too many minutes later to change it, plus we all figured "what the heck, why not?" And oh my GAWD was it good! Shout out to the kitchen staff at Waterloo - they used fresh sliced mushrooms. Don't even bother trying this from anyplace that uses canned mushrooms: it will not be the same awesome pizza we just devoured. We will definitely be ordering this again. Pardon me to anyone who is already a fan of this combo, but I just never thought the words "pepperoni" and "white pizza" went together as deliciously as they do when you're ordering from Waterloo. The picture shows the last 2 slices seconds before they were scarfed up. read more

I come here pretty often. The product is great, just about anything you order is going to be above average. They're one of the few places that use cup pepperoni on there pizza as well. Also, the deserts are amazing. I'm not sure where they source them from but they're legit. The cheesecake is perfect. Not too sweet and just the right density, the baklava is perfect, and tiramisu has the proper espresso taste. Mind you this is all at gas station. Highly recommend. Owner, and service are generally meh, but the food is worth it. read more

Best pizza around even sell by the slice so worth the trip there great service the garlic knots are amazing

I ordered a large cheese stake and was very dispointed . 1st. The roll was very old and it was toasted trying to make it better, did not work. The meat was very little and only covered 2/3 of the roll. What a riip off for what they charge. I do like there pizza but stay away from subs. read more

We order here a couple times a month. It's so close.. they deliver so quickly and everything is always so insanely hot a fresh it's like they have ovens in their cars. I always appreciate a good pizza and sub shop, they also have decent chicken Alfredo, my only gripe is their lasagne and red sauce items are very heavy veggie and almost like "Greek inspired Italian" but it's not bad, just not my fave item. Go to for us are pizza and subs chicken cheesesteak is chopped grilled chicken breast.. yum. read more

This is a review for the supreme pizza. I ordered it based off a recommendation in a local food group. I always get this style of pizza at restaurants. It was an early Friday evening with only 1 other customer so not busy. Shop is located in a small space attached to the Exxon station. I don't mind this setup. The workers seemed attentive and friendly. Once I got the pizza home 5 minutes away, it was very disappointing. The flavor wasn't there, tasted almost like they rinsed the whole pizza under water. The cheese and dough seemed undercooked. Fortunately, I also got some jumbo hot wings which were good. I had to force myself to finish the pizza so it wouldn't go to waste. There are too many other good inexpensive pizzas in the area to go through this again. read more

I love Waterloo. Don't be turned off by the fact its located in a gas station. The menu is quite large and I've never been disappointed. The Shrimp Salad here is really good. I recommend the house dressing. The slices here are also excellent and NY style. They're very large and pretty thin crust. I've never had a sub here but a friend of mine told me they're quite good. read more

First of all...I always like to try local restaurants and places like that. With that being said I wish that I didn't try this place, pizza was ok,but the beef sandwich was gross and why would you chop up veggies put on a sandwich?? You slice them so you can eat them better on a sandwich not small pieces so they slide and fall all over you... never again!!! read more

This place is amazing! I've been ordering delivery from here for years. This is my favorite lasagna in the entire Maryland. Their chicken fettuccine is great, pizza was great, the burger and the stuffed shells are always on point. They also give you a side salad and garlic bread with the pasta which I love. This is a small business so, please help them stay open cause as much as I'd love to, I shouldn't continue eating like this Just one small thing, this place is called Waterloo Pizza NOT Waterloo Pizza & Subs. IDK if they're related, but the latter does not give you salad and garlic bread w the pasta order. read more

Waterloo Pizza - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, Maryland

No idea why this gets recommended so much. The pizza was ok but very greasy. The location is not great and the inside wasn't clean.

Left food outside because I didn't tip, didn't call, didn't ring bell, or anything of the sorts that notified me that my food was here. Definitely sense attitude because I said no to a tip. Had to throw away the food because bugs got on it read more

Not going to lie...I was a little suspicious of "gas station pizza". But other reviews made me want to try it. So glad I did....delicious! read more

Waterloo Pizza - Small Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, Maryland

The food is pretty average but good for its price. A great place to eat for lunch around the area to grab and go. Having it be right by the college,high school and mall makes it great place to stop by on a lunch break. I had the pizza sub the first time I went and it was just alright. I felt like I could make a better one and it didn't have enough meat in the sandwich. The second time I went I got a 16 inch pizza and it was really greasy but I shared it with my friend and it was a very filling pizza. It really hits the spot after a long day of work or school. Having no place to sit as we wait for our food is kinda of awkward, so we just went back to our car and waited. Doesn't take long only about 5-10 mins, which is nice. It is also connected to a gas station so if you don't like any of the drinks they have there you can just get a different one at the gas station(you can also get chips or a side snack over there since there are not any in the pizza place). This place apparently stays open till 12 am but I haven't been there that late but it definitely gets good boi points for that. Overall the experience is fine and I still go there for lunch to fill me up. Not anything crazy but still pretty good. read more

Waterloo Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, Maryland

See all

Yum! Love the flavor and service. We've visited several times in last mont and a half.

Loved it for what it is. Great value. Speedy and delicious NYC style pizza to go! With that said, it even has a couple of small tables with a view if you don't mind outdoor seating near a car wash and gas station. Recommended! read more

I stopped here for gas every week for more than a year until I decide if I'd takeaway chance on gas station pizza. Now it's our "go-to" for good pizza and Greek salad. Thin crust is our jam, very fresh salad!! read more

Great pizza. Best in Columbia. I eat there every week.

Great pizza my favorite Columbia pizza spot :) I have ate here 3 times and never had a bad experience. read more

Best pizza in Maryland. Can't beat the price either. I love that it's a quick pizza place that's consistent

This little shop is away in a gas station. You might think that's an odd place to find somewhere good to eat. I certainly did. Don't let the location off but you. But I was pleasantly surprised by the pizza that I found there. I thought that the pizza was both hot and delicious. I really enjoyed the cheese pizza. And as you would imagine it was priced well. read more

Waterlook Pizza at Exxon does it again - I got the cheeseburger sub and it was loaded beyond belief. I should have just gotten the half...but opted for the whole - not realizing how large it was going to be. This time I got delivery - and it was RAPID. 30 minutes ahead of the GrubHub estimate. My SO got the Gyro w/Lamb and said it was very tasty. She did say it could have used a little more sauce. We ordered a pizza so we'd have lunch for the next day! This place is SPECTACULAR. read more

Second time I've ordered items with meat sauce recent...burnt. Lasagna was a 3/4 miss In ricotta cheese. Disappointment. Burnt on foil container. Very sad as the subs are good. I'm not sure when the Sauce changed been ordering from here for years. But last few times is enough to stop ordering anything with meat sauce. read more

My go to in place, instead of fast . The Chicken Quesadilla is my fav and everyone is so nice .