I have eaten here several times and find the regular slices to be terrible (soggy, oily). I've ordered pies with toppings and they're not evenly distributed (also soggy and oily). Not good. If you have to have pizza, it will work. But nothing special or memorable. Staff is indifferent. read more

I have gotten pizza from all of the places around here over the last 10+ years and Village is my favorite by a mile. Great value for a great pizza. I have eaten at least 100 pizzas from them and only once was it not consistent. read more

Our original choice for a restaurant to dine at on a Monday evening was closed so we opted to have dinner at this pizzeria. Though the wait between ordering and receiving our cheese pizza approximated a 1/2 hour due to numerous phone in orders to go, we would not hesitate to return because their NY style pizza was delicious. read more

See all

The pizza was great. Sauce was tasty and not too salty. Crust was perfect. Super friendly staff. I would go back.!

Had the urge for a Sicilian pizza. We used to call it square pizza on the Lower East Side It was good, tangy sauce a the dough was kind of too soft. Sandwiches were huge and tasty but cheese stuck to the foil I shall return though because overall it's a nice little town pizza place read more

village pizza ii has the best garlic knotsfresh, buttery, garlicky. unparalleled, would not trade for any other garlic knot out there.

God bless you, Village Pizza, and please never change. You can read the reviews - the pizza is good. They're cash only. The owners close for like, a month every year, and that's always when I need a sub the most. Because I am here to evangelize the subs at Village. When I say I want a sub, what I mean is, I want a sub from Village. And what I mean by that is, give me all that shredded lettuce. Some might think I'm poking fun, but I assure you - nothing hits the spot like that soft bread and shredded lettuce. I don't know how they make it so balanced and minimally messy. I just know, when I need a sub, it's Village or nothin. read more

Village Pizza II - Half of the turkey sub - Pizza Near Me - Catskill, New York

Food was awesome.always fresh!!.staff very friendly..had homemade chili with dinner..awesome!!!

A small cozy place to eat. The ambiance is Italian. Great pizzas, slices or complete pizzas, Subs are great. And soon there home made soup will be served,Like eating at your grandparents house. You will not be disappointed read more

Wow just wow. I never thought I would be almost assaulted at a pizzeria. I called in an order for a pie with toppings and on pick up was informed only cash. I had no cash and told them it would have been nice to know this upon ordering. Upon that one of their customers lashed out at me that I should have known better. Quite shaken I secured cash from their onsite machine and left with my pie to find out once I got home it was only a plain pie and I paid over $25 dollars for one with toppings. I truly felt violated. Kind of a switch situation. I called and they said "Opps" and come back for the right one (they couldn't have called me when they found the error?). My husband went back and just wanted our money back at this point since it was an hr later. He was again assaulted by what I would believe to be the same local who claimed he was being disrespectful for returning the pie. The guy literally was ready to throw a punch at my 6' 4" husband while the owner was onlooking. Really? Skip the drama and buy a pie else or even better make at home. Amen! read more

A great dining experience on Main St. in the Village of Catskill. Food always fresh and delicious. The owners and staff are great. read more

The service was exceptional for a busy Friday night! The pizza was delicious, you could smell the real ingredients! The drive home took forever, my son almost couldn't wait to eat it! I have eaten here many times, soups and lunch special are a great value. The price of everything is a great value especially during these hard times! read more

The pizza rolls are delicious and very reasonably priced. The staff are very friendly. Definitely recommend this place.

This was a fantastic pizza. Perfect crust, flavorful sauce, and they don't skimp on toppings, which are all clearly fresh. We ordered a veggie pizza and devoured it. It was exactly what we needed for dinner that evening and well worth the 40 minute wait on a Monday evening because we could walk around and enjoy the nearby shops in that part of town. They are clearly popular with locals and visitors alike. There are now signs in multiple places right when you enter the store and near the register clearly indicating that this is a cash only business. Really good pizza, really nice staff, and a really satisfying, simple meal. Can't really ask for more! read more

Best pizza outside of nyc. I travel from Troy to Catskill to get pies that I freeze. Family owned and they're from the city. I have tried to find good pizza closer to me but am always disappointed. read more

Some of the best pizza in town, and there is a lot to choose from at that. Only gripe is the wait time. Whenever I order anything other than a pizza, I always end up waiting longer than I'm told. Luckily it's always delicious, but it means I can't visit on my lunch break without ordering an hour in advance. read more

I travel for over a half an hour just for a slice of pizza. A "real" New York pizza - you can't go wrong read more

Have called this place SIX TIMES and no answer. 5 pm on a Tuesday. It should not be this difficult to get a pizza. I work as a cook and manager at a restaurant so I'm very understanding but this i just don't understand. It's a pizza place.. in Catskill ny.. ya know what I give up lol. read more

False advertising, 12' sub roast beef, $10 but total is $11.35, 15min wait unbelievable and it can't be busy at 12:35pm hardly any ppl in store and store phone silent, cash & or check only read more

Village Pizza II - 12' sub roast beef - Pizza Near Me - Catskill, New York

Best pizza around, and it's not even close. Great spaghetti and garlic bread too. Cash only but ATM in premises.

A great stop if you want grab and go as you make your way through the village of catskill! The pizza is good and is always fresh. They have a lot of options and can pretty much make whatever you want. The crust was airy but still crispy and overall the pizza was great. The owners are so nice and so is the rest of the staff! read more

Village 2 is not so secretly the best pizza in New York outside of the city. I've lived in upstate New York for nearly 20 years and all the locals know if you want the good pizza you go here. We live over an hour away and will make the hike here because it is just the best. The pizza is always cooked correctly, crispy crust, not too thin, and fresh delicious ingredients. I've never had them but I've also heard great things about their sandwiches. Any meal they serve, any time of the day I can vouch for 100%. Can't say enough good things about this place. If you intend on going (which you absolutely should), know that they only take cash and checks. Also make sure you call with a half hour notice at least, they tend to be pretty busy. read more

Village Pizza II - Margherita Slices - Pizza Near Me - Catskill, New York

Simply put, the very best pizza in Catskill. I make sure to always get a pizza (or two, or three) when I'm in town. Be advised they do not take credit cards so make sure you have cash. read more

Village Pizza II - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Catskill, New York

Been a staple on main street Catskill for as long as I. Am remember. They make a dam good sub.

This is a cute, casual spot conveniently located a short drive from Hudson. The vibe is very warm and inviting. The chef even asked us how we preferred our pizza crust! Most importantly, though, the pizza was great and very reasonably priced. I will definitely be back. read more

2021 and they're still accepting "cash only" on the main strip of a small town? Of course there's an ATM if you'd like to pay 4$ in fees for that single 20$ bill. There's a small business near me who just charges like the extra 2$ to cover the fees. As long as you're upfront about the extra charge most people are fine with it to avoid atm and bank fees. read more

Best pizza! Nice family! Old family recipes. Wish they delivered, but I get it. So I am stuck on all their great dishes! Yummy!

I'd like to call myself a "Pizza Connoisseur" - Andrea and I were visiting the Windham Area and staying @ Cuomo's Cove - We stumbled upon this place; checked out the Yelp Review; - Pizza was TRULY delicious. Family owned / local place - Doors down from the Catskill Police Department; - We will definitely be back. Attention "City Folk" - Slow it down; - service is fast - but, things definitely move a 'lil slow up in these parts. Its OK - Trust me, its worth it. Wholeheartedly enjoyed the experience! read more

Overcharged by $7 was told menu prices changed...I looked at 3 different menus online, printed and posted on the wall of the restaurant...they were all the same. I'm not sure but I think I got ripped off! I asked for a refund and was told no...bad service bad attitudes and if they want to raise prices take a few minutes and tell us by posting new prices I won't return.... read more

Tried this place while vacationing in the area and was throughly impressed. Solid pizza, generous portions, fresh ingredients. Particularly impressed with the tomato sauce, which I found to have a little more zest than your typical sauce! Highly recommend. read more

Cash only . Little organization. Need to get with the cashless times. Pizza is okay for the area

Great slices at a great place. Would definitely go back, and they're open later than most spots!

Love this little local pizza joint. I've never liked calzones, but I LOVE their calzones. The wait time is that of a typical pizza place, sometimes faster. read more

This is simply the best pizza we've had in a long time. And not just in the Catskills, but anywhere. We have been in the area for 25 years and full time since Covid, after living downstate. We missed nyc quality pizza, and we went here by chance, always keeping an eye out for a surprise. And what a gem of a restaurant. Simple, great ingredients, made authentically with love. We've been back often and is now is our go-to for pizza. If it was located in New York, it would be an institution. Bravo. read more

I love this place. The bad review a week ago had to be from a competitor. The adorable couple that own and run the place do a fantastic job. I love the remodel, and the hero's are A+. I found the establishment very clean and I don't mind waiting for service or great food. Some people expect McDonalds timing, well go there ! We drive out of our way going upstate just to stop in. I hope they will be there for years to come. read more

We are not from the area and to be honest we can be quite picky with our pizza. But after an evening of wine tasting we were feeling adventurous, so we stopped in and ordered a large pepperoni pie. However, I'm almost sorry we did....You may be wondering "WHY?" since I'm rating it five stars. Well let me just say that the crust was so crispy (THiS is very important to me) and the pizza was so delicious, that the place I hold dear to my heart back at home just won't compare now. Guess we may have to make another weekend trip here soon. read more

Ordered a small pizza and small baked ziti with meatballs for lunch. Both delicious and you get a ton of food for what you pay for. My only complaints are they are cash only, which was not mentioned and does not say anywhere, there is an ATM machine luckily but there is of course a $$ fee. Wait time is also extremely long. (50+ mins) read more

We were so happy to find Village Pizza II open around 8pm on a weekday night. I'm a picky pizza eater, being originally from metro NYC, and a four stars is a Very Good rating. But don't get me wrong - there was room for improvement. We got one each regular & sicilian pizzas with pepperoni on both. (We would have gotten OLIVES and pepperoni on one of them, but they only had black olives. Consider offering green too!) The cheese and sauce were both good, and the crusty tasty - but the cheese could have been stretchier, and the bottom crusts were a tad on the hard/crunchy side. [Great pizza flops. And the cheese REALLY stretches. Let's keep that in mind.] The sicilian top "crust" was appropriately pillowy. The pepperoni was "off", somehow, and that flavor dominated. Perhaps they use Boars Head? An excellent brand, but consider going with an Italian pepperoni brand for pizza instead. This place is "cash only" which was a minor inconvenience, but I can see where a lot of restaurants are in the "Tax Empire" state. read more

My fiance absolutely adores this place. Swears that it's the best pizza place ever. In my opinion, it's the best pizza place... in Catskill. I'm not even sure how many options there are for pizza in the area, so that might not be saying a whole lot. I find the pizza here to be very greasy and (can't believe I am saying this) there's almost too much cheese. The sauce tastes pretty good, but the crust is often too thin and flimsy on the bottom and just okay around the edges. You do, however, get a very large slice. All in all, definitely not bad but definitely not great. One thing I cannot believe about this joint is that they do not take credit cards! Come on, it's the 21st century and you are a pizza place!! I was really upset when I was picking up a pizza one day and told that I could not use my card, but that I could go across the street to an ATM (and probably pay an absurd fee there) to be able to use cash. Luckily I had cash on me, but I had planned to use it for something else. Had I not had cash on me, I would have left Village without my pizza because their prices are steep to begin with - I wasn't going to tack on another $2+ for an ATM fee to pay for the pizza. I really think Village should consider getting set up to accept credit cards. read more

Tried this place while visiting upstate. Let me start out by saying I'm a bit of a pizza snob, and while NYC thinks they have the patent on "real" pizza, they do not. It's hard to find "real" pizza in the states, trust me, having lived in Italy for years I'm always looking for that "real" pizza. This place came close. Decent pizza, actually made by real Italian family that runs it (not guidos, I mean real deal, old country Italians). Great service, friendly people... had a great chat with the owner. Dough was pretty good. Requested it made thin (like they do in Italy) and well done, and they nailed it. Sauce, decent. Was your typical, basic sauce. Cheese and toppings were good. Maybe a tad too much cheese, but good nonetheless. Overall, this snob was satisfied. Solid 7 out of 10 on my pizza scale. read more