Finally made it to Vargas Cut & Catch last summer to celebrate my student worker graduation, and it did not disappoint. We had a reservation, and the hostess set the tone right away . She was super friendly and welcoming. Our server kept the good vibes going the whole night: attentive, upbeat, and genuinely great energy. The food and ambience were on point. It's wild to think I used to hang out here in the early 2000s when this spot was a club called "21," you can still see the old "21" signage tucked in the bar area, which honestly adds a cool little nostalgic touch. The bar itself is beautiful, and the whole space feels elevated without being pretentious. Overall, amazing night, great service, great food, and a fun full‑circle moment. Can't wait to go back. read more

See all

I don't want to be pessimistic. The service was impeccable. Especially our main server and the guy who ran our drinks. Just amazing and worth every penny spent. However, the steak quality was not the same as past experiences. Chewy and tough and hardly any marbling. I'd argue it was a NY strip and not a ribeye. Every time I come to Galveston this has been my go to spot but I'm thinking it's more of an apps place. The bone marrow was tasty and the lobster was perfect. Also the mashed potatoes were in desperate need of cream and butter. Again, best service on the island. Just don't get the ribeye or potatoes. $300 should be well spent. read more

Wow! Enjoyed our anniversary dinner here -- left with full bellies and no regrets! Started with the bone marrow appetizer and a Caesar salad. Fantastic! I had the Gulf Red Snapper for my entree and my husband ordered the surf and turf special (wagyu in mushroom sauce with lobster tail). We had the brussel sprouts and lobster Mac and cheese as our shared sides. Also fantastic! So much lobster in the Mac and cheese! The snapper was topped with lump crabmeat which was not mentioned on the menu description (an added bonus)! Between our appetizers and dinner, we were served fresh homemade bread. For dessert, we ordered the crème brûlée -- the sugar topping was a little chewy but still so flavorful and creamy. They also gave us a small tiramisu for our anniversary dessert. Service was great. The atmosphere was nice. We really enjoyed our experience and our food! read more

Vargas Cut & Catch - Crème brûlée - Steakhouses Near Me - Galveston, Texas

See all

Celebrating my husband's birthday with his annual "birthday steak". We happened to be staying in Galveston Texas and had been waiting for an opportunity to try this place. The food: steaks were tender, mac and cheese was creamy and delicious and the brussel sprouts with squash was tasty. And the bread pudding was very good. The staff is very friendly and attentive. The thing to pay attention to is the synchronized service. Drinks are poured simultaneously for all guests at the table. Plates are placed before all guests simultaneously. This happens with two or ten! The decor is fancy, upscale. The lighting is low and dining feels private, as the tables are spaced well apart. You can't hear other conversations. Music volume is perfect. read more

See all

Got to have another experience at Vargas this past weekend and I was not as wow'd as I was the first time. Things seemed to be lacking flavor. The stand outs of the night were the friend lobster deviled eggs and of course the crab cake which is still the best crab cake I've had in Texas. For my main I got the redfish with the lobster cream sauce pasta and it was just so bland. All the sauce tasted like was butter and oil. And the fish was fresh for sure but I wish it was blackened. The sides we got were pretty good. My family is a big fan of the steak fries and onion but I wasn't really a fan. There just seemed to be a lack of seasoning this night on everything. The creamed spinach and Brussels sprouts were good. I got a Manhattan as my cocktail which was nice and we split a bottle Of wine. They gave my parents a tiramisu cake to celebrate their anniversary and We got a creme brûlée to go and it was a nice treat to end the night read more

See all

We went here for our 27th wedding anniversary and it did not disappoint! This was hands down the best meal my hubby and I have ever had in our life!! And the service was bar none!! Eating the food was like going on an adventure!! Highly recommend and we will definitely be back!! read more

See all

This is by far the best restaurant in All of Texas!! I am at a loss for words. Amazing everything!! We have been to many places and this place tops them all. Bruno was our server and he was so kind and attentive. The chef came out to meet us and was so humble and kind. I highly recommend for those who are looking for the best Lobster Bisque, fish, steak, and dessert. The Bread Pudding is a must!! We will be back as this place is at the top of our list now! read more

Ok, Aundre was AMAZING! He guided our meal, cocktails and more from beginning to end, absolutely superb! We had three adults and wanted to share, we had salad, lobster bisque, a filet and the redfish. We thought we were just getting an extra plate and we would settle it, we were presented with this beautiful lazy susan, so nice. Every single item was delicious. The pasta accompanying the red fish was delicious, the Sophia Mac and Cheese, creamy and perfect. Lump crab, medium rare filet. We could not have had a more delicious meal. Thanks so much to all the Vargas staff and family. Aundre, we can't wait to be back soon! read more

See all

Our table had a great experience. Service was great and the food was very pleasant. We would come back here again

Best service in Galveston, ask for Juan! The food was superb and the atmosphere is absolutely amazing. Check it out!

Food: 5 Service: 5 Ambiance: 4 Front of House: 0 (hostess & manager) Establishment is selective on their enforcement of dress rules. A dress scally cap is not allowed but ripped pants & flip flops are. Highly unlikely we'll be back. read more

If you're looking to drop some monies and treat yo self, you won't be disappointed. Service is top notch. Knowledgeable staff and they present the food and drinks at the same time and with a little pizazz. Tried the fried green tomatoes with lump crab meat this time. Great shareable app. I also switched up my normal filet with the bone in pork chop. So tender and well seasoned. It's one of the few entrees that comes with sides. Most are a la carte. If you plan it correctly you'll want to order dessert. There is a dress code so be sure to check it before you go. read more

See all

We tried something new tonight - Lobster Devils Eggs. I am not a fried seafood person so the lobster wasn't my favorite but the devils eggs were good. I will be back - for a drink at the bar :) read more

Vargas Cut & Catch - Lobster devil egg - Steakhouses Near Me - Galveston, Texas

I finally had a special occasion and an opportunity to dine at Vargas. And what a special treat it was! Talk about feeling pampered and taken care of! We had a total party of 6. Our server, Peter, was outstanding! When they come to bring out appetizer's or the main course, each person's food is delivered at the same time - choreographed! How fun is that!?! We ordered cocktails (I had the pink lady which was very refreshing!), bone marrow and oysters for appetizers and there was a special of hanger steak which was an amazing entree along with a variety of side items. Key lime pie was shared for dessert. A very special meal commemorating a special milestone in our family. read more

See all

Delicious food. I especially loved their bass. Very fast service and a romantic ambiance! This is the place you take someone if you really want to impress them read more

Vargas Cut & Catch - Oyster - Steakhouses Near Me - Galveston, Texas

Wife and I came here for my 40th birthday dinner - really impressed. Worked our way from wine to an appetizer, then to entrees and their famous bread pudding for dessert - with coffee and cognac. Never felt rushed, and definitely believe the value was there for a $300 dinner. Service was outstanding (Juan's knowledge and timing were both impressive; also he is just a really sharp, likable guy). Overall, the vibe inside was extremely elegant, a place you want to spend time and relax over terrific food. A+ read more

See all

By @iwanttobewhatieat. What the actual puck. @vargascutcatch was so good it's like a myth. No one would believe you because you have said "epic" so many times it's lost all meaning. But this restaurant is the epitome of epic. It's like epic had a baby with epic, and then that baby grew up and had an epic baby. The lamb lollipops? Fire. The lobster deviled eggs should be illegal. The Chilean Sea Bass? BOMB. Juan, our server, should run for President. Maybe you never even thought of going to Galveston, Texas, but if you claim to eat good food and haven't eaten here, you need saving. Get here immediately. read more

See all

My wife and I celebrated our 46th Wedding Anniversary last night. This was our first visit to Vargas Cut &Catch . The service, Food and Ambiance were fantasictic!! Bruno took care of us and he was awesome!! read more

First time to eat at restaurant..food was great , from appetizers to desserts..really enjoyed my grilled jumbo shrimp and wife's red snapper was also very good . Service was spot on and enjoyed how they served everyone at the same time ..unique touch.. ambiance was lively, but could hold a conversation with the table read more

Delicious food, attentive service and great atmosphere. Celebrated a friend's birthday and was very impressed. Definitely worth the price.

Excellent food! Service was good! Atmosphere was beautiful! We will be back! We had a little hiccup with one of the charges on our bill, but they responded swiftly and corrected it! read more

The prices are pricy, lol but the service and food was great! I only tried the crab cake and lobster deviled eggs. Both were excellent!

Aundre took such good care of us! Food was amazing experience was good as well. Everything from appetizer to desert was amazing read more

Vargas Cut & Catch - Steakhouses Near Me - Galveston, Texas

very expensive for the quality of food. Steaks over cooked and dry. Lot's of better restaurants with better food and price.

An exceptional dining experience from start to finish! The service at Vargas Cut & Catch was truly amazing--attentive, welcoming, and polished. Our sommelier was incredibly knowledgeable, offering thoughtful wine pairings that elevated the entire meal. The food was prepared to perfection--every bite was full of flavor and clearly crafted with care. The entire staff was professional and created a warm, upscale atmosphere. Highly recommend for a memorable evening out and Celebration for the UTMB White Coat Ceremony! We will definitely be back! read more

See all

One of the best restaurants you will ever go to. Excellent service and fantastic food

Great ambiance, perfectly cooked steak and the lamb chops were the best I've had! Service was superb. Highly recommended for a nice evening out. read more

See all

Remarkable food and service! I passed by this restaurant and saw the inviting interior. After checking out the menu, I was fortunate enough to snag a seat at the bar. It did not disappoint! My scallops with crabmeat was SUBLIME! read more

Vargas Cut & Catch - View at the bar - Steakhouses Near Me - Galveston, Texas

See all

Vargas Cut & Catch provides their patrons with a dining experience so memorable that it has been a month since my last visit, and I am still raving about it. I have also found myself comparing every steakhouse I have visited in the last month to Vargas, but no one comes even close to beating it. From the way that the waiter unfolds the napkin for you to place on your lap, to the synchronized dining service style (and synchronized cocktail pouring), to the delicious steak and sides, it was all spectacular. Also, Marko was beyond attentive and personable - it was a pleasure to have a waiter like him, it truly enhanced our dining experience. I cannot wait to visit Galveston so we can eat at Vargas again! read more

Went here on a March vacation. It's a very nice place. Be sure to bring your dress clothes. They have a dress code and there were some very nicely dressed people so you will want to match. The service was very good. It was fun to watch the waiters parade to a table with all of the entrees or drinks at once. I had the Chilean sea bass special. It was amazing. The sea bass was cooked perfectly, slightly crisp on the edges and buttery yum in the middle. It was on a bed of mashed potatoes and had a great sauce on the top that was a bit lemony like a light hollandaise sauce. There was a lot of crab on the top. I typically dont like crab, but this was high quality and did not detract from the meal. The green beans were good. There were also a few grape tomatoes on the side that had an interesting sauce in them, perhaps a marinara. It was the perfect meal! My daughter had the filet. It was cooked perfectly and was tender. The only negative was the seasoning was a bit mild. I like a little more seasoning. The lobster Mac was yummy with large chunks of lobster. The lobster was very chewy though. The baked potato was huge. I've ordered potatoes from places like this before and they are usually half the size. However, there was so much cheese in the potato, it was hard to find potato. Overall, I would definitely get the fish at this place before the steak. However it was all good. My only negative here was that they Nickel and Dimed you. I don't expect that when paying these prices already. My daughter got a Shirley temple (sprite with a little grenadine) and they charged her for a refill. I've never been charged for a refill of a Shirley temple anywhere. We also asked for extra sour cream and they charged $1.50 for it. Poor for Vargas. read more

See all

We closed out Galveston Restaurant Week(s) with our first visit to Vargas Cut & Catch. A great experience and we would definitely return. Excellent service and nice relaxed pace of dining. My martini, 21XX I think it was called, had X-rated (a liquor I had never heard of and was almost afraid to Google on my work phone- haha), Malibu pineapple, mango and passion fruit. Super delicious. Our server Alexandra went into great detail on all the expensive specials and I almost felt bad telling her we wanted the restaurant week menu after she spent all that time explaining the specials. The Caesar salad was one of the best I have had. Creamy dressing, lettuce chopped up well, a good amount of shaved parmesan, and homemade croutons. My husband's lobster bisque was wonderful as well. Salmon was cooked perfectly but was a little underseasoned. If there had been salt on the table I would have added some. The lemon dill cream sauce was perfect. Potatoes were delicious with plenty of butter. The lemon tart for dessert was underwhelming. The crust was so hard it was difficult to cut and a piece actually flew into my lap. Reminded me of the fancy restaurant scene with the escargot in Pretty Woman. The lemon curd filling was a little overly tart also. The tables next to us had some amazing looking desserts and I was having a little dessert envy. Definitely want to try a few of the other options in future. I would say this is a great option for a celebratory or special occasion dinner. read more

See all

This place was excellent., service, ambiance and staff are amazing. If you are on the island and looking for all 3 of those qualities look no further. read more

Vargas Cut & Catch - Excellent Cabernet recommendation by the staff. - Steakhouses Near Me - Galveston, Texas

See all

Vargas was wonderful. I wish I could go once a week. Some of the best seafood I've had in a long time Juan my awesome friend did an amazing job. My parents loved it and are planning on going to a show and going back. I can't because I live in Michigan now 10 stars for sure read more

The service is top-notch and the best on the island. I almost licked my bowl of lobster bisque it was so delicious and better than anything I've had on the East Coast. We were celebrating our anniversary and the staff went out of their way to make it special for us. Their dining room has beautiful lighting and the tables are nicely spaced so that you don't feel cramped. All the staff care about their service and it shows. read more

The service needs a major upgrade. I've never been treated so terribly by such an expensive restaurant, nor have I been so mistreated by a restaurant that is less expensive. The service was absolutely unacceptable. For the price of the items here, I expected top tier service. That is not at all what I received. Soon after our table of 8 was seated, 4 of the 8 water glasses were filled. 10-15 minutes later, the rest of the water glasses were filled, except for mine. Why? I have no idea. Then, someone at the table ordered wine. I asked for water. Another 5-10 minutes passed, and the wine was presented to the table. I still did not have water (or anything to drink) and a friend requested water for me (this is the second ask). The wine was served, my boyfriend asked for my water to be filled (this is the 3rd ask at this point). 5 minutes or so later; I FINALLY got my FIRST glass of water for the evening. Then, bread was brought to the table...only one basket, which was not enough for each person at the table to have one piece. 6 out of 8 people were able to indulge, but because it was placed on the opposite side of the table from us, my boyfriend and I did not get any, as there was no more from the one single basket that the table was given. The waiter did not return until the appetizers were served, so there was no chance to ask for another bread basket. At one point, I left the table for the restroom. Upon my return, a staff member picked up my napkin. I assumed he would place it on my lap, as they had done upon arrival. Nope. Instead, he took it and never brought one back. I then had to request a new one. Other people left the table throughout the night and their napkins were neatly folded by the staff and left waiting for their return, as expected, so I don't know why mine was taken away and not replaced. 3 of the 4 couples ordered appetizers. We all ran out of the crackers that accompanied and were necessary to properly enjoy the app, so they brought a new bowl of crackers to the table. But guess what! They again only brought enough for one side of the table and placed them on the opposite side, so we got none. Overall, I was extremely disappointed with the service and I've honestly had better steak (and most certainly better service) at less expensive restaurants. Very disappointing experience. If you're expecting to get what you pay for, I do NOT recommend this restaurant. I'm not sure how they are so highly rated. I could not wait for dinner to be over so that I could leave. We will likely never return. read more

My husband and I celebrated our 29th yr anniversary here last night and all I have to say is there wasn't any other place I would have rather spent it. Blake was our waiter and was on point with everything. We had a few questions about the restaurant and the food and his recommendations and knowledge of the food and restaurant was excellent. So if you're celebrating any kind of special occasion, I highly recommend going here. If I could give more starts I would. read more

See all

It was all so good...service, food, ambiance...well worth it!! I highly recommend taking a drive down to Galveston for this treasure chest full of yummy food! read more

Vargas Cut & Catch - Red Snapper over Angel hair pasta in lobster sauce with lump crab meat.... - Steakhouses Near Me - Galveston, Texas

See all

Great food, quick polite service and full attention to detail. The place to go in Galveston for that special occasion or just be pampered.

What a great place! Already love Rudy and Paco's, but going to be honest, Vargas is a LITTLE better. Both places are amazing, though. My brother and his wife come here all the time, but it was my first visit this weekend, and I will be back. Service, food, drinks, all fantastic. Really impressed as well with the decor inside. They have put a lot of work into this place, and you can tell. Definitely recommend! read more

Vargas Cut & Catch is one of my favorite places to eat in Galveston and is a must visit anytime I am in the area. My wife and I visited recently and had a wonderful experience. We started our meal with a Snow Crab Martini. Fresh, cool and meaty tender crab claws and giant shrimp were served with creamy crisp coleslaw, diced avocado and crisp plantain chips. Next we had a second appetizer, Black Sesame Ahi Tuna. The tuna was cool, fresh, topped with crisp sesame seeds and paired with a creamy sauce. I cannot visit Vargas without ordering the Lobster Bisque which is the best I have ever had. Fresh tender lumps of lobster meat swim in a flavorful, briny, lightly sweet and creamy broth. For my entrée I ordered the Gulf Red Snapper (even though it was very difficult to not order the steak). The fish was tender, meaty, seasoned, nicely seared, topped with fresh tender lump crab and sat on a bed of light creamy pasta. Finally for dessert I had the Cheesecake which was super creamy but light with a crisp crème brulee topping, crunchy graham crust at the bottom and paired with juicy berries. Overall, Vargas is the perfect spot for a high quality fine dining experience with phenomenal food. read more

See all