Cheese makes me drool. That's a fact! So When I heard there…read morewas a creamery I have yet to discover, I knew I had to take the drive out there. When looking at the name , I thought this place was in the town of Eden but it's about 50 minutes from Buffalo in South Dayton, NY on the Amish trail. While the place is small, they do have plenty of varieties of cheese and cheese curds to choose from. I purchased some tomato basil cheese curds and a brick of gouda cheese (which conveniently they were making fresh that day!) The prices were on par with other creameries I have been to. The gentleman who was working was very kind ... he recommended a good place on the trail to get chocolates! Once COVID restrictions lighten up, they hope to once again give samples of their offerings.

I came across Eden Valley Creamery at the S Dayton farmers market. They offered a free taste of…read moretheir cheddar, which was super good. I bought a slice of gouda to take home. Excellent!

I'm what they call a cheese snob.. this place by far has the not only the best tasting cheese but…read morean outstanding selection that beats any store brand by far including price. The smoked Swiss is the ultimate best.. I drive an hr and half a couple times each season and stock up for the winter before she closes down.. I shrink wrap it and it will last me until she reopens.. it's worth the drive. It's a small quaint place and the owner is wonderful.. you won't be disappointed

Nice selection of cheese for a charcuterie board. Prices good. Would have liked a little more…read moreassistance in pairing and what goes with what.

I drove here for my birthday, it's an hour and a half away from my house. It's the second year that…read moreI've done this. I absolutely love cheese and the varieties are endless. The Cuba shop brand is very affordable. Smaller packages are typically 3 to 4 dollars. Thank you for the free cheese samples!!!

A small shop with abundant offerings: Floor to ceiling choices for cheddar, curds, havarti,…read moreMunster, Gouda, Gruyere, feta, haloumi, chevre, Swiss, etc. Want local honey or maple syrup? They have it here, with forty or so different jams, relishes, and pickles. Staff are knowledgeable and can find anything for you. Need to ship that gift order? There's a desk in the back for that purpose. Lots of parking in a side lot; a few spaces out front. Wheelchair ramp on the side.

From the time I saw a random tiny wooden sign on the side of the road, I was curious about this…read moreplace. Now they have some more signage, but still sort of hidden. I stopped in on a Friday before they closed. I was greeted warmly by a woman who offered as many samples as I wanted! I tried quite a few samples and ended up buying some crackers, seeds, cheese curds, and a nice hard port wine cheese. They have all sorts of cute gifts, snacks and spreads as well as cheese. Prices were not cheap, but the service and samples made it worth it. I hope they do well.

A few months ago, I was stumped for a Christmas gift for my good friends of many years. After…read moregetting my hair cut in early December, I noticed a card for The Cheese Factory on the desk at my salon. Bingo! Heading up Taylor Road, I blew right by. The place is set back from the road a bit, and the signage is easy to miss. Once inside the little shop, there's a lot more to see than just cheese (but there is certainly plenty of that). Other food items like olive oil, pickles and crackers, kitchenware, assorted gift items - lots to look at. The guy at the counter couldn't have been nicer. Cheese Factory gift card, a nice bottle of wine - perfect gift. Mission accomplished!

Great place to get wonderful cheese and sausage at a terrific price from pleasant people.read more

Great service, with samples available to make sure you like what you're getting for cheese which is…read morealways appreciated. Our favorite was the aged mountain-style, very cheddar-like in sharpness, but maybe a little more creamy than it would be in a similar cheddar. Their speciality seems to be raclette style, so definitely stop in if that's what you like.

This is a review of East Hill Creamery as a wedding venue. Our friends chose this as their…read moreceremony/reception spot, and we had a great time celebrating with them. It's about an hour drive from Rochester. There is a gravel parking lot, and you enter through the store (where you can buy cheese and other fun snacks). There is a stairwell or an elevator to get up to the second floor where the wedding was held. Props to whoever designed this place for adding multiple restrooms, which were decorated with cute cow decor and stocked with mouthwash, feminine hygiene products, mints, etc. The food was excellent. Cocktail hour included a spread of fruit, crackers, and many delicious cheeses that were more exciting than the normal cheddar cubes on an appetizer tray. For dinner, salad, pizza, and cauliflower wings were served with lots of sauces and toppings. Dessert was a make your own ice cream sundae bar. Old Souls Catering was responsible for all of the deliciousness. There were two levels of the reception space, and the ceremony and dinner were held in the higher area. The lower area was the bar/cocktail area and dance floor. It was a bit awkward going up and down the stairs every time a new part of the event took place (I have a sprained ankle). There is a wheelchair lift to move between the sections but I wasn't going to get a staff member to do that for me ten times with everyone watching. Overall, this was a unique venue and even had a cheese vending machine outside.

First time here. It was okay. Nothing special. The sandwiches with basic cold cuts and greens were…read moreaverage, with bread that was too thinly sliced. No signature flavor (a special spread) or style (a special way to cut it) for the sandwich. The shelves and display case had expensive, so-called fancy food show products for sale and a small variety of cheeses. Service was acceptable, but be careful if you try too many cheese samples to taste what you want to perhaps buy. You get that look. We did buy a small portion of a cheddar out of courtesy, but I don't think its good for customers to be shamed into buying something.

For a cheese lover, this place has it all! A great variety, many choices, and a knowledgeable and…read morefriendly staff to help you pick some great cheeses if you aren't sure exactly what you're looking for. The sandwiches are great too!

Nice selection of Ontario and English cheese. Quite nice modern decor in the store and staff is…read morevery friendly. They have a good selection of flavored balsamic vinegars as well ($14 for 200mL bottle). Worth a walk around. Located right on Main Street. Would suggest that the store get a ramp for wheelchair/stroller access.

This is the cutest cheese shop, and the owner Jenny is so helpful! I love this place because we can…read moretry samples before we buy a big slice of cheese, and she keeps track of our favourites in her computer. The Bellavitano is my absolute favourite. I love their cheese picnic boxes too.