Was staying over night to have brunch at the mercantile and wanted to try this place after reading…read morethe reviews. We were greeted right away by friendly staff and seated immediately. Our server could not have been more helpful and sweet. Elizabeth was awesome! My sister and I decided to split the lasagna and each of us had a chopped salad. The lasagna was fantastic! The only complaint I had is I wish they would have given us something to serve ourselves with after we cut it up, instead of trying to scoop it with a spoon, but that is minor. The lemonade was great! Ranch dressing on the salad was also good and you can tell it was homemade. I don't know where another person got the place was dirty? It is an old building with worn floors but everything was very clean. If you happen to stop here for the night and need a place to eat, you can't go wrong with this place.

Immediately we were greeted & taken to our table.The Waitress was friendly , didn't rush us & told…read moreus about her favorite's to eat there. I had to ask. The Pizza was to die for. The Cesar Salad is awesome, you can split It as It Is Huge. The garlic not nots are delicious & don't forget to take home your dessert of Cinnamon not nots. Easy to heat up. Going here you will be treated like family. The small town vibe ,ambiance , & People Are Awesome.You Will Never Be Let Down at P Town so go in today as you will be glad you did !!!

5 Stars - Amazing Food, Perfect Takeout Experience! My…read morehusband and I ordered takeout and Highly recommend this place if you're looking for amazing food and a seamless takeout experience. I'll definitely be ordering again!

The little red building has a great vibe; it feels like a small-town pizza joint should. Clean,…read morecomfortable, nicely decorated. The owner is a super friendly guy that knows how bake a pie. No scrimping on the ingredients. Lots of cheese, fresh lean Italian sausage with jalapenos and black olives was on our perfect pizza. The large pie made lunch today and the other half reheated at home for lunch tomorrow. Excellent pizza! Excellent service!

Meeting up with a group, this Oklahoma chain is spacious with plenty of seating. They are known for…read moretheir pizzas, but we also enjoyed their fried mushrooms and garlic knots. To feed five of us, the large Pollinator was perfect with its garlic glaze, meat, banana peppers, and hot honey. It was so good!

Awesome service Good pizza…read more Fast service Clean Right down in the middle of several business walking distance eat and shop

We were staying at the Osage Hills state park and on our way to the Tallgrass Prairie Preserve and…read moreneeded something for our bellies! This place isn't fancy BUT the pizza we had on the buffet was hot, crisp and had lots of toppings! The crisp Parmesan bread sticks were yummy as well! They also had calzones on their buffet which my husband enjoyed. I loved the fact that they had marinara on the buffet for those of us that LOVE that red sauce and want extra! The salad bar was pretty decent. I loved that they had banana peppers and pickled okra on it. The staff was friendly. P.S. Sorry I forgot to take pictures

Pizza was very good. Owner was very nice and accommodating to a request for a pizza we wanted to…read moretry on the buffet. I highly recommend!!

I love their ice cream, always have a good variety to choose from. They are also located right in…read morethe middle of downtown which has such pretty views.

Located in the heart of town. The sweet shop has an array of candy and also a selection of ice…read morecream. There are tables to eat inside or some benches outside. The service was excellent

A comfy place where a lot of locals eat. We ate breakfast here twice and supper once…read more I had a Monterrey chicken sandwich, chicken breast, grilled onions and mushrooms on Naan bread- I loved it. Breakfast here is awesome. Super nice staff. Very reasonably priced. Pancakes just like I like them- not too"cakey", with a bit of chew. Oatmeal was good. Toast was pan fried and yummy! Hubs had eggs and bacon along with his pancakes- all great.

Totally comfort food at a place where a LOT of locals eat. We decided to bypass all the PW places…read moredowntown and eat somewhere else. Glad we landed at Buffalo Joe's. This would totally be a five star review but our waitress was a little slow and it took about 30 minutes for the food. But, the food was good! I had the hot hamburger and I would recommend getting a small (which I still couldn't finish). It comes with a side as well as the mound of fries so I tried the okra. My mom tried the meatloaf with mashed potatoes and gravy and coleslaw. She said the coleslaw was great. The meatloaf was a massive serving, about two inches thick! A lot of the lunch crowd was ordering what looked to be like a great chef salad. Saved that thought for future reference. I would totally eat here again.

Wow. I can't say enough about that staff at this place. Everyone was super friendly and helpful…read more My sister and I made a trip to come here and eat and we are so happy we did! We were seated in Justin's section and if you go there please ask for him! He is so friendly, helpful and loves working there! I had the breakfast cowboy burrito, it was good but I was also very happy with the salsa it came with. The salsa wasn't watery, and had a little bite to It. My sister got the veggie scramble she said it was great. We also wanted to try the cheesy grits, I'm a huge grit fan but honestly, these fell short. They had an enamel after taste from the crock they came in and seriously needed salt. But other than that everything was really good! Definitely make a reservation ahead of time as they do get busy!

I really can't believe I'm here. This was on my bucket list so now I can check it off. The only…read morething better would be if the pioneer woman herself appeared. I did some heavy duty shopping at the Merc.!!!! and also left behind probably a dozen more things I would've loved to have picked up and brought home. Yes, I would say it's a little more expensive than your average kitchen supply store but if you're going to somewhere upscale, I would say the prices are in line with that type of property. Lucky me -I made reservations for lunch for myself (since the boys decided they did not want anything to do with my shopping extravaganza!) I can't get over the quality and the quantity of the food. It's absolutely fabulous. They gave me complementary biscuits and homemade strawberry rhubarb jam. I would rate it five star -the biscuits just which you would like- light and fluffy and the jam freshly made and delicious. I also ordered what was called olive bread just because I love olives so much. I thought it would be a piece or two of bread with olives but instead it's like four or five pieces of bread, so I'll definitely be taking some home and it will become my dinner along with whatever else I have left because their portions are very generous. For my main course, I ordered the cornbread fish over rice and creamed spinach. It's not only beautiful and don't you know we eat with our eyes first!! Well, just take a look for yourself. Oh, me oh my happy day.!!!! Justin is my server. Everyone in both the restaurant and retail area have been absolutely wonderful and have helped me a couple times as I had questions and then I brought a baking pan down to pay for it with all my other Mercantile items not knowing that if the merch is up in the bakery, you gotta pay for it in the bakery....I did get a lot of stuff up there- some cookies, brownie and scones and some "vintage" candy for my husband. I don't know why I didn't put that small Bundt pan on the counter!! They actually have a beautiful staircase, but they also have an elevator so with my bum leg that was my choice. I took the mini Bundt pan back up, paid for it and then proceeded to take my three XL or maybe even 2XL Mercantile Brown Handled Bags out to my trunk. (I hope that my husband doesn't put me on top of the car for the ride home!!!) ----at the very least, I'm probably going to be squished in the backseat with those bags and my 72# dog; however, this was TOTALLY worth it. I can't stop smiling. I love it here. All that shopping made me hungry and timing was perfect so once my bags were safely in the trunk -I walked right up to the hostess stand -she confirmed my table was ready and I was seated on a very comfy cushioned area that was behind my 2-top but I believe it extended to either side of me where the tables were both 4-tops. Justin was my server and he was fantastic. He took excellent care of me and I observed him giving the same high quality customer service to customers at his other tables. He had that charming OK accent and indeed told me he had lived at the next little town all his life. We had actually passed through Bartlesville on the way to "The Bunkhouse" (our ABNB for the 2-nights which was very near Pawhuska. (I'll be posting other reviews regarding the "Merc" mercantile and general store and the merchandise available and what I purchased.) This is one of my best days ever. The only thing that could've added to my joy was if Ree Drummond herself made an appearance. I was shocked when I went out to leave for home and found the Drummond Ranch truck parked next to my car. I never found out if it was just parked there as an advertisement, (although I don't think they need any advertising), or if there was a Drummond on the premises. I didn't mention I took 2 Turkey Bacon Club Sandwiches along with the home made potato chips (they came with each sandwich) and a side of MacNCheese which is what the boys chose from the menu. Happy to report that everything was made to order as requested and my family enjoyed their meal just as much as I did-however they missed the incredible ambience!!!

Service was good, ordered the melted meatball pizza…read more Watched a gentleman throw the dough up and up and up, to get it ready to bake, I guess. Think he overworked the dough by the chew it had when it became my pizza. The meatballs? Were shredded pieces of meat? Spread barely across the pizza, there was hardly any. The dough was so thin that the first piece I picked up my fingers went through. It had mozzarella on it, I didn't see the shredded parmesan. After eating 4 pieces of the pizza, I realized I was still hungry. And this measly thing wasn't going to do it. Very disappointed. The flavor is all there, but just no toppings to mention. Oh and I saw two or three thin mushroom slices. The atmosphere was great; it was cool inside and darkish. Around 3Pm early afternoon on a Wednesday.

Not a good experience. Didn't know what they had. And then I didn't receive what I ordered. I would…read morenot recommend it.

As soon as I walked in I knew just by the smell that the pizza was gonna be great!! This to me is…read morethe best pizza in Oklahoma. I'm from nyc so I'm used to great pizza and this is the closest you gonna get to it. I will drive to Blackwell just for this pizza!! The sad part is I left my leftovers ‍‍ we didn't realize till we got home lol. The owner was so nice and told us he gets there at 5:30 every morning just to make the dough. Will return!!

Best pizza around. Lots of toppings, lots of cheese, great crust. Wings are the best around!!read more

Absolutely love this place. Service is great, food is awesome and the fried pickles are so…read moredelicious. I don't drink alcohol so I can't speak to that but it's worth the stop!! Ambiance is chill and good energy

First time going here. It was great. Lots of space so feels like a little more private since tables…read morehave room between them. Food was great! Fries are homemade and that was wonderful. Burgers were large and food was priced reasonably. Very attentive waitress and a great casual vibe. I would go back!