I've generally had great experiences here, which made tonight especially disappointing. We arrived…read morearound 9:40pm, knowing they closed at 10pm, we were craving ice cream. As we were literally steps from the counter, an employee flipped the 'open' sign to closed right in front of us and made eye contact as well.We were still within business hours, and being shut out like that felt dismissive and rude. It's such a shame, because the ice cream itself has always been great but that kind of treatment is hard to overlook, and we'll think twice before going back.

Cute ice cream spot. No indoor seating or dining. They do have a few chairs out in the front during…read morethe summer. Accepts cash & card. Has icies as well regular ice cream flavors.

This was my second time coming. There's so much to pick from on the menu. I went here because they…read morehave dairy free and no sugar added options. I got a cone of dairy free chocolate chunk. It was a little soft, but tasted okay. My partner had a NSA vanilla shake. I hope they expand the dairy free menu. I'd love to have a few more options, like coffee or caramel. They also have sorbet and funnel cake. I'll definitely come back.

My son requested a cookies and cream ice cream cake for his birthday. I wasn't satisfied with the…read moreoptions at the grocery store and other places like Carvel and wanted to support local small business. I was working on short notice and feared I wouldn't be able to get one in time but the folks at The Ice Cream House answered me promptly and were happy to help! They checked to see if any of the ingredients they use contain soy and unfortunately the cake did, but we came up with an alternative dessert for the child who is allergic to soy and he was perfectly happy with it! The cake was absolutely delicious and a very generous size especially considering what we paid. All my guests asked where the cake was from and my mother requested I have one made when her birthday comes around. Pick up was quick and easy and the cashier was so friendly, it was like talking to someone I knew. I am so happy with The Ice Cream House and will continue to go to them for my ice cream cake needs!

The ice cream here is delicious. I love that they have so many selections. The ice cream is velvety…read moreand creamy. The staff is really nice. You can try some flavors before committing to one to leave with. There is some outdoor seating which is nice. They only take cash though. There is an atm in the store but if you prefer not getting charged fees because of withdrawing from it, I would bring cash before coming. Although I came at a time where there wasn't anybody, I've been told they get very busy so keep that in mind.

Delicious as always ! Remember to bring CASH ! They do have an atm inside if you don't.read more

I don't know how this place can have any negative reviews. Being crowded during weekends just means…read moreit's good ‍ Plenty of Ice Cream Flavors to choose from, and they also offer a variety of Milk Shakes, Hot and Cold Drinks, and Snacks. Be prepared for a wait if you are visiting during weekends. Its cute little spot with limited seating, so plan accordingly.

When the whole of Oak Tree Center shut down for a winter snowmageddon, this lone shop made the best…read moreuse of the situation by keeping their shop open. There were quite a flock of customers including us even late at night. The store was clean and was serviced by a young Sardar boy and he handled the army of crowd quite well, all by himself. We ordered a cup of cotton candy, biscoff rolled ice cream and a glass of rose and rabidi Falooda. The only reason I rate this place a star less is for the the semiya/vermicelli that wasn't sweet and kind of making the falooda tasting experience little bland. But overall this place was a great find for us. Parking at Oak Tree center is abundant and will never be a question of parking unavailability.

This place is dangerous for my health! The fact that it's only few minutes drive from home, I can…read moresee myself coming here often. It's located on the 1st floor of the mall, near Macy's and Rain Forest Cafe. It's a small store front. You place your order and yes, there's pictures so you kinda know what the final order may look like before you place your order. An order cost $7.99 but you do get about 8 rolls of ice cream and unlimited toppings and the portion size can be shared for two. Note: I said it can be shared but not that anyone would want to after one bite. The cool part is you get to see them make your roll and how the ice cream went from liquid form to actually frozen ice cream roll. The staff is also very nice! They ask you what toppings you'd like and yes, you can take your time to decide. They don't rush you and they don't judge you either, haha. It seems to be a very popular place. I came on a Friday evening and was the third and I thought last customer ordering on the line. I ordered and paid and before I know literally a bus stop came by. There's about 20 people making a line afterwards. The wait was a bit long because there were many orders to make. There's only two staff and one of them was ringing up orders at the cashiers. I hope they have more employees for the weekend and summertime. This place can be a really big hit for mall goers. I will definitely come back to try other flavors ice cream roll and toppings!

Probably the most unbelievable ice cream I've ever had The store was clean, the staff was great…read more 10/10 recommend. Wish I had a picture but it was impossible to wait

This is hands down the best small-town ice cream shop around! Their flavors are incredibly…read moreunique--every visit feels like a new experience. You can tell so much creativity goes into each one, and somehow they're not just different, they're delicious every single time. The vibe is What really sets this place apart, though, is the people. The staff is always so kind and welcoming, and the owner, Heather, is truly amazing. She is so patient and warm with my twins, which means the world to me as a parent. You can tell she genuinely cares about every customer who walks through the door. On top of that, Heather gives back to the community in such meaningful ways, like hosting school fundraisers. It's rare to find a business that not only delivers an incredible product but also has such a big heart. We absolutely love this place and will keep coming back again and again!

This place is well cleaned spot is very organized very done and everything looks beautiful and…read moregreat. Grateful Service great food.

So good, so good, so good. If you get to the waterfront. That should be the best part of going…read more Sitting by the water rating some creamy homemade ice cream. Each flavor filled with goodness. Worth cheating on my no sweets. And a good reason to do an additional day at the gym.

Really yummy ice cream, they only had 2 sugar free options so I wish they had more variety. They…read moreare generous with their portions, this is only a small and I couldn't finish it all lol. I also recommend their salted Carmel, that one was yummy too.

My coworker and I wanted to get dessert after our dinner and found this place down the street. We…read moredecided to check it out. It's located on the same street as the Fresh Fish Market and across of Main Street Spirits on Main St in, I believe, downtown Rahway. There is only paid metered street parking around the area. Prior to ordering, I was given the option to sample some of their flavors. I ordered a small with two flavors: Banana Dulce de Leche and Espresso. The Banana Dulce de Leche was a pleasant surprise, with a good banana flavor that was unfortunately overpowered by the caramel. I also found the Dulce de Leche to be a bit icy, which didn't blend well. The Espresso was okay, but had only a light, aromatic coffee flavor. I thought it wasn't strong enough in my opinion. Overall, it's a nice spot for dessert after lunch or dinner, and the large seating area is a plus.

This is a fun spot for gelato or a coffee. I had a small cup with mango and coconut gelato. The…read morecoconut gelato was delicious and I enjoyed the mango as well. These flavor profiles in the flavors I had are strong so if you don't like coconut don't order the coconut gelato. There is a nice area inside to relax and enjoy the gelato. I liked the music that was playing when I was there as well.