This has got to be in my top 5 ice cream spots! The place is located right by the water so it's a nice view if you choose to have your ice cream indoors or outdoors. Thanks to the Yelp reviews I chose the salted caramel truffle ice cream and wow it did not disappoint, it was incredible!! The pieces of chocolate are amazing and the caramel is so gooey . I've been back two more times since this pic , I can't get enough! read more

Bayside Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Perth Amboy, New Jersey

See all

They didn't clearly let us know that they are closed for the winter.They actually referred us to other places.

My second time here and all I can say it MINT CHOCOLATE CHIP. So good ! Coincidentally the first time I visited was last year around this time. Not planned ! They have tons of great options. I even saw them make a banana sundae Note: - Located in front of a beautiful waterfront park - Plenty of parking - Usually a long line but it moves fast. - restaurant is practicing social distance so line is outside and they're only letting a few people in at a time. read more

Bayside Creamery - Rum raisin, mint chocolate chip - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Perth Amboy, New Jersey

This ice cream shop is tucked inside a residential area right across from the marina, they have quite a few tables and benches inside and outside but the bonus is really taking your treats across the street to the marina and being on the waterfront. All their flavors are really good, they always have at least 20 to choose from and they have soft serve as well. They offer a lot of different dietary options like sugar free, dairy free, etc. they make sundaes, shakes, they have a ton of different cones to choose from and they are so affordable!! Like you can let your kids go nuts here and you will not break the bank. The service is always great and the keep that line moving! read more

See all

This place is fantastic! I had possibly the best 2-scoop waffle cone ice cream ever here last week. The ice cream flavors were delicious and the chocolate/Sprinkle dipped cone was so fresh and crispy. We chose to eat inside in the ac and it was very comfortable. If it wasn't so hot- there's seating outside and across the street overlooking the marina. Can't wait to go back! read more

Very cute icecream place at the marina. Tons of flavors to choose from. Great prices too! Very clean inside as well. Nice outdoor seating at the entrance in the alleyway. read more

See all

So glad that I was told to come here! The ice cream is awesome & the prices are extremely reasonable! The place is very small and you could easily pass it if you blink. There are some tables inside and outside by why sit inside when you have the beautiful waterfront only steps away !? I decided to taste the cookie dough chocolate chip ice cream and I was instantly sold! There were over 20 flavors to choose from! They have many different options of cones to choose from as well. The lines are long here but it is definitely worth the wait !! I can't wait to go back again! I will try a milkshake next time :) read more

Bayside Creamery - Chocolate chip cookie dough on a wafer cone! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Perth Amboy, New Jersey

Love this place one of the best butter pecan ice creams around.Tried many other places but not like this Gem Ty.

Good ice cream, nice customer service people ! The place is very clean, easy to get there

I love to visit Bayside Creamery for ice cream any time I am in Perth Amboy because of their delicious and imaginative creations! This ice cream shop located in Front Street is a must stop for anyone exploring this historical area. The quality of the ice cream and the different flavors will satisfy you; their friendly, attentive staff and the clean, airy and great views of the bay will seal your return for sure. You can enjoy your pick inside in their small but cozy interior or if preferred or weather permitting outside in their patio or strolling taking in the views along the waterfront. Lovely place and great affordable ice cream! read more

Bayside Creamery - Ice cream time! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Perth Amboy, New Jersey

See all

One of the best ice cream store around in Perth Amboy. The view and variety of ice creams makes it so much better. They have from regular ice cream to vegan. It's absolutely amazing. I recommend this shop read more

I paid $5 for a large chocolate dipped waffle cone with two different flavors. This dessert alone filled me up quite a bit and it was so delicious. I had one scoop of hazelnut and one school of cappuccino crunch. I loved the cappuccino I just wasn't a big fan of the crunchy toffee bits because they were too sweet for my liking. The Hazelnut was super rich but just too strong for me. The line here gets seriously long because of the variety they offer but it's definitely worth a visit. read more

Bayside Creamery - Their icecream flavors - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Perth Amboy, New Jersey

See all

Some of the best ice cream I've had in central NJ. They have lots of unique flavors too. I got guava and PB ripple (weird combo I know, don't judge me I panicked) but both were so good. Really creamy and almost stretchy, kind of like a gelato texture read more

Bayside Creamery - guava and PB - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Perth Amboy, New Jersey

This ice cream shop is very charming. As previously posted by some other customers, it's Hershey's, but it's very good. They have a good amount of unique flavors to choose from. The salted caramel vanilla truffle and the coconut almond are my favorites. The owner and staff are very friendly and welcoming. I would have given this place 5 stars, but the staff member that was assisting us with our order was wearing her face mask just over her mouth and her nose wasn't covered at all. While we were ordering, she kept pulling her face mask down under her mouth to respond to us (as she was scooping the ice cream). Really? Yet as a customer, you expect me to wear my mask correctly for the entire time I'm inside your establishment. read more

coconut chocolate almond! the best! they have a variety of flavors but this is the one i always get. it's a combo of all great ingredients.

Delicious flavors! Staff super friendly and helpful considering 'social distancing'. Very clean and organized. The view UNMATCHABLE. read more

Bayside Creamery - cute decor - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Perth Amboy, New Jersey

Great ice cream esp their coffee and hazelnut but no water given .... odd. Staff is ok but nice seats and view at the marina. read more

Bayside Creamery - yum! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Perth Amboy, New Jersey

Good for the family or date night. Get an Ice Cream and walk the waterfront. I am not a big ice cream person but I really enjoyed my Salted caramel Ice cream. Place is cute, service is fast, scoops are big. Not much more to ask for. read more

This is my all time favorite ice cream shop, i don't live in perth amboy but my aunt does, so i come here every summer and get some ice cream, and i love it so much, they have the best ice cream, ranging from superman to vanilla it's an amazing ice cream shop, i wish i could give it more than 5 stars, and it's also really cheap! they have the best ice cream flavors, my favorites are cookies & creme, and Dulce de Leche, definitely recommend 10/10, im definitely coming back (I always do, and i always will) read more

Bayside Creamery is an adorable ice cream shop right near the lovely Perth Amboy marina. They have a great amount of flavors at a fair price and the inside of the shop is clean with plentiful areas so sit. Can get crowded on summer nights and the parking is a little annoying - but overall a great ice cream shop. read more

We were with our bike riding group and got there before it opened. The very nice owner and husband opened for us. The ice cream was delicious! Thanks! read more

It was only a super-random coincidence that I found this place. We had just got done watching the 4th of July fireworks on the Perth Amboy Waterfront, and we were walking back to our car. The place was crazy-crowded, although I don't think its actually that good. It was about as "family owned" as you can get. read more

This is the best ice cream shop ever. I've been coming here for a few years and I can't get enough of their hazelnut ice cream. My family and friends are hooked on it as well. It's worth it to make the 30 minuets trip to Bayside just to have a scoop and enjoy the marina any day. read more

If you enjoy ice cream this is the place to go! Delicious varieties. Expect long lines. Well worth the wait. Family owned & worked.

Not usually a huge ice cream person, but this was hands down the best sundae I've ever had! Customer service was bubbly and patient, and the location is so quaint and picturesque, with gorgeous views of the harbor. Family-owned feel, with a professional arsenal of flavors. If you're ever in the Perth Amboy area, would highly recommend! read more

We are from out of state came to Perth to attend a funeral. After driving by when admiring the area by the marina we noticed this location. Went in did notice it was very bright but small, cute and innocent. The ice cream was delicious my husband had pumpkin and I got cookies and cream. The person who attended us Edward, was very nice and quick! Quickly jumped to handle more than 7 people under 10 minutes. Thanks for the great service and ice cream! read more

Love bay side creamery. They are awesome. The customer service is the best. I see that a lot of the kids working there are from the academy and they have the best manner and always very pleasant. It can get very very busy but you WILL NEVER see them get rude or frustrated. I will drive a few miles, and pass the ice cream shop by my house just to come down to the water front to enjoy their fresh delicious ice cream. I make sure to brag to everyone at the hospital about bay side and when ever we have dinners at the armory we make sure to have our desert at the quaint bay side creamery. read more

Absolutely rudest customer service I ever experienced. The people working there literally "rock, papers, scissors, shoot" to see who would take our order. It was dead in there and we seemed to be a nuisance to them by coming in. The ice cream itself was subpar and had a huge chunk of ice in it when I got to the middle. I've never been so annoyed walking into an establishment and being treated in that manner. Definitely will never be going back. read more

I loved this ice cream shop when I was growing up, but after hurricane sandy they switched management and things turned to shit. They used to have soft serve, 30 flavors of "hard" serve, dozens of toppings and a great atmosphere. Now, theres no soft serve, hardly any toppings (they don't even have brownies), and basic flavors. They reconstructed the inside in a terrible way- the counter is now huge and takes up a large portion of the room. Generally, it's a wasted space. The room lighting is too bright and a lot of space for seating was replaced with an oversized counter. Now there is only 1 table to fight over. The ice cream is just decent. I'm not usually someone who posts reviews, but as someone who watched this store go from a wonderful ice cream shop to a mediocre shop consisting of "sundaes" I could easily just make at home, I am extremely disappointed. read more

The Ice cream there is amazing and they have so many to choose from!! Not only that but the servers are really nice and friendly and have a great attitude and the place is always clean too!! read more