Always being on the road can be stressful but I sure do love finding little gems like this. Those mom and pop places can serve up some great food. This little old school restaurant was certainly satisfactory. The menu has a good variety and fair prices. We enjoyed the food we ordered. My only remark would be I wished my Chicken Parm sub had more sauce. There were only a couple of employees working and they really stayed busy to serve everyone, both indoor diners and phone orders. If you're passing through, don't blink! Make a stop and try this restaurant. read more

See all

Tyler's went from being a really good pizza place to absolute garbage. They raised the prices, and the food quality has gone down. I ordered a cheese pizza for 10 bucks with extra sauce. I got burnt cheese no sauce which I will show you in the pictures and I also ordered an pasta salad that had no lettuce in it, but they did decide to put some sausage and slimy mushrooms and green peppers that don't normally fine in an antipasto salad. When I first walked through the door, there was nobody at the register so we waited patiently then the little girl comes around the corner because the phone rings decides to answer the phone and it is a personal call so while I'm sitting there waiting to have my order taken, she's taking a phone call . I give her my order. She tells me it's gonna take 30 minutes which whatever I'm fine with that as long as my food comes out the way I ask for it. She seem to be a little disappointed when she didn't. I used my debit card, but I never tip with my debit card. I always leave cash once I see my food but considering there was an attitude, I decided to pass this time 35 minutes later, I had to ask for my food, and in that time, I watched people come in waiting in line and then somebody come around the corner once the phone started ringing three different times. These people were made to wait phone calls, which makes absolutely no sense considering the guest standing right in front of you you should put the phone on hold, the girl from the back heavyset short hair came out and got on the phone with the guest who obviously had a problem with her delivery order was very nasty with them and told him yeah well it's been kind of a day and she hung up on them and then took another phone call and was rude to those people as well. It's disgusting how bad the customer service has gone downhill. I will never ever be back to this pizzeria. Being in a small town, it's really sad that a business would treat people the way I watched people being treated today especially since we've been going there for years, but that's OK. I'd rather drive 30 minutes and get a good pizza then deal with rude nasty people who can't put paper towels and toilet paper in the bathrooms. read more

Good food, nice people, could use more staff up front. Great place to gather, good atmosphere.

Best pizza in olive hill for sure. Food is always fresh and good. Could use less garlic though. If you don't like that make sure you tell them. read more

Zero stars not even one , i had a horrible experience last night with the staff ordered three pizzas and while i was paying someone came and took one to give to a party that was taking place , how rude . They said i could wait till they made another one that would mean my other two pizzas would get cold so didn't they changed me for the one they took so thats theft . Disgusting way to run a restaurant ill never go there again .gross staffing read more

Everything that I have had has been delicious. The waiting staff, the drivers and the owners are hard working and friendly.

Walked up to order, cashier said she would only take my order if I would be seated. Waited 25 minutes while she only answered the phone and served other customers. Very disappointed. Won't be back. read more

Good lunch special pizza and a soda for around $6. Nice friendly staff. Would come back again in town.

Loved this place at first, but been going downhill at times. We were told the wait would be 30 mins. We got there at 30 mins and had to wait an extra 40 mins. Pizza was cold. The pepperonis were tossed on it. They fall off when you pick up a slice of pizza. We were to get cheese sticks with the order since we got the special. We did not get them. We didn't mention it because we had already waited way over the time we were told. I was expecting a hot pizza since we waited so long. Nope, it was cool to Luke warm. Ridiculous. read more

This was about the only thing still functioning in "downtown" Olive Hill. Evidently there had been a flood and fire that closed many businesses. The food was certainly worth the price. Don't look for gourmet, but subs and salads are decent. My antipasto salad had everything in it but the kitchen sink. OTOH, I ordered coffee with cream. It cam with 2% milk, which to me, tastes like drinking black coffee. I don't usually take sugar, but I can drink coffee without cream(er) if it has sugar. There was none on the table, and the restaurant had neither sugar nor creamer packets. It seems that there are too few coffee drinkers (and they are known customers) for the proprietor to spend the money. Don't order coffee...unless you like it black. read more

We ate here with our 3 kids after visiting Carter Caves. This was a great local find. We got pizza, fried pickles, steak sub, giant fluffy crinkle fries and corn dog. Very good dessert selection also. It was all great. Service was very friendly and fast. The restaurant was cozy, comfortable and clean. Cash only, so hit the ATM first. read more

Tyler's Pizza - Great portions - Pizza Near Me - Olive Hill, Kentucky

See all

Stopped by here after a visit to the Carter Cave's. The pizza was awesome, & the staff were all friendly! I always look for smaller restaurants with great food and Tyler's definitely fit the bill for that! I will be returning if I'm ever back in the area! read more

We were staying at the campground at Carter Caves State Park and was looking for something to eat the day we setup. We came to Tyler's Pizza and were very glad we did. We were greeted they the friendly staff. The menu has a wide range of items from Pizza and sandwiches to Wings. We chose one of the specials, a 16" 2 topping pizza. We picked Pepperoni and Mushroom. The pizza came out quickly and was nice and hot. The crust was just like we like it and the sauce was fantastic. This was the best pizza that we have had in years. The total bill was very reasonable at about $15 for the 16" pizza and two drinks. Our experience was so good we came back the next day for lunch to try something different. My wife had the Stromboli and steak fries and I had the Fish Sandwich and steak fries. The portions were large and the sandwiches and fries were very good. We both left very satisfied. As we were paying the bill we got a chance to talk to the owner. We can't say enough good things about our experience here. We will definitely visit again when we come back to Carter Caves State Park area. read more

100% the best pizza in town and the area. Friendly service, amazing food, and even better people. The Tyzone and hot wings are to die for!

Awesome pizza and the price was right. Homemade, soft crust with a tangy sauce. Staying at Carter Caves and a park ranger recommended. Large was only $7.99! Would highly recommend!!! read more

Tyler's Pizza - Our pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Olive Hill, Kentucky

I love this little place. It has that home town feel and the best pizza and wings. It is very cozy and the staff are very friendly and welcoming. read more

Great lunch! Pizzas and Stromboli were FANTASTIC! And dessert was AWESOME! Second meals we've had here this week and both were delicious. Owner was friendly and chatted with us. High praise for this restaurant! read more

I would only be able to compare this to pizza made in Chicago, and that's probably not a fair comparison, so I'll just say it was ok and leave it at that. Its not like there are many area options. read more

It was better than expected. Friendly. Reasonable prices. Good pizza. Cash only though. read more

Tyler's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Olive Hill, Kentucky

See all

A friend and myself ate at Tyler's today and it was both terrible service and the food was not good. We ordered a philly steak sandwich and a tyzone. After 45 minutes we received our food. He said his sandwich was nasty and as for me my tyzone was a pizza that was folded like a taco. I ordered mine with sauce on the side and extra cheese, onions, black olives, and Italian sausage. What I got was sauce inside the taco, cheese, onions, green olives, Italian sausage, and mushrooms. I hate mushrooms. I bet there was 2 pounds of mushrooms in this thing. I would recommend the pizza rolls at the BP down the street over this place. Just my experience and opinion. read more

Good pizza with a tasty crust and lots of real cheese. Their version of a calzone was folded over pizza with lots of filling. The jumbo wings are not jumbo but tasty with sauce option. The service and friendliness was worth the trip. read more

Don't order from here if your in a hurry! They don't put them in the oven until the delivery driver gets back in the store to go on the next run! read more

I've eaten at this place since I was a kid. Me and my wife love going there when we are out grocery shopping. The owner is friendly and really cares about her guest. The staff are always friendly and attentive. The restaurant is always clean and welcoming. The food is great! They have items like pizza, calzones (called tyzone), burgers, fries, desserts, etc. My only complaint is the fact they don't accept credit or debit cards. This is a major nuisance. read more

DISGUSTING! Had food delivered to my hotel and 2/3s of the order was wrong. I called to have them send the right food and they were trying to make me pay for it again and wouldn't remake it. The dough on the bottom of the pizza was soaked in grease. No customer service skills at all. The menu had a picture of one item I ordered and it wasn't even made the way it shows. I feel like I was taken advantage of and they didn't care if it was right because I'm not local. Another family at the motel had similar issues. Stay away. The prices are cheap and you get what you pay for. read more

the food is really good, but there was this blonde girl there and she had such a bad attitude. i've never seen anyone with such a shitty attitude, while she was taking the order she kept shaking her head, had attitude all over her face and was talking to the customer like they're stupid. it was packed, but there was no reason for her to have such a bad attitude and be so rude. i work at a pizza shop too and i always make sure i'm being nice to all the customers and professional. really disappointed read more