Always busy, but the great staff keeps the line moving. Large outside area for kids to play in…read moreafter/before getting their ice cream. Cute, affordable, and welcoming neighborhood ice cream shop!

Yia Yia's has a small shack-like appearance. Parking is moderate. I've seen lines go down 104 on…read morehot afternoons, waiting to turn into the parking lot. I don't use the word AMAZING very often because it's so oft' overused. In this case, Yia Yia's is absolutely AMAZING. I ask for a small and it's HUGE. I ask for a baby sized and it's still more than I need. Being lactose intolerant, it's great to see options like the Dole whip flavors. Granted the flavor selection is limited, but it changes quite often so I get to try new flavors every time I visit (Which really isn't very often). If you find yourself on Rte 104 Between ROC and Sodus - make it a point to stop here, you will love it.

Molly V's has the best ice cream in the area! cute little spot where you can get one of their many…read moreflavors and sit outside on picnic tables or benches in the park. I'm so glad they opened up a storefront a few years ago! I do wish they had a more chocolatey vegan ice cream, but I do love their coconut pineapple one!

Ice cream is fantastic and service is excellent. Friendly atmosphere. Lots of flavors. Reasonable…read moreprices.

Outstanding ice cream, cookies and cinnamon rolls! The interior is charming, with cow decor,…read moreincluding black-and-white cow-spotted seating. Highly recommend.

Had dinner in the area and this place was recommended by one of the servers. Tried their hard ice…read morecream with a waffle cone. So creamy and delicious! They had a bunch of unique flavors, I had the caramel, mocha chip and got it to go.

Hedonist Artisan Ice Cream is right next door to their chocolate shop, and their homemade ice cream…read morehas the same high quality. My husband's salted caramel was rich and creamy. My raspberry lemon sorbet had just the right amount of sweetness. Very refreshing and a great palate cleanser after dinner. The shop is small with only one table so keep that in mind. Service is excellent.

Omg Hedonist rocks! I loved the dairy free chocolate and candy cane flavors together. The sweet…read morepotato marshmallow was so unbelievably true to those flavors that we bought a pint to take home. It went great with leftover Thanksgiving pie. The prices were reasonable and the shop was cute! Highly recommend.

There is something blissfully satisfying when you find really delicious ice cream. Even more so…read morewhen it's local and convenient to your house. I-Scream is my go-to ice cream spot because it's conveniently located and it's really lovely to go there. In the summertime (or during nice days) you can go to the rooftop and sit up there and overlook the plaza or just wander around the square. In the wintertime, there is plenty of indoor seating and it's fun to just go and potentially run into people in your community. The ice cream is rich and flavorful. The different flavored are great because they're unique to I-Square (at the very least, I haven't seen them anywhere else) and the girls working there are always friendly and efficient. I will never not go there.

They buy their frozen 5-gallon buckets from Purity in Ithaca and their soft-serve from Upstate…read moreFarms dairy cooperative. Enjoy local! The lines can be long on busy days, but it's worth the wait.

LOVE, LOVE, LOVE!!! Great service and they always seem to be enjoying their selves, a smile goes a…read morelong way Great size ice cream for the prices Traditions being kept and created.

No soft serve. So disappointed All the way here from Florida. We usually come in February and…read moreeverything is closed. I was really looking forward to ice cream. I guess I will have to find a new place.

I had one of the worst experiences ever at this location. I'm still taken back by the owner's lack…read moreof customer service. Today we decided to get our favorite ice cream because we were having a tough day and thought it would be nice to treat ourselves. Usually, the strawberry sensation is paired with Tahitian vanilla. Unfortunately, I didn't notice that it had been replaced with raspberry. I realized after I had already poured it because the color looked different. I thought, "Well, it's too late now, let me try it," but unfortunately I didn't like the combination. I went to the front and spoke to the gentleman who said he was the owner. I calmly explained what happened and asked what I should do. Without hesitation, and with a very unpleasant look on his face, he replied, "What do you want me to do about it?" I again explained that I had simply overlooked the flavor change, but he rudely responded that it was "right there" and continued by saying, "We don't waste food around here." At that point, I decided to walk away and remove myself from the situation. I dumped the ice cream because I wasn't going to pay for something that was an honest mistake and that I didn't enjoy. When we finished and went to check out with a very kind young employee, the owner came out from the back, saw the ice cream I had dumped, and attempted to charge me for it. I politely replied that I would not be paying for that. His response was simply that we could leave. I have never had an issue like this at the Webster location. This owner should consider taking a class on customer service or even anger management. There were many ways this situation could have been handled calmly and respectfully, but instead it was met with unnecessary hostility. It was a very bad look for what is supposed to be a "family business."

A very solid froyo place…read more It seems to be popular to a wide range of locals, for anything from date night, to family night, to post-awards and event celebrations. This is your typical self-serve froyo place, for those of you who prefer frozen yogurt and toppings over ice cream. They also carry Perry's brand ice creams if you prefer that. The cashier was nice, although the self-serve setup lends to very little human interaction. They have ample outdoor seating out front, which is nice, although the ambience is a shopping strip parking lot so nothing too fancy. Other notable details: they do have a rewards program.

Best chipwich I've ever had! The ice cream is very smooth and delicious. I'd definitely recommend…read morestopping by. You can get a cone, dish, sundae, or a pint to go!

Have liked this place in the past and is often a stop on the way from Honeoye Falls to to…read moreCanandaigua, but today hit differently. I got the Chocolate Lovers hard ice cream with chocolate sprinkles and it was to die for. I'm not even sure what little extra chocolate bits and crunchies were in it, but it was delicious!! And the single scoop size was very generous, enough to share!