Wow !!! Have been wanting to go for years and about the time we went the restaurant closed due to…read morea fire. Heard they reopened in a new location but never seemed to find time or thought about it. Decided today was the day....Have been kicking myself that we haven't tired it sooner. It was so good. Staff there were friendly, warm, and inviting. We spoke to the owner for a while about a shared experience in DC. The restaurant back in the day was so dark when it was the Black Cat and now is so open, light, and inviting. Nothing fancy but is great for a casual meal. Now for the Pizza.... What makes it so great is the thin light and crispy crust with the right amount of toppings and cheese. They offer many different and unique pizzas and am looking forward to returning and trying several other pizzas. Would highly recommend, truly a five star experience.

We loved Mangia Macrina's back when it was on Seneca Turnpike and after it was lost to a fire, we…read moredefinitely missed it. I am SO happy that they are in their new location. It's spacious inside and the staff is super friendly. It's clear they take great pride in their food, and they should. Is it going to be a little more expensive? Maybe. But you're paying for excellent quality pizza cooked in a wood fire oven. It took maybe 4 minutes to get my pizza to my table. There are so many unique offerings on the menu and if you're feeling like trying something different, go for the one with fig, goat cheese, rosemary and an amazing honey drizzle (Miele di Fico). They also do gluten free! Highly recommend for a great quality pizza.

Tried wings from Pizza Boys during a charity Battle of the Wings event and loved their Dubai…read moreChocolate Wings which earned them an award. Heard the year before they did a PB&J wing and knew that we had to try. Went on Wing Wednesday by happenstance ... Wings are .95 which is a great deal..they had a live band in the bar area but chose counter service instead. Wings came out quick and hot. The PBJ wings lived up to all the hype. After having wings at their restaurant I see why they have won awards for several years. Wings were tender, crispy, and the sauce was amazing. With it being Wing Wednesday and live entertainment it was rather crowed. This is your typical wing and pizza joint nothing fancy or stuff but a great casual place for a night out. Haven't tried their Pizza yet but that is next up on our list.

Orders the meatballs, 3 slices, and garlic knots with marinara. The meatballs were lukewarm and you…read morecould tell that they were frozen. The knots and marinara were cold - like, legit cold. Not even warmed up. The pizza was old and tasted old; you could also tell by how they added shredded mozzarella to the top of it. Really disappointing experience

the pizza is good, love the wings I got a calzone and didn't…read morelike it. the waitress was great, I would try it again

Joes is a different style of pizza if you havent tried it! Love this place with their upside down…read morepizza and fresh toppings! Always enjoyable!

First thing is first, amazing service and food…read more They actually cook the pizza on the stone which in my opinion the true way to make a pizza, the crust, sauce, and cheese were perfectly balanced with nice slices. On to the wings over the top not gooey or gross these were crispy and I opted for the Carolina Gold sauce, it's off the chain. Wrap this up with the fried dough bites just the perfect way to finish up this awesome purchase. Ps Our first time at this place ever.

We stopped in for a team dinner after calling and being advised they could seat and service 25+…read morepeople. I don't know if I would say it can accommodate 25 people or that it has about 25 seats for the whole business. But they were amazing with what we needed. They were able to make pizza, wings, keep track of drinks and overall a very friendly and speedy. The pizza was delicious! The BBQ wings so good. The restroom was clean once found. It's a must stop if in Rome. Parking was easy. Some public parking for 2 hours right outside the business available too.

Just had another pizza from this place. 1/2 with sausage and 1/2 garlic. Never disappointed. I'm a…read morebig fan of this place. Wings and garlic knots are fantastic. The crew is very accommodating and cordial. 5 stars for sure.

Excellent food and customer service!! 10 beans for a chicken parm dinner?!! Incredible! Keep up the…read moregood work work!!!

The cheese pizza was good, unique flavor. Place itself was not super clean. I saw a few people…read morestruggling to find a place to eat and finding a table that was decent.

Everything was excellent! Salads, pizza, subs. We really enjoyed them! The staff is the Best!…read moreEspecially Cassie!!

Wings are super unique, very good. We enjoyed the medium ones. They aren't saucy on the outside the…read moreflavor is inside and the outside is like bbq'd. I enjoyed the pizza its unique too- different than nys stye. Crust was really nice. Music was a choice, very loud and punk. But staff was friendly.

Personally I feel this is the best pizza in Utica... like a deep dish the sauce and cheese go right…read moreto edge ... crispy dotting and their cheese mix is my favorite.... Excellent sauce...

Went in for a slice on a recommendation. They had about 6 different pizza choices ready to go for…read moreslices. They have a thicker slice than I prefer but I got the mushroom and sausage which was LOADED with toppings. The crust was golden brown looking great but a slightly doughy but hard bottom which made cutting it difficult with plastic silverware as to not dirty my dress clothes. They used a mild spicy sausage which I liked as it gave a bit more flavor compared to the canned mushrooms. Slice was ok and good for a quick easy meal. The cheesecake slice was large and VERY dense with a side of strawberry topping for me to use or not use. It was very thick with large chunks of strawberries. A slice and a cheesecake cost $9. Service was quick and straight to the point. Overall ok quality It won't become a regular place for me but it's good for a quick meal when you have limited time.

Since they changed ownership I noticed a drop in customers. The regular people that were working…read morethere have all been let go. The fryer was always going. Not anymore. I ordered 2 plain slices and 1/2 sausage roll. The girl range it up at $25.xx! I looked at her like I wasn't going to pay that....she recalculated and the price was now $16.xx. Also the pizza was gooie. Should have been baked longer. May have to start looking for another pizza joint To provide consistent good pizza and I think I found it.

The food is always delicious and it has a classic pizzeria vibe. Staff is always polite, I am…read moredefinitely coming back!

Tried the pizza for the 1st time today and it was excellent. Very tasty, cooked perfectly and crust…read morewas great. This is hereby declared our official pizza source. We will have to try his other stuff soon. Good job.