This place has some serious potential, but be warned: getting your hands on their food can be a challenge! We ordered a large pepperoni pizza and 20 wings, and to be honest, it was the best pizza we've had in the area. Seriously delicious! The frustrating part is that this was the first time we've actually managed to place an order. We've tried multiple times before, but their hours seem to be completely inaccurate. Today, for example, their website and menu both said they were open from 4-8 PM, with a note to call at least 30 minutes before closing. I called at 6:50 PM, and when I didn't get an answer, I waited and called again at 6:59 PM. A very rude woman answered, i proceeded to request an order for pick up and she abruptly told me they were closed and cleaning. It's a real shame because the food is fantastic, but the inconsistent hours and poor customer service are a major letdown. We'd love to continue doing business with them, but they need to get their act together regarding their hours and how they treat customers. read more

1st time trying them and food was really good and tasted delicious. I will go back again definitely.

Their pizza is the best! Try the Tenderfoot wings. Wowza. You'll never try anything after them We had company from Virginia and they said this is real pizza. They even brought one home. Thank you Cuginis!!! read more

Was looking up pizza places in the area and found this place. I ended ordering an XXL pizza and some boneless wings The pizza was good. It wasn't too greasy or cheese. It was close enough to New York-style pizza. The wings were good with the "everything" sauce. When I picked up the pizza it was a little cold. I ordered the wings with the sauce on the side but got sauce in the wings. Overall the pizza is an 6.7/10. read more

Cugini's Pizzeria - XXL cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Barneveld, New York

Amazing subs. Chicken parm and Buffalo chicken were outstanding. Mozzarella sticks were perfect. Pizza was outstanding, too. Well worth going out of your way for this place. read more

Very pleasant surprise. Cugini's is a diamond in the rough. It may not look like much from the outside but they more than make up for aesthetics with their food. We had the fried ravioli and fried meatballs as starters and while the raviolis were recommended they were just alright. Same problem with all things stuffed with cheese, fry it and the cheese gets out, but the meatballs were impressive. Good size and great taste. But the stars of the show were the pizza and the service. Ella took our order, brought our food, made our pizza and even plated the first slice, because it was really hot and as she said it's part of my job. And what a job she did. We ate half in store and took half home. It was even better the next day. I can't wait to go back. Ask for Ella, she'll take care of you. read more

Cugini's Pizzeria - Fried meatballs and Fried Ravioli - Pizza Near Me - Barneveld, New York

See all

Spend all your money here till your broke. People breaking there backs in this place to outsell grandes and you all waist your money on that place read more

6 oz piece of lousy fish for $15.99. smells like crappy fish, tastes like crappy white fish, not haddock or cod! We. will never go back. 2 Tbsp pf coleslaw and crappy fries for their " Fish Fry" . Tasted aweful, sour, fishy and not worth the money. Your $45 pizza and wing special is way overpriced and sub-par compared to area pizzerias, Done spending my hard earned money on your foul food! read more

We were driving by and decided to stop here and are so glad that we did! The owners were both incredibly nice and even stayed open late in order to cook our 3 pizzas. They made us feel at home after a long trip. The best pizza was definitely the pepperoni. I recommend stopping here if you pass by! read more

I always order the broccoli pizza which has a garlic sauce, broccoli, tomato slices and ricotta cheese. Best pizza ever!

Best White/Garlic/Broccoli Pizza in (Barneveld, NY). Very Friendly Staff. read more

Sorry but I hate this place and I miss 3 tins! The pizza has hard plaque-like cheese and little seasoning in the sauce. It is very hard and sterile-feeling in the seating area: chrome and black. The staff are miserable in most cases. Sorry, no good pizza available in Barneveld. We go to Boonville for Capris, or to the Mall in New Hartford for pizza. If we feel rich we go to Macrinas or the new Blaze pizza. read more

Just happened to stop at this FANTASTIC spot on the way out of the mountains. Wow, were we surprised at the amount & quality of GREAT FOOD at a reasonable price. Warm welcoming atmosphere and a wonderful meal indeed. Plan on stopping into this place for lunch or dinner on the way to or out of the Adirondack Park....right on Rt. 12. Paul Clapper, Syracuse, NY read more

I was driving by this place. AMAZING sub. Made with love. Friendly staff, great COVID restrictions. LOVE the place

This is a cool little place. Pizza rumored to be the best around. Inside is clean, newly remodeled, Modern, bathroom squeaky clean and very nice. While the pizza and wings are a little pricy the service has been great and there has been people coming in and out consistently picking up Togo orders. They also have a free guest wifi. Great for leaving a yelp review. read more

See all

No, just no. Called to order a pizza even though I have heard terrible reviews on the place I decided to give it the benefit of the doubt. Lady on the other end sounded aggravated and just said they were closed for the weekend, what pizza place just randomly closes on a weekend? Also putting boulders in front of Stewart's, how moronic can you be? That nearly cuts your business in half when you do that. read more

The Menu : I had this places food for the first time this sunday. I checked their menu online, which was convenient as ive never been. My girlfriend and I both picked a calzone and her daughter got a small sub. Total order came up to $30.65, you may think "Wow, thats alot for those items" and I agree. Their menu is lacking in the fact that its outdated on their website. They have a new menu and of course, items are more money. What kind of place, has a calzone on their menu and ONLY includes cheese? ALL toppings were separate charges, so we picked 3 items each and they were all .75 more. Since original price was $8.25, that brings price of a calzone to $10.50. Insane. The Food : It was a smaller calzone than any other place ive had, but it was tasty. Toppings were great and included marinara sauce, just could have been a bigger portion. We wont go back for a long time, if I ever do at all. read more

Tried out this place when it just opened because of its convenient location and ordered a simple large cheese pizza. The pizza was subpar at best, the sauce tasted like it was just poured out of a can. The pizza places like Venice's, Pizza Boys, Rosario's, in the utica area make this joint look like Pizza Hut. read more

My family and I love cuiginis! The wings are always cooked crispy and the selection of wing sauces are great! Along with delicious wings their pizza is great too! Love the pizza sauce :) read more

What's with the hating on Cugini's? Maybe they've changed their recipes...it's pretty good! It seems that the other complaints have been about the sauce. I wouldn't know since I order chicken wing pizza every time. It's fantastic. The service is always friendly too. Honestly sad to see these reviews-if I had seen them a while ago, I probably wouldn't have tried their food. Glad I didn't see it until now! read more

Stopped by here for lunch during our road trip with minimum expectations. To our surprise, we had a very pleasant experience there: pizzas were fantastic with the right kind of cheese/sauce/crust, antipasto salad was made fresh with tons of good ingredients, server was attentive and helpful. I figured they deserve a shoutout! Thumbs up!! read more

This pizza was amazing, by far the best pizza around, If you like thin crispy crust pizza you are in for a treat. Even my picky son prefers this pizza over all others.....Keep writing your bad reviews other local pizza joint owners, anyone who tries this pizza can judge for themselves. read more

I've ordered pizza and antipasto a few times and appreciate the fresh ingredients. But today I ordered antipasto and got no pepperoni or black olives. Got very little lettuce and very little cheese. Was disappointed as usually quality and quantity is better. read more

Cuginis is great pizza place in an area where there is not a ton of options for a pizza. The pizza tastes amazing and the wings perfectly crisp. The tenderfoot wings are our favorite. A wonderful medium sauce mixed with blue cheese. The Stromboli are also delicious and my wife's favorite. If your looking for a delicious pizza place with fair prices, Cugini's is a great option. read more

Couldn't agree more with the original poster. These people run the dumbest hours and treat you as an inconvenience every time you come in. Nothing like feeling dumb for supporting a business. They wont last long in the north country, we don't tolerate attitudes like this read more

Unlike the previous posts I ordered for first time tonight and I thought I was great. Crust was like Un greasy fried dough and perfect amount of sauce read more

The previous two reviews are a bit unfair, as they were written shortly after this restaurant opened. The pizza menu and styles have changed and are much better now. I live a mile away, and go there regularly. It's hand-down the best pizza within 10 miles. read more

Best meatball sub in town, the only thing I don't like is that they close way to early 8:00pm on a weekend is a little to early 11:00pm is about right !!! read more

Great pizza!!! NY style, thin crust & big slices. Open on Sunday's. Clean bathroom. Friendly staff. Would definitely stop in again!

I have to disagree with the previous reviewer, I've eaten from Cugini's twice now and was pleased both times! The interior of the restaurant looks much better than it did previously, and I prefer a thin crust pizza. We ordered on a Saturday afternoon, it was only a 20 minute wait, and both the pizza and wings were very good. Counter staff was an older gentleman who I suspect was an owner and he was courteous and professional. Prices are a bit higher but I can't complain about the quality. If you're looking for a thin crust pizza, I say give them a try. read more

I ordered a sub from Cugini's and recieved it soggy and it barley had any meat. So disappointed and wouldnt recommend this place for a cold sub. My boyfriend on the other hand got a calzone and enjoyed it. Wish it was bigger though for the price you have to pay. I have no idea how the kid that made my sub is still working there. Im not the only person to complain about the food they recieve when he is working. read more