Absolutely a gem! This locally-owned place elevates the quiet downtown of Carlisle. Everything we…read morehave tried is delicious with complex flavors that complement each bite. The service is consistently great and very attentive to allergy concerns! This is our go-to date night and always our first recommendation for hosting and visitors.

One13 Social is among Carlisle's most top-rated restaurants on Yelp. After dining here solo on a…read moreWednesday night in April, I can say it lives up to the hype. Walking in without a reservation, I got a table right away. The host and server were both friendly and very helpful. Within minutes, my order was taken. After asking a question about how dry the local hard cider on the menu is, my server brought over a taste. It's not too dry and very, very good. Order it. The mushroom soup was perfect. The parmesan chip on top made it pop even more. The smash burger was tasty. The fries that it comes with are thin, but very hot and delicious. Overall, I had an excellent experience here. There's street parking out front to make it easy.

In downtown Carlisle, 1794 The Whiskey Rebellion captivates you with a unique atmosphere. With a…read moredecent number of sitting options, you feel comfortable with the company at your table. The menu has great options to pick from, and our service was nice and attentive. Most of the table had some of the steak options, from the filets to the medallions and then to the pot pie variation. The mashed potatoes were delicious - great flavor and taste. I'm not even a gravy fan but I wanted more. The steaks were cooked to our liking and flavored well. Would return for a nice dinner again!

Came here for the first time for dinner with hubby. We orders the whiskey rings appetizer (I.e.,…read moreonion rings), trout, Wagyu steak, and a couple of beers. Total came out to approximately $99 (not including tip). What's hot - Menu. Fairly short and straightforward menu. There appears to be something for everyone, even possibly vegans (I.e., mostly salads). - Quality. The whiskey rings appetizer was delicious- lightly breaded, crispy, nicely seasoned, and a good dipping sauce. My trout was served hot and nicely seasoned, as well. Tender and moist. I would've liked the skin to be crispy. The main disappointment was the steak, which I address below. - Location. Fairly easy to find in town. They have a nice indoor seating area and seating on their front porch. Their outdoor seating area is very pleasant when the weather is nice. - Price. With the exception of the quality of the steak, which I address below, their food is good value for money. What's not - Quality. The Wagyu steak was a disappointment. They cooked it appropriately (my husband ordered it done medium), but the meat was not tender at all. Rather, it was tough despite it being cooked medium. Would not order it again and it makes me doubt the quality of the rest of their meats. - Service. My husband's main issue with their service is that the second round of drinks we ordered were full price, rather than the happy hour discount. He insisted with the wait staff that we ordered the second round right at the end of happy hour, but they did not accommodate his request. - Parking. There is street parking, but it's timed and metered. There are a couple parking lots nearby within a block's distance, but they're more expensive- approximately $5-$6/hr. If you're willing to walk a few blocks, there is free parking. - Reservations. It's probably dependent on the day and time you go, but it appears reservations may be better. We went for Friday dinner. The hostesses asked us if we had reservations, which we didn't. As such, they asked us if we prefer to be seated outdoors or at the bar. My point is to be prepared. Final answer Willing to return, but not a first choice.

Friendly service and delicious food! We are new to town and…read morethis was a great first stop. The cheese steak was fresh and perfectly seasoned. The fries were crisp and tender. My son enjoyed the burger and my husband says the fish and chips were fantastic. We'll be back!

We've heard so much about steak night on Tuesday so we decided to go. We both had steak. I had…read moremine with mashed and asparagus and Jenni had mashed with green beans. The steaks were okay -- they seemed tough and mine, for medium seemed slightly over cooked with hardly any pink inside and what there was was very light pinkish / brown color. Jenni said her steak was done to her satisfaction -- medium well. I would say mine was probably also medium well. My steak had a lot of fat and gristle that I didn't eat. The mashed potatoes were amazing. My asparagus seemed stingy in size and number of stalks and added little taste or filling to my plate. Jenni said her green beans were okay. The iced tea was great. My Pepsi didn't taste flavorful though Alyssa said she checked the soda bags and they were full. I swapped for sweetened ice tea. Alyssa was a super friendly server who checked on us regularly. We want to patronize local businesses but we probably wouldn't get our meals again and would try something else. Jenni said she'd rate our experience as a 2.5 which is exactly what I'd give so we're going to round up since maybe our experience was just a little off this evening.

Monday lunch Ice tea, very good…read more Cup of beef veggie soup, very good. Cobb salad. Chicken way undercooked, it was crunchy and had a snap. Egg was dyed purple, food coloring, no thanks. Well I'm leaving I need to go find some lunch.

While passing through Carlisle, PA My wife and I stopped at Mays Family Restaurant. The restaurant…read morewas quaint and clean. The staff and cook were warm and friendly. We had a special which was a seafood trio of haddock, shrimp, and scallops. Perfect portions and very tasty. The fries were fantastic and the coleslaw was to die for. We highly recommend this restaurant for the inexpensive food, atmosphere, and easy location. You won't be disappointed. Joe & Cathy Lennon Boston, MA

I am emphasizing the perfect atmosphere. Came here for lunch to grab a couple of drinks and catch…read moreup with some friends. This place was the perfect spot. All of our food across the board was delicious and our waitress was fantastic!

The service was fine. The food however...it was the worst I've had in a while. Our nachos were…read moreburned and had dry and oddly flavored brisket. My cheese steak was inedible. The "cheese" tasted so wrong and the meat had almost a sweet flavor that made me feel sick. The side of extremely undercooked sweet potato fries didn't make up for it. The kids chicken tenders were interesting because two look like they sat in the fryer way too long and the rest were "just cooked". The crab cake sandwich was good and fresh but the potato chips were so salty and way over seasoned.

What a wonderful place. Has the best homemade mozzarella cheese sticks. I've gotten the Lobster…read moreBisque and salad, and their half a sandwich and soup and both had been great. Always good nice servers and very welcoming.

Sometimes less really is more! They put way too much meat on their sandwiches that involve lunch…read moremeat! You can't get your mouth around them! My parents are 88 and 90 ... they had a horrible time with their sandwiches! Maybe less meat and then lower the prices!! They are pretty steep on their prices and charge extra for everything!! They both ordered the 1/2 a sandwich with a cup of soup. They both enjoyed their soup. They said it was good but nothing special. My cousin and I both opted for a full sandwich w/fries. We exchanged 1/2 of our sandwiches. When I asked for mine w/out jalapeños you would have thought I had asked her to go out back and killed the chicken with her bare hand! Very strange look and a bit of a snotty attitude! The service was sooooo slow! And only a few people were in. We stopped in for an early lunch. (Just after opening) The new location is way too small. I'm surprised they chose to move to this location. The parking lot is tiny and weird shaped. There's not a lot of seating inside... I personally have tried all of their locations and it's always the same issues. It was not my choice to pick here, I would have gone elsewhere.

Drove past this tavern many times when I lived in the area, but never visited until I moved 520…read moremiles away. Larger inside than it appears, with a few nooks and crannies to accommodate customers. Prompt greeter and waitresses. The food was served and promptly and piping hot. I got the seafood Alfredo which reminded me of the food where we used to eat in Vincenza Italy (there it came with clams instead of crab meat). Too full to try desert, so can't comment about that.

They have delicious steaks and food options and great service!! It's a great local hangout where…read moreeveryone knows each other and is very friendly! Definitely worth the visit and it's always busy!

We started out with the cheesesteak egg roll, which was a unique and tasty option. The burger was…read morejuicy and full of flavor. I don't think that you could go wrong with anything on the menu.

It was really nice to sit outside while viewing the golf course. The food was pretty good.read more