I went back and forth before settling on a three star review; however, the kicker was three out of…read morefour dinners being disappointing. I had seen positive things about this restaurant on Facebook, going in my expectations were high. The end result was expectations not being met. I phoned ahead and was able to make a reservation. When my group pulled into the parking lot at 5PM, it wasn't full. This is generally not a good sign for a Saturday night. When we entered, it looked old school (big bar, televisions and a pool table). I generally see this as a positive indicator. The drinks we received were well made and the bartender was a nice guy. He gave us menus and we were waited on in the bar area. Both waitresses we were served by were very neutral in having us as guests. No extra chit chat. After ordering, we were directed to our table and were told we could go to the salad bar. I was looking forward to the salad bar as other social media raved about it. It was nice and all the items were fresh; however, it wasn't very big. The soup, available on the salad bar, was very good. The homemade dinner rolls were also good. The main meal is where things went backwards. One dining partner had a scallops and ribeye combo. When it was delivered to the table, the scallops looked pathetically small and the steak looked paper thin. Unfortunately, my impression of it being bad was what my dining partner experienced. They described the scallops of having a fish stick taste. They were disappointed in the meal. Another dining partner had the beef tip special. It was well prepared and was quite a large portion. It was an enjoyable meal. As luck would have it, myself and another dining partner both ordered the Triple O ribeye, a 16 oz cut covered with mushrooms, onions and peppers. We each ordered the garlic mashed potatoes. When it was delivered to our table it looked good. Sadly, while tasting good the potatoes weren't very warm. Having to move the topping to find the steak, I found my first piece a little difficult to cut, but prepared to order. After a few bites and after the final waitress appearance, I told my dining partner that I did not think my steak was a ribeye. They said they were thinking the same thing. Although generous in size, it appeared to be sirloin steak and while well-prepared, lacking flavor. Having eaten a good chunk, I decided not to make an issue but found the steak disappointing. If you look at my other reviews, I think you find them to be pretty generous. After contemplating this for a couple of days, I'd say people may want to try another restaurant when looking for a quality supper club experience.

Food was amazing! Bartender Jo and waitress Kenzie did a wonderful job. Great service and great…read morepersonalities and hospitality! Will be back!

We were looking for a supper club serving fish. We found the Just Stop in, it was packed but we…read moreput our name in and sat at the bar and talk with the people around us till our table was ready. The food was delicious, hot and cooked perfectly. The drinks were strong but not to much. Great place for fish dinner

Fish Friday! Great fish with friendly service. Well liked on Friday night could be a wait. Small…read moreplace nice bar area

Salad in the salad bar looked all yellowed. I've been to Supper Clubs before, this was very average.read more

Amazing small supper club. Staff was great, got into way last minute with no reservations. Salad…read morebar is one of the best I've seen. Got full off the salad bar offering!

What a treat! Great smells, even better food! I ordered the walleye with potato salad. The 1st…read morething I noticed was the rye bread. It was soft, and obviously fresh.....not stale like some places. Next test, the coleslaw. A-MAZING! I've been waiting for a place that serves fish to do their coleslaw right-they did! It was creamy, had that nice coleslaw bite that a lot of places miss. It was delicious. I'd recommend this place on their coleslaw alone! The walleye: beautifully breaded, crisp, and fresh tasting. I had to heat it up a little when I got home, and somehow it remained crisp. The only regret I have is I just now found Highland Howie's!! I'm definitely going to return! If you haven't tried them yet, I definitely recommend it!

Great food, small bar atmosphere, solid service. Perch was a bit underwhelming imo, but they do…read morehave a variety of other solid options. They only have one deep fryer so if you are there on chicken or fish night, prepare to be boxcar'd‍

Atmosphere: Think supper club mixed with sports bar. Huge bar area to sit at and lots of table and…read morebooth seating. Service: Friendly and funny bartender. Waitress was nice and checked in on our meal after it was delivered. Food: THAT REUBEN SANDWICH OMG. I will be back just for that. The tater tots were super crispy and ask for the jalapeno ranch dipping sauce, you won't regret it. Unfortunately the other person I dined with got the prime beef (prime rib? not sure) sandwich. The meat was tender but had no flavor. There was a ton of fat on it that was inedible so they ended up having to dissect their sandwich and eat it with a fork and knife and cut off all the inedible bits. Drinks: Good old fashioneds here. Can't wait to come back! Prices were reasonable.

Our waitress was really friendly and the place was clean but unfortunately that's about the only…read morething I could find note worthy about it. The food was mediocre my burger was over cooked when I asked for medium and my husband asked for rare and he got well done also the burgers had no flavor even with ketchup mustard ect nothing could bring out the flavor it's tasted like boiled meat. The fries were obviously frozen crinkle fries.

We went here for a Friday fish fry and we're very happy we did, we had walleye, haddock and perch…read moreordered in our group of 4 and we all were very pleased with the meal, I felt the price was reasonable for what we received, the old fashioned was spot on and the service was excellent. I will definitely be back as it was a very enjoyable night out!

The service was very friendly and the food was delicious. We would definitely stop again.read more

Bartender gave me the menu and a beer. She came back 9 minutes later after making eye contact with…read moreme three times and finally came back after I signaled her the fourth time by waving her in my direction to take my order. I decided not to eat after that rudeness and instead paid for my beer. Been there 10 Times and first time I've been served by this blond bartender. Gave her a ten to pay for the beer and she gave me 5 ones back. She's obviously more focused on the tips than service. I left a $1 tip and walked out. Last time there!!!

Super fun place, great people snd love the Shoots steak big burger …read more take all out of town guest there

We order and pick up Friday night fish to bring home and eat. Never been disappointed! Really good…read moreselection to pick from and the staff is so friendly!

Ordered a full chicken meal to go. All items were great. However, the Quart of stuffing was not…read moreheated at all. It was cold as if it came right out of the refrigerator. I think they forgot to heat it. Real shame. Thank God for or microwave. Order B12 - bar. receipt timestamp 09-aug-2025 5:23:18p