I have loved this place for over 20 years, best mozzarella and prosciutto bread, besides their meats and veggies

The veggies and fruit are amazing. Also, the deli dept is quality. It is small but, works perfectly.

Bought "wild salmon" today at 22$ per pound...not wild at all.the fish was grassy and old.shame on me,but NEVERE EVER AGAIN...scammers will be reported to the right department read more

Everyone who works in this store is helpful and friendly. We especially appreciate the deli guys, and front end workers. The blonde manager/cashier who is ALWAYS working is always so kind to both me and my son. She is welcoming and knowledgable. We are lucky to have this type of community store. read more

I like the catering Department! Everything is freshly cooked and very tasty!! It's conveniently located and it has parking. read more

saw a rat in the kitchen and told them but they didn't do anything and the food had hair in it

Top Tomato is always a good option when you're looking to pick up a few items without going into one of the larger grocery stores. From fresh fruits and vegetables to meats and fish and even dessert, Top Tomato has it all. They have one of the best store bought cheesecakes I've tasted. I have to say the parking at all of their SI locations stinks but this one is probably the worst. The store itself is very small and the crowds can become annoying. When I lived nearby I loved to walk here after work and pick up fresh food for dinner and leave the car home. read more

Top Tomato - Cheesecake - Grocery Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

I usually like to stop and grab some vegetables and We like the turkey London broil's in the lemon sauce. The coconut so great and sometimes we even like to try to cook foods read more

love the customer appreciation day that they do. also, when val-pak puts out their coupons. when you buy whats on sale here, then you save a lot of money. read more

BEWARE, whole family was poisoned by tuna purchased from the fish vendor here. Was gaslighted by the owner when I tried to have him rectify the situation. Fish was cooked immediately after purchase. Got something called Scromboid Poisoning. DO NOT shop here if you value your family's health. read more

Top Tomato - Reaction to tuna - Grocery Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Its a neighborhood store and I always try to shop local when I can However this place has one problem that's hard to overlook, The Fruit and Vegetables are not always the freshest. read more

I suspect they changed owners or workers in recent years bc this place a few years back was great. Now their food is not being made right. Their wraps and premade meals, who is making them?! They taste so off, bitter, inedible. I brought wraps for my family on my way home tonight for dinner and no more, I thought maybe they were off a few times, this is enough. No more from me. Every single one of us complained about the taste (6 adults). And we all got different wraps. The macaroni salad and Cole slaw also tasted like it went bad. The last and final time I ordered catering from them it wasn't good. What is going on???! ... food needs to be FRESH, SEASONED AND STORED CORRECTLY ... maybe get some new chefs in ... I'm unfortunately done being a patron at this location. read more

This review is for the cold cuts and the people who cut them. I've been coming to this store now since they opened. They are a nice neighborhood store with good sales. My problem is with the cold cuts, I do not buy them here anymore as they are to unreliable. There are only a few people behind the counter who actually take pride in the work they do. Most are kids who don't give a crap. It has probably been 6 plus months since I bought any cold cuts here as I now go elsewhere but was in a hurry and only needed 1/4 of prosciutto for a dinner recipe, so I just ran in and got it here. Well I didn't sit there and babysit the person cutting my food as I should have and when I got home I was totally amazed that for the like 16.99 a pound they charged me I got crap. Yes crap, it was horrible, dried out and not even cut right, it was in broken up pieces. Never again will I get any cold cuts here. read more

Always excellent service !! Deli counter help is amazing ...store is alway so clean. When you can't find something there is always someone to help you read more

I bought jelly donuts there tthat were green molded. Manager would not give refund. I will never shop there again

Review on deli. The food is very fresh. The issue is the cold cuts and the people serving. They need to cut the cold cuts as requested. I asked for very thin sliced salami and received the opposite. Thick to the point I had to throw out a 1/2 lb. Train the people you hire to listen to the customer and accommodate. read more

I want to like this place, but the management is so antisocial and downright nasty, and no surprise, so are many of the employees, so I was there today and they told me I had to purchase a bag, I said I dont need a bags, i pack them in my car where i keep them, so the cashier said you cant leave without a bag she said its store policy, so I said they're in my car, and she made me go to my car and get them and of course I had to pack 110 $ of groceries myself, she would not lift a finger, and when I got home she took the apples from the pile even though I paid, I checked receipt, so nasty and dishonest, who knows what the food is about, my advice go to pastosa read more

They raised their prices so much during this crisis and I mean sky high. I went to stop and shop a few minutes away, their prices are only a little higher on just a few items. I think they are greedy, they started charging extra fee for credit card customers last year and when they lost customers they had to abandon that gimmick. What's next, skimp on quality to to increase profit margins ? I'm done going there read more

The only reason I go to this place is for is the fish in front of the store. The fruits and veggies are ok, I bought a bag of cherries once that had nice ones on top of the bag and a bunch of weirdly deformed ones at the bottom. The check out girls are a hit or miss. Sometimes they're nice, sometimes they are nasty. read more

Top Tomato - Meal made from salmon bought from Seabreeze fish - Grocery Near Me - Staten Island, New York

I use the top tomato on bay Street and have never had an issue. This one is dirty and sells expired food. I was running late for work so figured I'd run inband grab a wrap quick for lunch since I didn't have time to make it at home. 5.99 for a small simple wrap is kind of pricey but I had to pay for my laziness so I bought it. I didn't even take a bite. The bottom of the wrap was so slimy, I open the wrap to see very gray roast beef, mushy tomatoes and hardened Swiss cheese that has turned a yellow color. I look at the sell by date, and it was yesterday. Who knows when it was even prepared since that date was included. Now I'm out 6 bucks, have no lunch and can't stop gagging from memories of the smell of the wrap. Buyer beware, premade foods not fresh. read more

Top Tomato - Sold padt sell by date, who knows when jt was actually prepared. Slimy wrap and roast beef had turned. - Grocery Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

Had food catered. It came late so food was cold when guests arrived. They didn't bring everything in the first trip. I paid for beef medalions but was given something else. read more

I started going to top tomato after many years of forgetting it is there. The side street sucks people park right past the corner to make it impossible to turn on and also parking lot sucks people just park like a free for all! Clientele are south shore people who aren't worried other people exist in the world. But anyway fish dept in the front is fair with prices and quality stuff. The veggies have good taste and the deli counter proletariat are good just need a better system of helping people. People order and just stand around and don't let you see inside the glass cases. Other than the people who shop there I have no complaints. read more

They are the worst. I bought crabs on Christmas Eve. The guy showed me a bigger size crabs from the back and told me it was $30 because it was bigger. I said okay. After I went home, and opened the bag the next day, found that they were all males, which means they are supposed to be cheaper because they have less meat than the females. Also, there were 2 guys and each one gave me a different price for the shrimp. One said $14 and the other said $10. They also charged me $6 extra for cleaning the fish without telling me. They are a lot more expensive than everyone else. I just went there because they were closer to my house. read more

I bought chopmeat for burgers yesterday.i brought it right home and put it in the fridge. I live 10 minutes away.Last night when I went to prepare it the meat reeked.It went right into the garbage and outside .Today I went back to the store with the receipt and the labels from both packages.The manager said no refund or store credit without the product.i tried to explain that the meat was rotten and I wouldn't put it in my car or keep it in my house but she wouldn't budge Top Tomato you just lost a long time customer over $20. read more

Bad service. Very very dirty. I catered an order from them they told me they couldn't deliver so I agreed to pick it up the next day. I went the next day they forgot the order. Way to go business people. Work in business myself. If any of my employees did that to a customer they'd be fired. So my reviews based on my experience A star is to one too many Cleanliness is sub par The appearance of the establishment and smells emanating from the place is offensive. A blessing in disguise I guess that my order wasn't completed. Will never go again. Definitely not top tomato. read more

I am beside myself during these times with the coronavirus how stupid and ignorant people are not keeping their space....This is why the virus is spreading....I just got home from Top Tomato on Page ave...Workers on the floor not spacing from each other and customers. Idiots...Especially, when I said to them in a nice way , 2 workers at the center of the floor...You guys are not spacing....They started laughing....Idiots...I told them you and people like you are the reason the virus is spreading...Keep laughing...See how funny it is if and when you get the virus. read more

Been in this store 2x last 2 wks & just today. Ppl behind register I guess make their own rules as to wearing a mask or not.. behind deli the same. I'm so tired of lack of mask or there improperly worn esp from ppl working in food stores.. for me this store has improved over the years but very disappointed now during this time where our lives & health r in jeopardy.. read more

I love this place, I go every other day for 10 years but the cashiers blatantly talk about the customers right in front of us like we're not even there. I've Seen this many times. Unfortunately it may be time to switch places. read more

I wish I could give that place a minus 1 because the catered food that I had at a party was TERRIBLE!!! We had pepper steak and the meat was chewy and I had to spit it out. If that wasn't bad enough the eggplant rollatini fell apart and was hard to scoop up as well and the mozzerella seemed old and was also hard to chew. Now let's get to the chicken cutlet 6ft hero....the chicken was dry and it had roasted peppers on it but if you blinked you would have missed it. Also, the bread was hard to chew and seemed a little stale. I was never a fan of their cooked food but this is probably the worst I have ever had from them. read more

This review is for their catering. I live a few neighborhoods away so I haven't gone grocery shopping in the store. Last month, my husband ordered half-trays of Penne a la Vodka, Eggplant Parmesan, Grilled Chicken and Vegetables, Roasted Potatoes, Mini Rice Balls, and the Caprese Salad platter for my graduation party. We had about 9 adults who were eating and it was more than enough food for everyone. There were plenty of leftovers which stayed fresh for days. I think the quality of the food is very good and the prices are reasonable. On the phone, the process could have been explained a little better. Overall, we were happy. We would definitely use Top Tomato in the future to cater another event. read more

Just out of sheer necessity I went here again last week....Apparently they're now tacking on a 3.95% purchase fee adjustment when you pay using a credit card? Pass their fees onto the customer? C'mon they're expensive enough....I'm done with them read more

Be careful when you use your debit or charge card. I had a bad experience where the cashier put my debit card in 2 times for my order. I got a double charge when I checked when I got home. When I called to let top tomato know, I had spoken to their billing person , they denied the charge and blamed the bank. It wasn't banks fault. The bank had checked and we're nice to reverse charge! Just Always Use Cash! read more

This store is horrible. I've ordered from this location twice and the staff is so disrespectful and nasty that I have no words. They messed up half of my first order and became angry when I asked them to fix it. Asked for a price for something and got screamed at because I had the audacity to question something. The second time I ordered- or should I say tried to the man kept writing down things I didn't say instead of what I asked for. When I was told there was a fee for curbside for a 5 item order (which was free up until now) I questioned why I hadn't been informed when I placed the order. They became increasingly nasty and told me I could shop elsewhere. Honestly, I'd never shop here again and I encourage you all to do the same. There's something to be said about kindness and human decency and this place has none. read more

Dirty disgusting produce. Bought Brocoli Rabe got it home it was full of worms. Gross.

Minus 1 star!! If you like expired food and rude cashiers that have a stick up there ass,this is the place to go. Eat and shop at your own risk. This is also an extremely dirty place and I think decayed bodies are in the back.Gives you an idea of what this place is like. There is stagnated water in the back that does not smell like channel NO.5 read more

Purchased chicken legs oct 7 with a sell by date of oct 10. Opened my fridge on oct 8 and it reeked. I called store and spoke with manager, no apology just says don't forget to bring in receipt. Not the first time I have had to return chicken and this will be the last time I will buy it there. read more

I don't understand why everyone is so miserable. Every time I have been in this store the cashiers never crack a smile or even say hi. You need to put a little effort into making your customers feel welcomed. read more

This place is gross, they advertise store made sausage on sale so any normal brain would think they have a surplus and its fresh, wrong, i got home cooked it, as its cooking it smelled real bad so i knew it was spoiled which makes me believe that they took the old rotted sausage and just re-wrapped it with a new sticker date to deceive the customer. Well I was deceived .we brought it back the next day for a refund but come on now, complete waste of time, money and gas traveling and natural gas cooking, total waste of my resources. Also the produce rots fast, i think they freeze it, the mangos look good on the outside but rotted on inside, I'm not going to any of their locations anymore. read more

TOP GARBAGE! RUDE RUDE RUDE CASHIERS... where is management??? Wait, what management??Keep that philosophy and your store will tank. Cashier was rude to an older woman before me ... ARGUING THAT SHE WAS RIGHT. Then they were extremely rude to me. Not to add that they cackle amongst themselves talking s--- about the clients. Never coming back. It was Sunday... only reason why I didn't go to management... not worth my time or energy . read more

Lost a customer over four cans of tomatoes. Drop your attitudes and clean up your acts. The girl at the register was so rude to my mom and elderly grandmother it's disgusting. Buy your cans of tomatoes else where. read more