I have been coming here for years , Jerry and all the boys in the deli and the butcher's always…read moretake very good care of me ! And the food is top notch ! No complaints

Dominant deli workers, however they make me and my wife feel safe. They always get our order…read morecorrect, and the food is amazing. I love their tuna salad, it's creamy, moist, and it has that Italian style aroma above your standard deli salads . I love their cutlets, and can't go wrong with a nice liverwurst sandwich. They don't get five stars because of the overpriced meats such as cutlets which are usually slimey, and the old lady cashier who does not make me and my wife feel safe. The macaroni salad is cheap and great, it's vinegary and TANGY- just how I like my salads. There is a little fella who walks around with an ear piece and he makes me feel safe. I like the new layout of the store.

Grocery store with a lot of Italian supplies. Meat and produce were relatively normally priced. A…read morefew deals for pasta, tomatoes, and other things. Minimal ethnic food supplies outside of Italian. A nice bakery in the back with different kinds of cakes and a lot of Italian cookies. Number of the boxes didn't actually have ingredients on the cookies and rolls, which makes it really hard to buy for people with allergies. Also, I have no idea how they sell any cereal as it was 7.50 a box...

Nicely stocked place with a good butcher selection. Fresh produce is abundant. Deli and Italian…read morespecialties are good as is the selection of prepared food. A good option in the area for Italian food

Supreme Italian Meats located at 645 Rossville Avenue has the absolute best meats available in…read moreStaten Island. The leg of lamb provided by Supreme for my family's Easter feast was the best I've Ever Had!! I highly recommend Supreme Italian for any and all of your meal preparations!!

Supreme Italian Market has made its way to Staten Island! This is the same family that had a…read morelocation in Bensonhurst Brooklyn on 86th Street and now offer up the same quality and selection in their new location. I stopped in recently for some veal and whatever goodies I'd see while browsing. They have everything you'd expect to find in an Italian deli/specialty store and then some. The place is immaculate and the prices are pretty standard for what they sell. The employees seem to be pretty friendly which is also a plus. The meat was tender, fresh, and cooked up perfectly. Really interested in checking out their prepared foods section next time or maybe even grabbing a hero. You got to stop in when you find yourself in Woodrow Plaza.

I've been ordering Italian sesame cookies for the last 40 years and I happen to come across Frank…read moreand Sals by mistake. When I called today to put in an order, Robert informed me that it was my 50th order and I could not believe it. Every order has been consistently great all the food is great. Robert is absolutely fantastic. You can't go wrong buying anything from Frank and Sals thank you guys so much.

I was looking online for fresh Italian bread from Arthur Avenue. I suspected that a delivery of…read moreauthentic, top quality Italian bread might bring a nostalgic smile from a NY-born-and-raised friend (recently moved to Hilton Head). Robert in the shipping department speedily filled the order and delivery instructions were followed perfectly. For days I had glowing reports of how bread and pizza alike were delicious and truly reminiscent of Arthur Avenue! Neighbors enjoyed the fresh bread too, and I just today heard that today's pizza rivaled the best NY pizza! My gratitude to Robert as well as Frank & Sal! Highest recommendations! Thank you!

sammy and his wife are the best! great food and greater people. best egg and cheese on the islandread more

When I'm not in NYC, I crave a proper bagel. When I crave a proper bagel, I can count on this…read moreunassuming joint to supply me the goods.

It's the absolute best meat market on Staten Island my family has been going there for many yearsread more

LOU Fanelli and family run this great butcher shop. Everything is fresh and made to order. Sausage…read morerings are spectacular, my kids love the pineapple and cherry "Hawaiian ring ". The brasciole are made to order and great, burger patty's are always perfectly made as are all the salads, rice balls and sides. You are going to spend a bit more as his prices are higher than some of the other Italian specialty stores but the individual service and fresh , prepared in front of you products makes it worth a few extra bucks.

It is good to find a halal butcher with such a nice selection of lamb. On the down side, you must…read morewait a long time for attention at the butchery even if no one else is there, which is frustrating. I think this is mostly if you are a woman. Cashiers are very nice. The grocery has some very good Turkish products. The bakery is average. Prices! This is an expensive market. For example, Cafe Najjar is $16.99 at Istanbul Grand Bazaar. This is more than twice as expensive as it is at Balady in Bay Ridge. I was shocked. For the prices alone I will shop elsewhere.

Amazing store! Great variety of products, fair prices. The meat section is superb. Impressed by the…read morequality and variety of meat. Lamb and steaks are excellent! Produce is great as well, large variety of cheeses. They sell goat milk, 20lb bags of flour. Their desserts are fantastic as well, large variety of Turkish delish. All in all, everything I need is there :) highly recommend.

Whenever I'm on Staten Island, I always stay at the Navy Lodge on Fort Wadsworth. This place is…read moreliterally just down the street, and I stop here at least once every time I'm on the island. It's just a good old-fashioned neighborhood deli/ market. Everybody is always friendly. The place gets busy, but you get through quick. I always get the same thing every time. My go to-is Two eggs on a roll, light mayo, a little bit of salt and pepper. It comes out perfect every time. The eggs are good, the roll is a little bit crusty, but not too soft or not too hard, they always get the mayo, salt and pepper just right. As of March 2025, they do have a very small "egg surcharge", but it's understandable. Even with that, the price is very reasonable. Especially for such good quality. Next time I'm on the island, I will be back. Thank you.

5 stars for their BECs…read more I've always driven by this place and I'm so glad I decided to try it out one weekend morning. I was really craving a bacon egg and cheese and wow, this place really delivered. (I haven't tried the other items from here but I will definitely return) I typically get a BEC on an everything bagel toasted, SPK (salt, pepper, ketchup) plus mayo. The bagel itself was great and the bacon was nice and crispy (they don't skimp on the bacon). $4 and you will be left happy and satisfied. Plus there's a parking lot!