Tony's 5 Star Transmission I brought my parents' 2010 Toyota Highlander in for a transmission drain and fill at 90,000 miles. It's been over two months since the service, and I can say from personal experience that the vehicle runs noticeably better. The gears shift smoothly and the drive feels more responsive overall. The team did a great job, and I had full confidence in their work. A few weeks later, I took my wife's 2012 Lexus IS250 in for the same transmission service. This time, Roger (pictured above) was the one who worked on the car. I drove it home and, anecdotally speaking, it felt incredibly smooth--no hesitation or slipping gears whatsoever. Two months later, it's still performing flawlessly. Misty, the manager, is the real heart of this shop. She not only runs a tight operation, but she also remembers customers by name and truly goes the extra mile to make people feel welcome and taken care of. While waiting for the Highlander to be serviced, I witnessed Misty and her team assist an elderly man who had previously gone to Walmart for a transmission issue. He was wrongly told to pour fluid into the radiator cap, which created a dangerous situation. He brought the car to Tony's, and Misty personally stepped in. Despite the mess, they helped him out without asking for a cent. That kind of kindness and integrity is rare in any business. Tony's 5 Star Transmission has earned my full trust. Between the quality work, knowledgeable staff, and genuine care for their customers, I wouldn't take our vehicles anywhere else for transmission service. read more

See all

If you are looking for a honest, caring and Christian based shop, it's Tony's 5 star transmission. I was scared before calling, they were honest after I was told that I may need a new transmission. Tony's diagnosed my vehicle found I was not in need of a new transmission. Thanks Tony's transmission you and Misty, you all were definitely a God send for me! Please yelp get the word out that jyou can definitely trust Tony's 5 star transmission can definitely be trusted! read more

I had a very disappointing experience with Tony's Transmission. After having my car serviced, it broke down again within a week. The issue was clearly not fixed, yet instead of standing behind their work, I was asked to pay even more money to address the same problem. There was no refund offered, and the level of service changed throughout the process, communication became poor and inconsistent once payment was involved. To make matters worse, when I walked in to pay the bill, the final amount had increased significantly without any written notice or prior approval, which felt extremely unprofessional and shady. The customer service was horrible, and the lack of transparency makes this shop very hard to trust. Between the poor-quality repair, surprise charges, and refusal to take responsibility, I would not recommend this business. Stay away. read more

Bad experience. Initial quote over the phone was for around $1100. When we went to pick up the Jeep they tried to say we agreed to 1600$. We had to argue with them for the rate they agreed to. Then within a week the transmission failed again. We decided to buy a car as a result. Be very careful for what they quote you over the phone and what they charge you in person. They were very rude when we told them their price was wrong and they agreed to go back down to $1100 dollars after a long and awkward period of arguing. Not fun. read more

From scheduling, to walking in, getting service done, and leaving, the staff and service was great! Manager Misty(?) was a delight to talk with about cars, work ethic, history of shop and/or just chit-chat. Technicians were friendly and respectful! I will refer my friends who need car and transmission service! read more

Just had them replace my motor mounts in my SUV. Wonderful experience every time! Highly recommend!

I was very impressed with the services I recieved here. I was referred by my regular mechanic as I had some good ol 8L90 problems on my Silverado. My transmission was overheating and they were able to get me back up and running. They never tried to upsell me and simply ensured I was back up and running properly. Great prices and great communication. Would highly reccoreccommend and I already have buddy going there soon. read more

Tony's actually came recommended from a friend. I was having transmission issues . I dropped my Tahoe off on a Tuesday. Got word back Wednesday that it needed rebuilt. Picked my Tahoe up on Friday. Everything was Great! Everything was running very well and Transmission was shifting smoothly. Better than it has in a while . The price was very Reasonable. Thank you! Very Happy With The Service!!! Would recommend!!! read more

I went to Tony's 5 Star Transmission with my Toyota Tundra in December 2023. I had some shifting problems with my automatic. They diagnosed it and determined the problems. With 225,000 miles on it they recommended rebuilding it. The parts and labor to repair was about 1/3 of what a full rebuild would have been so I had them do the repair, hoping it would fix the shifting issues. They told me up front that the valve body was suspect in the Tundras, so it was risky to do the repairs without replacing the valve body too. But that would have brought the cost up to almost the rebuild price. The repair was only partially successful, so they offered to go ahead and rebuild the transmission. That usually did not include the valve body but they found another transmission in the back that had a good valve body and replaced mine with that one and did the rebuild too. The total costs would have been $6500 due to removing the transmission each time and opening it back up. The owner stepped in and decided that was too much to charge me. We settled gladly to $4200 and still kept my 2 year warranty in place. It was incredibly fair and I was pleasantly surprised. It has been driving great ever since. Over the last couple of months, though, I have had this thump when starting from a stop. I was convinced it must be in the transmission. They worked for hours to determine this new problem. It ended up being the spline on the drive shaft lacking the proper lubrication. Tony came to my house to pick me up so I could drive it. (My wife was out of town and I had no way to get to the shop). He had me go drive it and said text me to let me know if it was fixed. I texted him, "yes it was great". Drove back to the shop to pay my bill and the sweet lady told me there was no charge. I was startled and started to argue with her that your guys had done work that was beyond what was expected in the free diagnostics. She said no and wished me a good day. I drove away very pleased but didn't feel good about leaving like that. I drove back and laid a $100 bill on the counter and said "take the crew to lunch". She said, "I can do that". Very pleased customer. They have any and all future transmission work of mine. Thanks Tony and crew, Brian read more

A little background, the transmission in the Inifinti Q50 fails like clockwork between 85K and 115K miles. I Initially, I took my Inifinti 2015 Q50 into a rival shop, who quoted me $5,700 to repair my transmission ($15,000 to replace it with a USED transmission). On a whim, I called Tony's as we were new to town and I knew no one. They were a pleasure to deal with and offered the intangible of honesty during all of my interactions. They were able to do the service required for under $1,000 saving me $4,700!!! The entire staff was exceptional to deal with and extremely honest. At the time was dealing with my Mother's failing health and trying to prepare for a trip back east, we had just relocated to Phoenix a few weeks prior. To say that life was presenting some challenges in a complete understatement. The dudes at Tony's worked tirelessly in getting my car repaired so that my wife and son would be safe while I addressed my mom's health back east. From Tony, Misty on down they are outstanding in my book and I would strongly recommend them. read more

My wife had a transmission light come on for a few minutes last week. We had heard of this place from a friend. She took it there to get it checked out. They did all the diagnostics and stated it is in great shape. For their time, no charge. Many places would charge a fee to simpend an hour running tests on your vehicle. They charged nothing. What they did was even more valuable for us. The technician noticed a sound in our differential. He stated it is the start of a problem. He then recommended us to a good, trustworthy place that specializes in differential repairs. This catch of an unrelated problem is good care from them. Some garages would have not mentioned the problem. We need more places like this. People who care to do the right thing. read more

Tony's Five Star Transmission - The business card from the shop. - Auto Repair Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

Arturo was very helpful and worked with me on a fair price for the transmission. They did a fantastic job. My car has been running great since. No sudden problems that weren't there after like other places I've been. read more

Had them rebuild my truck transmission lasted a year have had nothing but issues with it when you bring it back for them to look at it takes them a week to look at it would not recommend them read more

We were referred here by our mechanic after my daily driver started stalling. Bad news for me, it was the transmission. Right now buying a new car is not a wise move so we went with the option to fix. When we dropped off my car, the outside of the shop was packed. After talking to Tony, he let us know it would be a few days before he even looked at my car. A few days later, he called and gave us the option for a new transmission or a rebuild. We opted for the rebuild since our car is fairly new and low in miles. Again, he said it would be 2-3 weeks due to supply shortages which in my opinion is understandable. He called about 1.5 weeks later to let us know our car was finished. They did an excellent job and even gave us a warranty on their work. Had us come in about six week later for a follow up just to make sure everything was running smoothly. From start to finish we had very friendly service and they did an amazing job. Glad we found a trustworthy mechanic. read more

Definitely not recommended, service was nice at the beginning, but after 3 times my car broke down , they decided to start ignoring me even though I bought a warranty through them! read more

Tony's Five Star Transmission - Car leaked transmission oil after taking the car 3 times to the shop - Auto Repair Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

See all

Was referred to them by my mechanic. Took them 4 days to tell me what was wrong with my vehicle, and only after I had to cal them because they hadn't contacted me once. Was told it was not a transmission issue. To take my truck to dealership to reprogram some codes. My catalytic converter was stolen while my truck sat parked on their property. No video surveillance, no fence. When I spoke to the manager about what happened on their property and under their watch, he said he would call me to see how they could help me. All I wanted was for them to pay my deductible, as it happened on their property while my vehicle was in their possession. In the meantime I am out $500 for my insurance deductible to get my catalytic converter replaced. This business presents as a Christian business yet they did not even try to take responsibility or do right by the customer. I'll never take my vehicles to them again. read more

I called at least a half dozen transmission shops for an old 1985 classic vehicle that had a transmission slipping. All the other shops wanted to rebuild the transmission for a handsome sum. Tony's Five Star said they thought they knew what the problem was and it wouldn't cost much to fix. I took it in and they fixed it for a very reasonable price. Mind you they are a busy shop, but then again, I wouldn't want to deal with a shop that wasn't busy. It usually means there is a quality or customer service problem. I'd got back in heartbeat. Good honest folks. I also love their patriotic spirit in the lobby. read more

+. ABOVE AND BEYOND !!!! PD is the expert , the best , the top of his class in knowledge , integrity , communication , professionalism , explanation of services and above all - a GREAT human being. My wife's Escape needed a new or rebuilt transmission and Tony's Five Star delivered and delivered big ! We picked up the vehicle not only to find it running better than brand new - but we also found it fully detailed inside and out along with a full tank of gas and the tires and wheels shined. Nobody does service this way anymore - we are grateful and will always refer people we know and care about to Tony's. + Seriously , they should change their name to Tony's SIX Star Transmission! Call them !!! read more

I was originally refereed to Tony 5 Star from my normal mechanic...he stated that Transmission work is specialized and that Tony's Shop was the place that most mechanics in the greater NW area of the valley referred to Tony's because of their expertise and integrity. I experienced exceptional service from the start to finish..this began with the evaluation of my car.. to being provided with my options...I decided that I wanted Tony/PD to rebuild my transmission that was about 18 months ago (5/2021).My rebuilt transmission came with a Warranty that has been honored on some recent work.Let me close by stating this ....the work...the communication... the expertise its all there good old fashion service delivered with the right attitude.Tony has an amazing staff starting with PD who goes out of his way to make sure you are informed and being taken care. Thank you P.D. and staff read more

Got my transmission replaced and I was told it is under "warranty" but now I am having issues shifting in my vehicle and every time I call I get put on hold and call is left waiting... read more

I was referred here by another mechanic who spoke highly of this place. I read the reviews and it seemed people had wonderful things to say. I even called before going and explained the problems in detail, and the man on the phone was kind, calming and reassuring. So I was hopeful. That is not what I encountered when I arrived. The minute I walked in it seemed I was interrupting something important. I tried to answer questions about what was wrong with the car and kept getting interrupted and talked over. The car wasn't making the noise I was complaining about and because it wasn't, they were not going to be able to help me. Then as if forced, someone got into the car with me to drive it around to see if it would make the noise I was talking about. That should have been my cue to leave. It was an uncomfortable ride and by that time I'd given up thinking I was going to get any help. No one even offered to look under the hood. I don't know where that kind reassuring man was that I talked to on the phone, but he is not who I met when I arrived. Unfortunately I did not encounter the outstanding service everyone else raved about. Too bad after I drove all the way from Phoenix. Lesson learned. read more

Brought my truck to these guys in December of 2021 for a transmission range sensor replacement. Took a week or so for them to get my truck pulled into the bay to even look at it. Once it was "diagnosed and repaired" I was told that the new FORD range sensor that I provided from FORD that they installed didn't work either. I live close by so I drove by and saw my truck hasn't been moved at all so was curious as how they installed it without moving my truck from the side lot. Decided to say I needed to get into my truck for something and what do you know? The FORD oem part they said they installed but was inoperative was still sitting in the box on my passenger seat. Confronted the office and they said there was a miscommunication on which truck was mine and what work was done. Once they actually got my truck in the bay I was told my PCM wasn't communicating and their code reader couldn't recognize my truck. Got a new $510 PCM and had them install it. (They didn't secure it in with the bolts). Also had to show up on a Saturday to help their tech work on my truck. Got the truck back a few days later. Drove it for about 3-4 months and the range sensor failed again so I went back and tried to explain to them what was going on. There was a guy in there I hadn't seen before who instantly got defensive as soon as I tried to explain the history of the shop and my truck. Raised his voice and continued speaking over me and wouldn't let me talk or say a word. Very unprofessional. The manager PD came in and heard it all and intervened and got it settled down and ended up having them put another range sensor in under warranty. That part now failed. I decided to take my truck to the dealership rather than deal with tonys again. Dealership said that the range sensor has scratches and tool marks all over and appears to have been installed wrong which caused failure. Also ford said the PCM wasn't the correct one. I brought my stock PCM (that Tony's said was bad) to ford and they installed it back in my truck and said it works fine. So I had to pay FORD to reinstall my stock PCM in my truck and install a new range sensor along with fluid and shop materials for $2000. After paying Tony's close to $500 and buying a $510 PCM that is not needed or returnable. So is now a $510 paperweight. There is also damage to the transmission case where Tony's dug out the roll pin for the range sensor. read more

Tony's Five Star Transmission - Tool marks and damage to transmission case where pin goes to keep sensor in. - Auto Repair Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

See all

I took my f150 here to get my transmission rebuilt. Their customer service is great! But the work they do is very poor my transmission is kicking really hard when i slow down and speed up. I have took my truck to fix the problem, they kept my truck for a whole day and it does the same thing I also feel like I was over charged as well! Very unprofessional! read more

Great Shop did an excellent job. They were recommended by three different mechanics. They were thorough, the pricing was right. Instead of trying to up charge and give me something I didn't want or need they took the time and made sure that they did a thorough diagnosis. While I did take a few days to get the car done I know the only reason for that was they are that good. This is the first company that actually checked my Vin against possible recalls to make sure that I am safe. That was more than I ever asked for and absolutely has made me a customer for life. read more

Awful, I was referred to Tony's by my usual garage. They were honest and said that they do not do transmission repairs. I have used the referring garage for about 4 years and have found their service to be very good and reasonable. I was very very disappointed with Tony's five-star transmission. Immediately upon getting the referral to Tonys I called them to set up an appointment. No one picked up the phone but their message said to leave a message. I did leave a message stating that I was in need of a possible transmission repair. Nobody called me back that day. I thought ok, maybe they did not get the message? I called back again the next day. After another 24 hours, no response? I gave it a few days. No callback. Their website offers to book an appointment online with them. I did request an appointment online. Again no response after a few days? This is definitely not a company I want to do business with. Wow, if this is how they treat their prospective customers, who knows what they would do if they had my car? No one to talk to? read more

The service I received from Tony is greater than a 5 Star Rating! My car had to have the transmission removed to replace the rear engine seal. For whatever reason the new seal failed causing a small oil leak from the rear of the engine. Tony could not replace the seal again in a few days before I returned to Michigan for the summer. To honor his warranty, he agreed to reimburse me to have the work done in Michigan. I just received the warranty payment from Tony and I could not be more happy. read more

I found Tony's Five Star on Yelp. I'm so glad I did. I had a dealership that pulled a bait and switch on me. Telling me my Transmission was under warranty then trying to charge me a huge amount to fix it. I called and spoke with P.D. I can't say enough the lengths he went through to help me. He went as far as calling the dealership to find out why they were charging me more than a full rebuilt transmission to fix a small part. After his call the dealership changed their tune and my repair all of a sudden was covered under warranty. I have not even used Tony's Five Star but I would not take a vehicle anywhere else. read more

This was my first experience at this shop and I can't say enough good things about it. Art is the man he went above and beyond to help me with my transmission, he got me in and out. These guys made it hassle free and weren't wasting my time. I would highly recommend Tony's 5 Star Transmission to anyone that needs transmission work done! read more

not too happy,they took over 2 months to replace my floor shifter,when i got my truck back the transmission shakes,never did that before,they also left the floor of the truck dirty and with a new hole in carpet, losey work! read more

Tony's Five Star Transmission - Auto Repair Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

See all

2006 dodge ram 2500 had trans rebuilt in mid December aprox. 17,000 miles later same exact issue arose and had to get rebuilt again (was covered under warranty) and now 5 thousand miles later truck started throwing engine codes for the trans. seems like they have no clue how to build a transmission without screwing it up, and to top it all off if you call 45 minutes before closing they just put you on hold or ignore it all together WORST transmission shop by far since i can't do 0 stars i'll do 0/10 read more

My car was putting out weird codes and the auto shop I took it to said it was the transmission and recommended Tony's 5 star. They were very busy and I have an extra vehicle so they asked for a little extra time to fix it. No problem. They were also very friendly. When I got the call a found out it wasn't even the transmission, but instead a rodent had apparently nested in my car at some point a chewed some wires I was surprised and relieved that it was only going to be like $300 to fix it!! I was prepared to have to spend a few grand on the repair!! I was also pleased that they were going to fix it and didn't ask me to come pick it up to take it to an auto electric shop instead. I was very impressed with their integrity since I don't have a lot of faith in many auto shops and expect to get a little bit "screwed" by most of them. Like I said, they were very busy and I can understand why because they are an honest and busy shop. I won't hesitate to recommend or take my vehicles to them in the future. read more

Tell me good morning this is Doug Millard with a 2016 Colorado that you book that for the transmission shattering the Chevy dealer in my hometown where I bought it as replace transmission with a brand new one thank you very much for your information and diagnosis and hopefully I won't need your services but if I do I'll know where to tell everybody you were the best thank you read more

I was referred to Tony's five star transmission by our mechanic. Tony's is amazing! Our warranty on our car was about to expire in a matter of days, Tony's went above and beyond to contact our warranty company, document everything that was going on, they had exceptional communication to the warranty company and to us to keep us updated every step of the way. I feel truly blessed to have been referred to Tony's! Having to have repairs made on your car can be very very stressful, but dealing with Tony's it has been a true pleasure! I highly highly highly recommend Tony's Five Star Transmission! read more

Recommended by a different company when they found I had a transmission leak. Talking with them was comfortable, and they were upfront about having to take a while longer due to high volume. I was anxious they would end up holding on to my car longer than the quoted time, but they actually got it back to me a day early. They were good about honoring their quoted price, and while I'm normally skeptical of places I haven't been, I didn't feel taken advantage of at all (big plus because my demeanor honestly screams "naive," which is true). There was a slight issue following the repair, and they seemed sincere in offering what they could to help. If the repair holds up, I wouldn't hesitate to go back for any future problems. read more

They did excellent work on our Jeep and went out of their way to address our questions. Thank you P.D. and the rest of the crew at the shop.

Unlike most auto repair businesses, Tony's 5 Star Transmissions proved to be fair, thorough, and honest. P.D. shared that his top priority was to ensure that the customers were treated in a way he would want family to be treated. He offered both professional and friendly service to make dealing with an unfortunate car problem a bit easier to deal with. read more

So glad I went in & spoke to P.D. at Tony's 5 Star-after being quoted ridiculous prices elsewhere. The work was done in a timely manner, and my car runs great now! Thank you P.D. & crew! read more

An honest positive review: I had Tony's 5 star transmission rebuild my transmission from a wrecked 96 jeep cherokee to put in a new body/ build. From start to finish they made the process so easy and were very prompt with the rebuild. Unlike most i was actually interested in seeing it torn apart and they let me in the build room and ask any questions to fully understand what was being done. My 1996 Jeep Cherokee is ready to hit the trails thanks to everyone at Tony's 5 star! read more

I would like to take a minute and give you my review on Tony's 5 Star transmission. If I could give it 10 Stars I would do so. From the very beginning till the very end the service was above and beyond expectations. Petey was very helpful in explaining the process of rebuilding my transmission and the cost was below the quote that was given to me. After shopping around a bit, I decided to use their facility and have no regrets. They do excellent work and there's no hidden cost. I recommend these folks because of their experience, and their professionalism, and equally important honesty. Thank you Tony's five star transmission, I appreciate each and everyone of you! read more

Complete run-around after being referred by Gruelichs. Called like 5 times to make appointments and they were always busy. Finally told me they didn't have time. read more