We needed a restaurant half way between our house and our son's home. Tony's fit the bill. Little did we know how much we would enjoy our dinners. Not only that, but the staff was pleasant and helpful. We ate outside on their patio. After dinner Tony came over to make sure everything was satisfactory. We will be back to try some more of Tony's excellent Italian food. read more

Been hitting the town of Cranbury recently to just get out of Dodge and this place continues our streak of great choices. Blue walls creates a cool atmosphere (much welcomed on this hot day). The staff all seemed to rotate their responsibilities (like Trader Joe's) and all were proficient in their work. The lightly marinated vegetables which came with some bread (gratis) were a special treat and a surprising "welcome" to our meal. We shared the eggplant rollatini appetizer - delicious. I got the Branzino Limone and my husband got the Veal Donatello. Both were plate licking amazing. This is our new go to, and if you haven't been you need to go too!! read more

Tony’s Open Kitchen by Scotto - Italian Rum Cake. - Pizza Near Me - Cranbury, New Jersey

Tony's Open Kitchen by Scotto offers a wonderfully rich and extensive menu with something for everyone, including kids. As a food lover, I highly recommend it if you enjoy savory dishes, freshly prepared and served straight from the oven to your table. Be sure to check the specials--Tony and Carlo always have something delicious to share. I can't say enough about the quality of the food, the staff, and the welcoming atmosphere. read more

Everything wasn't perfect, but I'm giving this place a 4. The space is beautiful and open. A few TVs so you can keep up with what's going on, but not overly in your face. Staff were exceptional. Attentive but not overly so. Service was elevated better than you would expect from small pizza restaurant. Is it a pizza restaurant? I'd rather think it's a nice restaurant that offers pizza. They had me with the complementary marinated vegetables and bread basket. Everything was stellar. Eggplant Rollatini appetizer was just the way I like it. Chicken Parmesan was good not the best ever but very good. Nice fresh sauce. Linguine clams had a generous amount of fresh clam. The only disappointment of the night was the consistency of the carbonara. I always ask if they put cream in the carbonara, which is a sin. They said they did not, but the carbonara came out a too soupy for my taste. Maybe they added too much pasta water at the end I don't know, but that is my only ding on the night. I will definitely return. read more

- Service: Fast and friendly staff. - Ambiance: Spacious, nice, and clean. - Food: They have lunch special so if you want to save a bit, definitely check out their lunch menu! + They have the best calamari I've ever had. The portion is big and they included fried olives and pepper too! I have my calamari with pepper, salt, and lemon, so I cannot speak for their marinara sauce that comes with the dish. + They have a nice variety of pizza and pasta. I went with classic bolognese. The portion is huge and delicious. I took a peak at other table's pizzas and they look so good too. Would definitely come back for the pizzas and more pastas! Highly recommend anyone this restaurant if you ever visit Cranbury - a pretty historical town in Central Jersey. read more

See all

The food was great, but what really swayed my rating further upward was their stellar service. Our waitress (didn't catch her name but the check said Sasha!) was outstanding! My husband and I came in with our three littles to celebrate our anniversary - yes, it was absolute chaos but her calm demeanor and welcoming personality made our experience so much more enjoyable. Anyone with children knows how hard it can be but everyone was so accommodating!  For food, we were huge fans of the Contadina pizza - best artisan pie we've found in years! The rigatoni alla vodka was delicious - saucy just the way we like it! Our waitress brought out a huge tray with a display of desserts and there were an array of treats to choose from. .. truly something for every sweet lover.  We've added Tony's to our list of repeat restaurants! Can't wait to come back and try more off their extensive menu. read more

See all

Hit Tony's on the way home for takeout. Let me tell the Gnocchi Gorgonzola paired w/ a salad for 2 Perfection! That's a hard sauce to master. Thanks for making me dinner!!! read more

Tony’s Open Kitchen by Scotto - Ortolana pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cranbury, New Jersey

The open kitchen concept is the first thing you see when you walk in. Large space, relaxing outdoor dining area and personable, friendly staff and the owner, Tony is wonderful. The menu is extensive with everything from gourmet pizzas, appetizers, salads, entrees and delicious dessert tray! It is a BYO restaurant . First visit but definitely not our last. read more

I've gone here twice. The food is excellent. The Pizza's always spot on I always get the plane with the pep. The service is awesome. Everyone's happy, smiling and the atmosphere and ambiance is excellent. It's like a upscale sports club, but not so upscale. You feel uncomfortable. Period every age can go. There's 20 plus TVS and the food's great. You can't go wrong with the plain thin pie with some pep. And good people, it's very hard to find good restaurants with good people. And by positivity read more

Tony’s Open Kitchen by Scotto - The Ambiance Its Clean!! The customers and staff are enjoying themselves every tv has something if you want to watch something just ask! - Pizza Near Me - Cranbury, New Jersey

First, we were greeted and seated quickly, served water and the waitress took our orders after explaining food preparations and favorites. Before our food was served, the waitress Broussard a plate of very good marinated vegetables. The pasta carbonara and calamari were wonderful. The main courses were grilled salmon and chicken franchise were very good. No room for dessert though the dessert tray was inviting. Very good restaurant. Casual dress. Superb food. Prices were appropriate. Entree size was ok. Pasta portions and calamari were huge. Stuffed and happy. read more

Tony's Open Kitchen is a great Italian addition to the neighborhood. I recently went to dinner her with a group of 10. Everyone enjoyed their food. The pasta entrees were a hit and the Regolare Pizza was great (ohh.. that sauce). The service was fast and efficient. I ordered then eggplant parmigiana, which was awesome and a plentiful portion size. I liked the fact that it was not deep fried, but instead lightly battered and baked. The accompanying vegetables were all so flavorful and delicious. The complimentary bread was hot, fresh and tasty out of the oven. It's a BYOB, so that's a plus. I look forward to going back and trying some of the other entrees. Note: They charge 3% for using a credit card and will only do up to 3 credit cards per table. That created a bit of an issue with 10 people, since not everyone had cash on hand. read more

See all

Hey, just dined at Tony's open kitchen in Cranbury and the food was amazing as well as the service. The owner really knows how to make some traditional Italian food. I've ordered takeout from them many times, the food is always on point . Tonight I dine in and the service was exceptional. I want to thank Sophia our server for her friendly service, even though the restaurant was very busy. Great job! We will definitely be back. read more

I noticed this place when I searched Hot and New Restaurants on Yelp. We came for a family lunch and we all enjoyed it. The spacious and newly opened place was almost empty on a Saturday afternoon. There is even a patio when weather and crowds permit. We ordered 2 salads, a pie called a la Tony, and the baked zitis with sausage and meatballs. The salads were huge and well prepared, sorry no photos but the farro and veggie salad were both enjoyed. I concentrated on the pie, the ingredients were onion, garlic, mushroom and artichoke, I requested well done and was very happy with the results. This is grandma style and perfectly crisp on the entire bottom. I loved it. My uncle enjoyed his pasta dish, perhaps the meatballs more than the sausage. And they were a generous portion too. Customer service was friendly but unsure. I think some servers were new and were not at all familiar with the menu. There were a few hiccups but nothing major, and not in the food quality. I'd definitely return to try other items, but would likely order another pie. read more

Tony’s Open Kitchen by Scotto - A la Tony pie( requested well done, very good!) - Pizza Near Me - Cranbury, New Jersey

I have passed Tony's (Scotto's) many times and finally decided to try it with some friends. It's in a new strip mall and the outside entrance of the restaurant looks small but it's very open and spacious inside with ample outside dining. The open kitchen gives you a nice view into what's cooking and the entire staff are very welcoming. Once seated, they brought complimentary fresh focaccia with grilled eggplant- very tasty. We ordered pasta, chicken dish and pizza - all were freshly made with ample portions. Will come back to try more of the menu items and eat outside on a nice evening. We also enjoy the other Scotto's on Rt 33, which is very popular in the Monroe area. read more

Visited here a few times, had the Contessa pizza, by far the best pizza I've had in NJ since I moved here. The ambiance is very nice as well as the servers. read more

We enjoy eating at Tony's from the wait staff to the quality of the food. The dinners we've had are flavorful. Sometimes we go simple and inexpensive with a shared salad which is more than enough for two along with a personal pizza which again is enough for two. There is ample seating but on Friday's and Saturday's you may want to make a reservation. read more

I had chicken francese which was OK, not the best I ever had, Plenty of food in each portion. Ambience is a little strange in that it feels like you are eating dinner in an industrial warehouse, too open, not at all cozy. read more

Great family feeling. Informal yet classy. Excellent salads and menu choices were delicious. Staff is excellent and very welcoming. We went with a large group and there were no disappointments. Open kitchen and dining room is beautiful with all modern equipment and very clean appearance. Conveniently located. We will be back. read more

We have dined here multiple here, multiple times, as many as 10 people, and as few as 2. The service has always been good, and the food has been much better than many local restaurants. I have had meat dishes, pasta, pizza( their personal pizzas are great.) The owner is in kitchen, and circulates thru the dining room. For a local place, it is accommodating and consistent. We be back soon! read more

I feel horrible to have to write a bad review but felt it was needed. We went for business to this place and it was our first time, and sadly will be our last. Service was slow, and the waitress's seemed clueless on what to do. They didn't check on us to see if you needed anything or drink refils. In addition, the quality of the food wasn't enjoyed. If this is supposed to be an authentic italian restaurant, i am sorry, but you guys need to revisit your dishes and how they are prepared. The chicken was tough and chewy, with a horrible taste. The sauces were not good, and fell short of flavor compared to other italian places. Good luck~ read more

An underwhelming experience from the start, when we were told the kitchen was out of butter. For apps, we had the calamari, which did not have cherry peppers (as indicated on the menu) and mozzarella in carrozza for appetizers. Both were served significantly over cooked and under seasoned. For entrees I ate the veal piccata. Sauce wasn't bad, but it was a little gooey for my taste. I was also confused by the choice of vegetables served with the dish, as sweet potatoes did not complement. Dish just seems lazy. Vegetables were under seasoned. My husband got the veal parmigiana with penne. Pasta was over cooked and bland. Veal was cooked well. Everything was under seasoned. Servers never came over to check on our meal after serving. read more

See all

Food excellent. Service professional and friendly. Proprietor a gem. Ample space between tables.

We came here after receiving poor service at Zinna's. The food was excellent as was the customer service. The host, waitress and chefs were all professional, bt personable. Their main objective is to keep the customer happy. We brought friends (from Nashville) last week and again they delivered wonderfully! Thank you. They are busy because of word of mouth that it's a great restaurant with reasonable prices. read more

Food is great. Had the Halibut special tonight and it was amazing... We go once a week. Haven't had a bad meal there and have tried just about everything. We love the atmosphere and staff. So glad they opened here. Ellen & Joe M. read more

UPDATE: Our second trip to this restaurant and it did not disappoint. The fried calamari was spot on, and the Contessa white pizza was out of this world. The Contessa may have been the best pizza I've had since relocating to NJ. Julia our waitress was very pleasant, and Tony the owner was very cordial speaking with us at our table. Definitely recommend this restaurant. read more

Absolutely delicious food. Best gelatto we ever had here in the United States (tastes as good as what we had in Italy). Service was excellent. Coming again tomorrow evening. read more

Got the margherita pizza and it sadly did not look or taste like it. It was good cheese pizza tho. read more

Tony’s Open Kitchen by Scotto - Margherita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cranbury, New Jersey

We recently tried this restaurant and were both impressed. Our salads were fresh and plentiful. Our entrees (ravioli in pink sauce and linguine and clams) were absolutely delicious! We both had desserts even though we were full and were glad we did! We will be back! read more

Best chicken parm i've ever had in my whole life. The pizza is to die for also. I dream about the crust. Gessica is a wonderful server, she makes you feel like you're part of the family. 10/10 italian family restaurant. I love eating outside when the weather is nice! read more

A great place to get really good authentic food. Pasta is made fresh which is very rare to find in middlesex county. Great family atmosphere to grab something to eat and staff is extremely friendly. Really good place overall. Highly recommend anyone try this place if your in the area! read more

This was our second visit to Tony's. We decided to return to try the pizza even though our first visit there was very disappointing. There were 6 of us including 2 kids. We arrived and were seated right away in the relatively empty restaurant. The very pleasant server asked for drink orders (coke and water) and then described specials. We opened the beer we brought for two of us and then the server asked for our orders. We started to order pizza and she said " we don't have pizza today". They were short handed so no pizza. No sign on the door. Didn't tell us when we sat down. Didn't tell us when told us the specials. One entire side of the menu is pizza. We left having to leave opened beers. We will NOT return. They did not charge us for the 2 sodas we did order but small consolation. Went down the road to Cranbury pizza for less expensive pizza and salads. read more

The food was excellent. Nice size portions. Service was great. Can't wait to try the pizza next. read more

See all

Great Italian dish's byob. Try the veal piccata you won't be disappointed. Ask for daily specials.

Definitely a "must try." My daughter and I went there over July Fourth weekend. We were greeted, seated and served by Sophia who was fantastic and provided excellent service. We had the buratta app special which was delicious, my daughter had the ravioli which she couldn't stop raving about and I had the Branzino Acquapazza which came with a very nice sized filet and an incredible sauce. Can't wait to go back! read more

Very disappointed in the food. First we had a margarita pie as an appetizer the sauce tasted like tomato soup sauce. Then I ordered a special of salmon and mussels with the same tomato sauce. Half the mussels were not open the ones that were full of sand. My friends had eggplant rollatini that came out warm and dry with the same pizza sauce as my dish. As that wasn't the end after coming I was sitting on the bowl for two hours. read more

Food was perfect , pizza was amazing and for me to say that means a lot being from Brooklyn, and the owner tony was so nice he brought my kids out meatballs that they loved . Great service , really nice new interior all decorated with painting of Italy! Would definitely recommend 10/10 read more

See all

Finally, a restaurant where I feel like I am getting excellent value for my money. Food, service and atmosphere were wonderful. I had the Faro salad and one of the pasta dishes (garlic and olive oil) which they modified based on my request. The food was delicious and so well prepared I felt like I was in Italy. I would go back again and again. Ginny read more

Great food....lousy service The food was very good. However, the service was poor(and that's a complement). The server put her finger in a glass while filling it with water. I had to ask for bread and the appetizer dishes were never cleared.I'll go there NEVER AGAIN!!!! read more

Food was underwhelming. Maybe we caught them on an off night. Not interested in trying again

Lovely neighborhood BYOB Italian restaurant. Food was delicious and the service was excellent. Really liked the open kitchen concept.