Excellent Sicilian Pie featuring a generous helping of cheese and a crust that is both tasty and soft. Independent pizza joints in NJ are a local superpower not to be ignored. Another worthy addition to the pizza rotation. Five easy stars read more

The mozzarella sticks were crispy, golden, cheesy & fabulous. The ravioli alla pancini had a delectably creamy pink sauce. Perfectly delicious Italian lunch fare that really hit the spot! read more

Casa Rosaria's - Mozzarella Sticks - Italian Near Me - Plainsboro, New Jersey

See all

Feels like a mom and pop with delicious family recipes of pizza. Thin crust, rich flavors. Perfect for our day! Most of the drinks are bottle. read more

See all

This place is SO tasty and SO inexpensive. If you want some basic food for very little cost, this is the place. Oh and their menu is GARGANTUAN!!! You can please the whole family here and spend almost nothing!! read more

Clean and very friendly small place. Food was very good. You could blink and drive by it but don't!

Some co-workers ordered from here so I joined in I got the eggplant rollatini... it's a large portion that also comes with pasta and salad on side. It was pretty good Friends got ravolis with blush sauce and spinach and that was really good ... another got penne vodka with chicken ... he loved it. read more

See all

I ordered a Sicilian extra cheese pizza with pepperoni omg what a great pizza try it it's fantastic read more

Casa Rosaria's - Italian Near Me - Plainsboro, New Jersey

I should have listened to my reservations about a "Mexican/Italian" place. I ordered to go, but the inside of the restaurant is... quaint. I was hoping the "hole in the wall" place would translate into really good food, which often is the case. I ordered a shrimp and broccoli Alfredo and mozzarella sticks. The sticks were okay, but the watery marinara sauce wasn't. I tried dipping them In the "Alfredo", but as I soon discovered, it wasn't much better. The shrimp was shrimp. Not much flavor and overcooked. They just have run out of cream/milk and substituted sweetened condensed milk for the "Alfredo" sauce, because it was really sweet and not tasty at all. Surprisingly, the broccoli was awesome, and about the only thing I ate. read more

I've been living in Plainsboro for a little over 10 years, and realized that the staff at Casa Rosaria's has been the only one who consistently provided great customer service the entire time. Same friendly face at the counter and on the phone, same elderly man bussing tables and making deliveries, same warm and welcoming atmosphere, and even the menu hasn't changed much. You might almost think that my use of "same" implies boring or resistance to change with the times, but what I'm trying to convey is the familiarity and hospitality that most people hope to find at a local business in a small town. The charm is not something you'd get in one order, but something you nurture over time. Lunch specials, special dinners, coffee & dessert, pizza pies or slices-- whatever strikes your fancy, start somewhere-- and don't forget to BYOB! read more

See all

Moving to the area, I knew finding the perfect pizza was at the top of my list. After sampling several in the area, Casa Rosaria's was my last, and my only. Perfect, the owners are nice, small business owners and consistently deliver on time, perfectly melted pizza. Located in a "hole in the wall" corner, I knew I hit the pizza jackpot. Cheesy, crispy, cheesy:crust ratio - it's pizza perfection. The only place you should be ordering pizza if you live in the area read more

I love to visit my Mother in Plainsboro every chance I get to be in the Philly/Jersey area on business. Last night she was in the mood for Italian food and had received a circular from Casa Rosaria's in the mail, and wanted to try it out. And we had a great experience! We tried a slice each of the Brooklyn, Sausage, and Pepperoni pizza pies. The Brooklyn was square cut and the other two were thin-crusted ... each were big servings. The tossed salad is def big enough for two to share. And we also ordered the Linguini ala Rosaria. The pasta dish took a little while to prepare but we had plenty of pizza and salad as appetizers. And when the Linguini ala Rosaria was served it was a huge plate of pasta with mussels, clams, shrimp, and calamari! Too much to finish but it was delicious. The tomato-based red sauce was fantastic! The owner/chef has been there for 20 years ... and takes great pride in his service and menu. This is a "mom and pop" pizza and Italian shop ... well worth the visit and experience. read more

This place has many different food options for what you are craving! We ended up ordering the Cheese steak and Cannoli and they were very good. Our food was given at a reasonable time and the person who took our order was very kind. read more

Ordered off the online menu and there was a hiccup but thankfully the guy working the phones helped me out and still placed my order and was able to pickup and pay on site. Meatball entree was 10/10 would recommend again! The customer service was also 10/10 read more

Dropped in and ask owner to serve me whatever he recommended .... WOW! What a delicious special of flounder, golf ball size artichokes, capers and fresh herbs... my husband had clams and shrimp in white garlic sauce over angel hair pasta and the red garlic mussels ... This place rocks!!!! read more

I've only ordered delivery and here is my take: Food arrives FAST and HOT. i'm a creature of habit so I've ordered the same items over the past year... If I like it... then that's the only thing I get. LOL 5 out of 5 for the effort, speed & delivering the food hot. I'm never disappointed but it's sort of unfair comparing them to my Mom. Chicken Parm: 9 out of 10. [I ask for extra cheese on BOTH pieces of chicken, sauce is excellent] Eggplant Parm: 8 out of 10 Clams Casino: 8 out of 10. Chicken Francese: 8 out of 10 Stuffed Mushrooms: 8 out of 10 Hope this helps !! read more

Well, I have to admit that I was wrong about never coming back here! It's pretty close to where we live so we've been back a few times, and while it's not amazing, I do think it's better than my initial review suggested. The pizza was not bad at all - not super duper greasy, which was a nice surprise. My wife also loves their pasta with garlic and oil. Overall, we will probably be back at least one or two more times :) read more

Atmosphere - 5 Service - 5 Food - 5 Lemme tell you right now: the guys who manage this place, ring up your order, make your food, etc are awesome. They welcome you with a smile and freshly made pizza. I thought $18 for a large pie would be expensive, but I found myself ordering from them, again. The best part is that this restaurant defines small business; you give them your loyalty and consistency, and they'll hook you up with deals, a little extra food, or whatever. Nothing is better than walking into a restaurant and feeling like family. Definitely going to order more carry out pizza from here. read more

We decided to visit here tonight instead of our regular and we were pleasantly surprised. Service was friendly and flawless, pizza, onion rings and fries came out really good. Ignore the whiny reviews on here, seems like a bunch of privileged people who are too lazy to dine in or pick their own order up. We all know what happens with food when it sits while in transit. Definitely recommend here if you're looking for fresh food at a good price! read more

I just wanted to let you know we were very displeased with our experience tonight. We ordered 2 pizzas for delivery and it took 1.5 hours when we were told 30-45. The guy said they were $48 which is more than the cost on the menu but we were paying cash so couldn't do anything about it. When we finally got our pizza the toppings were wrong. Casa Rosario's was recommended by the courtyard Marriott but we will let them know they should reconsider doing that. read more

Good food and awesome service. They are open through this whole COVID pandemic and offer delivery. Truly grateful they stayed open to serve the community. Definitely order from them! read more

Stopped by here during my lunch break and got the Tuscany panini. It was so good and fresh and came out fast!!!

Starting this by saying I've only ordered take out so that's all I can speak on but it is always DELISH! I'm a sucker for their ravioli dishes, pizza, and pretty much any of their pastas with pink sauce. Delivery is always on time or early and the few times I've picked up it's been ready early. Definitely recommend them for takeout Italian comfort food at fair prices. read more

Given the current situation were living in I have supported all small businesses especially this one. It's very hidden so that many people are aware of this restaurant. They have a deal which is 2 large pies and a soda which is reasonable priced for us who don't have a job anymore but still want to treat the kids. I loved it and it got delivered pretty quick! Will be ordering again read more

I've been enjoying the pizza here for several years and for me it is the best in the area. I always call up and order to eat some there and take home the rest. Crust perfectly cooked, great amount of toppings. Best of all is the friendly greeting from the boss (who makes the pizzas) who has come to know me as a big fan. I've never had anything "off the menu" so can't speak to it, but I know this: you'll get good food sincerely prepared. P.S. Sometimes I opt for Papa's in Chambersburg, but I always come back here for what I consider "real" pizza. read more

Every time I called to check on my order, the person answering the phone hung up on me. Happened at least 5xs. Took an hour and a half to get my food when promised 45min. read more

Bad...just bad. I wish I could give it a half a star. They even have bad garlic bread...some kind of fake orange stuff on it. It's kind of hard to mess up garlic bread! The pasta fagioli consisted on broth, beans and pasta...it was bland and very boring. The eggplant parm was cold in the middle. And finally they didn't send the drink I ordered with the delivery driver. read more

I wouldn't disagree with reviewers saying this place might have the best pizza in the town of Plainsboro, which is a really small town by the way. We usually had a late dinner take out of medium or large pizza with chicken wings (around 20 bucks total). I think they are pretty good. The guys working there are pretty nice too. read more

Used to order pizza from here when I lived in Plainsboro, but tried it again while on a visit to the area. Pizza is solidly good, with decent toppings, good flavors. Very nice owner, great service, a small place, but offers delivery. Worth checking out. read more

Service is absolutely horrendous, as are the meatballs. We had the fried ravioli, which came out with our entrees after I specifically asked for it to be brought out before the entrees, it was sub-par. My boyfriend ordered the tortellini with vodka sauce, the tortellini was way under cooked, not al dente, but crunchy, the sauce was fine. My sister had the chicken parmigiana,which was your standard chicken parm. I had stuffed shells which were good and the horrendous meatballs which were more like mushballs. Our server as mentioned was awful, not present at all, and when given a coupon took $2 off our bill for what was supposed to be half off an entree. I pointed it out and she fixed it, we did not leave her a tip however, service was THAT bad. Also, beware, they charge for refills for soda. We will go back, but only for take out. read more

This place was close and I had a buy one get one half off coupon so I thought I'd give this it try. Ordered delivery and the food arrived fast and it was plentiful but lacked any real flavor. The chicken franchese was bland, no lemony taste. I couldn't even finish a piece of chicken. Such a waste! My husband's chicken parm was rubbery and his soup salty. Unfortunately, we won't be going back. read more

Casa Rosaria's - Chicken Franchese - Italian Near Me - Plainsboro, New Jersey

Terrible takeout experience with this place. Placed an order through Grub Hub at 4pm asking for it to be delivered by 6:30 and it never came. Called at 7:15 and was told they were really busy (it's a Wednesday! How busy can you be??) and it will be 15 minutes. Still nothing so I called again at 7:45 and now they're 1 minute away, 8pm my 2 large plain pies finally arrived. Never ordering from here again, 2nd occurrence this happened! read more

Omg best pizza and wings ever!!!! Marcelo the owner is just so nice and attentive. We called for a pick up and everything was in point: pizza perfect light in the sauce extra cheese and bacon I LOVE IT. Family run bussiness you get treated like a family and get huge portions I said that because my husband order a lasagna too. Thank you Casa Rosarias we will see you soon :) read more

This place is really convenient to where my parents live, so we typically go here to get pizza instead Papa John's, etc. My parents also love the fact that this place always has coupons, so you can count on getting a good deal. I haven't actually eaten in the restaurant or had any of their entrees - we always pick up pizza. They always have the food ready in a reasonable amount of time, and the pizza is pretty good (much better than those chains!). read more

The food is good and it's cheap. But the staff are not taking COVID seriously. Picked up my order and found the owner with his mask dangling from his ear. Patronize this restaurant at your own risk, I guess. read more

One word: Ew. I ordered delivery from here tonight and everything I got was just wrong. The garlic bread isn't baked and contains some weird orange sludge on the top, the seafood pasta contained mussel shells with literally no meat, and when I called to see if I could just get a simple pasta instead, the man who answered the phone told me it was my fault for ordering this food and there was nothing that he was going to do for me. Literally the worst. read more

The most horrible food I've ever eaten. Very oily chicken sandwich smelled very bad. The cesar salad was also not fresh. Don't waste your money here. read more

The business owner and the older man who delivers are lovely. It's the customer service and great prices that keep me around. Customer service like this is 1 in a million now a days. read more

I order from this place at least once a week from work in Princeton. I try to get something new every time, and I haven't been disappointed yet. No delivery fee, great staff, and when I was doing Keto, they were very accomodating. I wish I could give them 6 stars, haha. read more

Horrible! It might be good for pizza but nothing else. Every time I've gone there I've been disappointed. I ordered some garlic bread with my meal and it was so spicy i couldn't even eat it. Since when is garlic bread even spicy? Not even that but it took forever and we had to keep repeating our order because he just couldn't get it the first 3 times! read more

I'm considering this a hidden gem because I didn't find it till 8 months of living in the area. But hands down the best hot sandwich around! Will be ordering much more! read more