Tried Tomasino's Pizza in Orlando and it definitely gives that classic, no-frills New York-style pizza shop vibe. The pizza is the highlight big slices, crispy crust, and packed with flavor. You can tell they stick to that traditional style, and the portions are generous, so you won't leave hungry. They've got a solid menu too with calzones, pasta, subs, and garlic knots that are just as satisfying. What stood out to me is the atmosphere it feels like a true neighborhood spot. Family-owned energy, friendly staff, and that "welcome to the family" type of experience that makes it feel personal. It's not fancy, but that's the point. It's casual, comforting, and all about good food done right. Overall, if you're craving authentic, hearty Italian comfort food and classic NY-style pizza in Orlando, Tomasino's is a solid go-to. You can't go wrong with a nice pepperoni pizza! read more

I decided to drive out from Kissimmee to try this pizza. The last time I had Tomasino's pizza was when I was living in Winter Park. I had to find out whether the pizza was as good as I remembered it. We came in the afternoon on New Year's Eve, and it wasn't very busy. I only saw a few tables being served. We were seated immediately to peruse the menu. My party ordered an 18-inch cheese pizza, ten-piece chicken wings with mild sauce, a chicken Parmesan, and some garlic knots. The chicken wings were good. They were cooked well, hot, fresh, and crispy. The mild sauce is spicy, but manageable. The garlic knots were okay. It wouldn't be something I would have to get each time I came. The pizza was definitely the star of the show. We actually asked if two of the slices could have some sausage on them so my mom and I could share some of the pizza. She wanted to try it, but prefers sausage. The only downside was that our waiter was a little slow. He would pop up every once in a while to check on us. It also took him a while to return to our table after we placed our drink order, so we had to wait to order our main meal. Getting our check and some to-go boxes also took a bit of time. That is the only nitpicky thing I could point out. Otherwise, I'd definitely come back! read more

See all

This place was absolutely amazing! We stopped by after an event at Nona Adventure Park and discovered a true gem in the Lake Nona area. We actually found it by chance after the Mexican restaurant nearby was too crowded -- and I'm so glad it worked out that way! The pizza was incredible -- the crust was perfectly baked, and the flavor stayed with me for hours after. If you're in the area, you have to stop by. The service was exceptional, and our waiter, Jack, was incredibly friendly, knowledgeable, and clearly passionate about representing the brand. The ambiance was relaxed and inviting. I'm officially in love with Tomasino's Pizza! read more

See all

I generally like this restaurant I've never sat and I've always gotten pizza or apps to go, but they're like Dunkin, in that they're hit or miss. Generally speaking they're always hit on pizza, but the appetizers are just OK and then sometimes the appetizers are great. Never consistent that being said if you're just getting pizza amazing eat there if you get anything else good luck.. read more

Tomasino's Pizza - Curbside pickup - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

First time at Tomasino's Pizza!!! WOW, what a pizza restaurant! My wife and I were in the mood for some pizza on Friday night as we were in the Lake Nona area. We ordered 1/2 of Pepperoni and Mushroom and 1/2 Joe the distributor!!! The food was so good, that we said, next time we are in town, we will come have their delicious pizza. The Service was excellent. You can tell when a family own restaurant has people that care about their guest. They are friendly and attentive. The ambiance reminds me of a New York style restaurant. read more

Tomasino's Pizza - Yummy - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

By far the worst gluten free pizza I've ever had. Salad had huge chunks of the stem in it, not well prepped. Service was mediocre, hostess seemed annoyed we were there. Other than that ok read more

As Lake Nona locals, we usually dine at Piazza Italia, which never disappoints. We decided to give Tomasino's a try since it's closer to home and we saw a few mentions online, including on TikTok. Unfortunately, while the food itself was pretty good, the overall experience left a lot to be desired. The service was surprisingly poor. The place proudly touts "Welcome to the family" as a greeting, but if this is how they treat family, I'd hate to see how they treat strangers. There was no soap in the bathroom--seriously concerning, especially when you think about where the staff is washing their hands. I let one of the employees know, and she just shrugged it off. We ordered at the counter--one pizza, a draft beer, and a kid's pasta with marinara. The total came to $50, and we added a 15% tip, bringing it to $65. No issue tipping for good service, but what we experienced didn't merit it. We sat and waited, and the food arrived packed in to-go containers, even though we were clearly dining in. The beer came in a glass, but everything else felt like we were being rushed out. The server recognized the mistake, hesitated, then just walked away. No plates. No silverware. When I went to get some, I was met with attitude--as if I was inconveniencing them. We genuinely wanted to like this place. It's convenient, and the food isn't bad. But the lack of care, poor hospitality, and basic hygiene concerns make it hard to justify a return visit--especially when there are better options just down the road. read more

Tomasino's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

This place has been offering New York Style Pizza for 4 generations. It was started in 1925 in New City, and have turned Pizza making to an art form. We stopped here while on vacation in Orlando. We enjoyed the Buffet which included a combination of one appetizer, salads, the Garlic Knots with any three pastas or Entree's I had the Grilled Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo and my wife had Penne with Grilled Chicken and Pesto sauce. For our Entrees I had the Chicken Parmesan and my wife had the Eggplant Parmesan. We had the Tiramisu and Cannoli both for dessert which were excellent. We loved the ambiance of the old world feel and how welcomed we felt by the staff. Amazing atmosphere and staff. We will recommend this to all our friends and family that vacation here. read more

See all

I tried pizzas here 3-4 times , one time pizza was good then the dough was very mushy and soft so i chose well done pizza next two times and the peripheral dough came out hard and dry like a stone and pizza tasted stale----- never again. Average cost of large Pizza here is $34 compared to $21 in Pizzahut or Dominos. read more

Delicious food, amazing service! Thank you to Lincoln for creating an amazing atmosphere and ambiance for us to enjoy our family night out! read more

Tomasino's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Lake Mary location was excellent. Great service and food was great. Highly recommend. This coming from an Italian from New York.

I had a great experience here, and I want to give a huge shout-out to Lincoln. He's honestly one of the most dedicated and friendly people I've dealt with. You can tell he actually cares about doing a good job and making sure the customers are taken care of. He was super helpful and professional throughout the whole process. If you're coming by, definitely look for him--he's the guy who really keeps things running smooth! read more

Says they're open till 10 but you drive by 20 minutes before close closing, and they have all the chairs on the tables and look closed up

Pizza wasn't bad. My son asked for a Hawaiian and they didn't even heat up the toppings with the pizza. Kind a weird. Wings were decent and the pizza wasn't bad. If I'm in the area and hungry I might stop by read more

Tomasino's is located to the south of Narcoossee. It can get a bit busy at night so plan accordingly. The pies are extremely tasty (get the large size!). Overall a great experience! read more

This is low key a fantastic Italian/pizza joint. I thought their pizza was nice and crisp. Great sauce flavor and lots of options for toppings. It's also a pretty large pizza so you'll definitely have leftovers. Their buffalo wings were low key fantastic as well. Was not expecting it but I thought they were great. Nice and crispy, not doused with too much sauce. The girlfriend loved their garlic cheese knots and had gone several times after just for those. They were crispy on the outside, soft on the inside and buttery all over. She also got the penne Alfredo. She was hoping for a fettuccine but they didn't have it. Maybe you can ask for it though? Service was fast, and attentive. It's a smaller shop with more down to earth casual decorations. Great pizza place in the lake Nona area. Highly recommend! read more

See all

I would give this 4 stars but I ordered on door dash and I got the mac and cheese and the chicken parm. The mac and cheese was the best items when it came to flavor. The chicken parm was bland and my garlic knots were just knots.. no garlic. I tried to eat it but I just couldn't. Not sure if they specialize in great pizza ONLY but the chicken parm I wouldn't get again. The max and cheese was 10/10. Next time il try the pizza! read more

Tomasino's Pizza - Garlic Bread & Mamas Macaroni & Cheese - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

This is the second time coming here, it's a great place! It has a small parking area in front. Once you enter you are greeted by the waitress and then you can pick your seat. It has seating in the inside and outside. The inside is small, a couple of tables and booths, but very homey. The waitress was friendly and patient. I ordered the lunch specials-2 slices and a side Caesar salad ($10). We got the salad first- it was good. The pizza came a few min after, the slices are pretty big and it was delicious. Overall, will definitely come back! read more

See all

Jake's service was amazing. Very attentive and respectful young man. The food was 5 Stars!! The flavors were well developed and the handmade garlic knots are to die for! Started with some amazing mozzarella sticks.. overall a great experience!! Wish we had one back home. Family owned business that brought New York vibes.. A++ read more

When we arrived we were told to sit anywhere, so we decided to sit outside. The ambiance was really nice with the lights being on and the weather was cool so it was a pleasant experience. However, the tables outside were not clean and the chairs were not clean either. My moms jeans got dirty with something sticky from the chair because it wasn't cleaned. Ive been to Tomasino's in the past and tried their pizza. I remember the pizza being decent and the service being okay. This time around I tried their chicken parmigiana and it was definitely a let down. My parent's also ordered the same dish and agreed it wasn't very good. The tomato sauce tasted like it was out of a can and the chicken tasted really odd too. I did think the garlic knots were good as well as the fried mozzarella we ordered. The service was average, no wow factor. I guess you can call this place a hit or miss but I do not recommend their chicken parmigiana dish. read more

See all

Showed up before closing, but they turned me away saying they "didn't want to serve more people." Not out of food--just didn't feel like it. If you're going to close early, update your hours. Disappointing experience. Won't be back. read more

The food was amazing, we ordered the famous garlic knots with cheese and the mechanic pizza which was delicious!! We ordered a cheesecake for dessert and its one of the best I've found in Orlando. We had one of our best dining experiences ever with our server was Jake, who was helped by Mirella and they were fantastic! The food came out on time, they made sure our drinks were refilled, I would definitely recommend visiting Tomasinos, the family atmosphere was also great you can definitely bring the kids and grandkids!! read more

We came down here from Charlotte, NC to visit some friends. They ranged and raved about this place so why not try it out on Football Sunday? Let me tell you...omg. What didn't we order? Everyone kind of ordered something and we all tried each others between each other. We had... Bruchetta Knots Garlic Knots Cheese Knots Mac and Cheese Fries Bianca Pizza with Chicken Margaritas Pizza Bbq, Medium and Garlic Wings, extra crispy Calzone Caesar salad Spaghetti and meatballs Cheese pizza Penne pasta Cheese steak sub Hailey took awesome care of us, spot on with the food, great with the kids and just an overall amazing experience. Being from Buffalo, we all have high expectations with our wings...I would highly recommend this place for wings. Would be cool if they had a rewards program but Hailey explained they do a holiday special with card which is cool. Maybe a daily lunch special or a buy 5 slices get a free slice or something...just a suggestion, doubt they need it because the food is amazing...staff is awesome and the atmosphere is terrific. We will definitely return!!! read more

Tomasino's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Im from New Jersey and grew up around great pizza, so I'm pretty picky when it comes to pizza but this place was really good! The crust was thin and crispy, the sauce had great flavor, and the cheese was just right. It reminded me of the pizza I'd get back home. On top of that, the service was great too. Everyone was friendly and the food came out fast. It's not easy to find a spot that gets it right, but this one definitely did. I'll for sure be back read more

Good ny style pizza. The salad was huge and the cheeses garlic knots were doughy and good. Good option near the airport.

Really good food and really good service. The place is cute and has that pizza feeling that I really love. Our server was amazing, even as he was training others in the restaurant. He was nice and respectful, the other staff were too. 10/10 recommend. read more

Had an amazing experience at the Lake Nona(Narcoossee) location. Lily always gets my order down to the tee even with special instructions. She's always so friendly and happy to serve us with a smile on her face! The crew that cooks is absolutely phenomena! The taste stays consistent and always cooked perfectly to my liking! I HIGHLY RECOMMEND THIS LOCATION FOR AMAZING FOOD AND FRIENDLY SERVICE! Thank you again to the amazing staff at Tomasino's pizza! read more

We ordered out while in Lake Nona. We ordered through Yelp and the order was addressed quickly however it took some time to get processed. Our driver left Prior because taking too long and reassigned. When finally received everything was good. Only gave 4 stars because of how long it took. read more

Great pizza, service and ambience. We live I. the neighborhood and order food frequently from there. Always and excellent experience. Thank you!!! read more

The food was delicious !!! And Rosalina was a great waitress!!! Great service visiting from out of state would definitely go back .

The Lake Nona location is definitely the best Tomasino's location!! The outdoor seating is great for those not wanting to eat indoors. Food is excellent and they have Prosecco (not sure why, but I always want it when I'm having Italian food). Meatball sliders and mac n' cheese fries are ahhhhmmazing! read more

Tomasino's Pizza - Amazing meatball sliders - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

VG NYC STYLE PIZZA Tomasino Pizza in Lake Nona is the place to go for a NYC style pizza. The classic cheese pizza (18 inch $23 + extra cheese $2.59) has a thin chewy crust covered with a swirl of red sauce and a light layer of mozzarella. Sprinkle the slice with some dried oregano, parmesan and red pepper flakes, fold the slice and take a big bite! The extra cheese makes it doubly delicious! Tomasino's might not be for you if you prefer coal or wood fired oven pizzas that have crispy charred and bubbled crusts. read more

Wow! Delicious pizza! So they are NY style pizza, I am no means an expert on NY style but we do have lots of friends from there! It's thin crust. People are friendly inside and we got two pizza, butcher's pizza and ricotta be kidding me (recommended by our waitress), the meat was good but the white pizza was amazing!! So good!!! I think this is officially my favorite pizza. And it was even good cold the next morning! Best pizza in the area!!! read more

Tomasino's Pizza - Butchers pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

Love this restaurant, come here twice a week. Everyone is friendly and food is great. Shot out to our server Jake he is the best!!!

We heard great things about this place and recto see what it was all about. Located in Lake Nona we got there during an early Thursday evening. We went inside the restaurant and asked to sit outside. There was a good space outside to eat and everything was nice and clean. Our order was taken, large pepperoni pie and pizza fries. We didn't have to wait too long for our food. The food was good but there wasn't anything special about it. I felt I could have had better elsewhere but was paying for the atmosphere and location. I would come back but felt that I've eaten at better places. read more

See all

They have a great lunch special for two slices, salad, and a drink for under $10. The Caesar salad was really good, the croutons are huge, the pesto fries were amazing and really well seasoned. The pizza was fantastic I got the pepperoni and cheese. The atmosphere is interesting with bizarre photos of children, made me laugh. There is no wifi connection or cellular service. Overall good food, and even better lunch specials. read more

See all

The pizza is good. It's made with good ingredients, such as olive oil, unlike other places. I would rate this place higher if it was based solely on their pizza. Probably why they have a lot of take out. I highly recommend the pizza. We've eaten there several times now. The employees appear to be very young/inexperienced in customer service. Last visit we ordered a few slices of pizza and the bruschetta. The bread was cold, refrigerated cold. I mentioned it to the staff. We ate less than half a biscuit each. They said they would replace it. Never did, nor did they give a a discount. I never asked for a discount. I chalked it up to their inexperience. I will go back for the pizza. read more

Pizza was tasty! Just missing that extra NY crisp to it. Knots were the worst I ever had, cold and brick. Calzone was huge and good. Would try again. Restaurant was nice and intimate inside and service was ok. read more

See all

Hands down best pizza I've had in 20 years living in Orlando! It's like a gastronomic orgasm!! read more

The pizza is delicious. It's top three in Orlando for me. The restaurant isn't too big but they have an outdoor area that is nice on a cool night. I've had pasta and chicken parm which were not bad. They usually have a good selection of music playing and the wait staff is friendly and cool. I am thinking about the pesto pizza as I wrote this. If I'm on narcossee I'm definitely stopping in here. read more