What comes to mind about Jimmy's Auto Care is friendliness, reliability, and most importantly,…read morehonesty. I will never visit another car repair facility as long as I am alive.

Very unprofessional and nasty in there they have a girl now names Alyssa I believe she's very…read moreunprofessional very rude my car broke down on January 5th on a Monday could not find a tow until Friday morning so that day I got my car towed from where I live to Jim's auto care they called me within ten minutes after drop off & said they finished what was "supposedly" wrong with the car in ten minutes they told me "I had a bad starter" Not even two hours later the car breaks down again Friday afternoon January 9th. i call them the next day Saturday morning January 10 th 2026 to tell them the car is still doing what I said it was the first time JIM got on the phone and was being very rude saying "well I had find a way to get it there so he can see why " So I said why should I pay another tow 100 dollars when you guys clearly didn't do anything the first time to fix my car ? and charged me almost 500 dollars just for it to break down in the same day which was Friday afternoon they say "a bad starter" I called a tow told them bring it there this is now Saturday morning January 10th 2026 and Jim closed early on Saturday he didn't call me anything to tell me if my car was fixed yet or not on Saturday before he closed . so I had to wait all the way til Monday morning. I called Monday morning the girl Alyssa answers and immediately tell me "Jim said the car has been done but because I messed my own battery up by trying to start the car "when it cut off" I have to bring an additional 68 dollars or I can't have my car mind you I paid almost 500 already for a supposedly "bad starter" Jim gets on the phone & starts being extremely rude saying if I don't bring him 68 dollars because he had to put a battery in my car he would "put the old one battery in as well as the old starter and I would have to get it towed off his lot he then said if I bring credit card it'll be more so .because they don't like paying taxes so they rather cash but they put a lie on the receipt I then proceeded to walk to an atm get 68 dollars brought it to him and asked for receipts breaking down why I had to pay so much him and Alyssa started to say "he didn't charge for the battery he put it in my car for free . If that was the case why did I have to bring the 68 dollars ?? He was so rude and so was the girl Alyssa he gave me a receipt that says the starter was 196.70 so why was the whole thing almost 500 dollars my receipt says I paid 452 but that was also a lie. They are so unprofessional and I will NEVER RETURN back there EVER!!! He denied giving me a break down on why it was so much he says labor but there is no prof on my receipt that states labor was that much it says tax was 32 dollars they had my car a week just to say that . It breaks down again now they was mad and rude to me because they had to fix what it really was blamed me saying I messed up my own battery by trying to start the car they shop is 93 S Robinson avenue Newburgh ny 12550 I would never recommend they had my car blocked in telling me I had to wait for them to move it so unprofessional rude and distasteful. Highly say if you need ya car fixed do not go to them !

Excellent service!!! Honest, fast and thorough. Always goes above and beyond every time I'm…read morethere. Highly recommend Broadway Motors!

Very knowledgeable crew here at this shop. I always recommend them to everyone. Great service, fair…read moreprices.

Great if you need something cheap and fast. Terrible for your car and dishonest people. Went there…read morecuz my tire blew out on my all wheel drive vehicle. They had the tire I needed, showed me the tire, but when I went home I noticed a different tire on my car. This tire had a different pattern and different treading from my other 3 tires (which means it will mess up the all wheel drive on my car) when I called them, they tried to make it seem like I didnt know what I was talking about. I wanted to come back for the correct tire; They had it, then they djdnt, then the tire was fine, then it had something wrong with it. So they lied to my face like 5 times and tried to destroy my car hoping I wouldn't notice. And they keep saying "the brand doesn't matter" even though I'm telling them the tire is physically different in pattern and appearance not just brand. I needed something quick but now I'll be spending more money out of pocket to get the tire I need. If you don't know anything about cars, don't go to them. Or do all your research before hand cuz they will try to trick you

Do NOT take your car here! My wheel fell off less than 2 weeks after a brake/rotor repair…read more I brought my car in on June 6 for front brake pads and rotors. I returned on June 18 because something felt wrong, and was told it was fine. On June 22, while driving, my entire wheel came off, causing major damage to my vehicle. This was a terrifying and dangerous experience that could have seriously injured me or others. I went back expecting the shop to take accountability, but they refused to accept any responsibility. This kind of negligence is unacceptable. If you value your safety and your vehicle, please go somewhere else. I am pursuing this further through the proper legal channels.

Amazing service, super fast. we will be using for all of our future car needs. had no issuesread more

Where do I start? Edgar replaced the entire timing belt kit and did a CVT flush and fill on my…read moreSubaru Outback. He took his time and was attentive to detail as you may imagine on a job like this. Above all he did it with a smile! Definitely recommend his service for being reliable, honest and meticulous at what he does. If you need to get any work done don't pass up Moras Mobile!

Excellent! Found my new car repair shop. Kind and honest, looked at my car and topped off oil free…read moreof charge. After being ripped off as a woman in past by other shops, appreciated and trusted boyz repair shop.

Do you know that feeling when you are on the highway, far from home, and all of a sudden your car…read morestarts making a horrible shrieking sound? I hope you don't. It's a terrible feeling. But should you ever find yourself in such a spot, the answer is simple. Slow your roll. Exit the highway as soon as possible. Find a mechanic to patch you up and get you back on the road. Oh yeah, and pray to god it's not Saturday, since most reputable mechanics take their weekends off. Well, on a recent Saturday such a fate befell me and my poor Mazda5. The car is old, but in good repair. It's serviced regularly, and just recently got a clean bill of health. So that brain twisting screeching sound was really quite a mystery. Did I mention I know nothing about cars? Still, I pulled into a nearby Denny's to look under the hood to see if anything was clearly broken. I looked under the wheel well to see if some piece of metal snapped. And I saw nothing. So I hopped on the Yelp app and found that the Meineke next door was not just open, but also well reviewed. The team there saved my life. Not literally of course. As it turned out, my life was never in danger. But they were able to get my car on the lift, and take it out on road, all within about an hour of my showing up. They determined that it was nothing. Maybe it had been something. Whatever small piece of road debris had gotten into the wheel well, had apparently worked itself out. They could have told me something was wrong with the bushings. I could have been taken for hundreds of dollars at that moment. But instead, they sent me back on the road with a smile, and refused to take any money for their time. Sure, they didn't actually fix anything. But their trained eye gave me peace of mind. And that's worth a lot. Thank you random Meineke. You guys rock.

They saw me at the end of the day which was cool, but I came in for a tire that keeps going flat,…read morelow brake fluid, and worn pads/rotor. I ask if they found the hole in the tire and they tell me it's the TPM sensor and it's gonna be expensive to replace. I've been filling the tire up with air every 2 days for weeks. Either they didn't even look at my car or they don't know what their doing. If you don't got time at the end of the day to look at my car that's fine, but don't lie to my face. *Update* Went to another mechanic and they said I had a bad tire valve stem and replaced immediately.

Went in for a cut,shampoo and blow-dry. Used Lynn. She saw my hair was very thin, but when I was…read moredone,I looked spectacular!

From the owner: At Middletown Auto Repair, we pride ourselves on providing top-notch automotive repair and…read moremaintenance services in Middletown, NY. Our experienced and certified technicians are dedicated to ensuring your vehicle runs smoothly and safely. From routine oil changes and brake repairs to complex engine diagnostics, electrical, and transmission services, we handle it all with precision and care. Our state-of-the-art facility is equipped with the tools and technology to diagnose and fix any issues your car may have. We believe in transparent, honest service and offer competitive pricing to ensure you get the best value for your money. Whether you drive a domestic or foreign vehicle, our team is here to help you keep it in optimal condition. Choose Middletown Auto Repair for all your automotive needs and experience the difference quality service makes. Visit us today or schedule an appointment!

Great service done right the first time…read more Have been going there for oil changes, brakes and other repairs and have always been satisfied with the work. Highly recommend them.

considering I just went to this place and my oil indicator…read morelight just went on I think it is safe to say they do not put oil in my car - stay away!!!