started out great, I sent Tom to my sisters house (she lives 2 hours from me and her car broke down…read morein her driveway) to repair her car. Told him to address the thermostat hose, throttle housing and asked for an oil change as well. He had me buy the parts (great so far), we scheduled a day for him to make repairs. He showed up and changed the parts but couldnt get the car to stay on. He said the motor was probably blown or one of the pulleys were no good. And said the engine was smoking..Recommended to return and charge the battery and change the oil the following week. Unfortunately my sister paid him.... he said he would be back. I went to her house installed a new battery and an alternator. I sent Tom a video of the car working and just asked him to complete the oilchange since he was paid.. Tom agreed. Tom wont respond to texts or my calls. i have called and texted multiple times to give him the benefit of doubt before giving Tom this truthful and bad review. Dont waste yiur time with dishonest, misdiagnose and non standup Tom C mobile mechanic

On the day of service, the mechanic No/No Showed me. I sent multiple texts and heard nothing back.read more

We love John at Vails Gate Tire and Auto. They never do more work than needed and are fair with…read moretheir prices. John treats you like family. I was also very happy to see that when driving my car out they had put a seat protector so that nothing got on the seat. That's how it should be!

I had a very disappointing experience at Mavis Tire in New Windsor, NY, and I won't be returning…read more I made an 11:00 AM appointment on Friday, July 3 to repair a slow leak in my front right tire. A simple tire repair should not have taken 2 1/2 hours, yet that's exactly how long I was there. What I don't understand is why the technicians spent time opening my hood and inspecting mechanical components that had absolutely nothing to do with the reason I came in. I wasn't there for a vehicle inspection or maintenance--I was there to have a tire repaired. My tire should have been fixed promptly, especially since I had an appointment. To make matters worse, I was charged $43 to repair a tire with a nail in it. Most reputable tire shops charge around $20 for a standard plug-and-patch repair. The biggest disappointment came a week later when the tire started leaking again. I had to take my vehicle to another tire shop, where they repaired it correctly. While waiting, I also noticed that the customer experience left a lot to be desired. The restroom was dirty, the waiting room had uncomfortable chairs, and the television was broken, making an already lengthy wait even more unpleasant. So, after waiting 2 1/2 hours, paying what I consider an excessive price, sitting in an uncomfortable waiting room with a dirty restroom and broken TV, and then having to pay another shop to repair the same tire correctly, I have to ask: Why would I ever go back? Based on my experience, I cannot recommend this location.

The above negative reviews are totally off the mark. This a great great garage. No rip-offs…read moreguaranteed, and work done quickly and well, but Mrs. Levine has a quick and acid wit, and if you jerk her around she's going to jerk right back. She's a very funny lady and makes those Saturday waiting around repairs a delight. Her funny is so smart and subtle that I'm certain she's used to having most of her jokes go right over our heads. She has been a great help to us, and the times my daughter had little things go wrong with her clunker when she was in high school, they would sometimes fix them for next to nothing as a favor to a loyal customer (smart). The comment about not tackling complex jobs is also just silly. They build performance machines from the ground up for a hobby. They can handle anything. We found this place about 5 years ago. I'll never go anywhere else.

Best garage in New Windsor. Honest, & processional. They may not get you in right away- but that's…read morebecause they're popular and usually have a lot of work to do.

Don't be fooled by this being a repair center attached to a gas station. This is the best auto…read morerepair I have been to in the area. I went here on a Saturday around 11am (they close at 230p) and I was desperate for front brake pads. Instead of acting rude and unprofessional, like they did at Levines garage in vails gate when I called there, they (Carmine and Carmine) were very polite and professional and squeezed me in to get my brakes fixed. They ordered the parts and by 2pm I was on the road and my brakes are now better than ever and at a good price. This is where I will get my car fixed from now on and will never ever go to Levines garage again

From the owner: All mechanical repairs (no body work) We do everything and…read morewill match or beat any price Semi SYNTHETIC oil/filter change only 39.99

A&R has taken wonderful care of my car. The staff is always friendly, helpful, and willing to go…read morethe extra mile. I truly appreciate their excellent service and would highly recommend them. They always value the customers experience!

While my vehicle was at the shop, money was taken from it. I had dash camera footage that appeared…read moreto show a worker taking the money. I called the shop while the incident was happening, and shortly afterward, my dash camera was unplugged. I ultimately had to go to the shop in person to address the situation. When I spoke with the owner, Tony, I was extremely disappointed by how my concerns were handled. Rather than taking the situation seriously, he was dismissive and repeatedly denied that his employee had taken the money, even after I explained that I had video footage showing what happened. Tony told me that their protocol is to place any spare change they find inside a cup. I specifically explained that this was not done with my money, but he continued to deny that the employee had taken it. He also told me that, as part of their process when vacuuming a customer's vehicle, employees go through the glove compartment and center console. I find that extremely concerning. I don't understand why vacuuming a vehicle would require employees to go through a customer's personal belongings. At one point, Tony sarcastically asked me, "What do you want me to do, fire him?" He also said that I should have waited and allowed the situation to continue so we could see whether the employee was actually going to steal the money. I found that response completely unacceptable. I should not have to knowingly allow someone to take my belongings just to prove that something was wrong. Tony also stated that the security cameras inside the establishment have not worked in years. Given what happened, I found that extremely concerning. A business entrusted with customers' vehicles should have functioning security measures and should take reports of missing property seriously. What was most disappointing was the lack of accountability and the way my concerns were handled when I brought them directly to Tony. I can only speak to my own experience, but the combination of what I witnessed, the lack of functioning security cameras, and the explanation that employees routinely go through customers' glove compartments and center consoles has left me with serious concerns about leaving personal belongings in a vehicle at this establishment. Don't let this happen to you. Consider taking your business elsewhere.

Just wanted to take a minute to thank Jimmy's Auto Care out of Newburgh, NY, for helping us through…read morea sticky situation. As we traveled back from PA to RI, our car lost its brakes. Luckily we were able to get off the highway and to safety. We called Jimmy's and they were able to take our car in immediately. Not only was it ready the next morning, he stayed and fixed the car before closing, knowing we'd need it to travel home in the morning. Top notch customer service, fair pricing and just a really awesome experience. We made it home safely and couldn't be more grateful for the people of Newburgh, NY! ‍

Always fast, honest and reliable service. I get my inspections done here and I rarely ever have to…read morewait.

I have known sahr for 20 years now, back when he was fixing cars in driveways. He went to school…read morefor it and we both worked for toyota ar some point. I can honestly say he knows his stuff and now is teaching a younger generation a trade that is so important. I trust sahr and his team with my vehicles. Pas is a place where you can trust your getting a honest diagnosis and a trusted repair. All the employees are so nice and pleasant. From the receptionist to the mechanics you are treated as more than a customer, but like family. A nice clean enjoyable waiting room if you are waiting for your car and a dunking donuts across the street, its located in a great easy location. Whether its a normal repair, tires or if you are looking to add performance parts this is the place to go.

This shop is amazing. The staff is so courteous to everyone who comes in and welcomes them as a…read morecustomer.

My wife and I have been using star quality for years and are very pleased with its work. So, I was…read morevery surprised so see the negative reviews. Happy to say that has not been our experience.

PLEASE STAY Away !!!…read more This place is the biggest joke. I took my car in for an inspection and was given the runaround about why it couldn't pass, along with a long list of supposed issues that needed to be fixed. I left and had the car inspected elsewhere, where I was told there were no issues preventing it from passing and received my inspection sticker. Based on my experience, I would not recommend this place. The entire situation felt incredibly dishonest and like an attempt to sell me repairs I didn't need.

Had all four breaks and rotors replaced on my Mini Van in January of this year by Barry's…read moreautomotive. About two or three months in I noticed a shimmy in the steering when the breaks were applied while going downhill and +40 mph. During routine tire swap, asked mechanic to look at rotors. He said breaks were in good shape but rotors were warped and to take it back to mechanic that replaced them as most mechanics have a year plus warranty for defective parts. NOPE not here at Barry's Automotive in New Windsor, NY. The Lady running the shop said their warranty is 3 months. I checked called three other repair shops; two were yon year and one said 2 years.

Took my car to Barrys for an AC issue. Daniel was fast and fair. $200 for labor, repair (o rings…read morewere leaking) and Freon refill. Been an ice box ever since.