Food is always amazing. I always do carry out so I am not sure how the service is but they always seem very nice when the order is picked up. read more

Did not enjoy the food here. The sushi tasted funny and the hibachi dish I ordered. I could t finish because it wasn't good.

We were a little hesitant based on the appearance, but once we got inside and saw the restaurant was bursting at the seams with college students, we knew we'd found a new spot. I love the bento boxes and they have a great sushi menu. The ramen can be customized and they load it with protein. We've always had great service and it's such a treat to be able to get Japanese in Greencastle. read more

Tokyo Japanese - Sushi Bars Near Me - Greencastle, Indiana

See all

Every time we eat here it's delicious. We enjoy the staff & they're always on point & we usually don't want long for our food or drinks. I LOVE their sushi! It's always fresh & delicious! If you haven't tried it, you're missing out! read more

Tokyo Japanese - a man sitting at a table in a restaurant - Sushi Bars Near Me - Greencastle, Indiana

See all

Enjoyed their hibachi chicken and spicy salmon roll. Service was good and enjoyed the food! read more

We ordered delivery via door dash and it was overall disappointing. My friend liked her teriyaki salmon, but my udon noodles were very bland. The chicken with it was okay. The salad looked pretty close to going bad. Miso soup also wasn't great. The crab ragoon was good though. Maybe it's better earlier in the day :-( read more

When this restaurant first opened the food was a good American adaptation of Japanese food. I really enjoy good hibachi food. Originally the food was very flavorful. I need to be honest I do not eat the sushi or the ramen which looks like it might be pretty good. The last two times I have had the filet and shrimp hibachi dinner it has been really underwhelming. The meat and the shrimp had no flavor. None. I lived in Japan for three years so I have an idea of how Japanese food should taste. The people that work at the restaurant are very nice. However, the cook seems like he was pulled off the street in Naha, given 15 minutes of cooking instruction and was named chef. The intricate dedication to the craft of cooking true Japanese chefs display, is woefully missing. What started out as an excellent example of Japanese cuisine in rural Indiana has turned into a bland knock off playing off of the anticipation the Name Tokyo steakhouse implies. I really want this restaurant to be successful and I really want them to move toward higher quality Japanese cuisine. At least more flavorful. read more

I had been interested in coming here for a long time, yes I know it's a recycled Long John Silvers but you can't let that be a deciding factor. The decor and feel when you walk in was what you would expect, it was nice and I enjoyed just looking around the room. Service was very pleasant, it was a Monday so it was a bit slower but to be expected. The menu is very nice, decently priced, and accommodating to many, my wife has the chicken and shrimp hibachi dinner, I decided to try The Monster Roll. Both were fantastic, you could taste the freshness of both plates. I will definitely be back, I feel like I just discovered a hidden gem in Greencastle, IN. read more

This is the old long John silvers building. I wasn't really expecting much but wow, the food was amazing! The portions are huge and the prices are fair. Greencastle it lucky to have this place. I'll come here a lot. Highly recommended! I'll also post some pics. read more

See all

I moved to Greencastle a little over a year ago from Indy area and miss so many good food options, but Tokyo is one spot that makes that a little bit better! The food and service is always amazing. This ramen was so good and the pork was flavorful and tender! If you are thinking about going spicy go for it! It's just the right amount of heat without being insane. When I first drove past this place I passed it up since it's in an old Long John Silvers, but man am I glad I gave it another chance as the food is so authentic and super delicious. My other go to favs are there General Tso Shrimp and there sushi. read more

Tokyo Japanese - Spicy Miso Ramen w/ Pork - Sushi Bars Near Me - Greencastle, Indiana

The sushi is so good. Love the crabb salad and the poke bowls. Service is always good.

Great little hidden spot was surprisingly good sashimi. They have a wonderful selection of grilled food, teriyaki dinners, and sushi. Really hidden Jim . read more

Located in an old Long John Silvers, we were a little wary of rural sushi - but we had poke bowls. Everyone was able to customize their meal choosing protein, veggies and sauces. My favorite things in my bowl were the pickled veggies and tofu. I'm not a big sashimi fan and didn't order any but the rolls looked good. I liked my bowl and would eat here again. Sadly, I forgot to take any photos. read more

8 small Pieces of steak for lunch. Was very tough. Soup and salad were yuck. I will not be coming here again. read more

Good sushi in Greencastle! We are a family who all enjoy sushi. We ate here not expecting much (and I was already thinking about where we might go in Indy or Terre Haute next time). We got some General Tso, cal Imari and a few sushi rolls. The calimari was just ok. Not worth the appetizer $ and we'll pass next time. The Tso was very good. Much better than some local buffet, crisp, hot and great sauce. The sushi was the best part. We only had one specialty roll (Godzilla) along with some shrimp tempura and a few inexpensive rolls to keep the cost reasonable. We were not disappointed. The service was fast, accurate and friendly. We will definitely be back and highly recommend trying Tokyo if you love sushi! read more

Little pricy but always delicious. Really enjoy the atmosphere, even if it's an old repurposed Long John Silvers. Good service.

I will NO longer be driving to Avon or Plainfield to eat Japanese and sushi! This place is amazing. The sushi was so good and FRESH! The chicken teriyaki and rice was sooo good and flavorful and wasn't dried out! I will def keep coming back here read more

Tokyo Japanese - Crazy Spider Roll, aaamazing - Sushi Bars Near Me - Greencastle, Indiana

Tokyo is absolutely wonderful! You get an authentic Japanese experience in our small town at a great price. Staff are friendly and knowledgeable. Tokyo is great for a date night out or simply take-out. The wide variety of items will satisfy everyone. read more

We went for a family birthday. We ordered sashimi and rolls and others ordered ramen, teriyaki and udon, so we had pretty much the range of what they offer. It was all acceptable, but in no way delightful. The sashimi was limited to the Big 4 (salmon, maguro tuna, white tune and yellow tail). It was about what you'd get for grocery store sushi. Smallish pieces (but at same time, price was only $5, so it was fair), not particularly fresh or select, but what do you expect in a small Indiana town? The rolls were acceptable, but not more. The ramen was good, the udon was fair, the teriyaki was competent. Given the lack of any meaningful alternatives for a quality dining experience in Greencastle, we'll be back I suppose. But it feels like eating in a Howard Johnson. One unmitigated negative is the bathroom, it is in need of a thorough cleaning. read more

Don't go. They do t have a clue what they are doing. Ask for sushi and every time I get sashimi and that is nasty what a waste.

I've only had sushi here and it is the best sushi. I'm comparing to to Hirosaki, Tin House, Ichiban, and Kabutos. This place wins hand down. One time they did make me mad because I ordered the three sushi rolls lunch special but because I didn't specify it was a lunch special they charged me full price. I sent them a couple Facebook messages and they gave me a coupon to cover the difference. I never used the coupon but they did "rectify" the situation though I would have preferred the money go back on my card. Stopped going for a while after that but I've gone recently and have had nothing but great experiences. read more

Great food, funky vibe, lovely staff. The sushi is exemplary, the Hibachi a bit of a monochrome flavor, but still tasty.

The jalapeño and crab poppers were great the sushi was ok will be going back to try other menu items soon. read more

Tokyo Japanese - Sushi Bars Near Me - Greencastle, Indiana

I'm not a Japanese connoisseur, but I had filet and vegetable diner. My wife had teriyaki chicken with California rolls. My plate was very good. Not a lot of steak to be had in it though. Her California rolls were excellent but the chicken was all dark meat. The steak was good but not much of it. Some items were good enough that we may try it again. read more

The service is very friendly and the food is delicious.The environment is good, everyone come try it, very nice place. read more

Tokyo Japanese - Shrimp Tempura Roll is very good - Sushi Bars Near Me - Greencastle, Indiana

See all

My boyfriend and I came in for lunch. We ordered an appetizer that we had ordered before and it was nasty this time. We told our server and she refused to take it off of our bill. A few bites into my fried rice I found a hair in my food. The waitress put her fingers in my food and told me that the hair didn't come from them. Again they refused to do anything about it. We used to come here once a week for lunch but after this experience we won't be back & I will be sure to tell anyone who asks to not go. Drive to Narita in Plainfield. read more

Great sushi and great service. First time here, didn't know what to expect. Definitely pleasantly surprised. Anyone wanting sushi or sashimi I recommend to stop by. read more

Absolutely amazing food!! Great portions and they get your food quickly. Sushi is phenomenal and everything I've had was perfect. For being the only real Asian food restaurant in town, they knocked it out of the park. read more

Tried it for the first time this evening. Very surprised. Food was very good. Chicken was very tender, just wished there were more veggies. Next time, I'll order just the veggies and pick the meat off my husband's plate. read more

If you enjoy sushi, PLEASE avoid this place. The sushi tasted like it was spoiled. When our waitress asked how everything was, I expressed to her how the fish tasted off and she chose to argue with me instead. Upon receiving my bill, I was charged for the roll. I was not offered to have my order swapped out for something else or refunded for that matter. Extremely poor food and customer service. And after looking at the reviews I'm positive they are using bots to improve their ratings on Google. read more

The portions are good sized, the sushi is good! They use to much fish sauce in the miso soup, the salad is just lettuce that has ginger dressing that is thinned to much with water. Service is always good, they are a fairly new restaurant and just need to tweak a few things!!! read more

We are so lucky to have good sushi in Greencastle. My family and I really love this place. Highly recommend this hidden gem!