The Barbacoa Melt is my go-to and it's delicious every. single. time. It's braised beef with chimichurri, pickled onions, and cotija and jack cheeses. It comes with regular fries or truffle - both are delicious, but go with the truffle if you like it. I appreciate that, when ordering in UberEats, they have options to remove the fries and beverage, and it decreases your total. I don't think I've seen that before. I've never been inside the restaurant, so I can't provide feedback on the service or ambiance. What I can say is that my order is always correct and delicious. read more

Toasted - UCF Area - Barbacoa Melt - Burgers Near Me - Orlando, Florida

This place rocks!! Menu is simple enough for you to make a decision, and everything is unique and good!!! Fast service and clean place. read more

Toasted - UCF Area - This place rocks!!! - Burgers Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Tried Toasted near UCF with my daughter, and overall it was a solid experience with a few hits and misses. I had the shredded beef grilled cheese, which was pretty good--especially with the grilled onions--but I wish it had a bit more flavor overall. The tomato soup was a nice touch and paired really well with the sandwich. My daughter ordered the cheeseburger but wasn't a fan of the bread, saying it was a bit tough. However, we both agreed the truffle fries were a win! Perfectly crisp and topped with fresh rosemary, which really elevated the flavor. Service was fine, and the vibe was chill. I'd come back to try something else on the menu! read more

See all

Oh toasted! I love you so much. I've been going since 2018 and 95% of the time, my food is spectacular. Occasionally, the sandwich or fries will be a bit too cooked, but the consistency overall matters and usually, it's amazing. The cheeses are always spectacular. My favorite fry is shoestring so I love their fries! I've also taken a friend who can't eat dairy and he was so happy to have a unique item alongside me without suffering. It won't take you long at all to order. The decor is very cheese heavy, including cheese grater lights and a massive periodic table of cheeses. It's all adorable. If you're a cheese fiend like me: you MUST GO read more

The staff here was nice and the service was very fast. We ate inside, it's a very casual setting. I have heard of people studying here before. I got the fig and goat grilled cheese. The flavors were very good, it was a nice balance of sweet from the figs and honey and savory from the goat cheese and the flavor of basil fit in there quite well. However, for an $8 grilled cheese, I was surprised it was not a bit heftier. I also did a side of the tomato soup. Know that they have the tangier, more acidic type of tomato soup. This is just a general preference, but I prefer tomato soup with some cream or sweetness. My partner did the brisket grilled cheese. He loved the cheese it came with, did say the brisket was just okay. read more

Toasted - UCF Area - Fig & Goat Grilled Cheese - Burgers Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

The cutest grilled cheese gourmet sandwich place alive! They have a periodic table of cheese on the wall, everything is themed out. Our sandwiches came quick and they were super tasty. We had a Mac attack sandwich and the 101. The guy taking our order was friendly and helpful. We will be back!! read more

See all

lauren is so great. all grilled cheese me and my best friend tried were absolutely fantastic. service was quick and soup was also yummy. we got the tomato. for grilled cheese, we got the birria (so unique and flavorful if you like birria this is a must try) and the classic american!!!! Soooo good if you're in the orlando area check em out read more

I've heard of this place from others and had to try it out. I love grilled cheese sandwiches and the concept of this place is great. Their sandwich ideas are yummy and it seems to be moderately priced. However, they seem to be struggling with finding a good cook. Hubby and I tried 3 different sandwiches and they were all burnt. The outside shouldn't have any black on it. Honestly, if the sandwiches were cooked the right amount then I think I would have given them 5 stars. Should have gotten photos of the other ones. The girl at the front was patient with us trying to figure out which ones we wanted to try and she gave us her recommendations. What was in the sandwiches was good, it was just offset by the overly cooked bread. I'll probably try this place again in the hopes that they have improved their cooking timing. read more

Food is great, service is quick and polite, and menu has great variety. Environment was quiet and well decorated, and I haven't had a dish there that I didn't like. read more

Awesome burgers, crunchy fries, very pleasant and fast service, clean bathrooms. Very nice experience

Nice spot. Fun. Different. I stopped in for lunch recently. I have never been a grilled cheese devotee, so this was a hard sell from the start. Wry clean. Helpful, pleasant staff. Good food. Just not spectacular. I would try it again for sure. read more

See all

The service was spot on. The food was fresh and well prepared and tasted very good. I will be back read more

Toasted - UCF Area - Brisket grilled cheese and Tomato soup. - Burgers Near Me - Orlando, Florida

A simple order - gluten free chicken pesto with no cheese - somehow came with not one but two pieces of cheese. I sadly did not get lunch as I had no time to come back. Restaurant seemed unapologetic. read more

Toasted - UCF Area - Ordered no cheese and got 2 pieces - Burgers Near Me - Orlando, Florida

First time visit with my daughter. Huge variety on the menu! Staff were friendly. Food came fresh and hot! Yummy lunch option!

I love a grilled cheese and after a 2.5 drive I as running low on fuel (for me, not my car!). I saw Toasted from the road and decided to give it a try. I got the Mac Attack and oh my cheese was it good. Mac n' cheese + bacon + more cheese is always a good idea in my book! Toasted also had quite a few burger options, along with French fries and a few salads. Clean space and cute cheese themed interior. The person working the counter was friendly as was the person who brought out my food. Give it a try if in the area! read more

Toasted - UCF Area - Mac daddy - Burgers Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Toasted has amazing sandwiches. It is one of my go-to's for lunch near the UCF campus. My favorite two sandwiches are the braised brisket sandwich and the buffalo chicken sandwich. I get both on gluten free bread. The sandwiches come with a good amount of meat and with cheese and sauce. They are very flavorful and always toasted. The staff is friendly and makes the food efficiently. They also have a separate gluten free menu for those with allergies which is great. They have a vegan menu as well and an allergy guide. I can't wait to go back:) read more

See all

LOVED this place for a nice Saturday lunch. We had such a great staff member give us some good recommendations and our food came out quickly and was delicious. I got the Truffle Melt and added pickles (read: MUST add pickles), and we also got the Mac Attack. Both were fantastic! Perfect amount of cheese and bread toasted just right. Toasted does balance really well. Stop in when you're around the UCF area for some nice quality grilled cheese! read more

Toasted - UCF Area - Truffle Melt - Burgers Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

As a college student I would probably be in love with this "fancy" grilled cheese shop but as a sober adult it was just okay. I had the pesto chicken and the grilled cheese part of the sandwich was fine but the chicken tasted like a frozen piece of chewy meat. My wife had the brisket grilled cheese and it was much better. If you're getting a side of tomato soup for dipping go with the larger size because dipper size is really small. read more

I recently tried the UCF Toasted location for the first time. It was my second visit to a Toasted. My boyfriend's taste buds are much like a kids taste buds. He loves a good grilled cheese. He ordered the grilled cheese than came with macaroni. Again, macaroni... every "kid" loves it. He said it was delicious and it looked tasty. We shared a side of their salted fries which were very good. The food was tasty and the service was great. However, I personally feel that spending a little over $20 for 2 grilled cheese sandwiches and a side of salted fries is a little pricier than I would prefer to pay. Maybe I don't have that "kid" in me. read more

Toasted - UCF Area - Salted fries - Burgers Near Me - Orlando, Florida

As a UCF student it's one of my go-to spots with the ZUPP deal. the food just hits every time. Service is quick. Cute inside with a cheese wall. read more

So I've been to toasted before when I first moved in the area; I got the vegan roasted veggie grilled cheese and fries but don't remember it much. Today I got the vegan bella and truffle fries.....I LOVED the truffle fries. I ordered with DoorDash and it wouldn't let me change the patty to impossible so I got their vegan patty, which has a nice taste but I don't like the chucks of veggies or that it falls apart. The cheese taste good but don't like the fact it's liquid like cheese sauce instead of a slice on the hamburger....obviously makes since in a grilled cheese though lol over all I'll definitely go back to try more of their vegan options since the prices aren't that bad :) read more

I just want to start by saying I really wanted to like this place.. I got the Buffalo chicken grilled cheese, which had a good flavor but the chicken was a little on the tough side and made biting a piece off difficult. It would probably benefit from a slow cooker to really get it to fall apart. The bread was simple white bread, toasted very nicely and the cheese had a good flavor. And that was it. The plate it came out looked so empty. Not really big enough for a full satisfying meal. If they threw a handful of chips or fries on the plate I'd prob bump it up to 4/5 stars.. The staff were very nice and offered recommendations when asked. The establishment was very neat and clean. Not too busy at noon. Sorry but $10 will get you a lot further next door at Lazymoon. read more

Toasted - UCF Area - Keep in mind I'm not showing half the empty plate.. - Burgers Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Although the environment and interior was really nice and ambient, the food was below average. I got the braised brisket grilled cheese. It was very dry, didn't have much taste to it, and was over priced. if they put some seasoning on it, it probably would've been okay. $8 for a grilled sandwich, no sides or drinks, was not worth it. Service was okay. There was only worker but he was kind and helpful. read more

Great sandwich shop! The idea behind Toasted is that it is all grilled cheese sandwiches....but not just plain old grilled cheese. Lots of variations on the grilled cheese. There's Brett's much only 2 sections to the menu. Grilled cheese....& burgers (sure there is a "sides" Menu......but it's minimal at best). At its heart, it's a grilled cheese sandwich shop. This was my second trip here and it was tasty. The restaurant has a unique vibe....there is seating area and a walk up counter to order.....all the kitchen magic is out of sight.....which is fine.....nothing glamorous abt making grilled cheese. You order at the counter, are given a table card, then go find a seat.....they bring it out to you. I ordered the Barbacoa grilled cheese. Mixed cheeses, beef, mixed up with a rather nice blend. It walked the line between sweet and savory. This was an excellent choice. My lunch mate ordered the buffalo chicken and he said he enjoyed it. Here's my one gripe with this place......NEED SOME MORE SIDES! I really feel like the meal Is incomplete with out something with it. They do offer fries, Mac/cheese, & tomato soup ......which admittedly are traditional sides for a grilled cheese.....but there is nothing "wow" abt the side options. The "right" side pairing could easily transform this demo an good place.....that a great place! read more

Toasted - UCF Area - Barbacoa Grilled Cheese - Burgers Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

These are my favoriteeeee the truffle grilled cheese is the only grilled cheese I will pay for outside of making it on my own, it is to die for. Servers are always super helpful. Wish this place got more people it's often pretty empty when I have visited. read more

I ordered a big grill cheese with "5 different cheeses " allegedly. It was the smallest sandwich. I was literally so disappointed from first sight to last bite. I will never eat there again and I will never recommend anyone to go there. Extremely disappointing. Honestly whoever runs that store should be ashamed of themselves. read more

I was recommended this place by other vegans, and I was not disappointed! I ordered the Vegan Fireball, which has vegan cheddar cheese, tomato, jalapeño, & Sriracha on the most perfectly toasted bread. The cheese was ooey & gooey. The tomato & jalapeño added a nice, freshness to the sandwich. Although, I would've preferred the jalapeño was diced instead of sliced, so it was distributed throughout the sandwich more evenly. The Sriracha was the icing on the cake. Between the jalapeño & Sriracha, my nose was running and my eyes were watering. It was a heavenly, spicy dream. My sister ordered the Pesto Chicken, which has dairy mozzarella, pulled chicken, pesto, tomato chutney, & arugula. She loved her sandwich, and was even eyeballing mine. We also shared a basket of french fries, which reminds me of Steak N Shake fries. They're skinny-cut, crispy fries. Nothing special, but good, traditional fries! The service was great. The cashier/waitress was friendly. The food came out hot and quick. The atmosphere is laid back and casual. This place is perfect for those looking for a quick, cheap meal. We left happy & full of delicious food. Toasted is a new favorite of ours. We will definitely be back! read more

Toasted - UCF Area - Burgers Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

This place came highly recommended so I was excited to try it. I tried the Turkey burger sandwich. GAG CITY!! They seriously warmed up a frozen Turkey Patty in the microwave and put it between to Slices of bread. So gross. Never again. read more

I love cheese! And I've always been one of those people that swaps regular cheese for mac&cheese any day, just to try it - like on Shepard's pie, pizza, or in this case, grilled cheeses! I got the Mac Attack, but my friends also tried the sweet heat burger and truffle fries. All of it came out fast and was great quality. We will definitely be coming back! read more

See all

Great lunch. I had their SLICE sandwich which was a m w at pizza between toast topped with pepperoni and more cheese. My family also had their pull pork mac and cheese sandwich. Very rich and filling. We all shared a side of rosemary truffle fries. Good food, good quick service. read more

Toasted - UCF Area - Periodic table of cheese - Burgers Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Great service and food! Love the vegan options! Food is absolutely delicious and everyone I ever took loved everything they got!

Grilled cheese please! Toasted is a newer restaurant that popped up in the UCF area that focuses on grilled cheese. Apparently they have some other locations but this was my first time visiting any of them! I chose the As Gouda As It Gets sandwich and boy did it live up to its name! The bread was toasted just right (for the name of the place, in glad they got it right). It was filled with pulled chicken, garlic spinach, red peppers and of course smoked gouda. That crunch with the melty cheese- yum! I was happy to know that all of the cheeses are pasteurized too. Fries are served as a separate side and they are a very good size you could share. Food came out fast. Manager and staff came over to check on us too. I will be back! read more

See all

The kids meal was atrocious. It tasted like macaroni and cheese from the holidays about four days later after it's dried out in the fridge but you don't want to go to waste so you go ahead and reheat it. Neither my daughter I wanted to eat it. My wife had a braised gluten-free sandwich which was very soggy and could use some toasting. The irony wasn't lost on us since the establishment is named Toasted. Finally my sandwich was quite tasty. The chimichurri really set it off and I enjoyed it a lot. The french fries were nice and crispy. The tomato soup was OK nothing special which is why I gave this a three star overall. read more

See all

My love of grilled cheese brought me to Toasted to see what spins they were putting on a classic grilled cheese sandwich. Overall a good experience, but I am going to be picky because I expect better when you specialize on and market yourself on a specific item. The Braised Brisket & fontina grilled cheese sandwich was very tasty, but more of a brisket sandwich with cheese instead of the anticipated grilled cheese with brisket (less cheese than brisket = not grilled cheese). The Viva La Vegan received an average grade from my staff vegan. The Mac & Cheese is a standout dish not to be missed, very creamy. Conversely the Roasted Tomato Soup tasted more house mixed than house made and was not nearly as creamy as it should be. As always, I am not a fan of take-out style ordering lines for a more upscale sit down restaurant, but at least they bring your order to the table. Taste *** Quality/Freshness *** Presentation/Uniqueness ** Service ** Atmosphere *** Bar Cleanliness *** Price $$ read more

See all

Fantastic grilled cheese sandwiches. I had the "fig & goat" which had goat cheese, basil, and fig jam. Yum - salty, cheesy, and a hint of sweet! My dining companion had the impossible burger ("very very good") and described it as a little thicker than most impossible burgers, and the tomatoes were crazy fresh. We both loved the skinny cut French fries that came with it. The thing that made me wrote this review is that there is no need to bus your own table. See pic - they do it for you! read more

Toasted - UCF Area - No need to clear your dishes! - Burgers Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Never really liked grilled cheeses till I came here.. literally speciality grilled cheeses that are AMAZING! The grilled cheese that had Mac and cheese in it was one of my favorites before I went vegan. Haven't had the chance to try their new vegan grilled cheeses but plan on it next since I loved them before I was vegan - so I'm hoping they will impress me just as much now as they did then! read more

They should offer a classic grilled cheese and Campbell soup. I ordered the 101 and a cup of tomato soup. The soup tasted like marinara sauce. Why change the classics? read more

Went here on a whim for dinner one night and was pleasantly surprised! The truffle fries have the perfect hit of rosemary, the buffalo melt was delicious and while the as Gouda as it gets could have used more of a sauce it was still delicious! I very fun, quick and unique dinner idea for sure (: read more

I have eaten here twice, and both times my food was cooked way too long. Both times, the bread was black and tough to chew. I will not be eating here again. The truffle fries are okay, but do not taste like truffle at all. read more

Highly disappointed. Burnt sandwiches delivered to go. After reaching home we checked and got upset. Why would they even pack this kind of food and handover to a customer? read more

Toasted - UCF Area - I ordered 3 cheese sandwiches for take out.Perfectly burnt sandwiches. Why would you even pack this and deliver? Highly disappointed. - Burgers Near Me - Orlando, Florida