Updating my 2022 review. Pizza here is still really good. Great New York style pizzas with several options to select from. Delivery, carryout and dine-in all available. Outside of the pizzas, I have also tried the fried ravioli and tiramisu, which were both good. Summary - Primarily NY style pizza, but they do have other crust options - Pizza is sold by the slice, 14", 18" and 25" - Pasta, calzones, sandwiches, and even a burger on the menu - Prices higher than chain pizza joints but worth it - Carry out and delivery orders can be placed using the Toast app read more

My work group stopped in here recently and had such a yummy lunch! I have ordered from here many times on Door Dash because the food is not super overpriced on there and even with the fees and whatnot, it's affordable for me to order and have delivered to my work. Anyways, this visit was in person in the restaurant. There were four of us and we went early for lunch. We were one table of maybe 3 that came in while we were there, but there were so many take out/to-go orders that walked out the door while we were in there. They have redone the front area where you order and you can see all the different pizzas they make. I chose the Meat Lovers (1 slice) with a side salad and drink and it was very reasonable! The rest of my group opted for the two slice and drink lunch special. They all loved their meals as well. I highly recommend stopping in here if you like pizza! read more

Times Square Pizzeria - Meat Lovers Slice with Side Salad and Drink (Lunch Special) - Pizza Near Me - Lexington, North Carolina

Small pizzeria that doesn't look like much but offers great food. They have the option to order slices or to order a whole pizza with other options on the menu like pasta, sandwiches, appetizers, and more. It's mostly take out but the sit in area gives you an old timey pizza place that despite its appearance is kept very clean. read more

See all

Best pizza and calzones/Stromboli in the area! We always make it a priority to come here when we're in North Carolina. Clean, comfortable seating, unlimited soda fountain. Staff are very nice and helpful. read more

Thumbs up to Time Square Pizza. They never skimp on the toppings. The pizza was delicious as usual read more

Times Square Pizzeria - 14" pizza with sausage and mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Lexington, North Carolina

Im from NY ,moved to lexington NC 7 months ago . The pizza here is absolutely amazing and top 3 pizza i ever had even in NY. Hands down the best Pizza in NC. read more

One of the only two pizza places in Lexington I go to. Not quite what we're used to up north but the luzaa is always very good. The lunch special is very reasonably priced at $7.99 for two slices and a fountain drink. The slices are very large so you're really getting your money's worth. I had a slice of Chicken Caprese and 1 slice of meat lovers and the chicken caprese was really tasty! I devoured it before I could remember to take a picture lol. Definitely a great place to order from for the Superbowl! read more

Times Square Pizzeria - Meat lovers pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lexington, North Carolina

See all

Great food their chicken tenders are kinda bland but it's still Great I always order off of door dash bc I'm lazy but it's still good

Fresh Food Great Pizza taste just like New York . Staff was great they bring your food to you , Dam it's good food Love this places Going Back And they have Lunch Special. read more

Times Square Pizzeria - a slice of pineapple pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lexington, North Carolina

See all

Yum yum yum! Not much open on Sundays around here, so we ended up here by default. I'm so glad we did! I tried a slice of Buffalo chicken and BBQ chicken pizza. Both were DELICIOUS. (Bbq was my favorite) Plus you can get 2 slices and a drink for $8! (At least that was the special when we went) We will definitely be back. read more

Excellent food. Nice to find a spot with true New York style pizza locally. They also have a nice variety of specialty pizzas to try. Recommend. read more

Some of the best pizza around highly recommend. I've been going here for years now, anything you get will be delicious. Great and friendly staff too. read more

I was born and raised in Manhattan and this is genuine NY pizza ! We've done order pick up twice now nice to have genuine NY pizza in Lexington. read more

Times Square Pizzeria - sausage pepperoni pineapple slice - Pizza Near Me - Lexington, North Carolina

See all

Just ordered two pizzas, asked for a margarita and they sent a pepperoni. Called them and my answer was "we will get it right next time"! I used to own a very respectable pizzeria, and that isn't the right answer! Place is disappointing to say the least! read more

Pizza.... F'n Delicious Fries.... Pretty damn good Cheese sticks.... decent Bathrooms.... Has a patched up hole for every one star rating this joint has. Overall a solid 4 stars. Just stick with the pizza and avoid the bathrooms unless you are in for a uneasy sketchy laugh. read more

Times Square Pizzeria - Cheese Pizza Bacon Cheese Fries Side Fries Mozzarella Sticks - Pizza Near Me - Lexington, North Carolina

I love a good pizza by the slice place for lunch and this one hits the spot. Lots of options and all of them are delicious. I love the cheeseburger pizza! Wish they could freshen up the dining area, it's a little dingy and tired but I don't go there for ambience! read more

I came to Time Square during lunch on a weekday. Wasn't too busy, easy to find somewhere to sit and my food order was ready in no time. They have daily specials that fit your cravings in all types of ways. My favorite part about Time Square, is when ordering by the slice, it isn't your basic pepperoni or plain cheese by the slice. This is all specialty pizzas by the slice with no extra charge! They had about 10 pizzas to choose from! I ordered the 2 slices and a drink special, but ordered two of the same slices instead of mix matching. So good and full of flavor!! Customer service was quick and friendly! Very welcoming as I walked in the door! read more

Times Square Pizzeria - a close up of a pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lexington, North Carolina

See all

We ordered a 25" "the Works" pizza and had it delivered. Delivery was on time and the pizza was hot. The driver was friendly and actually arrived ten minutes before anticipated. The pizza..... it was typical New York style thin crust with sparse toppings, but it was pretty good. The crust and sauce were good. The cheese was sparse. You won't find and cheese trailing your slice as you take it from the box. The toppings were all good and fresh, with the exception of the sausage-it was very freezer burned and off putting. I simply pulled all of the sausage off of the pizza and it was pretty good after that. read more

I really hate to leave negative reviews but this was just totally meh. More than I hate to leave a negative review, I hate to spend a good amount of money on really lackluster food. The calzone was pretty tasty, but under filled and small for its price, and that is the best thing I can say about our experience. We got two pizzas and both were totally cardboardy, dry and bland. The toppings were skimpy and the price was not. I don't know if it's a "Covid times" thing or their typical performance but we were completely unimpressed, I am sad to say. read more

First time ordering and was not disappointed. Salad was super fresh, wings were perfectly cooked and pizza crust was on point. As a native NYer it's hard to get passable pizza but the crust was exactly as you want it and the flavor was delicious. This will be our go to as new residents to the lake. read more

Great pizzas, did a pickup and brought them home. The huge 24" pizza is a beast. Honestly it's as good as a New York pizza shop and I am visiting family in town but would love to go back again! read more

Stopped in for a slice and it did not disappoint all 5 of us! The crust was so crispy!!! Highly recommend...

Had no idea about this place and I love finding gems like this. This is the best pizza I've ever had. If you want something different than the usual greasy pizza places, go here! If you love good pizza and want pizza night to be exciting again, go here, you won't be disappointed. The mix of flavors on this pizza sounds crazy. I felt like a Ninja Turtle ordering it, but Holy Cow! If Ninja Turtle pizza is wrong, then I don't want to be right! Order ahead to pick up or enjoy there, family or just a couple. The baked ziti was amazing. Pizza is not their only gem. The chocolate mouse was just the cherry on the cake for this indulgent night. read more

See all

The food here was delicious and it's conveniently located. The prices are about average price for what you're getting.

Terrible terrible and terrible. Over priced bullsh$&. You call this an Italian sandwich? Your pizza is rubbery and cold. Please stay away from this place but I know it's also hard because you can't find a pie in this town except dominos and papa John's...but it's better than this. Two slices of meat? Was suspect and friend and found out. Stay away! read more

Times Square Pizzeria - Italian Sub - Pizza Near Me - Lexington, North Carolina

See all

Just ordered their pizza me and my brother were all about it definitely worth a try well be back next week

Ordered pizza the other night, it was so good!!! Crispy, cheesy and delicious. Definitely recommend!

Great New York style pizza and calzones in a strip mall. Very unassuming place but do not pass it up!

When they first open it was the best pizza, however after a year it is not that great nor does it taste like NY pizza. Also when ordering for delivery they have been forgetting part of the order or food is burnt or not well cooked. read more

They would not honor a coupon that I purchased as fundraiser for the local Boy Scouts. It was for a free 14" inch cheese pizza with purchase or 18" inch 1 topping pizza. The boy behind the counter with AirPods in said the owner wouldn't honor it. read more

Times Square Pizzeria - a free 14 cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lexington, North Carolina

Tasty but ruined. We complained about the pizza on the right cheese sticking to the lid of the box and they said they would send another. The one on the left and the main picture is the replaced pizza. All of the cheese piled in the corner. The service was great and delivery driver was really nice. However the presentation not so much. read more

Times Square Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Lexington, North Carolina

See all

Great spot! I really love the prices and deals that they have daily. Such a reasonable price and great quality. I got the two slices and drink deal, which is about $8. The slices I chose were one slice pineapple only and then a speciality BBQ chicken slice. I really like the amount of pineapple on the slice, it wasn't like I was wondering where any toppings were. The New York style pizza was great and true to NY! I didn't really care for the BBQ chicken slice, the chicken is fried chunks and sauce really thick. I believe someone who likes that would enjoy, the flavors were good but just not for me. Finally the garlic knots and they are amazing. This is the best item on the menu to me. If you like bread and garlic, you're in for a treat. Staff was friendly, accommodating, and knowledgeable. Will be going back! read more

See all

I called in my order from High Point, NC requesting a white sauce spaghetti with a twist. The Chef said "He will create a surprise for me and hope I like it." 5-Stars for a yummy white sauce spaghetti with veggies!! Thank You! read more

There are two locations near me and they are not created equal. This location is awesome and the one off Peter's Creek is the opposite. This location had awesome fresh single slice options of many specialty pizzas in their window. The other location had 2 options that after eating one was a day old and sat the day I ordered it. This location has friendly service and made us feel welcomed. Other location is awkward. We ordered the largest pizza and when they brought it out and was the biggest pizza I had ever seen and was so good. We had a large party of 10+ and sat at the mega table. Great service - I will be back to this location. Other location I will pretend does not exist. The white pizza here is awesome and they have a stuffed pizza my son said was the best. This location is hard to get to since they worked on the highway - my friend had to lead me in and GPS doesn't like it. Lots of good pizza places as options but in Lexington I will find my way back to this one. Other location I would find myself to Burke St. instead. read more

Hands down the best pizza in town!!! Tried a few other spots so far while visiting from SoFlo for the next 5 weeks and I keep coming back to this one for a reason. read more

Great place. Pizza is the best in the areas. Staff are friendly and laid back. Makes me feel like I am home.

I travel on a weekly basis and when I don't feel like going out I will order delivery. Most the times it's blah, but this time I ordered delivery from here. Baked ziti was so good and very hot along with a great side salad. Also some dessert to top it off. I highly recommend this place, if I could give them more stars I would. read more

I've ordered from here a handful of times. I love their pizza, fresh tomatoes in their sauce and real mozzarella cheese. The pasta is a big let down. I've ordered the Alfredo multiple times, and each time ive been disappointed. The pasta is always plain, then they throw it on some watered down sauce and call it Alfredo. What in the world... no flavor, no creamy ness. Just pathetic. It's like watery chicken noodle soup. I wanted to think it was just the cook on that day but this is really what they call Alfredo. Don't do the pastas. Save your money and your taste buds. Even taking it home and adding your own spices and cheeses to the dish, it still tastes horrid. read more

Omfg the BEST pizza!!! And I'm from NY. The long island big mac pizza is amazing. All their pizzas are amazing.

Placed my delivery order at 1:54pm on a Sunday. I work downtown, so I was 5 minutes from the restaurant. I ordered (6) garlic knots, and a slice of pizza for my lunch at WORK. I proceeded to call the restaurant at 3:00 to ask if my food was out for delivery. They reassured me that it was out for delivery. It is now 4:00pm (two hours after the order time, or from the time I was CHARGED ON MY CARD FOR THE MEAL) and I still have YET to receive my small, $13.00 order. I am extremely disappointed in the lack of rapport and support from the staff to manage the issue, along with the time that it took for me to even receive my order. This was my first and only experience with the restaurant, and I will not be ordering again. read more