Today we decided to order pizza from Tiano's. We called ahead to order three pizzas. The person who answered the phone immediately said, "Tiano's, hold for a minute," and left me on hold for about five minutes before I finally hung up. I figured they were busy, so I called back about 15 minutes later, but the call went straight to voicemail. The voicemail was not even set up. My wife and I both tried from different carriers, Verizon and Spectrum, and had the same issue. We kept trying over the next 15 minutes, thinking maybe the phone lines were tied up because they were busy taking orders. We eventually drove there to place the order in person, only to find they were not busy at all. When I mentioned the phone issue, they told me they "always have problems with the phones." I can only imagine how much business that costs them. I placed the order, and the lady with the thick dark-framed glasses read it back correctly: two large cheese pizzas, one large half cheese / half pepperoni and ham pizza, and one chicken calzone. We were told about a 30-minute wait. When we got home, the order was wrong. We received three large cheese pizzas, with no pepperoni or ham on the specialty pizza we paid extra for. The chicken calzone also had ham in it, which I assume was supposed to go on the pizza. Now I'm wondering where the pepperoni went. Unfortunately, the person who ordered the calzone does not eat ham, so that ended up going in the trash. On top of that, the quality of the pizza was disappointing. The middle of the pizzas seemed undercooked and sloppy. When you picked up a slice, all the cheese slid right off. It's a shame, because we really want to like this place. read more

See all

This place was highly recommended to me by both my grandparents. So my dad, grandma and I went for dinner. We ordered the large Tiano's special. It was quite large and covered in all the delicious toppings you'd ever want. Pepperoni, ham, Italian sausage, green peppers, onion and mushrooms. One large was plenty for the three of us. We even had two slices leftover. The people behind the counter and the lady working around the dining room were super nice and friendly. I'd say typically this is the kinda place you'd get the pizza to-go but the dining area was just fine. I like to eat my pizza fresh out of the oven. I hate it's so far from home because this pizza was absolutely amazing and I'm already craving more! read more

Tiano Pizza - Large tiano's special - Pizza Near Me - Madison, North Carolina

See all

The Tiano's large pizza special never fails as a fresh low cost spur of the moment meal.

Staying nearby, it's always our tradition to get pizza out first night away. This was the closest to our Air BnB. Pizza was not relay at the expected time. Which is fine if it's a few minutes. It was over 15 minutes past the time. The cheese was not cooked all the way as I could still see where the cheese was shredded. We got a supreme but with NO sausage, no ham and no mushroom. They had all of these toppings on the pizza. Yuck. I started to pick off the toppings I don't care for but there wasn't much left on it! The pepperoni was really good so it gets a 4 star review from me which is being generous. read more

They have really went down hill. Ordered a Steak and cheese it was dry and bland no seasoning at all. Very disappointing.

Good italian food here - the baked ziti with meatballs is VG; and you get a salad with it or FFries. Pizza is very good too. Sauce is very very tasty. The ladies and men there work very well together and the orders are always correct. Nice big place so you can sit down with your family or friends. Has tables and chairs. read more

Love to go here after work and grab some excellent subs to take home to the family, and enjoy an ice cold frosty Red Oak while I wait. Great food, friendly folks and a clean place to don't get much better than that. read more

Tried Tiano Pizza twice, once for a pizza, once for subs. First visit was a small pizza. Very busy, line was about 10 people when I arrived and was almost to the door when I left. Little bit of chaos as a result, if they knew you they took care of your order, if they didn't, you had to keep an eye out and ask if something was yours. Pizza was made quickly, simple pepperoni and mushrooms. Mushrooms were the canned variety, not fresh, but were plentiful. Crust was tasty and crisp and sauce was tasty as well. Second visit was for a subs, a steak and cheese and an Italian. Interestingly, the Italian is not listed on the menu as a hot sub, but was delivered hot. Steak and cheese had decent amount of ingredients, and the crusty bread was good. Flavor was a bit lacking, but it was still good. Will return when I'm in the area again. read more

Great food and service. Thought they would never live up to the old owners but they are doing just fine

The steak subs and pizza are delicious and plentiful! The atmosphere is super casual and the staff is friendly. Don't let the outside keep you from going in. You will be glad you tried it. read more

Those new people that took over should not be in restaurants, first they brought the cooks from Star pizza in who have been known not the wash their hands and touch food without gloves but second they can't even figure out how to make a decent pizza, my pizza literally felt to be half an inch thick on one side but then the other had holes and black parts in it from where I guess it burnt in the oven, I was too embarrassed to take a photo because we had ate in so we just left, I'm not sure where these new owners have came from or what experience they have in restaurants but I sure do miss the old Tianos that was based off of family and the community rather than these new people that seem to be serving slop for a paycheck, we won't be back read more

We got to-go pizza from this well established pizza and pasta place. We called our order in, and it was ready in the promised 30 minutes. The pizza was cooked a bit unevenly, but the cheese pull was amazing. The buttery mozzarella really hit my taste buds right. Four of us shared a large pepperoni , and my parents had a small cheeseburger. If you want a great take-out spot, I recommend Tiano! read more

Steak hoagies are probably the best thing on the menu. Just wish I could get them to toast the bun before adding anything. Pizza is decent if you are looking for thin crust pizza. I really wish some place around here did a thick crust though. read more

Excellent food! I recommend the pizza (any type or toppings) and the steak stromboli. My mom loves the Italian sub. Never had anything bad here. read more

We were touring the beautiful & historic town of Madison, NC when we decided we were hungry for pizza. Siri brought us to Tiano's Pizza! We are so glad we discovered this Italian gem (October 13, 2018). You can tell they have been doing this for over 30 years! We ordered 2 Large Pizzas. Our first pizza was the Tiano's Special (Pepperoni, Sausage, Hamburger, Ham, Onions, Mushrooms, Green Peppers, Cheese & Sauce). Our second pizza was Hawaiian (Ham & Pineapple, Cheese & Sauce). Both pizzas were filled with toppings and tasted amazing! There was just the right amount of sauce and cheese. There were plenty of all the toppings too! We noticed a lot of people ordering sandwiches; by the numbers sold, they must be good too! We will be back again to try more items on their menu!!! Most Sincerely!!! read more

See all

The staff is friendly! They make you feel like you're their only customer!! The food is great!! The pizza is wonderful and the subs and fries are amazing!!!! I love this place! read more

What an awesome surprise! we moved to this tiny town in Madison and saw this little place in a shopping center with Food Lion and thought why not try it? The food is fantastic. Whether you get a dinner like eggplant Parmesan, a fresh salad or there perfect pizza you will not be disappointed. it's amazing to find such a high-quality place and such a small community. It's very casual, but has good service and you can always get a place to sit. read more

Always a go-to spot for me. Great cheesesteaks, and pizza. Very friendly staff. Can't go wrong.

Family owned and been around for 30+ years!! Best pizza in town!! Awesome service every time!! Love this place and highly recommend it!!

We get their pizza and its pretty good. We order ahead and pick up is pretty quick. Will try the subs next! Ample seating inside. read more

Tiano Pizza - the menu for the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Madison, North Carolina

See all

Great authentic Italian food and great people. Just walking in you can tell it's going to be good. Recommend the Stromboli!

Great food and a very friendly staff. We had the cheesesteaks and pizza. It was Delicious!

Best place to go if you want some real pizza and subs. I've been going to this place for a while and it never disappointed me. Great costume Service great food just overall great! read more

After eating at Tiano's multiple times it safe to say that their food is consistently delicious. Service is friendly and the food comes out fast. Beer is a plus as most most smaller places in the area don't serve alcohol. It's a good simple pizza joint with New York inspiration. read more

Tiano Pizza - a pepperoni pizza on a pizza board - Pizza Near Me - Madison, North Carolina

The best steak and cheese sub. I've also got there chicken sandwiches. Absolutely the best. Staff is always friendly and even my call in orders are always hot. Wonderful place to eat. read more

Has always been my #1 favorite place to get a steak and cheese stromboli! Something about the cheese I love!!!

After being away for a while I couldn't wait to come back and try the steak and cheese special again. I was so disappointed with my experience I wish I would have kept my memory of eating here in my high school days. I ordered the steak cheese special which consists of steak, cheese, mushrooms, and pepperoni. I also ordered fries to go with it. The sub was all bread with hardly no meat inside. It had no taste at all. The fries where also bland. What happened to this place? I think the best choice now if you are in Madison Mayodan Stoneville Area would be Blue Naples. I'm saddened to say I will not be back. read more

Best Philly bar none. Many other choices for anyones flavor. Absolutely one of my faves for dinning out.

Some of the best pizza I've had here in Madison hands down!!' Try it you will Love it!!! read more

Hidden away in a shopping center hole in the wall place but the food was the best. I was there in town visiting for a week and got food there two times in one week. Sicilian pizza is the best. Stuffed shells even better definitely recommend this place. read more

Best pizza anywhere!! Great steak and cheese subs also

I'm from the north so I'm used to northern pizza which is amazing but so far, this is the best pizza I've had in the south

Haven't been to Tianos in a while. Was in the mood for some pizza. Looks like they have redecorated. It looks just the way a pizza place should. Homie atmosphere with the stain glass light fixtures. Ordered a large pepperoni and mushroom pizza. Tea is brewed and sweet which always good. I don't drink sweet tea often but when I do I like it strong. Pizza was excellent!!! Crust was crispy and had wonderful flavor. Sauce was some of the best I've had in some time. Cheese and just the right flavor. I will definitely be back. read more

This is one of our favorite places to grab dinner. My husband enjoys their pizza. I always get a steak and cheese sub with onions and mushrooms! They're really good! read more

I love their steak and cheese sub its great. Haven't tried anything else yet but the pizza looks good too.

food is fine, these people never cut the grill hood fan on....NEVER! you smell like grease when you come out.....it stays in your closes....... read more