It's honestly shocking it's taken us this long to try Star pizza since it's in our home county, but…read moretoday was the day! Online ordering made getting our pizza seamless! I walked in and my order was ready to go. The staff was super friendly and the space brings a sense of nostalgia with the vinyl booths and bar area. The pizza was SO GOOD. Crispy pepperonis, melty cheese, a crust that's just the right thickness. I think this may be a pizza winner for us. We will definitely be picking up Star Pizza when in Mayodan frequently!

Went to Madison to hit up another restaurant that ended up being closed to handy dandy Yelp led us…read moreto Star pizza. We had heard good things from a friend and decided it was worth a try. Party of 4 tried the Star fries (extra crispy fries with extra seasoning). And a meat lovers pizza. The server was young and seemed inexperienced but she did a decent job, the fries were great. Can pit piping hot and were nice and crispy, the pizza was good too. The crust was crunchy and the meat was smoky and plentiful. All in all enjoyed the meal and would like to go back to try something different from the menu next time. Only 4 stars because they don't have fountain drinks and cost wise bottled drinks at a restaurant like this is not sustainable if you drink a lot of soda with your meal.

Today we decided to order pizza from Tiano's. We called ahead to order three pizzas. The person who…read moreanswered the phone immediately said, "Tiano's, hold for a minute," and left me on hold for about five minutes before I finally hung up. I figured they were busy, so I called back about 15 minutes later, but the call went straight to voicemail. The voicemail was not even set up. My wife and I both tried from different carriers, Verizon and Spectrum, and had the same issue. We kept trying over the next 15 minutes, thinking maybe the phone lines were tied up because they were busy taking orders. We eventually drove there to place the order in person, only to find they were not busy at all. When I mentioned the phone issue, they told me they "always have problems with the phones." I can only imagine how much business that costs them. I placed the order, and the lady with the thick dark-framed glasses read it back correctly: two large cheese pizzas, one large half cheese / half pepperoni and ham pizza, and one chicken calzone. We were told about a 30-minute wait. When we got home, the order was wrong. We received three large cheese pizzas, with no pepperoni or ham on the specialty pizza we paid extra for. The chicken calzone also had ham in it, which I assume was supposed to go on the pizza. Now I'm wondering where the pepperoni went. Unfortunately, the person who ordered the calzone does not eat ham, so that ended up going in the trash. On top of that, the quality of the pizza was disappointing. The middle of the pizzas seemed undercooked and sloppy. When you picked up a slice, all the cheese slid right off. It's a shame, because we really want to like this place.

Food was great! You walk in and order at the counter. Everything is made fresh and made by a real…read moreItalian cook! The place is very clean and the staff is very friendly. The food came out hot! If you're ever in town and are looking for good food, Tiano Pizza is a place to try. They have many more goodies to try.

Best ever Just celebrated my birthday there yesterday. I…read morehighly recommend!! Large pizza and best service. I go there every year on my birthday and then times in between

So this pizza place is AMAZING!! I've never had such a great tasting pizza!! Don't know what they…read moredo differently but it was the bomb!!! And when he says large...it's freaking large!! Will definitely visit this pizza restaurant again when I'm back in Eden!!! Loved it!!!

We had a Chef's salad, sub, pizza and wings. My fiancé said the sub was good but could've used more…read moremayonnaise. I am not particularly fond of too much mayonnaise, so I thought that it tasted fine. The pizza was good. Not very hot, but it was loaded with toppings, so there again, perhaps the reason for the temperature. Salad was good and loaded also, but they gave very little ranch and we had to ask multiple times for more because the containers were very small that they came in. Wings were good. Over all food was good. I'd probably go back. It just wasn't great. Customer service was good and the employees were very courteous. Restaurant was clean and neat. Seating/table area is not large, but it could hold maybe a small group or two.

First of all, how does the price of what you call a special with a drink, cost the same without a…read moredrink. Make it make sense. Second, just because restaurants have the same name, definitely doesn't mean it has the same experience or quality. Very disappointed in this Stromboli, presentation was a dud! It was not completely cooked and the sauce was very salty! Not the experience I expected since the Elizabeths in VA are amazing. The guy who took my order was nice but not sympathetic to the huge difference in cost with the special. The atmosphere is so dated and it's too dark even to enter. I'm sorry, but never again.

Came here for a family get together for Christmas. Not only was our waitress phenomenal and extra…read moreattentive, but the food was top notch and full of flavor! The ambience is typical pizzeria/italy vibes, but this place is great for when you want some fresh Italian food at a fair price. If you happen to get Amber as your waitress you won't be disappointed in the service she provides. Thank you for a great night! My wife and I will be returning for sure!

Oh, Little Italy Pizza... where do I even start? My wife and I stopped by on a Friday night, lured…read morein by the promise of cheesy, carb-filled happiness. We decided to go for the white pizza because, sometimes you need to get away from a typical pepperoni, but that was not a good choice unfortunately. The pizza arrived looking all innocent and promising, but one bite in, and we were hit with the crushing realization: this thing had zero flavor. Like, none. It was like eating a soggy cracker that someone whispered the word "cheese" to from across the room. No garlic, no seasoning, no pizzazz--just a sad, bland circle of disappointment. I kept eating, hoping maybe the next bite would surprise me....it didn't. The service was fine, and the place itself had a decent vibe, but let's be real--if the pizza doesn't deliver, what's the point? Little Italy, I wanted to love you, but you left me with nothing but regret and a craving for actual flavor.

This is a solid Italian place. Nothing out of the ordinary but is usually pretty consistent.read more

Typical Italian food. Clean atmosphere. Service is at order counter which is a little undesirable…read more I'd rather be waited on at the table.

poor management march 24,2026 over 3 hours still no pizza delivery worst service ever need new…read moremanager that female sucked

The worst customer service Ive ever experienced. They messed up my order. No apologies and treated…read moreme very rudely. I had to wait for them to remake my pizza. Called corporate to complain about how they treated me after they messed up my order. I believe they intentionally spit in my pizza so I threw it out. Corporate told me they would refund my order. Never happened. They lied!!! T

My new piece of heaven. Headed to SC, and saw a sign in Reidsville, NC for BISCUITVILLE. Fresh made…read morebiscuit with pimento cheese and a country fried steak, everything perfectly cooked. My husband and I dipped out wedge fries in the country gravy, wish we had more fries!! The grits were a bit tight and I wanted them peppery, so I added the rest of the country gravy and it was great.

I eat breakfast here at least three times a week. Friendy…read moreservice. Good prices and selection. There's a reason they are so busy all the time. They are an asset to our community.