I stopped by Thirsty Pagan in Superior after a long road trip, and it was exactly what I needed. The atmosphere was relaxed and welcoming, making it a great place to unwind after being on the road. I ordered the calzone, which was delicious and definitely lived up to the recommendations, and the drinks were just as good. The staff was friendly, knowledgeable, and helped me with some great menu options. Overall, it was a great experience, and I'd definitely stop by again the next time I'm in the area. read more

Thirsty Pagan Brewing - Breweries Near Me - Superior, Wisconsin

This was a busy place midafternoon on a Saturday, but service was fast and pleasant the whole while. My husband tried their beer while I had a blueberry smash, a seasonal drink, which I loved. We shared the TPB #1, a hot and cheesy bread, as live music played nearby, the musicians fantastic and the songs familiar. We were still able to talk without a problem. We really enjoyed our stop here. read more

See all

Food was so good! We did the veggie pizza and the pretzel bites and everything was a hit. So much flavor. Service was meh. Everyone around us had to ask for refills. It wasn't terribly busy. Music was really loud and annoying. read more

See all

Great local spot for pizza and live music. They also host various other events like trivia. We stopped in on a Saturday for lunch as my dad liked the local band performing. We got the loaded pretzel bites and a personal sized pizza with pepperoni and feta. I love that they have personal sized pizza options so everyone can get something they like. Food was good and it is a cool location being in an old train depot. read more

Thirsty Pagan Brewing - Pepperoni pizza with feta personal size - Breweries Near Me - Superior, Wisconsin

See all

We were happily greeted when we entered and were seated right away. Loved the open atmosphere of the place. We ordered a couple of beers, as well as, an appetizer and a small pizza. Our waitress returned a few minutes later to let us know that they were out of the appetizer we had ordered. She suggested another one which was very good! The pizza was really tasty, too. When our beverages were looking low we were approached and asked if we wanted another. Our waitress checked in on us during our stay. We ended our visit with some delicious desserts! This is a nice mellow place to enjoy a meal and good beer! Order a few crowlers before you leave! We will be back again! read more

See all

Best pizza in the tri state area. Been going here for years and they haven't changed a thing about the quality of their pizzas (which is exactly how it should be) read more

Thirsty Pagan Brewing - Breweries Near Me - Superior, Wisconsin

Unique. Outstanding pizza! The crust, sauce and spicy sausage is perfection! Wish we had one of these in our hometown

Just came in for a beer and snack. Our group got the stuffed mushrooms, loaded pretzel and a personal pan pizza. The mushrooms were delicious with some taste of garlic. Loaded pretzel was good too but like mushrooms more. Personal pan even though small was perfect! I washed it down with a craft beer. Come give them a try. read more

Thirsty Pagan Brewing - Burnt wood black beer - Breweries Near Me - Superior, Wisconsin

Excellent service, a creative menu and a good selection of beverages. The reuben appetizer was even better than the calzone, which was excellent! Give this place a try! read more

See all

**Update** We had the Derailed pizza yesterday and asked for extra sauce because the last few pizzas that we've had here have been short on the sauce. If I'm paying $40 for a 16" pizza, it's pretty tacky charging for the extra sauce like an extra topping, especially after skimping on most of the veggies that are supposed to be on a Derailed pizza. You'd think we'd ordered a black olive pizza! It's no longer worth the drive for pizza at Thirsty Pagan. read more

Hands down, some of the best customer service I've had for a large party. I reached out to Deb via email about hosting my daughter soccer team for a team family dinner on a Friday evening. She responded to my request in less than 24 hours. She was very kind and helpful. She graciously gave me time to gather final numbers and call her back about 3 days before the event. We had 40 people, choose to do the salad, pizza, and soda option. They also were able to accommodate with Gluten Free pizzas too! We asked for food to be ready and served right at 7pm and they were set up and right on time!! We had one other server Shana helping. Both Deb and her were smiling and cheerful! I HIGHLY RECOMMEND this venue to groups of all sizes. The building is a historic train depot and they did a wonderful job keeping the original charm of the building while turning it into a beautiful venue!! Thank you Deb and Steve!! read more

Thirsty Pagan Brewing - Exterior view from the road - Breweries Near Me - Superior, Wisconsin

The pizza is delicious, the place has a great vibe, and typically there is live music.

Sat down by myself and ordered a Pepsi and loaded Pretzel bites to start, but then after the pretzel bites were brought to me the waitress walked away without asking if I wanted anything else, to which I still wanted to get a pizza. Then after I finished the bites the waitress came back over with the check all ready to go. At that moment I realized I didn't want to speak up if I wasn't even given the chance to order anything else. The people I talked to were great, but the failure to see if I wanted anything else main course even was very off putting. read more

Pizza was a little more bland than I recall from last time but we absolutely still loved this place. I had their Octoberfest and it was pretty good, however, my friend had their Pilsner and man was that refreshing. Glad I don't like by here because I'd be spending every dollar I made there getting the pizza and a pint. Love the building, super friendly staff, parking everywhere, there's just not enough good things I can say about this little place. read more

This was a nice stop on a weekday night when I was passing through town. They have live entertainment, which worried me at first, but it turned out delightful- a solo singer/acoustic guitarist with real talent. The personal pizza (I chose sausage, red peppers, onions) was quite tasty. The tomato soup special tasted a bit too much like pizza sauce, which was a little odd (but OK). Staff were very friendly, but unable to properly recommend a smooth tasting beer out of their collection (I'm sure they do better with IPAs). read more

Thirsty Pagan Brewing - Personal pizza with sausage, red peppers, and onions. - Breweries Near Me - Superior, Wisconsin

Great venue and awesome beer. Building is an old railway station and is nicely decorated. Love the hazy and regular IPA's, bought crowlers to take along. Quick friendly bartender. read more

This was some of the best pizza that we've had! The crust was amazing. Loved that the patio was dog friendly as well. Awesome menu with lots of options. Pizza, calzones, a large selection of brews. I liked being able to do a personal pizza with 3 toppings. Their homemade sausage was bomb. We definitely will make this a regular stop when we go up north again! read more

Thirsty Pagan Brewing - Breweries Near Me - Superior, Wisconsin

Stopped in twice while camping in the area. Place was recommended by my nephew who has played music there a few times. He knows we like quality craft beer and pizza. Man, we were not disappointed! Nice selection of different brews, tasty pizza, breads and salads, friendly capable servers. Unique setting inside and out. Plenty of parking. I treated myself to some merch. Owner Steve there the 2nd time we were in and he was incredibly personable and knowledgeable. read more

See all

This place is such a vibe! It's like a eclectic hippie took a Green Mill and made it their own. Came on a Wednesday eve and it was moderately full and a epic mustache guy strumming on a guitar. All the young (good looking) staff were attentive and kind. Seemed clean and family friendly(ish)! There are a few tables outside and did see a couple with a dog. Food came out promptly and was good. Brownie for dessert was just OK. Despite my mediocre brownie - I would recommend and will definitely be visiting again! read more

See all

We were in town for Grandma's Marathon and picked this place for our post race dinner. We could not have picked a more perfect place! There was a short wait of 15-20 minutes when our party of four arrived. We went to a bar for a couple beverages while we waited. I ordered the Lawn Chair cream ale and, to be honest, it was one of my least favorite cream ales I've had. Still, any beer is good after a marathon. We were seated within the 15-20 minutes they quoted. We ordered the cheese bread as an appetizer which came with a cup of dipping sauce. I love pizza sauce so that was a great plus. We ordered second beers. This time I had the Dreams of Orange cream ale. Now that one was a wonderful cream ale! Then we all ordered pizzas. Husband and son split a large pizza. The waitress warned them that it was very big and I told her that we'd just run a marathon. She said even so she didn't think they could eat it all. Darned if she wasn't right! It was the thickest, most topping filled pizza I have ever seen! Granted it was not cheap at $42 but they loved it and did have leftovers. Son's girlfriend ordered a 10 inch pizza and I ordered a gluten free spinach and feta. Mine was fabulous, especially for a gluten free and also came with delicious dipping sauce! It was the perfect post race meal! I highly recommend it if you're hungry and like beer and pizza. read more

See all

Upon first looks on the place it seemed kind run down. Not a very clean location on the outside. However, we decided to sit on the patio. The drinks and food were pretty good. If you are looking for some unique breweries check this place out. read more

Thirsty Pagan Brewing - Breweries Near Me - Superior, Wisconsin

See all

After a trip to the Minnesota high point, this was EXACTLY what we were looking for: Staff: outstanding service and very friendly. (this is WI so, that's a given.) Beers: average selection of standard beers, but some great seasonals! Food: they make pizza, but it is 100% their own. I don't even know how to describe this style of pizza. It's think, but it ain't cakey and it certainly ain't deep dish. It's unlike any pizza I have ever had. Ambiance: the best aspect of this brewery, live music EVERY NIGHT. Don't hesitate to cross the bridge into 'Sconi! read more

Thirsty Pagan Brewing - Good friends, United in Wisconsin - Breweries Near Me - Superior, Wisconsin

Went here on a Wednesday night while in town. We were surprised by some live music when we arrived. We didn't catch the singers name, but were very impressed. Also impressive is the number of rooms to this restaurant. We were in what seemed like one of the main sections, but as we looked around, we found a few more dining areas. Our waitress was quick to come and get our drink order and appetizer order and was very friendly. We ended up ordering a flight of four beers: North Coast Amber, Burntwood Black, Lawnchair, and Room for Cream. My favorite was the amber as it was smooth and very drinkable. My friend's favorite was the Room for Cream, which he described as the best light coffee beer he's had. This one worked very well, where most don't. For our appetizer, we got the lasagna rolls with sausage. It was quite tasty and the ricotta was thick and well flavored. The sausage also had a nice little kick to it to cut the cream. Also ordered was the chicken alfredo pizza, but with the standard red sauce as opposed to the alfredo. It had a nice pan style crust and the presentation was pretty fun in the pan. Definitely one of the better pizzas I've had and that was without the chicken on it! Odd occurrence we had was that we took a couple slices and couldn't taste/find any chicken on our chicken alfredo pizza. We mentioned it to our waitress and she checked with the kitchen. They told her that the chicken was finely shredded, but we couldn't taste or find it, so she ended up bringing us out a cup of chicken. The pizza was even better with the addition of its main ingredient. Overall, great service and very good food and beers. Only downside is that the pizzas are on the more expensive side with the 13" pizzas being slightly more expensive than the 16" pizzas at most places. They do taste good though. read more

See all

The food was insanely expensive!! ( $40 for a large pizza) Our server did not talk to us Also drinks were $9 for a N/A cocktail Tables were put very close togather! read more

We went this evening and we were a party of thirteen. We got to the room and they didn't have enough chairs. The band was nasty sounded like three cats in a fight. Then we ordered and I ordered a salad asked for pepper and was told they were out of pepper. They didn't have enough plates and silverware. The kicker was the gratuity that was tacked on was 20% and we got hit with a plastic tax and we were asked again if we were going to add more tip on top of that. read more

We went here on a nice day out front with our dogs. There wasn't the most shade but still, a nice area to enjoy some great brews and pizza with the pups. The staff was really nice and the Derailed pizza was the best supreme or works-style I've ever had. Perfect not too deep dish almost Detroit style pan pizza. Really really good stuff! read more

Thirsty Pagan Brewing - Breweries Near Me - Superior, Wisconsin

See all

It's a small town brewery with a great selection of good beer. We really enjoyed our visit here. The beertenders were very helpful and let us order samples before committing to a pint. Thirsty Pagan has the finesse of a brewery, but the heart of a small town bar. read more

3.5 Stars Pizza and brewery in cool old train depot building. We were on the road and ate dinner at an odd time so it wasn't busy or loud. I had the curry naan and hummus for an appetizer, my husband had the Reuban rolls, we shared the Mediterranean pizza (with chicken added), and we each had a beer. The hummus and naan was very tasty, but my husband said his app was just OK. That was made up for, however, with how delicious the pizza was. In spite of the Mediterranean being way more style (my husband is more of a sausage and mushroom pizza guy), my husband repeatedly exclaimed over how good it was! I also liked that it was a little on the well done side. Points off for: a hair on the bottom of the pizza pan and pretty dirty bathrooms. I will also note that there's a small stage in the main dining room and we were relieved that there was not live music while we were there! I'm old and don't like surprise concerts. I would suggest walking around the building a bit to take a peek at the historic train depot. Also, keep a close eye out when looking for the building, the small Thirsty Pagan Brewing sign is not super obvious to spot. I'd come back for the tasty pizza next time we're in Duluth or Superior. read more

Truth be told, if this was a food, more specifically pizza, review, it would be five stars. This is modest deep dish pizza, not as grandiose as Chicago or Detroit, but unquestionably delicious. It was the second of three pizzas tried the day I visited (Luce and Ursa were the others) and it was our favorite. We happened to be here New Years Eve, amongst a great staff that were accommodating and friendly, and listening to, presumably, a talented local artist. I'd like to recuse myself of absolute authenticity here as I have done with other nearby breweries I have not had as many visits to justify the veracity of my arbitrary stars. The beers I tried were fine. Not great, not bad, just middle of the road. This probably was my only reason to cast aside one star during this review, though I hope to return and have my mind and taste buds blown for my next visit. Definitely worth putting on your to-do list if you're in Duluth or Superior, and easily worth the moderate cab fare to get here if coming from the former. read more

Thirsty Pagan Brewing - TPB Special - Breweries Near Me - Superior, Wisconsin

Five stars for the pizza and food, really good stuff. Their beer is not up to the level of the food, but as a whole this experience is great. Love the old train depot being repurposed. Great place to take the family out for pizza or to grab a craft beer. The building is 5 stars too, I love old train depots read more

Thirsty Pagan Brewing - In an old train depot! Super cool building - Breweries Near Me - Superior, Wisconsin

Really cool building that was an old train station. There was also a cute patio out front with string lights and flowers but the weather was a little chilly and rainy so we opted to sit inside. Monday happy hour specials were pretty good - $4.25 draft beers and $6 apps. We got the chicken parm dip, a cream ale, and the "O hell wit it" witbier to start. I didn't love the chicken parm dip and probably wouldn't order again, but it wasn't bad. The beer was super good though, especially the wit, nice and refreshing summer beer. We also ordered the special Korean BBQ pizza and it was amazing! Pork belly, gochujang sauce, and kimchi were the perfect amounts of everything and something a little different than our norm for pizza toppings. The 13" was more than enough for two people with leftovers too. Very friendly and quick service so we really enjoyed this pizza spot on our way through town! read more

Thirsty Pagan Brewing - Korean BBQ 'za - Breweries Near Me - Superior, Wisconsin

See all

Loved this wonderful find, just off the beaten path. Located in an old train depot, the atmosphere is perfect for a brew pub serving amazing pizza. The beer selection was impressive as was the live music! We ordered the Derailed pizza which was so loaded with ingredients, we had to use knives and forks to shovel in the greatness. Hannah was our server and did an amazing job of taking care of us. We will definitely be by making this a frequent spot any time we are in Superior. Highly recommend this place, and it's family friendly too! read more

See all

We visited Thirsty Pagan Brewing with our kids. The building is neat and the kids loved the train that came by while we where eating. The Cauliflower pizza was awesome as well as the other two we tried with their regular crust . Service was great and so was the beer and root beer. Their desserts where a great way to end our meal and are big enough for 5 of us to share. read more

See all

Great Pizza, Beer, and they also know how to mix a great drink! Service was great also. We've heard good things about this place but it exceeded expectations. The only negative is it's a little on the pricey side. read more

Thirsty Pagan Brewing - Artichoke pizza ( Weekly special) - Breweries Near Me - Superior, Wisconsin

See all

This was my first time visiting the new location. It's much larger than the previous location. There was wonderful live music playing. The pizza was delicious as always. The server was great. Tasty beer! read more

Thirsty Pagan Brewing - TPB Special - Breweries Near Me - Superior, Wisconsin

Food was good, beer was good, music was good, service was good but it's not deep dish pizza. It's regular pizza in a deep pan

This is an amazing place. The depot setting is really cool. We had a train go by right outside that shook the floor while we were eating. The beer that I had with lunch was tasty. We had a really good pizza. I was able to buy a growler to take home. This was a very nice experience that we hope to repeat in the near future. read more

See all

Historic (old Superior train depot next to an active track!), fun vibe and relaxed atmosphere here! We had an awesome experience here at Thirsty Pagan Brewing! The brews were tasty and the Derailed Pizza was superb! We got a growler to go, since it was so hard to stop at two favorites! The Detailed Pizza offered everything imagined on a pizza (it was worth it BY THE POUND!) Our server had everyone for lunch spread out and had his mask on the whole time. We felt very safe in this establishment. read more

See all

Pizza was great--we had the 10" TPB and that was enough for 2 of us. We also tried their ranch based on reviews and it's a MUST! I had never had pizza with a side of ranch, but when the ranch is this good--you find anything you can to dip into it. read more

Cost. They nickel and dime you. Two burgers and one salad was $72.00. The problem is they don't tell you it's an extra cost. For example, I ordered thousand Island dressing for my burger and it was an extra cost. I would not recommend it. read more