Cancel

Open app

Search

Thelma Carol Wine

4.7 (10 reviews)
Closed • 2:00 pm - 8:00 PM

THELMA CAROL WINE · YELP ASSISTANT

Ask Yelp Assistant

Thelma Carol Wine Photos

THELMA CAROL WINE ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Outdoor seating
Dogs allowed

You might also consider

More like Thelma Carol Wine

Recommended Reviews - Thelma Carol Wine

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Croatian Manhattan w/ Orahovac.
B R.

What a spot. Find everything you need for proper adult enjoyment-liquor, wine, conservas A must visit when in Milwaukee. Great bar and helpful service. Can't say enough about the comfort of the room.

shelves of wine in a wine shop
Nancy B.

An update to my previous review to say that they have reopened and the place looks great. Ample selection of wines and very cool vibe make this place a great spot to stop by in Walker's Point.

See all

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of D.S. A.
9
419
477

7 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0

3 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of B R.
1
107
81

11 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

I love this place. Amazing staff and great drinks. The atmosphere is library chic and very welcoming. Will be back here again. :)

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Jerel was absolutely amazing, knowledgeable and personable. We wanted to spend all night at his bar. 10/10 recommend

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Louis L.
2
114
316

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Thelma Carol Wine

Review Highlights - Thelma Carol Wine

“Jerel and Rebecca are some of the most knowledgeable people when it comes to wine and spirits.”

Mentioned in 2 reviews

Read more highlights

Verify this business for free

People searched for Wine Bars 431 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Mother’s - Fried Tofu (gluten friendly!)

Mother’s

4.1(27 reviews)
2.8 mi•Bay View

First time here. It's a historic building on the south end of Bay View. A big old white building…read more(previously called the White House) with a small parking lot on the south side. We had reservations at 6:00 on a Saturday night. (It was cold, a little drizzly, and windy out.) The front entrance has several steep steps, and when you walk through, you are literally at the host station. They were going to seat us right behind the host station, but we knew it was going to be a problem as people went in and out. We asked to be seated a little farther from the door, and after a bit of discussion (it sounded like this was going to be a little issue), they were able to find a table for two in the parlor. So glad! Got settled in right away with menus and waters. Our server did a good job of getting us up to speed on the menu, the service, and the cocktails. They did a very good job throughout the evening (thanks, Roberto). We settled on the Window Seat (Beef Tallow and Rosemary Washed Vodka, crazy but true) and the Night Clubbing (with espresso-infused Campari). Both were very good choices. We decided that we wanted to start with three dishes and then regroup if we needed more. These included the Bok Choy Salad, Cumin and Cinnamon Braised Pork Shoulder, and Venison Tartare (Dijon Ice Cream?). The Bok Choy Salad was a real surprise, with the entire collection being so bright and flavorful. The dates had a meaty quality. The dressing with Nuoc Cham was savory with just a bit of heat. We both decided that we could have made an entire meal of that. The Pork Shoulder came next and was a good portion, with the meat tender and flavorful. The Quinoa Polenta was interesting, but I can't say that it was something I would seek out. I have had Beef Tartare before, but this was a first for Venison Tartare, so of course I just had to order it. What struck me first was that the entire thing (not just the Dijon Ice Cream) was very cold, almost frozen. I tried a couple of bites, and it was so cold that unless you let it sit in your mouth to thaw out, it was somewhat tasteless. I spread it around the plate to thaw out, and it was a big improvement. It's a good-sized portion, and even after loading up on the three pieces of bread, there was still plenty left (maybe a couple more pieces of bread?). There were a couple of desserts that we would have loved to try, but we were full and had a performance to attend. So we will have to wait until next time. Really enjoyed our first dinner. Loved the inventiveness of the menu. The staff all seem to really care about the business and the diners. With the placement of the front door and the draftiness of the dining room, we will likely book our next dinner when the weather turns warmer.

What a gem of a place located in a street corner in a historic house in Bayviee. This place had a…read morecozy but spacious feel. They were festive with Halloween decorations and had a gothic feel. I tried the lamb jerk dumplings and tofu. Highly recommend. They both had unique flavors especially the lamb. The tofu had a nice crispy texture to it with the soy based sauce glazed over it with scallions. I also tried a mocktail version of La Pucelle, it wasn't explicitly listed in the mocktails section so you can order a mocktail version of some the alcoholic cocktails. For dessert I tried the Panna Cotta, it was my first time ever trying it and tho go get it was really good. It had a pomegranate sorbet scoop on top sprinkled with frankincense laid on a bed of shaved ice with the creamy base at the bottom of the bowl. It was refreshing! The waiter was very helpful, he explained how they served food and drinks and when I asked about I n residents for the dessert he was able to describe them in detail.

Photos
Mother’s - Beetroot Chocolate Cake (gluten friendly!)

Beetroot Chocolate Cake (gluten friendly!)

Mother’s - Shishito Peppers (gluten-friendly!)

Shishito Peppers (gluten-friendly!)

Mother’s - Pork Shoulder (gluten friendly!)

See all

Pork Shoulder (gluten friendly!)

Thief Wine Shop & Bar - Very nice cheese plate.

Thief Wine Shop & Bar

4.3(110 reviews)
0.8 mi•Historic Third Ward
•$$

I only tried the orange wine- but it was absolutely delicious. Kind of dry and floral, not too…read moresweet. Really loved how the location was right in the middle of the market, and close to my hotel. I'm more of a wine drinker, which is a little harder to cater to in MKE, so really glad this spot exists. Will definitely be coming back when I'm in the area!

This place is fantastic. I have never been to the public market on a weekend. It was…read more.. overwhelming. I was staying nearby, an was planning a little picnic, I knew theif wine shop would be perfect. They have the bar setup in the middle, but I was feeling a bit crushed by all the people and just perused around the bottle area. Their selection is fantastic. They have it separated by location and cover all price points. Everyone can find something. I was given space to look around. Twice someone asked me if I needed help, but it was polite and not pushy. Once I found a Montepulciano I was interested in, someone came over from the bar to check me out. I asked him if it was possible to get one of the cheese trays to go, and was told it was no problem. He would ring it up for me and get right on it. He offered me a seat at the bar while I waited, but I was happy just looking at their other wine options. The cheese plate was super tasty, and a really good value at $15. There were four cheeses, grapes, almonds, crasins, and bread. We really liked the selection and were impressed with the size. Seriously nothing but good things to say. A wonderful reason to visit the market.

Photos
Thief Wine Shop & Bar
Thief Wine Shop & Bar
Thief Wine Shop & Bar

See all

Blu - The view from Blu.

Blu

4.1(176 reviews)
1.1 mi•Downtown, East Town
•$$$

We went to Blu for afternoon tea and it was incredible. From the moment we walked in and saw the…read moreamazing view of the city, we were hooked. We were seated by the window. Our tea package was a gift and as first timers we weren't sure what to expect. We had the option of a mimosa or prosecco to start. While sipping on our prosecco, our tea butler stopped by to present the teas. She did a great job describing everything, it was hard to pick! I went with a tangerine ginger, and my sister went with the vanilla. We both took her recommendations for infusions. You receive a generous amount of tea. The presentation of snacks and treats is beautiful. We had the luxe menu and enjoyed everything. An extra bottle of prosecco had been tacked on and when we were ready, staff popped it open and kept it chilled next to our table. The pianist was lovely. Played great music and also did a round of happy birthday. We were celebrating my birthday so I was gifted a slice of carrot cake which was delicious. While this isn't something you would do all the time, we are already looking forward to coming back for another birthday celebration.

The Blu is such an amazing lounge with amazing views of the city. The bathroom scene is…read moreeverythang!! Yummy crafted signature cocktails for any mood so you won't be disappointed! Marcus is great addition to the bar mixing up some goodness. Dale was witty & entertaining as well. I can't wait to return on a Friday or Saturday night for live music. This lounge is #BarbieApproved

Photos
Blu - Cocktails in Blu!

Cocktails in Blu!

Blu
Blu

See all

Pilot Project Brewing - Milwaukee - Sunday Brunch

Pilot Project Brewing - Milwaukee

4.2(145 reviews)
1.3 mi•Westown, Bronzeville
•$$

I was looking for a good brewery to try in the city and stumbled across Pilot Project. With a great…read moreselection of brews and delicious food, this absolutely fit the bill. It was a little industrial with a lot of seating, so this is a good spot to balance getting those fun going-out vibes with actually securing a seat. There seemed to be something for everyone on the menu, and they had a lot of collabs with other businesses. We opted for two different IPAs that were both delicious. For food, we split the cheese curds, hummus, and BBQ pork Mac and cheese. The cheese curds were extra crispy and I loved the garlic Parmesan seasoning. The chive crema served alongside was herby, creamy, and unique, giving a refreshing contrast. I enjoyed the selection of veggies with the hummus and the grilled garlic naan was delicious, though the hummus itself did taste just like the Sabra red pepper kind that you could buy in a store. However, the Mac and cheese absolutely stole the show- it was decadently cheesy with a wonderful white cheddar sauce, and the pork itself was slightly sweet and super tender. The scallions and jalapeños completed the picture perfectly. Would definitely recommend ordering this. The bartender taking our orders was also super nice and even brought a complimentary pour due to the wait for the second round, which we'd not mentioned at all. Overall, we had a great experience and would absolutely return next time we're in the area!

Celebrated a friend's birthday and there nothing better than the bartender helping support your…read moremission to make it special! If you're wondering if you can make a candle sit up right in a cocktail- I tried it , and proved you can! Pina Coladas are nothing short of *amazing* Wild Wisco linedancing was the perfect haven for when the tornado alert went off in Milwaukee. Getting home a huge tree was split in half so grateful to have been elsewhere!

Photos
Pilot Project Brewing - Milwaukee - Rooftop Cocktails Happy Hour

Rooftop Cocktails Happy Hour

Pilot Project Brewing - Milwaukee - Stouts!

Stouts!

Pilot Project Brewing - Milwaukee - Taco Special

See all

Taco Special

Thelma Carol Wine - wine_bars - Updated November 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...