Good LORD this place knocked my socks off. After hearing my vegetarian girlfriend RAVE about their grilled cheese, I finally gave in and decided to give The Toasted Pickle a shot. And by god, was I impressed. It's a small little sandwich shop off of Michigan Ave that has seating for maaaybe 20 people. I ordered the spicy chicken sandwich to go, and when I got home to open my box, my jaw dropped. These guys put not one, but TWO mf chicken breast cutlets on this poor, poor bun. Topped with delicious house made pickles (their namesake), a fresh and tangly slaw, and a spicy oily sauce, this thing was a behemoth. And for, like, $15?? This is two meals for the average person. My only complaint was that the bun simply could not shoulder the monstrous burden of what it contained. Additionally, dude the fries are phenomenal. And they absolutely LOAD you up. Get the truffle upcharge, it's worth it I promise. I have been a Two Beards fan for the better part of the past 15 years, but man, in terms of value, The Toasted Pickle takes the cake. I can't wait to experience whatever else these guys are whipping up behind the counter. read more

The Toasted Pickle - Spicy chicken sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Grand Rapids, Michigan

See all

We love The Toasted Pickle at Grand Haven. The line is always a mile long there so I was expecting a wait at this newer location. It was busy for sure with all seats full inside. We decided to get our order to go. The restaurant was clean. The service was fast. We tried a couple of the sandwiches that had turkey - Long Tall Sally and Sixie from Dixie. Both sandwiches were stuffed with plenty of meat. One was on the gluten free bread. And the bread actually had good flavor but was literally dripping with butter. Way too much butter. The other sandwich had no issues and was delicious as usual. The pickles were all very soggy and not that great this time. Overall, they were great! It was our first time trying the gluten free bread but next time I would tell them to lighten up on the butter. Otherwise, I will be coming back to try more. I am glad they came to Grand Rapids. read more

The Toasted Pickle - Outside - Sandwiches Near Me - Grand Rapids, Michigan

See all

We really enjoy the Grand Haven location, so we were excited to see a new location in Grand Rapids. I ordered online and made my way over to the restaurant to pick our order up. I received the, "Order Ready" text right as I pulled in. They make it very clear to not pull into the drive thru until you receive that text but the parking lot is very tight so this can be kinda tricky. The guy working the window was very friendly and my food was waiting for me. I really enjoyed The Hooker, which is their fish sandwich. I also had a cup of spicy corn chowder, which was delicious. My wife had a half salad and half sandwich while we shared an order of truffle fries. Honestly, we really enjoyed all of the food. The prices are definitely steep. In total, we had a cup of soup, 1 full sandwich, 1 half sandwich, half a salad, and fries. Our total came out to $50 for two people for lunch. We would have it again. read more

The Toasted Pickle - "The Hooker" (fish sandwich) and cup of Spicy Corn Chowder - Sandwiches Near Me - Grand Rapids, Michigan

After a day of running errands we decided to place a pick up order for lunch on our way home. It has recently opened, so we expected a bit of a wait, but online ordering in the platform was very straightforward and sends a text when food is ready which was convenient. The interior was clean and efficient for pickup. We had a turkey sandwich, stacked Mac, fries and a pickle to share. It was a ton of food. The Mac did surprise me and was super tasty. Also liked their fries - definitely try some of their yummy sauces too, so good! Overall a good edition to the GR area. read more

See all

I've had The Toasted Pickle in both Rockford and Grand Haven before, so it's exciting that they opened this location much closer to my house. I stopped in during their first week open and ordered some lunch. They currently aren't taking online orders as it seems like they've been pretty slammed with people coming in, especially around the lunch rush. There were a few people in line ahead of me, which gave me time to browse the menu. I ordered the half Dixie from Sixie, the Smokin' Dragon, and an order of their beer battered fries. They let me know that I'd get a text when my order was ready, which I could pick up in the drive through or inside. I went back to my car to wait - it was about 20 minutes until I got the text, and it took a few minutes for them to greet me at the drive through, but again, it was their first week open and they were BUSY! The food was as delicious as I remembered from my other visits - the sandwiches were stuffed and even the half sized sandwich was large for me. (Their half sized sandwiches are a smaller version, not just half the meat.) Prices are very reasonable and in line with other similar sandwich shops (like Schnitz Deli). The quality of the food was great and their fries are awesome. I will definitely be back! P.S. Yes, parking kind of sucks, and they don't have a ton of space to dine in. You can pay to park in the lot behind Grand Coney across the street, or find street parking on Michigan or the side streets. read more

See all

This was my first time trying any of the Toasted Pickle locations, and I ordered takeout via Toast. The food was ready on time within 20 minutes. The milkshake was kept cold, which I appreciated, and the oreo flavor was delicious. The cuban sandwich was unique; not exactly traditional, but good flavor! The housemade pulled pork wasn't mind-blowing, but good. I liked the amount of bacon on it, as well as the sweet&spicy pickled and aioli. Really my only complaint is the truffle fries were not impressive. I didn't taste any truffle, although the fries themselves were OK. I don't think the pimento cheese pairs well with the truffle fries, so maybe I'd try the other dip next time, if anything. There are a few other sandwiches I definitely want to try, plus with the yummy milkshakes, I will order here again. read more

See all

We're super excited that the Toasted Pickle is now in Grand Rapids! Whenever we visit Grand Haven, we often stop at the Toasted Pickle for delicious sandwiches. This time, our visit to their new location was for Poutine Week, and it was great to check out the new place. It's has a cozy, hole-in-the-wall feel, and the counter service reminds me of old sandwich delis. Their contribution to Poutine Week took a deviation from traditional poutine with their Triple Pickle Poutine. We also enjoyed taking shots of pickle juice while waiting for our food. We're excited for the chance to go back and try some of their regular menu items at the new location. read more

The Toasted Pickle - Triple Pickle Poutine (Poutine Week special) - Sandwiches Near Me - Grand Rapids, Michigan

Love this place! I've now been to the Grand Rapids location multiple times, and I keep coming back for a reason. It's a cozy little space on Michigan Street with takeout, pick-up and dine-in options. The food is great and the service has always been very friendly. I've sampled multiple menu items and have not had a bad one yet. While the French Dip and Italian Bomber are good, I have been gravitating towards their burgers, which are exceptional. My boys and I have tried over 40 places for burgers in the GR area, and this is one of our very favorites. The Pickle Poppers and Truffle Fries are tasty sides and the 'Pickle Dippin' Sauce' is quite addictive. read more

See all

The food was great and i had a lovely time with my husband! You guys do food great keep it up!

Excellent sandwich! Hot French Dip on a cold day hits the spot. Dragon Fruit Lemonade tastes great but wish they had hot drinks on a subzero day like today. Plenty of comfy seating and very pleasant service from the staff. I plan to return often. read more

The Toasted Pickle - French Dip and Dragon Fruit Lemonade - Sandwiches Near Me - Grand Rapids, Michigan

Toasted pickle has some of the best and most unique options in the area! The portions are generous especially for the price. The truffle fries are a must try and you can't go wrong with the long tall Sally or famous green goddess. Everything's is made super fresh and you can taste the quality in every ingredient. read more

The Toasted Pickle - Sandwiches Near Me - Grand Rapids, Michigan

FAAAANNNNTTTAAAAAASSSSTTTTTIIIIIIICCC! I was in town for work and went two days in a row. I got The Hooker the second day and it was my first ever sandwich that needed eaten with a knife and fork. read more

The Toasted Pickle - Sandwiches Near Me - Grand Rapids, Michigan

I'd heard a lot about the other Toasted Pickle locations and was eager to check this one out. So far, it's okay. I'm impressed with the number of tables they were able to cram into the former Mai's Thai shop, but, when it's crowded, things get cramped in there. Definitely better as a pick-up restaurant than a sit down. Food has been average so far: the sandwiches are not memorable but they're good enough. Lots of room to improve, and I hope they will! A $15 sandwich is a hard swing for me -- regardless of how common an occurrence it is across GR. read more

Back again - this place is going to be a problem for my heath. Very good and have been impressed. read more

The Toasted Pickle - Green Goddess - so good. The goat cheese makes the whole thing - Sandwiches Near Me - Grand Rapids, Michigan

See all

I highly recommend this place when you're in the area! I had the best burger in my entire life here and it was amazing! I love that you're able to serve yourself and don't have to relay on waiters. Only thing I'm not the biggest fan of is it is a little pricey. Still very very good!! read more

Great food! Loved the turkey sandwich and burger we ordered. Prices felt reasonable and we tried a few extra menu items just to scope out the place a little better. We didn't try anything we wouldn't want to order again! read more

So good!! I love pickles and I haven't had a bad sandwich yet!!!! Definitely will be coming back for more

My Nashville sandwich was kinda tasty. It had a good crunchy crust. It was hard to decide what to get there were so many choices.

Amazing Food! Happy, Upbeat and Pleasant Service! It's very clean & I'll be back again!

Yes, that is the thinnest "1/2" chicken I've ever seen. This is criminal!!! lol Chick-Fil-A's hot chicken sandwich has 5x more chicken in it and is 1/2 the cost of this sandwich. read more

The Toasted Pickle - 1/2 chicken hot sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Grand Rapids, Michigan

Incredible addition to a town with an already great food scene. We've always enjoyed the Toasted Pickle in Grand Haven and were thrilled to see this today. I can't name many places that have pickle juice dispensers at the front of the restaurant! Anyways, the store just opened and the staff is getting their legs but everyone working there was super friendly and willing to make the experience great. There is adequate seating inside with a pretty nice renovated interior but the drive through addition just sweetens the deal. Highly recommend the Green Goddess sandwich and the Mac n Cheese. read more

Im a Foodie and the food I had here was mid. Wouldn't mind trying something else though.

Tried it without the turkey, it was good. Still would have preferred it with my 3$ turkey. read more

The Toasted Pickle - Alec +turkey. Paid 3+ extra for turkey and didn't receive turkey. - Sandwiches Near Me - Grand Rapids, Michigan

See all

This was a soft open, but I can see some major pains. One, the shop is small. Maybe 6 tables, very cramped. Parking is small. They need outside tables. Two, cost is EXPENSIVE! 4 people was $80!! $20 a person for a sandwich?? They are good but not $20 good. IDK, I would eat again but it wouldn't be my first place to head to. I'd rather stop at Grand Coney across the street. read more

The salad was ok but lacked ingredients. Most of it was greens. My friend had a sandwich and she said it was very good. All you get is a pickle with your sandwich, fries etc. are extra. They are pricey for what you get. Seating is limited in the winter but in the summer they have a nice deck area. Employees were very friendly. read more

Amazing Italian bomber sandwich! So big I could only eat half. New place with good food.

We love everything about the Toasted Pickle. Every location has consistently great food! If you just want a cheap hotdog, go somewhere else.‍ read more