Overall some great things and some okay things: They have a large outdoor seating which is nice. I got the steak and it was cooked very well. The bread was good. My dirty martini was tasty. Service was friendly Some things they good do better: It wasn't very busy and the food and drinks came out slow. The fries were just okay. Portions in some of the dishes were small for the price. read more

See all

Had a nice lunch at The Tavern at the Colgate Inn. We ate the corn chowder soup and Caesar salad. The soup is creamy and made from local sweet corn with potatoes and bacon. It is hearty and delicious on a chilly day. The salads were crisp with tasty Caesar dressing, shaved Parmesan, and big croutons. The service was friendly and the fireplace is very inviting. read more

See all

With great outdoor seating at the Colgate inn, the Tavern is great for lunch or dinner, or even just grabbing a beer at the bar. The burger and fish came out quickly and the service from the staff was attentive while dealing with several others. In terms of price, this is a pricier option in Hamilton for the quantity of food. My suggestion is to go to the bar or "the library" their speakeasy and grab drinks here for the experience and to see the beautiful inn and grab food in the town to continue exploring. read more

See all

Came for lunch. The Colgate Inn Tavern once was very good. Haven't been here in years, but decided to give it a try since there are limited dining choices in Hamilton, NY. My friend and I started with the soup of the day, loaded potato soup. Arrived luke warm after a 20 minute wait. Decided not to send it back to reheat, because we had already waited 20 minutes! If it had been HOT, it would have been really tasty, if it had been hot. We also ordered the endive and golden beet salad, which showed up 15 minutes after the soup. Fortunately it was supposed to be served cold and was delicious. See photo read more

The Tavern - Beet & Pistachio Salad - American Near Me - Hamilton, New York

When not familiar with food establishments in a town, I always seek a place with a 4+ rating in Yelp, and have never been disappointed! That includes this place! Oh my! The soup of the day for lunch was French Onion, and I think it was the best I've ever had! Definitely top 3. The turkey panini was excellent also. And the chocolate chip cookie skillet dessert was just the right size - and fantastic! I will be back here! My server was Shannon, and she was also fantastic- attentive, and served the food with perfect timing - I wasn't rushed to finish any part of my meal, and the next item was served upon completion of the former. I can't wait to return! read more

The Tavern - French Onion Soup - American Near Me - Hamilton, New York

See all

Lisa A was amazing on wednesday!!! amazing service, amazing food, and amazing everything!! the atmosphere was very comforting and laid back. i will definitely be coming back!! read more

Visiting from CT for a family memorial service early this morning and after being on the road for hours and truly exhausted, was greeted by the friendliest of smiles by Amanda at the Front desk and then then pointed me to the restaurant. Upon entering The Tavern Inn, Shannon immediately offered a nice hot cup of coffee (which I soo needed). My husband and I came back for lunch and we were greeted by my morning g friend, Shannon, and Glenda at the bar, and we had the burger and fries which was so Juicy, tasty and awesome! We went back to the restaurant for dinner, and I personally requested Shannon as our waitress/server. Her smile is infectious and she helped me reclaim my favorite umbrella that I left behind earlier! For dinner, we ordered the Bavarian pretzel sticks as an appetizer (so yummy), and I had the cod special which was delicious and my husband had the mushroom cavatappi. Great recommendations for dinner....! This place is a gem! The staff is amazing, the food is awesome and reasonably priced, great ambiance, and the service matches the best of any 5 star restaurant. Will be back again when visiting family for sure. Highly recommended!! Marie C. Stratford, CT read more

Beyond disappointed!! The new menu is not worth your while. Way over priced...putting low priced ingredients in trendy bowls and over charging for them is offensive. An embarrassing money grab in my opinion. This establishment would be smart to consider a summer menu for locals using products from local farms! Live right down the road and will no longer consider going there and will let others know. read more

Had a great a lunch experience here. Our server Shannon was super attentive and helpful. The French onion soup was delicious and the atmosphere was very cozy! read more

Ate here for dinner and breakfast. The food is fantastic, the Waygu burger was flavorful, juicy and well prepared. The pretzels were obviously made fresh in house, slightly crisp on the outside but doughy and spongy inside. The wine list is well thought out, and has some seriously well priced gems if you know what to order. The next morning my 16 year old son said it was at the level of the Michelin starred restaurant I am a partner in. The biscuits and gravy were extremely well prepared. Service was friendly and attentive, and speed was what you should expect from a restaurant like this. Actually, breakfast came out much quicker than I would have expected. I would highly recommend the tavern. We were staying at the Colgate Inn, but we almost did not eat here because of the recent negative reviews. I don't usually review restaurants as I am a partner in a fine dining establishment, but I felt I had to comment on the Tavern's quality. read more

Yummy! The maple glazed salmon had amazing flavor and was cooked perfectly. The house cut fries with garlic aioli were very good as well. The scallops in the scallop risotto were very flavorful and well cooked, but the actual risotto had a bit of an odd flavor. Overall, though, a delicious meal finished off with a warm cookie skillet. You can't go wrong with that! read more

The Tavern - Maple glazed salmon (so good!), delish house cut fries with garlic aoli, and scallops and risotto in the back - American Near Me - Hamilton, New York

Saturday 2/15/20 Our server Brian was excellent. French onion soup Steak Quesadilla $15 Beef Tenderloin, Pico de Gallo, Jewett's Cheddar Cheese, Fruit of the Fungi Mushrooms Wine Tuscan. Excellent. Corn Chowder Spicy Grilled Turkey Burger $13 Chipotle, Lettuce, Tomato, Lime Cilantro Slaw, Flour & Salt Brioche Bun. Excellent. They have Excellent selection of Beer. Draft, Imported, Domestic, Domestic Craft and Local Craft Beers. A good selection of wine. read more

I have to be honest, the food was okay. Nice atmosphere and it is the only place open after 8:00? Nice selection of before dinner drinks. I especially liked my n/a beer. I ordered the strip steak. Cooked as I ordered and was no seasoned well. Oh no, served with instant potatoes? And while the carrots looked nice they were too undercooked. My son ordered the rib eye and felt it was overdone. He had asked for the potatoes to be swapped out for the wild rice. That didn't happen but we let it go at the time. A starch is a starch. His haricots were also undercooked. My other son got the salmon and rice. He ate quietly with no complaints. No bread basket? Was there a side salad option? read more

I had a great mid-week visit to Colgate and dinner at the Tavern was perfect. Sitting by the fireplace, my daughters and I enjoyed a leisurely dinner. Food was great - charcuterie, spinach & artichoke dip, wagyu (?) burgers. Service was attentive and friendly. The atmosphere cozy and what I consider "old New England. " We will be back. read more

You know...it's one of those places that I have often overlooked but super glad to have stopped in. I am not normally a tavern type of girl, looking for normal fare (burgers, fries, sandwiches). First of all...the atmosphere is cozy and inviting. The bar is beautiful, and there are plenty of tables. Second of all, they have home made pasta. We both ordered this - but different preparations. So glad we did. It was really delicious with plenty to bring home. Highly recommend the Greek app too. So much to share - you could even order that as a meal. We will be back, when cheering on the football team! read more

Limited menu but very well executed. The best poutine I've ever had! Absolutely delicious food and friendly service.

We arrived on a Friday at 1:00PM the room was ready and very clean and nice, we had lunch and dinner her and food was great. We recommend and will be staying here again soon. read more

Food was inedible. Not sure what these reviews are talking about. They didn't even have the hamburger they have in the picture. Tried to go to the diner but it closed at 7pm. **strongly avoid** read more

We went to the tavern this morning for brunch with our daughter. We were told it was a buffet --not my favorite but oh well, the place is super charming so why not. Well, the buffet bins were pretty empty, the eggs were crumbly and dry, there was no bread to go with the toaster, etc. We asked when more food would come out and they said a big group had just come through so we would have to wait for more food. We waited a while and then just ate the little that was there and then we (3 of us) were charged $100 (no alcohol just coffee). Ridiculous. Will not be going back. read more

Just got lunch to go here and I'd asked if they could put chipotle aioli on the side if they had it / if not no problem -- when I picked it up, the girl told me they didn't have it so she made her favorite 3 different dips for me to try. The caramel sauce for the sweet potato fries was really good and I never would've ordered that on my own. I just thought it was an extra kindness for her to do that, it made my day :) The sandwich was also delicious read more

I don't often write reviews but this place deserves recognition. The food is amazing to say the least, my whole table loved their dish so much they refused to share even a bite. The inside is cozy and warm, and the staff is so kind. Not to mention the bathrooms are pristine. read more

Great food - love to eat here when visiting my son at Colgate. Great atmosphere as well.

I took a trip to Upstate NY recently and wanted to find a nice restaurant to start the weekend. I found this restaurant on the Resy app and decided to take a drive. It definitely is in a remote area (I am from the city), but it is a hidden gem! Located in The Colgate Inn, which is a cute little hotel. I would have stayed at this hotel if I would have known. The staff is super friendly they make you feel like home. You definitely don't need to dress up for this place. The place was super clean and they have huge servings. I tried their mussels in butter which was soo good and their NY strip steak with summer veggies and corn. The NY strip steak was the biggest piece I have ever had, you can definitely split it between 2 people. The quality of the food was really good and our server made us a special drink- a summer old fashioned and made us feel at home. Definitely check this hidden place out! read more

Saturday afternoon (8.21)on a tour of Colgate we came in for lunch and were fine with a wait but it was clear the staff didn't have a handle on things as we waited for nearly 30m while empty tables were not bussed or just left clean but unseated. It was busy but not packed but the staff didn't do a good job and we left. Went to Rusch's had great service and good food. read more