I had a five star experience here at The Sugar Mill, as soon as you open the door you're hit with the sweet smells of goodies in the cake case. I ordered the Lemon Blueberry Cake slice and it was delicious. It's not easy to find lemon and blueberry in the same slice. Now I know exactly where to go when I feel like it's time to have the two inside one slice. I will be back here again soon. read more

See all

I was in love with the history they put into the business, I felt a part of a real mom and pop shop learning about how the skill was absolutely passed down on the plaque they have next to the counter. I found out about them via DoorDash maybe a month ago, but everything looks so much better in person. I've already ordered the slice of lemon blueberry cake twice, I tastes so good.. the mix between the fresh blueberry flavor in the middle and the pop of lemon on the icing both mixes so well with the fluffy cake. It's not too sweet, it's also a VERY nicely sized slice. If you're not sure what to get, I'd recommend that. The owner is very kind and you can tell him and his team put a lot into making sure every cake is made with the same level of care! I will definitely be back! read more

The SugarMill - Lemon BlueBerry Cake - Cupcakes Near Me - Conyers, Georgia

Best Bakery in Atlanta. Made fresh daily. I always order assorted cupcakes. But everything I've tried had been great.

I crossed the street without looking and almost got hit by a car once, that was the second closest I've been to experiencing Heaven. The first was when I tasted the cream cheese brownie from The Sugar Mill. A truly divine experience. Every dessert they serve is exceptional. /10 read more

Had a sweet tooth the other day, so I decided to try to bakery out since I was in the area. I asked if they had caramel cake (my favorite), but they didn't, so I chose the caramel cinnamon roll instead! It was very tasty! Very flaky and moist at the same time! The icing was great! My husband got the red velvet cake. I tried a piece of it, ....ok., not a big fan of red velvet though. I will be back again to try their other delicious looking goodies! read more

The SugarMill - Caramel Cinnamon Roll - Cupcakes Near Me - Conyers, Georgia

See all

These are hands down the best cupcakes I've ever had! Fresh, moist, and packed with flavor. The frosting is perfectly balanced--not too sweet. Highly recommend for anyone with a sweet tooth!" read more

My 5 year old: "Best cupcake ever!" This place is a gem. Island forward pastries with the classics as well. Super kid friendly service and ambiance, with many treats for grown ups only which I appreciated. Will be back for sure. Carrot cake next time, but Vienna cake was just so good. read more

The SugarMill - The best cupcake ever - Cupcakes Near Me - Conyers, Georgia

Grandmas POUND CAKE So it's really hard to find pound cake from scratch ‼ but if you know you know and this bakery knows how to make it THANK GOD I will be back read more

The SugarMill - I ate most of it lol but it's delicious - Cupcakes Near Me - Conyers, Georgia

See all

We ordered using UberEats one evening when are sweet tooth was screaming. We ordered 2 of everything and spent a very pretty penny. Cream cheese brownies were spongy, we prefer fudgy richness. The banana pudding cheesecake was good but didn't redeem the rest of the items we purchased and didn't like. All the cakes and cupcakes we received were incredibly dry and crumbly - really bad and we did not finish any of them. We had strawberry cake (icing too sweet), Virgin Island cake (almond flavor and multi-fruit fillings was tasty; but dryness ruined it), key lime cupcake, and chocolate cupcakes (burnt bitter flavor which wasn't espresso in nature). Wish we could say we enjoyed it better, but most went in the trash. We normally give the benefit of the doubt and try again, but with every baked item being so dry it will be hard to convince hubby to return. read more

I love this spot for a quick sweet tooth! This cupcakes are SO good, especially the red velvet. *chefs kiss

Best cupcakes I've had in a while! Will be back very soon, want to try cake slices next!

Hola! Just wanted to take a moment to applaud this spot. Their customer service is always exemplary and I am yet to make to a bad choice as we work our way through their menu. Most recently, they helped me pull off a 50th birthday surprise, which rendered this Virgo speechless. :) The cake was EVERYTHING we could have asked for and Mr. J's uncanny ability to hear and execute what his customers need remains evident. My baker is #betterthanyours :) read more

Excellent cakes but custom service needs improvement. I will visit again and try to overlook nasty behavior.

While visiting my mom with my kids, we decided try this place out. We purchased 3 cupcakes, key lime, cookies and cream, and chocolate. Two out of three were okay. We also purchased two slices of lemon pound cake, and a slice of strawberry cake. The pound cake was okay a bit dry but something I can finish off with some coffee. The strawberry cake was very, very dry not fresh at all! I gave it two stars because the place was cute and the service was great. But I'm sure we won't be back. read more

The SugarMill - Lemon Poundcake - Cupcakes Near Me - Conyers, Georgia

See all

This is my go to spot for my custom cake needs for any occasion. I also frequently get a few dessert items when I'm in the area. To top it off, this place has THE BEST customer service. Definitely worth the money and worth coming back each time after. Thank you to Cyrus and the staff! read more

See all

The address is actually in Conyers at 1427 Highway 138 SE. I tell you this because I'm really not that into sweets; but THIS place? OMG the cupcakes (one chocolate fudge and one red velvet), the cheesecake (cookies and cream, I was afraid of the red velvet, but it looked delicious), and good God the most buttery red velvet croissant with cream cheese filling and a chocolate drizzle, that you will EVER taste! The cupcakes are fresh and moist and absolutely heavenly in flavor. Everything is made in-house. Even the experiment (Venice - multiple layers of fruit-filled bliss; I wouldn't include the mint) was awesome and would make the perfect wedding cake. I finished EVERYTHING! read more

See all

I've purchased from this bakery three times & have been pleased with the quality. The cupcakes & croissant are excellent! The location & parking can be a challenge but so far that hasn't deterred me. I highly recommend! read more

Delicious! The owner of the store is so friendly and knowledgeable. It's a family owned shop which is nice to support. Their cupcakes are delicious, even if you put them in your fridge and microwave them, they still taste amazing! The price is very accurate for the quality of the dessert. The cheesecakes are phenomenal as well. Whenever I have a sweets craving I stop on in here! read more

This is a lovely family-owned bakery that is now my go-to destination for cakes, cupcakes, cheesecakes, cinnamon rolls..... whatever my sweet tooth craves. The almond amaretto cake is my favorite but the carrot cake is also great. Cakes are moist, not too sweet. My mom enjoys the croissants, (now I'm craving the turkey and pepper jack croissant!) Bakery is always clean, they also sell coffee and wifi is available. The owners take great pride in their business as they clearly appreciate their customers. I'll be back next week to pick up my baby girl's birthday cake! read more

The SugarMill - Cupcakes Near Me - Conyers, Georgia

See all

This is the best bakery I've ever been too. The pastries were incredibly delicious. We ordered the pistachio croissant, caramel cinnamon roll, keylime cupcake, and the carrot cake. Every item was amazing. The service was unbeatable. We will be regulars. I would have taken pictures but we couldn't wait to dig in. read more

My go to bakery for custom cakes. Great hospitality and service. Cake taste great. Will be back!!!!!

Whenever I want cheesecake this is my go to spot!! I am a forever customer and love that they take holiday orders. My favorites are strawberry cheesecake, lemon pound cake, strawberry pound cake. read more

I'm disappointed that I was very disappointed with my first visit here. I bought a variety of things: macadamia nut cookie, a piece of blueberry lemon cake, chocolate chip cookie and a caramel cinnamon bun. Both the cookies were dry and most certainly not fresh. Mind you cookies are made by someone else and sold at the bakery, but dry cookies reflect on the bakery. The blueberry lemon cake was okay, but I wouldn't order it again. Now, the last item, the caramel cinnamon bun was good, not great, but good. Save your money folks! read more

They have made both of my daughters birthday cakes a very special occasion. They make beautiful cakes that taste delicious!

Please update your hours of operation. Several websites and the door still read 'Open at 9' and I was told they weren't open until 11. That's a huge window of difference. read more

I be love this place. My favorite items are the key lime cupcake and the carrot cake cupcake. Every time I visit I am never disappointed. The cupcakes are the perfect size and just the right amount of sweetness, not to mention the flavors are amazing! read more

Phenomenal Cupcakes and the Lemon Blueberry Cake is one of the best I have ever eaten!! We will be return customers for our Bakery Needs!

Been visiting local bakeries in hopes of finding one that I would become my "go to" for all of my celebratory needs. The SugarMill is a very quaint, cozy establishment. The cakes and other baked goods looked very tasty. I ordered a couple cupcakes just to see if they tasted as good as they looked. I hate to say that I wasn't really impressed. The key lime cupcake tasted like a vanilla cupcake with a light key lime frosting. The same with the others. Compared to other establishments in the area with the same flavors, I probably wouldn't choose this place over the other. read more

My boyfriend and I visited this place while we were in town the other day.. and I have nothing but good things to say. I would definitely recommend this place to anyone craving some sweets! The people were very friendly and the cheesecakes were amazing! We will definitely be back next time we are in the area read more

AMAZINGLY Delicious!!! I stopped by for the first time with my 11 yrs old daughter who saw the store and would not stop until we visit and happy that we did. From the moment we stepped inside it was a warm and welcoming atmosphere. Everything looked amazing and as I talked with the owner as he decided the cakes and cupcakes I was blown away. I had the Virgin Island Vienna cake and OMG it was amazing! My wife is from the Virgin Islands and she "has never had better". Oh, And my daughter who can be snooty about store brand cakes...Publix and etc, had one word QUALITY!!! read more

SIMPLY DELICIOUS! Now, I have had the pleasure of eating many treats from this Bakery. Treats like cake, cinnamon rolls, cupcakes, croissants, cheesecake and many more. I promise you everything is SIMPLY DELICIOUS! Yesterday and Today I had a chance to eat a banana muffin and blueberry muffin from this Bakery. All I can say about the muffins is WOW! SIMPLY DELICIOUS! The muffins were moist, lots of flavor and BEAUTIFULLY PRESENTED! Listen, if you live in Conyers, Ga or plan on visiting, you must stop by this Bakery which is called "THE SUGAR MILL." You will be greeted by people that are friendly and loving. The atmosphere is awesome too! Go and treat yourself, you will not be disappointed!!!!! read more