The Stuffed Olive has ENDLESS flavors of martinis!!! Some of the flavors were a bit strange, like mashed potato or birthday cake. They all seem very interesting! I can't wait to come back and try more. We ordered the spinach artichoke flatbread which was super salty, but that wasn't a problem for me since I love a good salty snack paired with a super sugary drink! This place is suuuper cute and it's right next to I/O the arcade bar. Loved the vibes and had a great time. Thanks! read more

See all

Surprisingly fun spot, especially if you like martinis and unique drinks, their list is impressively long and fun. The appetizers I've tried have been good especially the stuffed olives, they service has been a bit inconsistent. Overall, worth checking out for the drinks! read more

The Stuffed Olive - Tapas Bars Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

Stuffed Olive has a hotel ambiance, the seats, lighting, and decor all feel comfortable corporate. There is typically available seating and the servers are quick to get to you. After you order your drinks you may need to wave them down if you are wanting more. The food is good but definitely a little over priced considering the size. There are a TON of martini options to choose from and very creative additions you can add. Plan on walking as it is not in a location with feasible parking options. This is a good spot to casually sip and chat with a friend or two! read more

See all

This is the absolute cutest and coziest little Restaurant. The ambience makes it perfect for date night, girls night, brunch or any sort of get together. The way the seating is set up, you even feel comfortable going to eat alone. The food was fresh and hot when he came out. The sliders with the caramelized onions was so tender and juicy. I didn't get the ghost pepper cheese because I knew it was going to be too hot for me. Also, the Thai chicken flatbread was enough for two people to share. The martinis oh my goodness the martinis!! From the picture you can tell that we were there in the daytime and we had to stop ourselves at one each. They were so good. This is a spot that we would definitely go back to. We totally enjoyed it & Staff was fantastic. read more

See all

This place has an extensive martini list! Amazing decor, lots of different seating options and very cool lighting! Service was great. We only tried a few tapas, but portions were small. All in all, a great date night spot or place to take visitors for apps & a martini or two before dinner. read more

See all

This was delish! We went as a part of the Madison Restaurant Week and so I got the $20 brunch which comes with one appetizer (monkey bread - divine!), one main (hangover burger) and one dessert (chia pudding). All of it was super yum! I wish that the burger had some more flavor, however. I also got a delicious bloody mary, perhaps my favorite one I've ever had! Our server was amazing! She was very attentive, helpful, and kind. The restaurant interior is also beautiful and is probably a wonderful place for a night out! read more

See all

Visiting a friend in Madison for a short weekend trip, and she recommended we go to The Stuffed Olive. It was so good, we came by the next night too!! The martini options seem endless, and all the drinks are absolutely delicious. Both visits our server was very attentive and gave great recommendations. The interior has a lot of seating options and also bar-seating. The lighting, in my opinion, was a bit too bright for a bar, wish it was either bright all the way or darker instead of an in-between dimness. We ordered 2 drinks each and we of course had to try each other's drinks, and sincerely could not decide which was the best because every drink was so delicious and came with adorable decor!! If I had any suggestions for this place, I would say I wish The Stuffed Olive had a tasting option for the drinks, maybe like best sellers tasting menu or a themed tasting menu based on the names of the martinis. I would absolutely try that, especially because I really wished I could try every martini option in the menu! If I'm ever visiting my friend again, I definitely will be coming back to The Stuffed Olive!!! read more

The Stuffed Olive - Big Berry, German Chocolate, Girl Scout Cookie - Tapas Bars Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

Service was great, we were a group of five with various check options needed and our server was so accommodating. She also gave great recommendations based on individual tastes. The atmosphere is casual but sophisticated, very nicely appointed. The drinks and food were exceptional. We ordered a variety of tapas and flatbreads to share. The Thai chicken flatbread was the only item that we thought could use improvement, maybe serve with a lime slice - it could use a touch of acid. Everything else was exceptional. Highly recommended! read more

See all

What a fun night out at this place!! Over 100 martinis to choose from. I had the cherry koolaid, and yes, it tasted like kool aid. Absolutely delicious! My husband had Daydreaming with Flora. That was tasty as well. It was crazy busy on a Saturday night. It was also the Saturday before St Patrick's day. Our server Danny was friendly and attentive , even with a busy crowd. This is a great place for groups and date nights. Can't wait to try more drinks! read more

The Stuffed Olive - Daydreaming with Flora - Tapas Bars Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

Attention ! As soon as we entered we were greeted and picked our location. Recently opened as I saw the construction process earlier this summer I have wanted to try Olive. 107 different cocktails and martinis, well 108 now. Sort of tapas/small plates but slightly larger. Red Pepper Hummus was flavorful and the veggies tasted right out of a garden. We also enjoyed the Med Flatbread but with added Italian Sausage. Seared Tuna was tender for not being Ahi but seared perfectly. Now back to 108, so I was chatting with our great server Juliette about the martinis. I asked about an Aperol Martini ? I didn't see it on the menu nor did she find it in her handheld. So we got to talking and created one. I initially thought Aperol with Vodka splash of OJ and Club Soda or a bubbly of choice would do the trick. Juliette chatted with Joe the bartender and got to work. What he created was Aperol with Makers Mark muddled lemon and strawberry with champagne. I love bourbon so it was a nice twist. What turned out is a great tasty drink that will be popping up on the menu. Of course Dan the GM liked it as well. Stuffed Olive is a great environment for a cocktail and a small bite before dinner or for us it is a great place to have a lighter dinner and enjoy the staff. read more

See all

Tay was our bartender tonight, it was our very first time here. She was so lovely and carried on a wonderful conversation about all of the martini's they have. As someone who doesn't normally drink she steered me to the right one and we will def be back!!! read more

Brenton made us the most fabulous martinis. So many choices and very reasonable. Don't walk by, stop and have a martini! read more

The Stuffed Olive - Love potion and Chocolate Espresso - Tapas Bars Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

Not sure how this place is in business. Our poor waiter obviously was not trained well. It was a goat rodeo of an experience. Items ordered never coming to the table. Main plates arriving before appetizers. For one of our parties the appetizer came with the main plate. Waiter couldn't manage to find our bill on his remote checkout appliance and had a small breakdown so the other waiter had to bail him out and finish the transaction after 5 minutes of him sitting against the wall by our table just udderly confused. We would of liked to have seen the bill to see if it was correct since we didn't receive some of our appetizers but thought that would of just pushed him over the edge..some patrons left as they never got any service after waiting over 30 minutes and not being addressed. It wasn't a full house.. Now why the generous 2 stars you ask? Well, my food tasted solid. I had the caprese flatbread and it was good but definitely could be better had they used fresh tomatoes especially this time of year and them being 2 blocks from the Dane County farmers market. I also had the hummus and it was good and the donuts for dessert were decent. One of my parties had the tuna and he said it could have been more flavorful but it was ok. He also said the bruschetta was solid. My husband had the whiskey sliders and he said they were good (juicy) and would probably order again. The last in our party had a pesto chicken flatbread and she said it was pretty good but needed more pesto. We were supposed to have the olive appetizer but it never came so can't speak to those. Our other appetizer, the spinach dip came after we had our meal. He had forgotten about it and when he brought it out you could tell it had been sitting a while. I think it would be good freshly baked. As for drinks, one had a dirty bird and it was way too dirty... need to lighten that up a bit. 2 had mocktails and they were fine (lemonade based) and the last had the Rose that was on special and it was solid. Womens restroom was not clean.. yuk! We obviously are not returning. I can't imagine they will be around long if they don't make changes. We truly felt bad for our server. Not trained well and where is the manager to help support him when he needs it? Or the owner? read more

This was our first time here, and will be our last! The food wasn't as described, monkey bread was under baked, toast was burned, service was poor and server was unattentive and not helpful! read more

The Stuffed Olive - Description said powdered sugar, not heap of cream. Told the server we have dietary needs, she just brought an extra plate. UNderbaked. - Tapas Bars Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

This is a "martini" bar with small plates. It's more like the McDonald's of martini bars. It could be better. The martini glass wasn't chilled. The garnishes weren't available per the recipe, which would be fine if it were communicated. Example, "spicy pickle girl" was supposed to come with a gherkin and a cocktail onion but it came with two bread and butter pickle chips.....if you want a nice martini experience this is not it. If you're 21 and having your first martini, it'll do. read more

Amazing! It's a cocktail bar idk why you'd take the food seriously. Extensive wonderful menu of drinks I love how unique they get and doing specials from time to time. Cute little events like drag brunch and jazz brunch! read more

The Stuffed Olive - Martini - Tapas Bars Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

10/10 Jackie was the sweetest server and great recommendations. The bartender made me an amazing cosmo and my friends also enjoyed their martinis just as much as I did. We sat on the patio with 70° it was perfect. Interior is very very nice too. BOGO martinis on a Monday?! Sign me up. read more

The Stuffed Olive - A man enjoying a martini. - Tapas Bars Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

Drinks, service, and ambiance were great! Food was dry, black spots on the raspberries. Cheese & carrots were dry. read more

Drinks were good. Food was meh. I think the chicken skewers were past its prime and very dry. it's not cheap. So come for the drinks but maybe skip on the food. read more

This place is what state street has had on and off for the past couple of years. A martini bar! I love that it is all associated with tap tap and the Roxy. It's a great combination of fun on state street and I could see this being a good starting point for a night out! read more

Amazing vibes at this corner spot with cool music and amazing light. 108 martinis on the menu, and the olive app is a great starter. read more

See all

Kali was great! Nice shared appetizers and great ambiance. We will be back on our next trip to Madison

This is the best establishment in the madison area. The best service, bartenders, and drinks in the Madison area. Shout out to kali, Colton, James, and Ashlyn. read more

Amazing food and drinks!!! Even better service. 10/10 spot for me! The hangover burger is one of the best burgers I've ever had! Very clean and relaxing place to go out too! read more

We went at Friday @ 6 to an almost empty bar. Sat at the bar and were not greeted by any of the 3 bartenders for 10 mins. We ordered martinis and some food. The martinis we ordered were pretty good. We went classic, not any of the fun wild ones. The food, however, was very disappointing. We got the spinach artichoke dip, sliders, and Thai chicken flatbread -- which the bartender had said was one of her favorites. All of it looked like it had been made days before and simply reheated. The slider patties were much smaller than the buns and the toppings in the flatbread didn't extend nearly to the edges, making it mostly crust. After a couple bites, we gave up eating it and ditched our plan to order another drink. When the bartender asked how everything was and we told her we weren't too happy with the food, she didn't seemed that surprised. Overall, it was extremely disappointing and I won't be returning there for anything other than a basic martini on a quiet night. read more

The martinis here are always fantastic. The staff does well even on busy nights. Special shoutouts to the bartenders who are always extra attentive and absolutely hilarious; Kali, James and Ashlyn. read more

We came in with a group, excited to try this place out, but left incredibly disappointed. We were seated fairly quickly, but then... nothing. No server came by to greet us, no menus, no waters -- not even a "we'll be right with you." We waited over an hour before finally deciding to leave. read more

Sorry, but the food sounded better than the presentation and flavor and my Naked Martini (Gin) had a pervasive sweet flavor that had to be left in the shaker that was not cleaned well. Plenty of staff and not busy, lacking attention to detail behind the bar. Too bad! read more

Sunday afternoon 18 people in the restaurant (8 at the bar, 10 seated) 10 already had drinks. It took 20 minutes to get 2 drinks. When we got those drinks, one of them was wrong. The bartender, who delivered them, looked at us as if we made the mistake, rolled her eyes and walked away, and proceeded to make the correct order. For my first drink, I ordered a mule that came in a copper mug and then later ordered a second one that came in a glass. Hard to believe there weren't any clean copper mugs since none of the 18 people in the restaurant weren't drinking mules. Noticed others in the bar irritated with the waitstaff trying to take orders and the bartender not being skilled enough to keep up. Maybe it was her first day?? in any case where was management to rectify this issue? I'm never going back there and experiencing that again. read more

We came in late on a Friday afternoon, close to 5. The bar was mostly full, but the rest of the place was still pretty empty. Our first drinks were both pretty tasty. That's where things went downhill. I counted 5 staff members behind the bar - none of whom ever asked if we wanted another drink or food, of which we wanted both. And frankly, the bar is not that big. The menu looked amazing, the drinks were tasty, but as we watched all five people ignoring the actual customers - we couldn't do it anymore and literally had to wave at someone to get our bill. If I was the owner I would be pissed that the staff let people walk out the door who were still hungry and thirsty so that they could socialize with each other and check their Instagram feed. read more

Went here on a Saturday afternoon. I love Martini's so was really looking forward to 100 choices. I went in the ladies room and it was filthy, my shoes were sticking to the floor and trash all over the floor. Went to the bar and told my sister I would have a drink but could not eat here. If bathroom is that dirty think what kitchen must be like. Mentioned it to staff and answer was we are working on it. Another words F*****". We left. read more

If you are looking for a place like no other, look no further. Maybe you can find another place with a good martini, or a place with almost as nice ambiance. But what you can not find anywhere else, is the service we were provided by Danny Stumpf. Stuffed Olive will not disappoint and Danny will make sure of that. read more

came in with a date and they were so friendly. the drinks were so fast and we had a good time talk to kali.

Lili was lovely and attentive; the dry martini was spot on! The array of tapas we ordered were just the right portion - ahi tuna, crab dip that was steaming and nicely spiced and with great pita chips. Loved the ambiance! read more

drinks were strong asf i got drunk off of one it was spectacular i'm gonna be back every week don't fret

Overall, loved the vibe in The Stuffed Olive! We ordered the most delicious Girl Scout Martinis- shoutout Lily!! read more

I have been here quite a few times since it has opened in Madison, and I absolutely love this place. There is a bartender/server named Lilli, and she is incredible. I always get the same dirty martini and she always makes the best drink every time! She also goes above and beyond to ensure everyone is having a great time! read more

Lilli and Dan were fantastic!! Was such an enjoyable experience with an inviting atmosphere and super friendly staff! Made our Sunday night super fun! As well as the fact that the drink selection is endless and delicious! read more

Most of the food was great! We got the Olive sampler platter, crab rangoons, and the artichoke flatbread. The seared tuna was not seared it was cooked through and dry and not good. Drinks were great and strong and service was great. If the tuna had been good, it would have been five stars. read more