Cancel

Open app

Search

The Smithy

4.0 (121 reviews)
Open • 5:00 pm - 10:00 PM

The Smithy Photos

THE SMITHY ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Moderate noise
Casual
Good for kids
Outdoor seating

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - The Smithy

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Surf and turf excellent. We had a party of11and it  went very smoothly. The food was excellent and the service was excellent as well.

We had the surf and turf and it was excellent, The service was excellent as well. I highly recommend.

Rachel B.

We had such a nice time visiting The Smithy last night. The host was very friendly and gave us a seat very close to the fire place which was lovely. The service was very polite and informative, as it was our first time there. The salad bar was very fresh with a few different choices. The cracker station with cheese block was a fun and different option rather than your usual bread basket. I decided to go with the filet mignon and baked potato and my fiancé ordered the striploin and lobster tail. We both enjoyed our meals very much. The ambiance was cozy and the service was warm and welcoming. We wish we lived nearby, we would definitely come often. We will definitely visit the next time we are in town. Thank you for such a nice evening!

Sonia S.

Really enjoyed my meal. The steak was perfectly made. I'm very particular of my steak and they made it exactly how I like it Will be back soon

Best porterhouse I have seen in a while. Huge filet.  Ron loved it. His birthday meal, he said it's the best he has had, perfectly cooked!

First trip to The Smithy did not disappoint! Took Ron for his birthday. Ron, a trained chef with very discerning taste, loved it. Said porterhouse was the best he has had and wants to go back next week. We will. My birthday ! Well worth the half hour ride. Everything very very fresh. Great salad bar too. I loved the cod and many fish options ! Recommend the baked potato with butter and sour cream, just like grandma made served in tin foil too. Beautiful atmosphere, much to see on the walls and lovely antiques, fireplace. Great for this time of year too. RJ recited all of the many specials with ease ! Great service, very attentive.

Clam chowder
Sara N.

We came here for my moms birthday, per my brothers recommendation, as he is a frequent visitor who lives nearby & really likes this place. My hubby ordered clam chowder which he enjoyed, & I partook in the salad bar, which was good. We all got steaks, which were cooked to perfection, & seasoned just right. My brothers girlfriend really liked her salmon as well. This place has a nice ambience, but service was definitely on the slower side.

Steak and Baked Potato

See all

10 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 4 of 4

Ask the Community - The Smithy

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Seafood 991 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Supreme Seafood Restaurant - Clam Chowder, a good one!!!

Supreme Seafood Restaurant

4.3(229 reviews)
24.3 mi
•$$

The food was delicious. Best New England clam chowder we've had in a long time. Creamy but not too…read morethick - full of clams and potatoes in every bite. We also got the Codfather sandwich - lite panko crusted piece of cod, melted in your mouth. The calamari was large pieces, which means chewy to me, but this was tender and flavorful. Light batter that wasn't greasy. Can't wait to go back and try other items - and get more of that chowdah! The woman who greets you and takes your order was super nice and on top of everything. She made sure the food was good and cleared our dishes quickly. Very pleasant - a 5 star employee.

Great fried seafood! Great service! We were headed to the coastline for some fine dining seafood…read morebut there was a lot of flash flooding and could not get there. Hubby was riding shotgun and searched and found Supreme Seafood not too far away. We were a bit surprised when we got there, not very similar to where we were heading. A little spot in a small strip mall. Looking more like a sandwich shop or a breakfast place than a clam shack. We were the only customers on a rainy Sunday but we took a chance. I had fried shrimp, hubby had fried clams and a side of onion rings. The fried items were excellent. I assume they mostly do take out. The Cole slaw was pre-portioned, cold and a little dehydrated. It looked nice, we gave it a stir and took a couple of bites but left it there. The tartar sauce and cocktail sauce were also pre-portioned and too cold. Even though we ordered half orders on the seafood, we had enough leftover for lunch on Monday. The place was clean, mostly. They need to clean the salt and pepper shakers and try to make the tables less sticky feeling.

Photos
Supreme Seafood Restaurant
Supreme Seafood Restaurant - Fried shrimp, sea scallops, calamari, clam strips and fillet of sole fish! Served with french fries and coleslaw.

Fried shrimp, sea scallops, calamari, clam strips and fillet of sole fish! Served with french fries and coleslaw.

Supreme Seafood Restaurant - Owenego's view from the Shanty

See all

Owenego's view from the Shanty

Aldini's Restaurant - Fried calamari, delicious! not at all rubbery as you can get sometimes elsewhere.

Aldini's Restaurant

3.8(12 reviews)
1.8 mi

The service and staff were both friendly & attentive. The food quality, taste and presentation were…read morea HUGE disappointment! We went there for the first time last night because it was late and we were hungry. My husband ordered the meatball grinder, it was all bread & hardly any meatballs or cheese. He said the sauce was OK- not great. I ordered the appetizer butterfly shrimp, and a cup of chicken soup. The shrimp came dark brown and overcooked, but thanks to the tangy chili sauce -I did not complain. I asked for a recommendation on the soup and they said chicken. I was expecting homestyle chicken noodle soup, but it was a bowl of spaghetti noodles (literally) in very bland, almost watered down, broth. There was barely any vegetables or chicken, and what carrots, onions & celery I could find were too finely cut. The scarce chicken looked canned. It was definitely lacking the basic flavors of chicken soup (garlic, salt, pepper and rich broth). I'm sure there are regulars that go there and love what they eat every time. However, we did not have that experience, so unfortunately we will never go back. Which is sad because this area is seriously lacking restaurants.

While back in the area I was recommended this place for Italian food and/or pizza…read more My wife and I ended up getting chicken picatta along with a huge Caesars salad. Both were nothing this world ! Homemade dressing in a Caesar can't be duplicated. Friendly wait staff and it was obvious that a lot of regulars frequent this place. Will be back for the red sauce !

Photos
Aldini's Restaurant - Our Cabernet and Pinot Grigio

Our Cabernet and Pinot Grigio

Aldini's Restaurant - Specials board, although we ate more casual fare this visit.

Specials board, although we ate more casual fare this visit.

Aldini's Restaurant - Family style dessert, fried dough balls with cinnamon sugar, vanilla ice cream, whipped cream, chocolate and caramel sauces.  Amazing!

See all

Family style dessert, fried dough balls with cinnamon sugar, vanilla ice cream, whipped cream, chocolate and caramel sauces. Amazing!

7 Seas Restaurant and Pub - Scrod topped with crabmeat.

7 Seas Restaurant and Pub

4.1(369 reviews)
11.8 mi
•$$

Looking for a hole in the walk that serves the absolutely best fried scallops in southern…read moreConnecticut, that's tucked into one of the finest walkable New England coastal town centers- that hosts plenty of action from time to time on their perfectly manicured green ? Look no further than Milford Center's 7 Seas ! Their Fresh, large, juicy & perfectly fried scallops can't be beat. Served with perfectly fried petite potato wedges & an outstanding coleslaw, mate with a cold beer & you'll reach nirvana. Truth be told, have munched here on & off for 30+ years & not much has changed: great burgers, chowder, f&c's & a pretty decent beer selection PLUS lobster rolls ( best in season ) doled out in a friendly & genuine dive bar atmosphere with the classiest staff that own 100 watt smiles. Not a raw bar place though. Biggest surprise: an icy cold zero alcohol IPA from Athletic, brewed in Milford CT. Outstanding ! For a joint with no parking, you know the food & people have got to be good to keep reeling folks in. Hint #1: for parking: behind the Milford Library there is a lot. Short walk from there on an easy to moderate grade. Hint #2: If you're Uber-ing, the center is a great place to do a pub crawl.

Consistently closes earlier than poster hours. Pours are not fair and the bartender acts like he…read moreowns the place. Idk maybe he does but this place is absolutely indifferent to business. Door says 10? Closed at 8. Wild. And the food is basicalty microwaved Sysco. Pure trash.

Photos
7 Seas Restaurant and Pub
7 Seas Restaurant and Pub - CT Lobster roll

CT Lobster roll

7 Seas Restaurant and Pub

See all

The Smithy - seafood - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...