Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    The Smithy

    4.0 (121 reviews)
    Open 5:00 pm - 9:00 PM

    The Smithy Photos

    THE SMITHY ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Casual
    Moderate noise
    Good for kids
    Good for groups

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - The Smithy

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Surf and turf excellent. We had a party of11and it  went very smoothly. The food was excellent and the service was excellent as well.

    We had the surf and turf and it was excellent, The service was excellent as well. I highly recommend.

    We had such a nice time visiting The Smithy last night. The host was very friendly and gave us a seat very close to the fire place which was lovely. The service was very polite and informative, as it was our first time there. The salad bar was very fresh with a few different choices. The cracker station with cheese block was a fun and different option rather than your usual bread basket. I decided to go with the filet mignon and baked potato and my fiancé ordered the striploin and lobster tail. We both enjoyed our meals very much. The ambiance was cozy and the service was warm and welcoming. We wish we lived nearby, we would definitely come often. We will definitely visit the next time we are in town. Thank you for such a nice evening!

    Sonia S.

    Really enjoyed my meal. The steak was perfectly made. I'm very particular of my steak and they made it exactly how I like it Will be back soon

    Best porterhouse I have seen in a while. Huge filet.  Ron loved it. His birthday meal, he said it's the best he has had, perfectly cooked!

    First trip to The Smithy did not disappoint! Took Ron for his birthday. Ron, a trained chef with very discerning taste, loved it. Said porterhouse was the best he has had and wants to go back next week. We will. My birthday ! Well worth the half hour ride. Everything very very fresh. Great salad bar too. I loved the cod and many fish options ! Recommend the baked potato with butter and sour cream, just like grandma made served in tin foil too. Beautiful atmosphere, much to see on the walls and lovely antiques, fireplace. Great for this time of year too. RJ recited all of the many specials with ease ! Great service, very attentive.

    Clam chowder
    Sara N.

    We came here for my moms birthday, per my brothers recommendation, as he is a frequent visitor who lives nearby & really likes this place. My hubby ordered clam chowder which he enjoyed, & I partook in the salad bar, which was good. We all got steaks, which were cooked to perfection, & seasoned just right. My brothers girlfriend really liked her salmon as well. This place has a nice ambience, but service was definitely on the slower side.

    Steak and Baked Potato

    See all

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 4 of 4

    Ask the Community - The Smithy

    You might also consider

    Supreme Seafood Restaurant - Clam Chowder, a good one!!!

    Supreme Seafood Restaurant

    4.3(223 reviews)
    24.3 mi
    $$

    I follow a couple on IG they went to eat the famous lobster roll at Clam Castle and that was our…read moreplan. We arrived at Clam Castle and as I was about to get out of the truck my cousin text me the viral lobster roll at Supreme Seafood. I told my fiancé I want to go to Supreme Seafood. He said it's only down the street. We arrived and I was very excited. As we walked in we were greeted by the owner and the two young ladies at the counter they were very welcoming and iit was very clean inside. It's a very small establishment with a eclectic vibe and it was quite cozy. Our starters were clam chowder and I had the shrimp corn chowder. It was very flavorful and they didn't skimp on the shrimp. My fiancé ordered a full order of the clam strips with coleslaw and I ordered the $55.00 lobster roll with steak fries and coleslaw. They do have a $40.00 lobster roll which 4 Oz and $80.00 which is 16 Oz of lobster meat. The clam strips were fried perfectly and there is nothing better then tasting that fresh clam they were perfect. My lobster roll had 8 oz of sweet, succulent meaty lobster over flowing in perfectly toasted buttery roll. I had very huge pieces and there were some trying to escape the roll but I won that fight that lobster roll was banging. The new owner informed me that the original owners were there for 35 years. The new owner had been there for 4 years. I told him where I was initially going and he said they had a family that ordered their 2 foot lobster roll that cost a working $230.00. He showed us the lobster roll he prepared and what was left after the family of three which included two adults and a newborn baby. I will definitely return to try the 2 foot lobster roll. If your in North Branford, CT please stop and enjoy all the delicious seafood at Supreme Seafood. To all my Yelper let's continue to eat our way through the world.#Foodie4life.

    My first time with the new owners and everything went well…read more I like whole belly clams and finding them can be difficult and they are pricey. This is one place that has them, fried to perfection and offers them in their Combination for a small upcharge. I got an order, which was a generous pile of scallops, shrimp, belly clams and filet. I got a separate order of fried calamari with cocktail sauce; another fave. The eat in area is cute and comfortable and the two men, owners, I believe were friendly. I ate about half of my order and took the rest home. Yum!

    Photos
    Supreme Seafood Restaurant
    Supreme Seafood Restaurant - Fried shrimp, sea scallops, calamari, clam strips and fillet of sole fish! Served with french fries and coleslaw.

    Fried shrimp, sea scallops, calamari, clam strips and fillet of sole fish! Served with french fries and coleslaw.

    Supreme Seafood Restaurant - Owenego's view from the Shanty

    See all

    Owenego's view from the Shanty

    The Smithy - seafood - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...