The burger basket may be one of the best deals price wise is the state of Maine. The burger basket with a soda was $14, which is around the same price as a large Big Mac meal (except with much better ingredients). The hand cut fries were perfect, not to many restaurants still make their fries this way. It was nice knowing that the potatoes used were grown in the area. The hot honey cheese curds were phenomenal and also a great price. The service was excellent! The staff were very friendly and kept a clean dining room. I'll definitely be stopping again next time I'm in the area! read more

The Rusty Crab - Burger Basket - Burgers Near Me - Mars Hill, Maine

See all

The place was pretty packed when we got there, so we chose to eat at the bar. It took forever to get a waitress to bring us any drink or take our order. Then it took forever again to get our food. We had waitresses not make eye contact, it was weird. Hubby had the haddock in garlic butter which was good, but not much garlic flavor. I had the cheese curds and calamari. Nothing special to either of them other than they could have gone a little lighter on the breading. We've been here over all hour already and now can't get our check. It's starting to become super frustrating. Everyone was very polite and smiley but the waitressing needs some work. read more

My experiences at the Rusty Crab have not been great, but also not terrible. Been here twice, the service was pretty good, the food was ok. Both times, an item advertised was not available, so I settled for something else. I didn't enjoy the meals enough to crave another visit however I didn't dislike them enough to prevent me from stopping in if I was absolutely in need or with someone who's an ted to go. read more

A solid spot whether you live in the area or passing through. They offer lots of choices. Over the past few days we tried a few different items from The Rusty Crab. The pizza was good. The burgers were yummy with a choice of griddling or chargrilling. I of course ordered mine with a side of poutine! The chicken salad was not that exciting. The waitstaff were friendly but were busy with the amount of people frequenting there. They have a bright, open dining space that fills up quickly in a town with few dining options. I should note, that though we didnt try one, they have an extensive list of margaritas! At least 20 flavors! read more

The Rusty Crab - Specials menu - Burgers Near Me - Mars Hill, Maine

Delicious fried and broiled Haddock sandwiches with hand cut fries! We will definitely go back!

As a 49 year old that has traveled to 44 states and 22 countries, the whole clams with mashed potatoes from the Rusty Crab was probably the best meal I've ever had. There are chives in the potatoes and the clams were absolutely perfect. Our server Alyssa was also top notch. If I didn't live in Florida, I would easily eat here weekly. GET THE WHILE CLAMS AND ASK FOR ALYSSA!!!!! read more

Burgers are amazing! The pizza was a terrible,black,burnt,bubbly mess! (Both times) Seafood is very pricey! Place can feel a bit cramped. Service is average. read more

I. Am. Impressed. Okay, so I'm not usually a lobster roll person. I usually order a whole lobster 1.5 pound soft shell; personally I feel putting good lobster on a roll is just as weird as putting prime rib on a bun. But since moving further north, I haven't found a place that makes a lobster dinner, only lobster rolls. So, I've ordered a lot. I don't eat the bun, order it made with butter (as opposed to mayo) and served warm. This is the BEST lobster roll I've had in the County. The lobster tasted freshly cooked and picked. The server (a young teenage boy, super nice and thorough--I've never seen a car hop follow up on an order and customers before) asked how I wanted the roll made. And I got to have it EXACTLY the way I like it. It's also the first appropriately priced roll I've seen in a long time! I know how market pricing works, and most places significantly over charge just because they can. Being as good and reasonably as it is, I'll definitely be back and probably have to control myself to not go weekly. My husband had the cheeseburger, and he was pleased too. It was a real burger, not some cheap frozen patty. The ONLY reason I didn't give this 5 stars was that my lobster meat had shell bits in it. I've never experienced that before. read more

The Rusty Crab - Lobster roll - Burgers Near Me - Mars Hill, Maine

Very nice seating and views. Portions were nice size and the price was great for a family restaurant.

Consistent and tasty. The staff is always nice and the food is as advertised. When I get the seafood hankering... they're my local go to. They're on that fine line of worth and portions. What they lack in portion, they make up in service and quality. read more

Don't blink or you'll miss this roadside gem. These rolls are full of claw lobster and dressed perfectly on a crispy toast. Fairly plain but real lobster rolls, they could've used some fresh lemon and I would have given them 5/5. Highly recommend the hush puppies instead of fries and add the maple syrup for dipping. read more

The Rusty Crab - Lobster roll, lobster roll meal, side of hush puppies. - Burgers Near Me - Mars Hill, Maine

See all

Shrimp were tiny and had no flavor. They didn't write my order down and surprise it came back wrong. They corrected the mistake with what I ordered and it followed the average trend. Under staffed having only 1 waitress for 10-15 tables plus the bar. I had high hopes. I drove a good bit to try it out. Doesn't get a thumbs up or down. Just. Average seafood a bit overpriced read more

I got the fisherman's platter to go got two meals out it excellent food. Also grabbed a pizza for the next day was also very good.

Place is clean but the good stops there. We stopped for lunch on a Friday. Ordered crab cakes which had very little crab, cake fell apart and they were cold. My friend asked for roumalade or aioli and the server responded... what's that? I ordered BBQ chicken for 13.50 and was served 2 small pre-made chicken fingers in a bowl of BBQ sauce. 2 in our party did get ok food, however, we waited over an hour for lunch. Wouldn't be quite so bad if we hadn't watched 5 other parties get seated on, waited, served and checked out while we continued to wait. Nobody was particularly rude but we were certainly ignored. We are 2 elderly, easy going couples. We never got an update, never got refills and never got an apology. I know times are tough but this was awful. We were hoping to go here with our large group of snowmobiling enthusiasts this winter but we have decided to find something different. read more

I really love the food at Rusty Crab but there's one thing that everybody is not mentioning there is a serious problem with ticket times in that restaurant . It's not uncommon to go in there and wait over an hour for your food. First thing people are gonna say is well it's a new restaurant he's getting used to the equipment but it was the same way when he was in the little shack next to the car wash read more

If I could give this place negative stars, I would. We walked in on Thursday at 6. Told we could pick one of 3 tables by the bar. We sat for 20 minutes watching a meandering young man who worked there wander through the dining room back to the kitchen, then repeat. We watched the waitress talk up patrons, except us. No greeting, no I know you're here. We grabbed meandering boy, to ask about service and he said he could bring us drinks. Finally waitress shows us to take our order. As part of my order, I asked for hush puppies to start. Meandering boy shows up about 15 minutes after we place our order to tell us there were no hush puppies. Excuse me? It takes 15 minutes to notice that A) I ordered them, and B) you don't have them? About 7:00, the waitress comes with scoops of cottage cheese and cole slaw for sides. This is about half an hour after we placed our order, and the first time we have food on the table. We finally got entrées, which were room temp. I asked for crab legs, and had to ask twice for a nut cracker to eat them. My melted butter for my crab legs and seared scallops was room temp sludge. Oh, I replaced my starter with fried mushrooms. We got them for dessert. If you want a timely, HOT meal in Mars Hill, go to Al's. read more

To go order. Very rude people. Didn't get what I ordered. Hung up on me after wanting to speak to manager. 32.00 for fish sandwich, French Fries,and coleslaw and two crab cakes. No drink. Save your money and go to Captain D. Way better and way less. read more

Very cute business, a little pricy, but very understandable why. The workers are all very nice, and the food was amazing. If you've got the money, definitely give this place a try! read more

The Rusty Crab is amazing. Haddock sandwich was the best thing I have ever put in my mouth.

My husband and I went to the Rusty Crab's new location for the first time today. We were really looking forward to it, we heard such good reviews about the old roadside location. We arrived around 1pm on a Sunday and very hungry! I ordered a cheeseburger, fries and coleslaw, my husband ordered deep fried shrimp with fries, no apps. It took well over an hour to get our food. Our waitress never came back to our table after serving our drinks and a coleslaw. We had to flag her down to ask if she could check on our meal. She said she was 3 weeks new to the job as she apologized for the service and blamed the wait on the kitchen. I do understand short staffing issues, but if the wait time after being seated is going to be that long it should be mentioned before being seated. I also saw other customers that arrived after us served meals before we were. The food was nothing to make us go back again in the future. It took two hours total, in and out, for subpar "fast" food. Way too long to wait! Very disappointed. read more

We absolutely love The Rusty Crab. We like the combo that comes with everything. The food is perfect, the customer service is top notch & the tarter sauce is divine. I recommend you drop everything & head to the Rusty Crab. What are you waiting for? GO! read more

The Rusty Crab - The Rusty Crab in Mars Hill, Maine is outstanding! - Burgers Near Me - Mars Hill, Maine

See all

This is the BEST FOOD in Maine. Big portion of food and great prices. The service is A++++! Definitely won't be disappointed when you eat here!! Highly recommend this place!! read more

Came up to Mars Hill, ME from Boston area and everyone I asked about getting a lobster roll said this place could not be beat! So I decided to take the short ride down the street to try it out and drove right by it the first time, the place is tiny (but you always know the tiny places usually have the best food) , so it is run out of a trailer type thing with an area built around if so when your ordering in the cold winter your nice and warm! The food it self was really great, I myself got the Haddock nuggets dinner with came with 1/2 pound of fish nuggets, fresh fries, cole slaw, and a roll with butter for around $9, plenty of food!! Now the fish was fresh fell right away while eating it, the fries are probably as fresh as you can get them, grown in town and cut and cooked when you order them! Not too much of a selection of drink inside but there was a Pepsi vending machine outside of the shack! Service was awesome the guy serving us was nice and talkative and I am looking forward to eating here again if I'm back in this area! read more

This place is great! They have the best takeout around, and their prices are very reasonable! Definitely the best seafood in northern Maine!! read more

Sixth lobster roll of my trip ... the best yet ... very fresh and tender ... a little mayo and a little lettuce... I forgot to take a picture!!! The Rusty Crab ... a half mile north of Mars Hill. I highly recommend it if you love lobster rolls like I do. read more